Wayfair serves as a dedicated online home goods superstore, offering a vast, curated selection tailored specifically to furniture and decor. In contrast, Amazon Furniture operates as a massive open marketplace, providing endless variety and the convenience of Prime shipping but with a less guided shopping experience. Wayfair excels with its style-based filters and in-house brands, while Amazon's strength lies in its competitive pricing from third-party sellers, extensive user reviews, and unparalleled delivery speed.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right online furniture retailer for your home.
Wayfair: The One-Stop Shop for Home Furnishings
Wayfair is one of the world's largest online-only destinations for home goods, positioning itself as a comprehensive source for everything from furniture and lighting to rugs and cookware. The website is designed to make it easy for shoppers to browse millions of items across a wide range of styles and price points. It appeals strongly to new homeowners, apartment dwellers, and anyone undertaking a decor refresh who values selection and convenience.
- Product mix: A massive inventory covering every home category, including sofas, beds, patio sets, lighting, rugs, and decor. Wayfair features a mix of its own private label brands (like AllModern and Birch Lane) and products from thousands of third-party suppliers.
- Style/vibe: Caters to nearly every aesthetic, from modern and farmhouse to industrial and coastal. The site’s strength lies in its powerful filters, allowing you to shop by specific styles, colors, and materials to create a cohesive look.
- Price point: Known for accessible and mid-range pricing. Sofas typically range from $300 to $1,500, with many popular options falling in the $700–$1,200 bracket. Dining sets can be found from $250 to over $2,000.
- Quality: Quality corresponds with price. Entry-level pieces often use engineered wood (MDF) and basic upholstery, while higher-priced collections feature solid wood frames and more durable fabrics. Customer reviews are crucial for judging a specific item's durability.
- Sales: Wayfair runs frequent sales events, including its major annual "Way Day" sale, offering deep discounts across the site. It's rare not to find a sale category active at any given time.
- Delivery & Assembly: Most items ship for free over $35. Large items like sofas or bed frames are delivered to your doorstep, with options to upgrade to in-room or white-glove assembly services for an additional fee. Assembly is typically required.
- Return policy: You can return most items within 30 days of delivery for a refund or store credit, though you will have to cover the return shipping costs, which can be significant for large furniture.
Wayfair provides an approachable, specialized shopping ecosystem for home goods, making it ideal for those who want a guided experience in finding pieces that fit a specific aesthetic.
Shop Wayfair: wayfair.com
Amazon Furniture: The Marketplace of Endless Options
As the "everything store," Amazon's furniture department is a vast and varied marketplace featuring millions of products from countless global sellers. It is not a curated furniture brand itself, but rather a platform where established brands and small businesses alike offer their goods. Amazon's furniture shopping experience leans heavily on user reviews, its powerful search engine, and the major benefit of fast, free Prime shipping.
- Product mix: An almost limitless selection of furniture, including sofas, office chairs, bed frames, storage solutions, and outdoor sets. It features products from thousands of brands like Zinus and Ashley Furniture, alongside countless unbranded options.
- Style/vibe: Highly eclectic and uncurated. You can find minimalist, traditional, bohemian, and modern pieces, but you’ll need to do the legwork to sort through the noise. There are fewer tools to help you build a cohesive room compared to specialized retailers.
- Price point: The price spectrum is enormous. You can find basic end tables for under $50, functional sofas starting around $250, and high-end designer pieces for several thousand dollars. Prime Day and Black Friday often bring significant deals.
- Quality: Quality varies dramatically from seller to seller. Some products are made with particleboard and thin fabrics, while others from more reputable brands feature solid wood and high-performance materials. Reading customer reviews and checking seller ratings is non-negotiable.
- Shopping Experience: The familiar Amazon interface, extensive Q&A sections, and customer-submitted photos are invaluable. The ability to filter by Prime shipping, average review, and specific features makes narrowing the selection easier.
- Delivery & Assembly: This is a key advantage. Amazon Prime offers free and incredibly fast two-day (or even same-day) delivery on many items. Most furniture requires self-assembly, although an "Expert Assembly" service can often be added at checkout for a fee.
- Return policy: Generally offers a generous 30-day return policy on most items, with a relatively hassle-free process, which is a major draw for buying sight-unseen furniture online.
Amazon is the ultimate destination for price-sensitive buyers who prioritize delivery speed and are willing to dig through reviews to find a great deal.
Shop Amazon Furniture: amazon.com/furniture
Wayfair vs. Amazon Furniture Comparison
Price Comparison
Both platforms are highly competitive on price and cater to budget-conscious shoppers. Wayfair’s pricing feels more structured, with frequent, predictable sales events (like Way Day) where you can snag significant markdowns. Its private labels help keep costs down, offering stylish looks for less.
Amazon's pricing is more dynamic and often dictated by third-party sellers competing with each other. This can result in some of the lowest prices on the market, especially for basic items. Lightning Deals and major sales events like Prime Day can offer deep, but often short-lived, discounts. In general, for a standard item like a mid-range sofa, prices will be comparable, but Amazon often has more ultra-low-budget options.
Style & Aesthetic
Wayfair is the clear winner for anyone seeking a curated, style-driven shopping experience. Its website is designed to help you visually coordinate pieces. You can browse curated shops, filter by aesthetic (e.g., "Modern Farmhouse," "Coastal"), and use room idea galleries for inspiration. This makes it much easier to furnish a room with a consistent look and feel.
Amazon, on the other hand, is a true marketplace. While you can search for "mid-century modern coffee table," the results will be a jumble of items from different sellers with varying quality and design interpretations. It's fantastic if you know exactly what you're looking for but less helpful for those who need design guidance.
Quality & Construction
Quality on both platforms is a mixed bag and correlates directly with the price. At the lower end, expect engineered wood, veneers, and basic polyester fabrics on both Wayfair and Amazon. Mid-range and higher-priced items will feature more solid wood, sturdier metals, and better upholstery.
The main difference is consistency. Wayfair's self-owned brands create a baseline of expected quality, even if it varies between lines. On Amazon, quality is seller-dependent. An item from a reputable brand like Christopher Knight Home will be very different from a no-name drop-shipped product. Careful reading of customer reviews, especially those with photos, is essential for judging quality on Amazon.
Shopping Experience
The shopping experience is a trade-off between specialization and convenience. Wayfair’s website is built from the ground up to sell home goods, with superior filters, room planning tools, and detailed product specifications. It feels like walking through a massive, well-organized furniture store online.
Amazon offers unmatched universal convenience. If you have Prime, the appeal of a single cart, trusted checkout process, and lightning-fast shipping is hard to beat. Its review and Q&A ecosystem is robust, often providing more user-generated content than Wayfair. However, the site's overall interface is not optimized for aesthetic furniture browsing.
Delivery & Assembly
Amazon Prime delivery is the industry gold standard for speed. Getting a new office chair or bookshelf delivered in two days for free is a powerful perk. For larger items, Amazon's scheduled delivery service works well. Wayfair's free standard shipping is also relatively fast, but it typically doesn't compete with Prime's speed. Where Wayfair has an edge is in delivery options for very large furniture, its white-glove service, which includes assembly and rubbish removal, is a valuable service that Amazon doesn't universally offer.
Return Policies
Both retailers have very good 30-day return policies, a major factor for buying large items online. Amazon’s process is famous for being incredibly simple and customer-friendly, especially for items sold directly by Amazon. For large furniture, they’ll often arrange a pickup from your home. Wayfair also accepts returns within 30 days, but the shopper is responsible for return shipping fees. For a heavy item like a sectional or dining table, these fees can be substantial, making returns more costly than on Amazon.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your priorities as a shopper, your budget, and your project's needs. Both are excellent online destinations, but they cater to different customers.
Choose Wayfair if:
- You are furnishing a room from scratch and want a cohesive, stylish look.
- You value tools like style filters and curated collections to help guide your decisions.
- You want the option for white-glove delivery and assembly for very large pieces.
- You enjoy browsing and getting inspiration just as much as buying.
Choose Amazon if:
- Fast and free shipping is your top priority.
- You are hunting for the lowest possible price on a specific type of item.
- You are a savvy shopper who dives deep into customer reviews and seller ratings.
- You value a simple, no-questions-asked return process above all else.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Wayfair or Amazon cheaper for furniture?
It depends on the item. Amazon often has lower absolute prices on very basic, commodity-like furniture due to its massive seller network. However, Wayfair's frequent and deep sitewide sales can often make mid-range, style-focused pieces more affordable than comparable items on Amazon.
Which has better quality furniture?
Neither is a high-end retailer, and quality on both platforms varies widely. Quality is not a feature of the platform but of the individual product and seller. Your best tool on both sites is to meticulously read the product description for materials (e.g., "solid wood" vs. "MDF") and scrutinize recent customer reviews with photos.
Can you return furniture to both Wayfair and Amazon?
Yes, both have 30-day return policies. Amazon's return process is generally considered easier and often free. Wayfair also accepts returns but usually requires you to pay the return shipping fees, which can be expensive for heavy furniture.
Is assembly required for furniture from both retailers?
Yes, the vast majority of furniture from both Wayfair and Amazon will require assembly. Both offer add-on professional assembly services for an additional cost at checkout on many items.
Which platform is better for finding a specific style?
Wayfair is significantly better for style-based shopping. Its navigation, filters, and curated collections are all designed to help you find and coordinate items that fit a particular aesthetic, like modern coastal, traditional, or industrial.
Does Wayfair have a membership like Amazon Prime?
No. Wayfair offers its own branded credit card with benefits like rewards or special financing, but it does not have a subscription membership like Amazon Prime that offers universal free, fast shipping.
Which is better for small spaces?
Both platforms have excellent options for small spaces. Wayfair has specific filters for "small space" furniture that makes it easier to find apartment-sized sofas and dining sets. Amazon's sheer volume means you can also find plenty of compact furniture by searching keywords like "apartment sofa" or "small dining table."
What well-known furniture brands can you find on Amazon?
Amazon's marketplace includes hundreds of recognizable brands, especially those known for affordable, ready-to-assemble furniture. You can find popular brands like Zinus (bed frames and mattresses), Ashley Furniture (sofas and case goods), and Christopher Knight Home.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
