Yes, BenchMade Modern is worth it for shoppers seeking customizable, contemporary furniture with solid, USA-based construction. Their quality consistently surpasses mass-market brands, particularly in frame durability and upholstery, justifying their mid-to-high-end price point.
The brand offers a strong value proposition by balancing made-to-order design, quality materials, and a direct-to-consumer model. While you'll pay a premium over budget options, you receive furniture built for longevity that rivals more expensive designer brands. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what to know before you buy.
How Is BenchMade Modern's Quality?
BenchMade Modern's quality is generally well-regarded, with an emphasis on durable materials and solid construction methods designed for modern living. Here's a closer look at what to expect:
- Frame Construction: Frames are a major strength, typically built from kiln-dried hardwoods like oak or maple. This prevents warping and ensures long-term stability. The joinery is modern and reinforced with techniques like mortise and tenon or steel-reinforced dowels, leading to sturdy pieces that rarely feel wobbly.
- Upholstery & Cushions: The brand uses high-density foam cushions (around 2.0-2.5 lb/ft³) which resist sagging better than the industry standard. Upholstery options are extensive, including performance fabrics with high abrasion resistance (rated for over 50,000 double rubs), which is crucial for high-traffic homes.
- Materials & Components: From steel and aluminum hardware for legs to solid wood or premium veneer dining surfaces, the material choices reflect a commitment to durability. Stitching is typically precise and double-stitched, holding up well to daily use.
- Common Complaints: While customer satisfaction is high, the most frequent complaints are minor. Some performance textiles can be prone to slight fabric pilling over the first year. Custom order lead times and occasional shipping damage are also cited, though their customer service is reportedly responsive in handling these issues.
Is BenchMade Modern Good Value for the Price?
For discerning buyers who prioritize customization and durability, BenchMade Modern offers solid value. It effectively bridges the gap between fast furniture and high-end luxury brands.
Price Positioning
BenchMade Modern sits firmly in the mid-to-high-end of the market. Most sofas cost between $2,000 and $4,000, while dining tables range from $1,200 to $3,500. This places them above brands like Article but generally below premium brands like Mitchell Gold + Bob Williams, offering a competitive price for USA-made custom furniture.
What You're Paying For
The price tag is justified by three key factors: extensive customization (size, fabric, configuration, leg finish), domestic manufacturing (most assembly is in North Carolina), and quality materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames. The direct-to-consumer model also eliminates traditional retail markups, meaning more of your money goes directly toward the product itself.
Where You Get Good Value
- Custom-Sized Sofas & Sectionals: The ability to specify the exact dimensions of your sofa for a perfect fit adds significant value that most competitors don't offer. This is their core strength.
- Performance Fabric Upholstery: Chairs and sofas upholstered in high-durability fabrics like Crypton or Sunbrella are a smart investment for families or pet owners, ensuring the piece looks good for years.
- Modern Beds & Dining Tables: For those seeking a specific contemporary aesthetic, their tailored designs provide better durability and material quality than you'd find at a lower price point.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- For Impatient Shoppers: The 4 to 12-week lead time for custom pieces can be a major drawback. If you need furniture immediately, the value diminishes compared to in-stock options from other retailers.
- Basic Configurations: If you don't need or want detailed customization, you might find similar styles for a lower price from brands like Article, though likely with a step down in frame construction or material origin.
BenchMade Modern Quality by Category
Quality can vary slightly within a brand, but BenchMade Modern maintains consistent standards across its key offerings.
Sofas & Sectionals
This is BenchMade Modern's flagship category. Frames are kiln-dried hardwood, and high-density foam cushions provide durable support that resists premature sagging. With prices from $2,000 to over $4,000, they are an investment, but the combination of American manufacturing, customization, and quality materials makes them a worthwhile purchase expected to last 7-10 years with proper care.
Dining Furniture
Dining tables ($1,200-$3,500) and chairs feature metal bases or solid wood legs with surfaces in solid wood, natural wood veneers, or durable laminates. The construction is solid and designed to handle daily use. For buyers who value a clean, minimalist aesthetic combined with sturdy engineering, their dining furniture offers good long-term quality.
Bedroom Furniture
BenchMade Modern's beds use the same robust framing principles as their sofas. The upholstered beds are well-padded, and the wood-frame options are sturdy and quiet, with minimal reports of squeaking. The quality aligns with the price, offering a significant upgrade over particle board or MDF alternatives from fast-furniture brands.
Our Verdict: Is BenchMade Modern Worth It?
BenchMade Modern is a solid choice for anyone seeking well-built, customizable contemporary furniture who is willing to pay for quality and domestic production. It’s ideal for the modern homeowner who prizes design and longevity over the lowest possible price.
Quality Grade: B+
Using kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-density foam, and durable performance fabrics, BenchMade Modern delivers above-average furniture. The craftsmanship is excellent for its price point. It falls just short of an A rating because it doesn't offer the heirloom-level, artisanal details (like eight-way hand-tied springs) found in true luxury brands, and minor fabric inconsistencies can occur.
Value Grade: B+
The combination of a direct-to-consumer model, extensive customization, and durable materials creates a strong value proposition. Considering the pieces are made in the USA and are built to outlast cheaper alternatives by several years, the price is justified. The long lead times and premium cost are the only factors holding it back from a higher grade.
More Quality Brands Like BenchMade Modern
If you appreciate BenchMade Modern's focus on quality construction and modern design, these other brands offer similar standards and aesthetics.
Article
Article offers stylish mid-century modern furniture with a similar direct-to-consumer model at a slightly lower price point, typically 20-30% less. They often provide quicker shipping on in-stock items, making them a great option if you need quality pieces without the wait for custom manufacturing.
Shop now at article.com
Joybird
Joybird specializes in customizable, mid-century-inspired pieces with an incredible range of fabric options. Their quality is comparable to BenchMade Modern, utilizing hardwood frames and high-density foam, making them a direct competitor for those who prioritize fabric selection and vibrant colors.
Shop now at joybird.com
Mitchell Gold + Bob Williams
If you're looking for a step up in luxury and craftsmanship, MG+BW is an excellent choice. Their furniture is heirloom-quality with lifetime warranties on frames and higher-end construction details. Expect to pay a significant premium, but the investment translates into pieces that can last for decades.
Shop now at mgbwhome.com
Medley Home
Medley focuses on eco-friendly, non-toxic furniture handcrafted in the USA with sustainable materials like solid domestic wood and natural latex foam. They offer a similar level of craftsmanship and customization with an emphasis on sustainability, appealing to the environmentally conscious buyer.
Shop now at medleyhome.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Is BenchMade Modern furniture made in the USA?
Yes, BenchMade Modern furniture is primarily manufactured and assembled in the United States, with a large portion of their operations based in North Carolina. They emphasize domestic sourcing for materials like hardwoods where possible, which is a key part of their quality promise.
How long does it take to get BenchMade Modern furniture?
Because most pieces are made to order, you should expect a lead time of 4 to 8 weeks for production. Shipping can add another 2 to 4 weeks. In total, a custom order can take up to 12 weeks from purchase to delivery, which is a consideration for anyone on a tight timeline.
Is BenchMade Modern better quality than Article?
BenchMade Modern generally offers a slight edge in quality due to its focus on domestic manufacturing and robust, customizable kiln-dried hardwood frames. Article provides excellent value with comparable aesthetics and often faster shipping, but BenchMade Modern is typically considered the more durable, longer-term investment of the two.
What is BenchMade Modern's warranty like?
BenchMade Modern offers a solid warranty that reflects their confidence in their construction. They typically provide warranties ranging from 5 to 10 years that cover manufacturing defects in frames and cushions. Their customer service is generally reported as responsive and helpful in processing claims.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
