Tuft & Needle is a direct-to-consumer brand known for its affordable yet high-quality foam mattresses and simple, functional bedding. In contrast, Brooklinen positions itself as a premium home essentials label, specializing in luxurious bedding made from high-end materials like long-staple cotton and linen. The core difference lies in their primary focus: Tuft & Needle solves foundational sleep comfort at a great value, while Brooklinen focuses on elevating the bedroom with premium, stylish textiles.
Let's compare these two popular brands to help you decide which one is the right fit for your home.
Tuft & Needle: The Affordable Sleep Solution
Founded in 2012, Tuft & Needle disrupted the mattress industry by offering a high-quality, comfortable foam mattress directly to consumers online, cutting out steep retail markups. The brand is built on transparency, simplicity, and value, appealing to first-time buyers, young professionals, and anyone seeking a straightforward, reliable sleep setup without a huge financial investment.
- Product mix: Primarily known for mattresses, particularly their flagship foam model. They also offer pillows, mattress toppers, bed frames, and a basic line of bedding.
- Style/vibe: Modern and minimalistic. Their designs are clean, functional, and easily integrate into almost any contemporary bedroom style.
- Price point: Very accessible. A queen-size Original Mattress typically costs around $495, and bedding accessories usually fall between $20–$100.
- Quality & Materials: Mattresses feature their proprietary T&N Adaptive® foam, which is CertiPUR-US certified to be free from harmful chemicals. It’s designed to provide pressure relief and support with a moderate amount of cooling.
- Shopping experience: The website provides a simple, streamlined process. They offer a 100-night sleep trial for their mattresses, with free shipping and hassle-free returns.
- Sustainability: Beyond the CertiPUR-US certification, the brand focuses on responsible manufacturing and waste reduction in their production facilities.
Tuft & Needle is an excellent choice for shoppers who prioritize a comfortable, quality mattress at an unbeatable price point.
Shop Tuft & Needle: tuftandneedle.com
Brooklinen: The Premium Bedding Expert
Brooklinen entered the scene in 2014 with a mission to deliver luxury-hotel-quality bedding at a more accessible price than traditional high-end retailers. The brand emphasizes superior materials, expert craftsmanship, and timeless design. It appeals to discerning shoppers who are willing to invest more in their sleep environment for durability, comfort, and a touch of elegance.
- Product mix: Extensive collection of premium home textiles, including sheets, duvet covers, comforters, pillows, towels, and loungewear. Their specific focus is on bedding.
- Style/vibe: Sophisticated and refined. Their collections often feature classic designs, tasteful patterns, and a curated color palette that brings a polished, luxurious feel to the bedroom.
- Price point: Premium. Classic Percale or Luxe Sateen sheet sets begin around $150 for a queen, with comforters ranging from $200–$400.
- Quality & Materials: Known for using high-end materials like long-staple cotton, linen, and cashmere. Many of their products are OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety and GOTS certified for organic content.
- Shopping experience: Offers a more curated and inspirational shopping journey with beautiful imagery and styling advice. They provide an impressive 365-day trial period on most products.
- Sustainability: Committed to ethical manufacturing and responsible sourcing of natural fibers, alongside eco-friendly packaging and textile certifications.
Brooklinen is the superior option for those prioritizing premium fabrics, sophisticated style, and long-lasting quality in their bedding and bath linens.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Tuft & Needle vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a significant price difference between the two brands that reflects their target audiences. Tuft & Needle is the clear winner on affordability. With a high-quality queen mattress under $500, they provide some of the best value in the sleep space for foundational items.
Brooklinen operates in a premium-to-luxury category. While their prices are competitive for the quality they offer, a single set of their popular Luxe Sateen sheets costs more than a third of a Tuft & Needle mattress. Brooklinen positions its products as a long-term investment in comfort and style, whereas Tuft & Needle focuses on immediate function and value.
Quality & Materials
Both brands prioritize quality, but they define it differently. For Tuft & Needle, quality means durable, certified-safe foam that provides reliable support and comfort for years. Their foam is engineered for performance and safety, earning the CertiPUR-US seal.
Brooklinen's quality is rooted in the materials' feel and origin. They use long-staple cotton, which results in stronger, finer, and softer threads than regular cotton, ensuring the sheets are both breathable and durable. Certifications like OEKO-TEX and GOTS provide an added layer of assurance about the safety and sustainability of their textiles. In terms of sheer tactile luxury, Brooklinen has a clear edge.
Style & Aesthetic
Tuft & Needle embodies a minimalist, modern aesthetic. Their products feature solid, neutral colors and clean lines, designed to work in any space without making a loud statement. The style is utilitarian yet pleasing, perfect for those who prefer an uncluttered, contemporary look.
Brooklinen offers a more refined and intentional style. Their color palette is sophisticated, and they frequently offer limited-edition colors and classic patterns like stripes or windowpane. Their products are designed to be a centerpiece of the bedroom decor, evoking the feeling of a well-appointed, elegant space.
Shopping Experience
Both brands offer excellent direct-to-consumer online experiences. The Tuft & Needle website is built for efficiency, making it easy to understand the product benefits and complete a purchase quickly. Their 100-night trial on mattresses is a major confidence booster for such a significant purchase.
Brooklinen offers a more immersive experience, with beautiful photography and content that helps you imagine the products in your own home. Their standout feature is an incredibly generous 365-day return policy on most items, which allows you to sleep on sheets for nearly a year to decide if you love them. This policy demonstrates immense confidence in their product quality.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands have strong commitments to sustainability. Tuft & Needle's focus is on what's inside their mattresses - foams that are free of harmful chemicals and have low VOC emissions. They also work to manufacture responsibly in the USA.
Brooklinen’s efforts are concentrated on their textiles. By using natural fibers from responsible sources and securing certifications like GOTS and OEKO-TEX, they ensure their products are safe for both consumers and the environment. They are also transparent about their ethical manufacturing standards.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands are excellent choices, but they cater to very different customers and product needs.
Choose Tuft & Needle if:
- You are primarily shopping for an affordable, high-quality mattress.
- Your budget is a top priority, and you're looking for the best value.
- You prefer a simple, modern, and minimalist design aesthetic.
- You appreciate a straightforward, no-fuss shopping experience for sleep essentials.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You are focused on upgrading your bedding with premium sheets, comforters, or duvet covers.
- You are willing to invest more for luxurious materials and superior craftsmanship.
- You want a sophisticated, classic aesthetic for your bedroom.
- You value an extra-long trial period (365 days) to ensure you love your purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Tuft & Needle or Brooklinen cheaper?
Tuft & Needle is significantly cheaper. Their core product, a foam mattress, is an entry-level to mid-range item, while their bedding is also priced for accessibility. Brooklinen operates in the premium market, where their luxury sheet sets can cost hundreds of dollars.
Which has better quality furniture?
This depends on the product. Tuft & Needle's mattress quality is excellent for its price, offering durable, CertiPUR-US certified foam. Brooklinen's quality shines in its textiles, their long-staple cotton sheets are softer, more durable, and more breathable than standard bedding. Each excels in its respective product category.
Does Brooklinen sell mattresses?
No, Brooklinen does not sell mattresses. Their brand is entirely focused on bedding, bath products, and other home textiles and accessories. If you need a mattress, Tuft & Needle is the brand to consider between the two.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
While Tuft & Needle designs its foam to be more breathable than traditional memory foam, natural fibers are often superior for temperature regulation. Brooklinen's Classic Percale cotton sheets, as well as their linen collection, are exceptionally light and airy, making them a fantastic choice for hot sleepers.
What are the return policies?
Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night sleep trial for their mattresses. If you don't love it, they'll arrange for a pickup and give you a full refund. Brooklinen has one of the most generous policies in the industry, offering a 365-day trial period on most of their products, giving you ample time to wash and sleep on their sheets to ensure they are the right fit.
Is Tuft & Needle bedding comfortable?
Yes, Tuft & Needle bedding is designed to be comfortable and functional. It tends to be made from materials like jersey knit or percale, offering a soft and breathable feel at a great price. However, it's not designed to compete with the sheer luxury and specific weave options (like sateen) found at Brooklinen.
Is Brooklinen worth the price?
For those who prioritize the feel and longevity of their bedding, most customers find Brooklinen to be worth the price. The use of premium, long-staple cotton results in sheets that get softer with every wash and are highly durable. If feeling a touch of luxury every night is important to you, Brooklinen is a worthy investment.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
