The Whynter and Breville compressor ice cream makers are two of the best options for homemade frozen desserts, but they serve different users. The main difference lies in features, design, and price: the Whynter is a durable, no-frills workhorse focused on reliable performance at a more accessible price point, while the Breville Smart Scoop is a premium, design-forward machine with advanced settings for precise control over texture.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which ice cream maker is the right investment for your kitchen.
Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Ice Cream Maker
Whynter's ice cream makers are built for home cooks who want the convenience of a compressor model without the complexity or high cost of professional machines. This machine is known for its durable construction and straightforward operation, freezing batch after batch without needing to pre-freeze a bowl. It’s a popular choice for families and frequent dessert makers who value function and reliability above all else.
- What it is: A self-freezing ice cream maker with a built-in compressor, eliminating the need for pre-chilling bowls.
- Key features: Built-in audible timer, powerful compressor, motor protection function that shuts off to prevent damage if the mixture freezes solid, removable stainless steel bowl.
- Price: Around $250 - $350, offering great performance for the price.
- Style: Functional and modern. Its stainless steel housing gives it a sturdy, utilitarian look that fits well in most kitchens but is less focused on high-end aesthetics.
- Materials/Construction: A combination of a durable plastic base with a stainless steel exterior and a stainless steel mixing bowl. It feels robust and is designed for frequent use.
- Pros: Excellent value for a compressor model. Simple to use with minimal settings. The powerful motor and compressor can handle back-to-back batches effectively. Durable build quality ensures longevity. Larger 2.1-quart capacity is great for families.
- Cons: Lacks the advanced texture and hardness settings of pricier models. Can be noisy during operation. The design is practical but not as sleek as premium alternatives.
This ice cream maker is ideal for anyone who primarily cares about getting consistently great, homemade ice cream from a machine that is reliable and easy to use.
Shop this product: whynter.com/product/whynter-ice-cream-maker/
Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker
The Breville Smart Scoop is an advanced ice cream maker designed for the culinary enthusiast who craves precision and control. It offers 12 automatic hardness settings, allowing you to create everything from soft sorbet to hard-packed ice cream with the turn of a dial. Its sleek stainless steel design, thoughtful features like a "keep cool" function, and intuitive interface make it a standout premium appliance.
- What it is: A premium, self-freezing compressor ice cream maker with smart technology for automatic hardness sensing.
- Key features: 12 hardness settings for sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream, a pre-cool function to speed up the process, a "keep cool" feature that holds a perfect temperature for up to 3 hours.
- Price: Typically around $400 - $500.
- Style: Sleek and minimalist, with a polished, brushed stainless steel finish common to all Breville products. It's designed to be a beautiful countertop appliance.
- Materials/Construction: Built primarily from high-quality brushed stainless steel with sturdy BPA-free plastic components. It feels solid, heavy, and meticulously engineered.
- Pros: Unmatched precision with 12 hardness settings. Very user-friendly with a clear LCD screen. Pre-cool speeds up churning time. Sleek, high-end design looks great on the counter. The keep-cool feature is incredibly useful.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than Whynter models. Takes up more counter space. Can be overly complex for users who just want simple ice cream without fussing over settings.
The Breville Smart Scoop is for the home cook who sees kitchen tools as an investment and wants the best in design, features, and control to perfect their culinary creations.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/ice-cream/bci600.html
Whynter vs. Breville Ice Cream Maker Comparison
Materials & Construction
Both brands produce appliances built to last, but there's a clear difference in the materials. The Whynter uses a mix of stainless steel and durable plastic for a sturdy, functional build. It feels reliable and capable of handling years of use.
The Breville, however, leans into premium construction with a body made almost entirely of brushed stainless steel. It not only looks more high-end but also feels more substantial and well-engineered, contributing to its heavier weight and quieter operation.
Features & Ease of Use
Herein lies the biggest difference between the two. The Whynter excels at simplicity: pour in your mixture, set the timer, and press start. It's foolproof and delivers excellent results without any guesswork. It's a fantastic appliance for someone who wants to "set it and forget it."
Conversely, the Breville Smart Scoop is all about customizable control. Its primary feature is the set of 12 hardness settings that automatically adjust churning time based on your selection (gelato, sorbet, hard ice cream, etc.). Features like pre-cooling the chamber and keeping the finished product cold for hours are incredibly useful and elevate it from a simple appliance to a smart culinary tool.
Price & Value
The Whynter is the clear winner on price, costing nearly half as much as the Breville. For that price, you get the most important feature: a powerful compressor that makes delicious ice cream on demand. It represents excellent value for anyone whose main goal is avoiding freezer bowls.
The Breville's value lies in its premium user experience - the beautiful design, precise controls, and convenient smart functions justify the higher price tag for serious dessert makers or anyone who appreciates high-end kitchen technology.
Style & Versatility
Style-wise, the Breville is an undeniable showpiece. Its sleek, uniform design fits perfectly in modern kitchens and alongside other high-end appliances. The Whynter is more utilitarian, it looks fine on the counter but doesn't have the same design-forward presence.
In terms of versatility, while both machines can make sorbet, gelato, and frozen yogurt, the Breville provides dedicated, optimized settings for each. This makes it easier for a novice to achieve perfect-textured results across different types of frozen desserts without experimentation.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines are excellent choices that create fantastic homemade ice cream, but they cater to very different priorities.
Choose the Whynter if:
- You're shopping for your first compressor ice cream maker.
- You are on a budget and value performance over aesthetics.
- You want a simple, straightforward machine with minimal settings.
- You need a larger capacity - its 2.1-quart bowl is great for families.
Choose the Breville if:
- You are a dessert enthusiast who wants precise control over your creations.
- You want a beautiful, high-end appliance that looks great on your countertop.
- Your budget allows for a premium machine with smart features and conveniences.
- You plan to make a wide variety of frozen desserts like gelato and sorbet often.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Whynter and Breville ice cream makers?
The biggest difference is in their approach. Whynter focuses on providing the core function - compressor-powered freezing - reliably and affordably. Breville offers that same core function plus a host of smart features, 12 specific hardness settings, premium design, and convenience functions like pre-cool and keep-cool for a substantially higher price.
Do I need to pre-freeze the bowl for either model?
No. Both the Whynter and Breville are compressor models, which means they have a built-in freezer. They self-freeze, allowing you to make batch after batch without ever needing to put a bowl in your freezer for 24 hours.
Which one is easier to clean?
Both are quite easy to clean. They feature removable bowls and mixing paddles that can be washed by hand in warm, soapy water. Neither machine’s removable parts are typically rated for dishwasher use.
Can both make gelato and sorbet?
Yes, both are capable of making gelato, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. However, the Breville Smart Scoop has pre-programmed settings specifically for each one, which automatically ensures the ideal texture and consistency without user guesswork.
How long does it take to make ice cream in these machines?
Churning time for a typical batch is between 30 and 60 minutes for both machines, depending on the recipe ingredients and final desired hardness. The Breville's pre-cool feature can shorten this time by chilling the machine before you add the mixture.
Is the Breville Smart Scoop worth the extra money?
For a dessert hobbyist who will use the distinct settings for different types of treats, or for someone who values premium design and smart technology, the Breville is absolutely worth it. For a casual user who just wants good homemade ice cream, the Whynter offers better overall value.
Which brand is quieter?
Generally, the Breville is considered quieter. Its premium build and heavy-duty materials help dampen the sound of the motor and compressor more effectively than many other models, including the Whynter.
What is the capacity of these ice cream makers?
The standard Breville Smart Scoop model has a 1.5-quart capacity. The popular Whynter model highlighted here has a slightly larger 2.1-quart capacity, making it a better choice for serving bigger crowds or families.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
