Tuft and Needle is a direct-to-consumer brand focused on high-quality foam mattresses with a straightforward online shopping experience, while IKEA is a global furniture retailer offering a wider variety of mattress types, including foam, spring, and hybrid models, at highly accessible price points. The primary difference is in the business model: Tuft and Needle offers a premium "bed-in-a-box" with a generous in-home trial, whereas IKEA provides budget-friendly options that you can test in-store before you buy.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right brand for your bedroom.
Tuft and Needle: The Direct-to-Consumer Comfort Specialist
Tuft and Needle disrupted the mattress industry by simplifying the shopping process and offering high-quality foam mattresses directly to consumers online. The brand is known for its proprietary foam, a generous 100-night trial, and a hassle-free return policy, which appeals to modern shoppers who value convenience, transparency, and a quality product without the traditional showroom markup.
- Product mix: Primarily focused on mattresses, including their original T&N model, the premium Mint mattress, and a hybrid option. They also offer pillows, mattress toppers, and some basic bed frames.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist and modern. The focus is on sleep performance and comfort rather than visual design, with clean lines and a simple aesthetic that fits into any bedroom.
- Price point: Mid-range and value-driven. A queen-size mattress typically runs from $495 to $995, positioning them as a more affordable premium alternative to legacy brands.
- Quality: Known for their durable and supportive T&N Adaptive® foam, which is designed for pressure relief and breathability. All foams are CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring they are free from harmful chemicals.
- Delivery &, Assembly: Mattresses are compressed, sealed in a box, and shipped for free directly to your door. Assembly is as simple as unboxing, unrolling, and letting the mattress expand for a few hours.
- Return policy: A key feature is their 100-night sleep trial. If you don't love the mattress within that period, they offer a full refund and coordinate a local pickup for donation or recycling.
Tuft and Needle offers a hassle-free way to buy a high-quality, durable foam mattress online, making it ideal for shoppers who prioritize long-term comfort and convenience.
Shop Tuft and Needle: tuftandneedle.com
IKEA: The Budget-Friendly Furnishing Giant
IKEA is a world-renowned Swedish brand famous for its affordable, stylish, and functional home furnishings. Their mattress collection reflects this ethos, providing a vast range of options for every budget and comfort preference. Known for its one-stop shopping experience and flat-pack convenience, IKEA is a go-to for those furnishing a first apartment, guest room, or children's bedroom without overspending.
- Product mix: Extensive, featuring a wide variety of mattress types including memory foam, latex, innerspring, and hybrid models. They also offer a full ecosystem of bed frames, bedding, and bedroom furniture.
- Style/vibe: Rooted in simple, practical Scandinavian design. The mattresses are designed to be functional and fit seamlessly with IKEA's broader range of home decor products.
- Price point: Highly budget-friendly. Queen-size mattresses can start as low as $150 for basic foam models and go up to around $800 for higher-end hybrid options.
- Quality: Varies significantly by price. Higher-end models offer good value and durability, but entry-level mattresses are best suited for temporary or light use, as they may lack the advanced foam technology and long-term support of specialized brands.
- Delivery &, Assembly: Mattresses are typically sold rolled up for easy transport. You can pick them up in-store or have them delivered for a fee. Assembly is minimal - just unroll and let it expand.
- Return policy: IKEA allows you to exchange your mattress once within 90 days for a different one if you're not satisfied, but this is a one-time exchange policy, not a cash refund trial. Unopened mattresses can be returned for a full refund.
IKEA is the go-to for shoppers on a tight budget or those who need a functional mattress quickly, offering the unique advantage of in-store testing before purchasing.
Shop IKEA: ikea.com
Tuft and Needle vs. IKEA Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear price distinction between the two brands. IKEA is the undisputed winner on upfront cost, with some queen mattresses available for under $200. This makes them an extremely accessible option for students, temporary living situations, or guest rooms that see infrequent use.
Tuft and Needle operates in a mid-range price tier, with their entry-level queen starting around $495. While more expensive, the price reflects a higher quality of materials, better construction, and superior durability. Tuft and Needle provides better long-term value, as their mattresses are designed to last for years, whereas IKEA's most affordable models may need replacing sooner.
Quality & Materials
Tuft and Needle builds its reputation on quality materials. Their proprietary T&N Adaptive® foam balances softness with firm support, provides excellent pressure relief, and is infused with graphite and cooling gel for temperature regulation. Being CertiPUR-US certified also gives peace of mind regarding chemical emissions and safety.
IKEA's material quality is directly tied to the price tag. Their cheapest foam mattresses use basic polyurethane foam that may not offer the same level of support or longevity. Their more expensive models, which include latex and hybrid pocket-spring options, are much better and offer good comfort. However, across the board, Tuft and Needle's specialized foam technology generally provides more consistent performance and durability.
Shopping Experience
The shopping experiences could not be more different. Tuft and Needle offers a streamlined, risk-free online process. You can research, order, and receive your mattress without leaving home. The 100-night trial is a core part of their model, as it gives you ample time to determine if the mattress is right for you in the real world.
IKEA offers a traditional retail experience combined with online shopping. The biggest advantage is the ability to visit a massive showroom and physically lie on dozens of different mattresses to find one that feels right. This in-person testing is crucial for many shoppers. While they offer delivery, the process can be more complex, and their return policy is an exchange-only offer rather than a full refund trial period.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands take sustainability seriously. Tuft and Needle uses CertiPUR-US certified foams, meaning they are made without ozone depleters, mercury, lead, and other heavy metals, and have low VOC emissions for better indoor air quality.
IKEA has extensive global initiatives aimed at using renewable and recycled materials, reducing waste in its supply chain, and becoming "climate positive" by 2030. They have strong commitments to responsible wood sourcing and other eco-friendly practices. While both are commendable, IKEA's scale allows for broader environmental initiatives across its entire product line.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your budget, preference for online vs. in-store shopping, and how long you need the mattress to last.
Choose Tuft and Needle if:
- You prioritize long-term comfort and durability for your primary bed.
- You want high-quality pressure-relieving foam that provides consistent support.
- You prefer a simple online shopping experience with a generous, risk-free home trial.
- Your budget is in the mid-range (around $500–$1,000 for a queen).
Choose IKEA if:
- You are on a very tight budget.
- You want to test out a mattress in-person before making a decision.
- You need a mattress for a guest room, a child's bed, or a short-term living arrangement.
- You are looking for a wider variety of mattress types, including innerspring and latex.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Tuft and Needle or IKEA cheaper?
IKEA is significantly cheaper. You can purchase a basic IKEA foam mattress for as little as $150, while the most affordable queen from Tuft and Needle starts around $495. IKEA's main appeal is its extreme affordability.
Which has better quality furniture?
Tuft and Needle generally offers better quality and more durable mattresses. Their proprietary foam is designed for long-term support and comfort, which is why it comes with a 10-year warranty and a higher price tag. The quality of IKEA mattresses varies greatly by model.
Which mattress lasts longer?
A Tuft and Needle mattress is engineered for longevity and typically lasts longer than most of IKEA’s entry-level and mid-range options. It's considered a better long-term investment for a primary bedroom.
Can you return a mattress to both stores?
Yes, but their policies are very different. Tuft and Needle offers a 100-night trial with a full refund if you're not satisfied. IKEA allows a one-time exchange for a different mattress within 90 days but does not offer a free trial with a full refund once the mattress has been used.
Is Tuft and Needle or IKEA better for back pain?
For sleepers with back pain, the consistent support and pressure-relieving qualities of Tuft and Needle's Adaptive Foam are likely to provide more relief than the basic foam found in IKEA's budget mattresses. Proper support is key, making Tuft and Needle a safer bet.
Do I have to assemble the mattress myself?
Both brands sell mattresses that are easy to set up. They typically come rolled or folded in a box. You simply take the mattress out, unroll it onto your bed frame, and allow it to expand to its full size, which can take a few hours to a full day.
Can I try IKEA mattresses before buying?
Yes, one of the biggest advantages of shopping at IKEA is that you can visit their enormous retail stores and lie down on their entire mattress display to test them out before you make a purchase.
Which is better for guest rooms?
Due to its low price point, IKEA is an excellent choice for a guest room mattress that won't be used every night. You can get a comfortable-enough option without spending a lot of money.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
