The Toddy Cold Brew System and the Oxo Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker serve the same function but approach it from different angles, focusing on either simplicity or design. The Toddy system, from the brand Toddy, is a famously simple, large-capacity brewer known for its affordability and consistent results, whereas the Oxo model is a sleek, compact, and feature-rich appliance designed for modern kitchens and ease of use.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you pick the right cold brew maker for your home.
Toddy Cold Brew System
The Toddy is a legacy product in the world of at-home coffee, famous for its straightforward, no-frills method of making low-acid coffee concentrate. It is a workhorse brewer that prioritizes function and reliability over aesthetics, making it a long-time favorite for coffee enthusiasts who want a consistent, large batch without any complicated steps or technology.
- What it is: A simple, immersion-style cold brew system consisting of a brewing container, a decanter, a reusable felt filter, and a rubber stopper.
- Key features: Large brewing capacity, minimal moving parts, and a proven immersion method that produces a smooth, rich concentrate.
- Price: Around $30 - $40, making it one of the most budget-friendly options available.
- Dimensions: Approximately 7-8" in diameter and 12" tall, requiring some dedicated counter or storage space.
- Materials/Construction: Built with durable, BPA-free plastic designed for longevity and frequent use.
- Style: Utilitarian and classic. Its functional design is meant for performance, not to be a countertop showpiece.
- Pros: Very affordable, incredibly easy to use and clean, produces consistently smooth coffee, durable build, and large capacity is great for making a week's worth of coffee at once.
- Cons: A bit bulky and may not fit in smaller refrigerators or cabinets easily. The design is dated compared to modern alternatives. Requires purchasing new filters periodically.
The Toddy is perfect for budget-conscious coffee lovers, beginners, or anyone who values a simple, reliable brewer that just works and can make large volumes of concentrate.
Shop this product: [toddy_product_url]
Oxo Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Oxo is known for thoughtful, ergonomic kitchen tools, and their cold brew maker is no exception. It combines a sophisticated look with innovative features to streamline the brewing and dispensing process. It's designed for someone who appreciates both form and function and wants a clean, compact unit that looks great sitting on the kitchen counter.
- What it is: A modern, compact cold brew maker with an integrated filtration and dispensing system.
- Key features: Sleek, space-saving design, borosilicate glass carafe with measurement markings, and a built-in switch to easily dispense coffee concentrate without mess.
- Price: Typically ranges from $50 - $70.
- Dimensions: More compact at around 6" in diameter and 9" tall, ideal for smaller kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: High-quality, BPA-free plastics and durable borosilicate glass give it a premium feel.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and stylish. It is designed to complement contemporary kitchen aesthetics.
- Pros: Beautiful countertop-friendly design, compact footprint saves space, clean and easy "rainmaker" water distribution system, simple one-touch dispensing lever, and all components stack for neat storage.
- Cons: More expensive than the Toddy system. Smaller brewing capacity may not be sufficient for households with multiple coffee drinkers. More parts to clean.
The Oxo Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker is a fantastic choice for design-conscious individuals in smaller homes or anyone who wants a more refined, mess-free brewing experience.
Shop this product: [oxo_product_url]
Toddy vs. Oxo Comparison
Design & Footprint
The most immediate difference between the Toddy and Oxo brewers is their design and size. The Toddy has a large, utilitarian bucket-and-decanter design that is built for function. At nearly a foot tall, it takes up significant counter space and might be too tall for some refrigerator shelves. It's a system you likely store away when not in use.
Conversely, the Oxo is designed with aesthetics and space-saving in mind. Its compact, cylindrical body and sleek look make it a device you can proudly leave on the counter. The components nest within each other for tidy storage, making it the clear winner for apartments, small kitchens, or anyone with limited cabinet space.
Ease of Use & Brewing Process
Both systems simplify cold brewing, but in different ways. Toddy's process is almost foolproof: you add coffee and water to the brewing container, let it steep, then place it on top of the decanter to drain. The key step is pulling the stopper, which can sometimes be messy if not done carefully.
Oxo aims to refine this process. Its "rainmaker" top helps distribute water evenly over the coffee grounds, and a built-in lever starts and stops the flow of concentrate into the glass carafe with no mess or fuss. This integrated dispensing system gives the Oxo a slight edge in cleanliness and sophistication during the filtering stage.
Materials & Durability
Both systems use durable, BPA-free plastic, and both are built to last. The Toddy is a testament to simple, robust construction - its thick plastic parts can withstand years of use with very little wear and tear. It has a workhorse reputation proven by decades of customer use.
The Oxo feels more premium, combining high-quality plastics with a sturdy borosilicate glass carafe. The construction is solid and reflects Oxo's commitment to quality kitchenware. While its dispensing mechanism introduces a potential point of failure that the Toddy doesn't have, it's a well-engineered component designed for long-term reliability.
Price & Value
There's a clear price difference. The Toddy cold brew system is the budget choice at roughly $30-$40, offering incredible value for what it does. It's the economical pick for getting started with large-batch cold brew without a significant investment.
The Oxo is more of a premium appliance, priced around $50-$70. The higher cost is justified by its superior design, space-saving features, cleaner dispensing system, and overall polished user experience. Its value lies in making the cold brew process feel a little more elegant and convenient, especially for those who see kitchen tools as part of their home's decor.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both systems deliver excellent cold brew concentrate, but they excel in different areas and suit different home coffee brewers.
Choose the Toddy if:
- You're on a tighter budget and want the best value for your money.
- You want to make large batches of concentrate to last the entire week.
- You prioritize proven simplicity and reliability over modern features.
- You have ample counter or storage space for a larger brewer.
Choose the Oxo if:
- Kitchen aesthetics are important to you and you want an appliance that looks great on your counter.
- You live in an apartment or have limited kitchen space.
- You prefer a very clean, mess-free dispensing method.
- You're willing to pay more for enhanced user experience and a more compact design.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between the Toddy and Oxo?
The main difference is their design philosophy. The Toddy is a simple, large, and affordable brewer focused purely on function. The Oxo is a compact, stylish, and feature-rich brewer designed for modern kitchens and a more convenient user experience.
Which one is easier to clean?
The Toddy is slightly easier to clean due to its simple, two-piece design (fewer nooks and crannies). The Oxo has more components, including the rainmaker lid and the filter mechanism, which require a bit more attention when washing.
How much coffee concentrate does each one make?
The standard Toddy system is larger and typically yields around 50 ounces of coffee concentrate. The Oxo Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker is smaller and produces up to 24 ounces of concentrate.
Is the Oxo worth the extra money?
If you value a space-saving design, countertop aesthetics, and a foolproof, mess-free release mechanism, then the extra cost for the Oxo is likely worth it. If you just want good cold brew and don't care about looks, the Toddy offers better purely financial value.
Do I need special filters for the Toddy?
Yes, the Toddy System uses thick, felt-like disc filters that are reusable several times. You will need to buy replacement filters periodically. Oxo uses included perforated and paper filters, which are also available for repurchase.
Which one is better for beginners?
Both are great for beginners. The Toddy's dead-simple process makes it impossible to mess up, but the Oxo's guided features, like measurement markings and the easy-pour lid, can feel more user-friendly for someone brand new to making coffee at home.
Can the Toddy fit in the fridge while it’s brewing?
Its height (around 12 inches) can make it a tight squeeze for many standard refrigerators. The Oxo, at just 9 inches high, is much more likely to fit on a fridge shelf during the brewing phase.
Which one produces a less acidic coffee?
Both immersion systems are excellent at producing low-acid coffee. The Toddy brand built its reputation on creating a famously smooth, low-acid coffee profile, which it consistently delivers.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
