Wayfair is a massive online marketplace offering an unparalleled selection of home goods across every conceivable style and budget, from affordable basics to higher-end furniture. Bed Bath & Beyond operates as a traditional retailer with both physical stores and a robust online presence, focusing on a more curated selection of trusted, practical home essentials like bedding, kitchenware, and organization tools.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home decor retailer for your space.
Wayfair: The Online Megastore for Everything Home
Wayfair established itself as a go-to online destination for furniture and home decor, offering a seemingly endless catalog of products. The brand aggregates items from thousands of suppliers, making it a one-stop-shop for customers furnishing a home from scratch, especially young professionals, families, and DIY decorators who value variety and competitive pricing.
- Product mix: A vast selection spanning furniture, lighting, rugs, decor, outdoor gear, and even major appliances. You can find everything from a $200 sofa to a $2,000 bedroom set.
- Style/vibe: Extremely diverse, covering contemporary, modern, farmhouse, rustic, and eclectic aesthetics. Its wide range makes it easy to find pieces that fit nearly any interior design theme.
- Price point: Ranges from very affordable to mid-range. It's known for budget-friendly finds, frequent sales, and daily deals.
- Quality: Quality can be inconsistent as it varies widely between the thousands of brands featured on the site. Shoppers should rely heavily on customer photos and reviews to vet products.
- Sales: Sales are almost constant, with major events like Way Day offering some of the best discounts of the year.
- Return policy: Offers a straightforward 30-day return policy for most items in their original condition, though return shipping fees may apply.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers multiple delivery options, including free shipping on most orders over $35 and optional white-glove service for large furniture assembly.
Wayfair is the perfect choice for shoppers who want a gigantic selection, enjoy hunting for deals, and are comfortable making purchases based on online reviews and product dimensions.
Shop Wayfair: wayfair.com
Bed Bath & Beyond: The Reliable Home Essentials Hub
Bed Bath & Beyond is a well-known name in home retail, famous for its big blue coupons and physical stores that allow customers to see and touch products. It specializes in home essentials, offering a trusted, curated selection for the kitchen, bedroom, and bathroom, catering to homeowners and families seeking functionality and brand reliability.
- Product mix: Focuses heavily on bedding, bath supplies, kitchenware, cleaning tools, small appliances, and home organization. They also carry a selection of smaller furniture pieces like accent chairs and storage solutions.
- Style/vibe: Leans toward classic, traditional, and functional designs. The aesthetic favors practicality over trend-chasing, ensuring pieces are timeless and easy to integrate into most homes.
- Price point: Pricing is competitive, especially when using their frequent coupons and discounts. Prices for items like sofas can range from $300 to $800 before applying any deals.
- Quality: Product quality is generally more consistent than Wayfair, as they offer trusted national brands alongside their own private labels. This leads to a more predictable shopping experience.
- Rewards program: Offers a loyalty program that provides rewards and discounts, which can be combined with their famous coupons for significant savings.
- Return policy: Offers easy returns, with the added benefit of being able to return online orders to physical store locations.
- Delivery & Assembly: Provides in-store pickup, same-day delivery in many areas, and standard shipping for online orders. The focus is on convenience for everyday essentials.
Bed Bath & Beyond is ideal for shoppers looking for reliable name-brand home goods, who appreciate the ability to shop in-store, and love a good coupon.
Shop Bed Bath & Beyond: bedbathandbeyond.com
Wayfair vs. Bed Bath & Beyond Comparison
Price Comparison
Wayfair generally has lower starting prices across a broader range of products. It's common to find sofas under $300 and dining sets for less than $400. Their frequent sitewide sales and "Open Box" deals provide even more opportunities for savings, making it a budget-shopper's favorite.
Bed Bath & Beyond's list prices may seem slightly higher on average, but their value comes from persistent coupons (like the famous 20% off one item deal) and a rewards program. For specific categories like kitchen appliances or bedding sets from known brands, a well-timed coupon at Bed Bath & Beyond can often beat Wayfair's price.
Style & Aesthetic
If variety is what you need, Wayfair is the clear winner. Its enormous catalog covers every design style imaginable, from minimalist and Scandinavian to rustic-industrial and maximalist glam. They are also responsive to current trends, quickly adding collections that reflect the latest in interior design.
Bed Bath & Beyond has a more cohesive and conservative style. Their selection centers on classic, traditional, and transitional pieces that are functional and built for everyday life. While you can find contemporary items, the overall aesthetic is less about making a bold design statement and more about creating a comfortable, practical home.
Quality & Construction
Quality at Wayfair is a mixed bag. As a marketplace for thousands of vendors, the materials and construction can range from low-end engineered wood and simple upholstery to premium solid wood and high-performance fabrics. Reading customer reviews and paying close attention to product specifications is essential to avoid disappointment.
Bed Bath & Beyond offers a more predictable level of quality. Because they curate their selection from established brands and develop their own product lines, there's more consistency. You can generally trust that the construction and materials meet a reliable standard, reducing the guesswork compared to shopping on a vast marketplace.
Product Selection
Wayfair’s selection is immense, extending far beyond typical decor into categories like large appliances, flooring, and bathroom vanities. If you are furnishing an entire home or undertaking a remodel, Wayfair offers the convenience of finding almost everything in one place.
Bed Bath & Beyond has a much more focused inventory. Their strength lies in domain-specific categories: bed linens, bath towels, kitchen gadgets, vacuums, and small-scale storage. While they do not have the large furniture variety of Wayfair, their depth in these core home categories is excellent.
Shopping Experience
Wayfair offers a best-in-class online shopping experience with powerful search filters, idea boards, and a "View in Room" AR feature. The entire journey is designed for digital convenience, from browsing to checkout and delivery scheduling.
Bed Bath & Beyond provides a hybrid experience. Their website is easy to navigate, but their key advantage is their network of physical stores. This allows shoppers to see products in person, get a feel for quality, and enjoy the convenience of immediate in-store pickup or hassle-free returns.
Delivery & Assembly
For large items, Wayfair's optional white-glove delivery service, which includes room-of-choice placement and assembly, is a major benefit. Their shipping network is built to handle oversized items like sectionals and bed frames efficiently.
Bed Bath & Beyond focuses on quicker gratification for smaller items. With options like same-day delivery and buy-online-pickup-in-store, it's ideal for when you need a new set of sheets or a coffee maker right away. Their delivery services are not as focused on large, heavy furniture.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your shopping preferences, what you're looking for, and your priorities.
Choose Wayfair if:
- You want the broadest possible selection of furniture and decor across all styles.
- You are furnishing a space on a tight budget and need access to very low price points.
- You are confident shopping online and diligently read customer reviews and product details.
- You need large items like a sectional sofa, dining table, or major appliance.
Choose Bed Bath & Beyond if:
- You prefer seeing and touching products in a physical store before committing.
- You are primarily looking for bedding, bath essentials, kitchenware, or small appliances.
- You are a savvy shopper who loves taking advantage of coupons and rewards programs.
- You need an item today and want to use in-store pickup or same-day delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Wayfair or Bed Bath & Beyond cheaper?
Wayfair typically has lower sticker prices and more options at budget-friendly price points. However, Bed Bath & Beyond's frequent coupons and promotions can often make their products more affordable, especially for branded items.
Which has better quality furniture?
Bed Bath & Beyond generally offers a more consistent and reliable quality level because its selection is curated from trusted brands. Quality on Wayfair can vary dramatically from excellent to poor, so it requires careful research and review-reading from the shopper.
Who has a better product selection?
Wayfair has a vastly larger and more diverse product selection, covering nearly every category of home goods, including large furniture and appliances. Bed Bath & Beyond has a more focused selection centered on essentials for the bedroom, bathroom, and kitchen.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, both have return policies for furniture. Wayfair's process is done via mail and may incur shipping costs. Bed Bath & Beyond offers the added convenience of returning online orders to any of their physical stores, which can be easier for smaller items.
Does Bed Bath & Beyond sell large furniture like Wayfair?
Bed Bath & Beyond's furniture selection is much smaller and focuses on accent pieces like chairs, ottomans, headboards, and storage cabinets. They do not have the extensive catalog of sofas, sectionals, and large dining sets that Wayfair offers.
Do both stores have physical locations?
Only Bed Bath & Beyond operates physical retail stores. Wayfair is an online-only retailer, though it has opened a few flagship stores in select locations.
Which store ships faster?
For small- to medium-sized items, Bed Bath & Beyond often ships faster and offers same-day delivery or in-store pickup. For large furniture, Wayfair's shipping times are competitive, though they can vary based on the supplier's location and stock.
Which is better for kitchenware and small appliances?
Bed Bath & Beyond is traditionally stronger in this category. They carry a deep selection of well-known brands like KitchenAid, Cuisinart, and OXO, and their coupons make these items very affordable. While Wayfair also sells them, BBB is more of a specialist.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
