The primary difference between West Elm's Down Blend and Poly Fill lies in material, feel, warmth, and care. Down Blend, a mix of natural down and feathers, offers luxurious, plush, and highly insulating warmth with a sink-in feel, whereas Poly Fill is a 100% synthetic, hypoallergenic material that is loftier, springier, and much easier to machine wash.
Here’s a complete look at both options to help you choose the right bedding fill for your home and sleeping style.
West Elm Down Blend
West Elm’s Down Blend options, frequently found in their duvet inserts and pillows, are designed for those seeking the premium softness and insulation of natural down. By blending down with feathers and sometimes synthetic fibers, it provides a balance of cloud-like softness and gentle support, making it a popular choice for a luxurious sleep experience.
- What it is: A fill material typically combining goose or duck down with larger feathers for structure and warmth.
- Key features: Exceptional insulation, lightweight, highly breathable, molds to your body for a cozy feel.
- Price: More expensive than synthetic options, with duvet inserts typically ranging from $150 to $300+.
- Feel & Comfort: Incredibly soft and plush with a "sinking in" feeling. The natural fill is breathable, which helps regulate temperature and prevent overheating.
- Materials/Composition: A mixture of down clusters and feathers, encased in a cotton shell. West Elm often highlights its use of materials certified to the Responsible Down Standard (RDS).
- Pros: Superior warmth-to-weight ratio, extremely plush and luxurious feel, very breathable, long-lasting with proper care.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive, can be an allergy trigger for some, requires special care when cleaning (often requires gentle cycles or professional cleaning), not vegan-friendly.
This fill is for anyone who prioritizes a luxurious, enveloping feel and authentic natural warmth in their bedding and isn't limited by allergies or a tight budget.
Shop this product: westelm.com/products/down-duvet-insert-b2039/
West Elm Poly Fill (Down Alternative)
West Elm's Poly Fill, also known as Down Alternative, is the go-to synthetic solution that mimics the comfort and loft of natural down. Made from high-quality polyester fibers, it delivers warmth and softness while being completely hypoallergenic and significantly easier to maintain, making it a practical and functional choice for many households.
- What it is: A synthetic fill made from polyester fibers engineered to be light, lofty, and insulating.
- Key features: 100% hypoallergenic, resistant to moisture and dust mites, easy to machine wash and dry.
- Price: More affordable, with duvet inserts typically ranging from $100 to $200.
- Feel & Comfort: Lofty and springy rather than plush. It provides consistent, even support and warmth without the heavy weight of some natural fills.
- Materials/Composition: 100% polyester microfiber fill inside a cotton or poly-blend shell.
- Pros: Ideal for allergy sufferers, budget-friendly, very easy to clean at home, vegan-friendly, holds its shape well after washing.
- Cons: Less breathable than natural down, may trap heat for hot sleepers, doesn't have the same luxurious "sinking" feel, can sometimes flatten more quickly over time.
This is the ideal option for people with allergies, families with children who need easy-to-clean bedding, or anyone seeking a comfortable, animal-free fill at a lower price point.
Shop this product: westelm.com/products/down-alternative-duvet-insert-b3286/
West Elm Down Blend vs. Poly Fill Comparison
Feel & Comfort
The difference in feel is one of the most significant factors. A Down Blend insert is famously plush, soft, and feels like you’re sinking into a cloud. It contours to your body, offering an unmatched coziness. The natural fibers are also highly breathable, wicking away moisture and helping to regulate your body temperature throughout the night.
Poly Fill feels different - less like sinking and more like floating. It has a springy, airy loft that provides a more uniform surface. While very comfortable, it doesn't quite replicate the malleable, plush feel of real down. Because it's synthetic, it's also less breathable, which can be a concern for those who tend to sleep hot.
Allergies & Health Considerations
This is where Poly Fill has a clear advantage. Its synthetic nature makes it inherently hypoallergenic, meaning it won't trigger allergies to feathers or down. It also resists dust mites and mold growth more effectively, making it a safer choice for anyone with asthma or respiratory sensitivities.
While many of West Elm's down products are filled with hyper-cleaned materials to reduce allergens, there's always a risk for those with severe feather sensitivities. For a truly worry-free sleep, Poly Fill is the superior option.
Care & Durability
Poly Fill is the winner for convenience. Most poly fill duvet inserts and pillows from a brand like West Elm can be thrown directly into a standard washing machine and dryer, making them perfect for kids' rooms or anyone who values a low-maintenance routine. They tend to dry quickly and retain their shape well.
Down Blend requires a more delicate approach. It often needs to be washed in a large-capacity, front-loading machine on a gentle cycle. Drying can be a lengthy process, you often need to use low heat with tennis or dryer balls to help break up clumps and restore the loft. Some people prefer to have it professionally laundered to ensure it lasts.
Price & Value
There's a clear price separation between the two. Poly Fill is the budget-friendly choice, often costing 30-50% less than its Down Blend counterpart. This makes high-quality comfort from a brand like West Elm much more accessible.
Down Blend is an investment. You are paying a premium for the luxurious feel, superior insulation, and natural materials. Well-maintained down can last for years, often longer than poly fill, so its long-term value can be excellent for those who are willing to spend more upfront and care for it properly.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both options offer great comfort from a trusted brand, but they are built for different sleepers and lifestyles.
Choose the West Elm Down Blend if:
- You crave a truly luxurious, plush, and "sink-in" sleeping experience.
- Maximum warmth is your top priority for cold climates or if you're a cold sleeper.
- You value the breathability of natural fibers to help regulate temperature.
- You are willing to invest a little more time and money into proper care and maintenance.
Choose the West Elm Poly Fill if:
- You or others in your home have allergies, asthma, or sensitivities to feathers.
- You need bedding that is exceptionally easy to machine wash and dry.
- You are looking for the most budget-friendly yet comfortable option.
- You live a vegan lifestyle or prefer to exclusively purchase animal-free products.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference in feel between Down Blend and Poly Fill?
The main difference is plushness vs. uniformity. Down Blend is soft and malleable, allowing you to sink into it, while Poly Fill is loftier and springier, providing a more consistent, supportive cushion.
Which fill is warmer?
Down Blend is naturally a better insulator and provides more warmth for its weight than Poly Fill. It's the ideal choice for very cold environments or for people who get cold easily at night.
Is West Elm's Down Blend hypoallergenic?
West Elm often uses down that has been thoroughly cleaned and sanitized to remove dust and dander, making it "hypoallergenic" for many people. However, those with a true feather allergy should still opt for a fully synthetic Poly Fill to be completely safe.
How do you wash West Elm bedding inserts?
Always check the care tag. Generally, Poly Fill inserts can be machine washed in warm water on a gentle cycle and tumble-dried on low heat. Down Blend inserts typically require a front-loading washer (to prevent damage) on a gentle, cool cycle, and a long, low-heat dry cycle with dryer balls to break up clumps.
Which fill is better for pillows?
This depends on your sleep position. Down Blend pillows are great for stomach and back sleepers because they can be easily molded. Poly Fill pillows are often firmer and hold their shape better, making them a good choice for side sleepers who need more consistent neck support.
Does Poly Fill go flat over time?
Over several years, synthetic fills can lose some of their loft and become more compressed. Fluffing them regularly in the dryer can help, but they generally have a shorter lifespan than high-quality, well-cared-for down.
Which fill is more breathable for hot sleepers?
Down Blend is more breathable. Natural down allows air to circulate and wicks moisture away from the body more effectively than synthetic polyester, preventing clamminess. Hot sleepers often find down more comfortable year-round despite its warmth.
Is the higher price for Down Blend worth it?
If your ultimate goal is a luxurious, cloud-like feeling and superior temperature regulation straight from a high-end hotel experience, then yes, the extra cost is often worth it. If your priorities are practicality, hypoallergenic properties, and budget, then Poly Fill offers fantastic value and comfort.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
