The IKEA Kallax and Billy series are legendary storage solutions, but they serve fundamentally different needs. The Kallax is a versatile cube storage unit with a deep, symmetrical design and fixed shelving, ideal for display, vinyl records, and use as a room divider, while the Billy is a classic, shallow bookcase revered for its adjustable shelves and space-efficient vertical storage.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right IKEA shelving unit for your home.
IKEA Kallax Shelf Unit
The Kallax is famous for its simple, modern cube design and unmatched versatility. Its rigid grid structure and substantial depth make it a popular choice not just for shelving but also for room dividers, media consoles, benches, and as a perfect home for vinyl record collections due to the cubes' dimensions.
- What it is: A modular cube storage system with a thick outer frame and fixed internal shelves that create perfectly symmetrical squares.
- Key features: Symmetrical 13"x13" cube openings, thick 2" outer frame, can be placed vertically or horizontally, compatible with IKEA's square inserts like doors, drawers, and baskets.
- Price: Ranges from around $50 for a 2x2 unit to over $200 for a large 5x5 configuration.
- Dimensions: Standard cube interior of 13" x 13" with a depth of 15 3/8". Available in many forms, from a 1x4 column to a massive 5x5 grid.
- Materials/Construction: Particleboard and fiberboard with a paper foil or painted finish. The internal grid provides significant structural support.
- Style: Bold, modern, minimalist. Its geometric silhouette makes a clean design statement.
- Pros: Extremely versatile (serves as a console, bench, divider, etc.), perfect dimensions for vinyl records and standard storage bins, works horizontally or vertically, thick frame looks substantial and sturdy, easy to accessorize with inserts.
- Cons: Shelves are not adjustable, limiting its use for books of varying heights. Its 15 3/8" depth takes up more floor space than a traditional bookcase.
The Kallax is perfect for anyone prioritizing versatility and a clean, modern aesthetic, especially for storing uniform items like records, Drona boxes, or decorative objects.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/kallax-series-27534/
IKEA Billy Bookcase
The Billy bookcase is one of IKEA's most iconic and longest-running products, representing the quintessential, no-frills bookcase. Celebrated for its simplicity, affordability, and adjustable shelves, its primary function is to store books and display objects of all sizes in a space-saving manner.
- What it is: A classic and functional bookcase with a thin profile and adjustable shelves designed primarily for storing books.
- Key features: Adjustable and removable shelves, shallow 11" depth, various heights and widths available, can be customized with glass doors, solid doors, and height extension units.
- Price: Highly affordable, starting around $50 for a standard tall and narrow unit and priced accordingly for wider models.
- Dimensions: Standard depth is 11”. Common widths are 15 3/4" and 31 1/2". Available in multiple heights from 41 3/4" to 93 1/4" (with height extension).
- Materials/Construction: Particleboard with a paper foil or wood veneer finish. Center shelf is typically fixed for stability, while others are adjustable.
- Style: Timeless, understated, and functional. It blends into most decor styles without overpowering the room.
- Pros: Extremely cost-effective, adjustable shelves provide maximum flexibility for different sized books and objects, shallow depth saves floor space, endlessly customizable with doors and add-on units to create a library wall.
- Cons: Not as visually interesting or robust feeling as the Kallax. Shelves on wider models can visibly sag over time if overloaded with heavy books. Its shallow depth and open-back design make it unsuitable as a standalone room divider.
The Billy bookcase is the go-to choice for book enthusiasts, homeowners needing to maximize storage on a small footprint, and anyone who values functional adjustability above all.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/billy-series-27525/
Kallax vs. Billy Comparison
Dimensions & Scale
The most immediate difference is in their footprint. The Kallax is significantly deeper at 15 3/8" compared to the Billy's slim 11" profile. This depth makes the Kallax feel rock-solid and suitable for use as a room divider or a low-slung media console. Placed on its side, a 2x4 Kallax serves as an excellent TV stand or bench.
The Billy bookcase, on the other hand, excels at maximizing vertical storage without consuming valuable floor space. Its shallow depth allows it to line the walls of a hallway, bedroom, or living room without making the space feel cramped. It's designed to be tall and unobtrusive.
Versatility & Customization
Both units are customizable, but in very different ways. The Kallax offers functional versatility. Its purpose changes depending on its orientation and where you place it. Customization comes from IKEA's ecosystem of perfectly sized inserts - you can fill cubes with doors, 2-drawer sets, or fabric boxes to transition from open display to concealed storage.
The Billy's versatility lies in its internal configuration. The adjustable shelves are its superpower, allowing you to create custom-height rows to perfectly accommodate anything from small paperbacks to large coffee table books with minimal wasted space. You can also turn it into a closed cabinet with optional glass or solid doors or build upwards with height extension units.
Style & Aesthetics
The Kallax makes a bold, geometric statement with its thick outer frame and symmetrical grid. It has a distinctly modern and tidy look, especially when filled with uniform bins or a curated display of objects. It can be a centerpiece in a room.
Conversely, the Billy bookcase has a classic, utilitarian design that is made to blend in. Its thinner frame and simple lines allow the contents on the shelves to be the main focus. It's less of a style statement and more of a practical backdrop for your collection, fitting seamlessly into traditional and contemporary decor alike.
Who Each One Works Best For
Choosing between them comes down to your primary storage needs. The Kallax is for the person organizing more than just books - think vinyl records, kids' toys in bins, craft supplies, or decorative objects. It's for someone who wants a multi-functional piece that can act as a partition, console, or creative display unit. Its modern look fits well in contemporary living spaces.
The Billy is for the avid reader and collector. It’s for someone who needs to efficiently store a large book collection in an organized, space-saving way. The adjustability is key for minimizing wasted vertical space. Anyone who wants to build floor-to-ceiling library walls or needs simple, functional storage without fuss on a tighter budget will find the Billy to be a perfect fit.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both of these IKEA staples are excellent storage pieces, but they are built for different purposes and priorities.
Choose the Kallax if:
- You're a vinyl collector - the cubes are the perfect size for 12" records.
- You want to use storage bins (like IKEA's Drona box) for concealed storage of toys or clutter.
- You need a sturdy, deep unit that can double as a room divider, bench, or TV stand.
- You prefer a clean, modern, and symmetrical look in your furniture.
Choose the Billy if:
- Your main goal is to store a large collection of books of different shapes and sizes.
- You are limited on floor space and need a storage unit with a shallow footprint.
- You need the flexibility to change shelf heights as your collection grows.
- You're on a tight budget and want the most efficient shelving for the lowest price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Kallax and Billy?
The main difference is versatility versus specialization. The Kallax is a versatile cube system with fixed shelves that works as a divider, console, or general storage, while the Billy is a specialized bookcase with a slim profile and adjustable shelves designed to efficiently store books.
Can you use Kallax for books?
Yes, but it's not ideal for a diverse collection. Since the cube shelves are fixed at 13" tall, you will have a lot of wasted vertical space for smaller paperbacks. It works best for displaying larger hardcover books or stacking books horizontally.
Can you use the Billy bookcase as a room divider?
This is not recommended. The Billy is only 11" deep and is far too unstable to be used freestanding in the middle of a room. For safety, it must be anchored to a wall.
Which one is more stable?
The Kallax is much more stable as a freestanding unit due to its greater depth (15 3/8") and cube structure. However, IKEA recommends anchoring both units to a wall to prevent tipping.
Do Kallax shelves fit vinyl records?
Yes, perfectly. The 13" x 13" inch cubes are one of the main reasons the Kallax is so popular among vinyl enthusiasts, as they provide an ideal fit for 12-inch record sleeves.
Are the shelves on the Billy bookcase adjustable?
Yes, most of the shelves in a Billy bookcase are adjustable. Typically, only the middle shelf is fixed for structural stability, while the others can be moved up or down as needed.
Which one is stronger, Kallax or Billy?
The Kallax generally feels more rigid and robust because of its thick frame and internal grid structure that distributes weight. While the Billy is perfectly strong for its intended purpose, its wider shelves can be prone to sagging if consistently overloaded with heavy hardcover books.
Can you put doors or drawers on a Kallax?
Yes. IKEA sells a variety of Kallax inserts, including single-door cabinets, two-drawer units, and even glass shelves, that are designed to fit perfectly inside the cube openings.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
