While West Elm's Cool Walnut finish and the furniture from Acorn might appeal to those seeking warm, modern wood tones, they represent fundamentally different approaches to furniture. West Elm's Cool Walnut pieces typically feature a wood veneer over an engineered wood core for a stylish, mid-century modern look at an accessible price. In contrast, Acorn is a boutique brand specializing in handcrafted, solid hardwood furniture, offering heirloom quality and a higher price point.
Here’s a detailed look at West Elm and Acorn to help you decide which brand's furniture is the right fit for your home and budget.
About West Elm’s Cool Walnut Furniture
West Elm’s Cool Walnut furniture is a cornerstone of their mid-century modern aesthetic, known for clean lines, minimalist hardware, and a versatile design that fits well in urban and contemporary homes. This collection focuses on delivering on-trend style at a price point that is accessible to a wide audience. It's an excellent choice for those looking to furnish their space with a cohesive, modern look without venturing into high-end price territory.
- What it is: Stylish, modern furniture featuring a Cool Walnut wood veneer over an engineered wood or MDF core.
- Key features: Mid-century modern-inspired designs, slim profiles, and consistent finishes. Pieces are often designed for apartment living or smaller spaces.
- Price: Mid-range. Side tables can start around $300, while larger pieces like media consoles and dining tables range from $800 to $2,500.
- Style: Contemporary, mid-century modern, and eclectic. Suitable for urban apartments, young professional homes, and modern family living spaces.
- Materials/Construction: Generally a real wood veneer layer on top of an engineered wood substrate (like MDF) and sometimes combined with solid wood legs or accents.
- Pros: Affordable and highly stylish. Frequent sales and promotions make pieces even more accessible. Versatile sizing fits a variety of room dimensions. Large retail presence with showrooms for in-person viewing.
- Cons: Veneer construction is less durable long-term than solid wood. It can be more susceptible to chipping, scratches, and water damage. Quality can vary between pieces.
West Elm's Cool Walnut line is ideal for style-conscious shoppers who prioritize a modern aesthetic and affordability for furnishing small to mid-sized spaces.
Shop this brand: westelm.com
About Acorn Furniture
Acorn is a boutique furniture brand that stands for timeless design, natural materials, and artisanal craftsmanship. Their pieces are constructed from solid, FSC-certified hardwood, built to last for generations. Acorn appeals to consumers looking to invest in heirloom-quality furniture with an understated, rustic-modern appeal that highlights the natural beauty of the wood grain itself.
- What it is: High-end, handcrafted furniture made from solid hardwoods, with a focus on durability and timeless, minimalist design.
- Key features: Traditional joinery techniques, natural wood finishes, and sturdy, substantial construction.
- Price: Higher-end. Dining tables typically start around $1,200 and larger storage units can exceed $3,000.
- Style: Rustic-modern, Scandinavian minimalism, and timeless transitional. Complements spaces that value natural materials and classic design.
- Materials/Construction: Solid, FSC-certified hardwoods like walnut and oak. Finishes are often natural oils or light stains to protect the wood while showcasing its grain.
- Pros: Exceptional durability and longevity due to solid wood construction. Timeless designs that won't go out of style. High emphasis on sustainability and artisan craftsmanship. Each piece has unique character from the natural wood grain.
- Cons: A significantly higher investment upfront. Furniture is often larger and heavier, making it less ideal for small apartments. Limited physical showrooms for viewing before purchase.
Acorn furniture is the right choice for homeowners who want to invest in durable, forever pieces and value craftsmanship and natural materials over temporary trends.
Shop this brand: acornfurniture.com
West Elm vs. Acorn Comparison
Materials & Construction
This is the most significant point of difference. West Elm's furniture, including pieces in its Cool Walnut finish, primarily uses a wood veneer over an engineered wood core. This approach allows for consistent, stylish looks at a lower cost. While perfectly functional for everyday use, veneer can chip or peel over time and is more vulnerable to moisture damage.
In contrast, Acorn builds its furniture from solid hardwood. This means every part of the piece - from tabletops to legs - is milled from solid planks of wood. This traditional construction method results in superior sturdiness, longevity, and the ability to be sanded and refinished decades down the line, making it true heirloom-quality furniture.
Style & Versatility
West Elm’s Cool Walnut style is distinctly mid-century modern and contemporary. The designs are clean, often featuring sleek hardware and slender legs. This aesthetic is highly trendy and works perfectly in modern, urban, or eclectic interiors that need furniture with a lighter visual footprint.
Acorn’s design ethos is more understated and timeless. The focus is on simple silhouettes that allow the natural beauty of the wood grain to be the star. This style lends itself to rustic-modern, minimalist, and Scandinavian-inspired homes, grounding a room with natural texture and warmth that won’t feel dated in a few years.
Dimensions & Sizing
West Elm excels at creating furniture for a variety of living situations, especially smaller-scale city apartments. They offer a wide range of sizes, including many compact or modular options for media consoles, desks, and storage that can fit into tighter spaces without overwhelming a room.
Acorn’s furniture tends to be larger and more substantial, reflecting its solid wood construction. These pieces are designed to be focal points in a room and are generally better suited for more spacious environments where their presence won't feel crowded. The emphasis is on lasting presence rather than space-saving functionality.
Price & Value
West Elm provides exceptional value for style-focused shoppers. Its mid-range pricing, combined with frequent sales events, makes it possible to achieve a fashionable, modern look on a realistic budget. The value comes from getting a high-end look for less upfront cost.
Acorn furniture represents a different kind of value: long-term investment. While the initial cost is significantly higher, you are paying for premium materials and craftsmanship that ensure the piece will last a lifetime. The value is in its durability, timeless appeal, and the fact that it won't need to be replaced.
Who Each One Works Best For
West Elm’s Cool Walnut furniture is an excellent match for urban dwellers, first-time homeowners, renters, and anyone who enjoys staying current with design trends. If you love the mid-century modern aesthetic, need pieces that will fit in a smaller home or apartment, and are working within a moderate budget, West Elm is the clear winner.
Acorn furniture is tailored for homeowners who are investing in their “forever home” and prioritize longevity and craftsmanship. If you prefer timeless, nature-inspired design over fleeting trends and are willing to pay more for solid wood heirloom quality, Acorn offers pieces you can pass down for generations.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer beautiful wood furniture, but they cater to very different priorities in quality, style, and budget.
Choose West Elm's Cool Walnut Furniture if:
- You love the mid-century modern aesthetic and clean, contemporary lines.
- You are furnishing an apartment, condo, or smaller space.
- You have a moderate budget and want to maximize style for your money.
- You enjoy updating your decor every few years to keep up with trends.
Choose Acorn Furniture if:
- You want heirloom-quality, solid wood furniture that will last a lifetime.
- Your budget allows for a higher-end investment piece.
- You prefer timeless, rustic-modern, or Scandinavian styles.
- Craftsmanship, natural materials, and sustainability are your top priorities.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between West Elm Cool Walnut and Acorn furniture?
The primary difference is construction. West Elm's Cool Walnut furniture is typically made with wood veneer over an engineered wood core, prioritizing style and affordability. Acorn furniture is made from solid hardwood, prioritizing durability, craftsmanship, and longevity.
Is West Elm's Cool Walnut finish real wood?
Yes, the top layer is a real wood veneer, which is a thin slice of actual walnut. However, the core beneath it is engineered wood (like MDF), not solid wood through-and-through.
Which brand is more durable?
Acorn is significantly more durable. Solid wood construction can withstand decades of use and can be refinished to erase signs of wear. Veneer furniture from West Elm is more susceptible to irreversible damage like chipping or water swelling.
Which brand is better for small apartments?
West Elm is generally better for small apartments. They offer a wider range of compact sizes and designs with a lighter visual weight that is ideal for smaller rooms.
Why is Acorn so much more expensive than West Elm?
The price difference comes down to materials and labor. Solid hardwood is a much more expensive raw material than MDF and veneer. Additionally, Acorn's furniture is handcrafted using traditional joinery, which is a more labor-intensive and skilled process compared to mass manufacturing.
Can I see this furniture in person before buying?
West Elm has a large network of physical showrooms across the country, making it easy to see and touch their furniture before purchasing. Acorn operates primarily online and has a very limited number of boutique showrooms.
How do I care for veneer vs. solid wood?
Veneer furniture (West Elm) should be cleaned gently with a soft, dry or slightly damp cloth. Avoid harsh chemicals and protect surfaces from moisture with coasters. Solid wood (Acorn) can be cared for similarly, but it is much more forgiving, deep scratches or stains can often be sanded out and the area re-oiled or refinished.
Which brand is more sustainable?
Both brands make sustainability a priority. West Elm has large-scale initiatives for sourcing FSC-certified wood, using recycled materials, and engaging in fair-trade practices. Acorn's approach is rooted in its artisanal model - using locally sourced, sustainable wood and creating long-lasting products that discourage throwaway culture.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
