Thomasville is a classic American brand rooted in traditional, heirloom-quality craftsmanship, offering timeless and often ornate designs. In contrast, Ethan Allen provides a more versatile blend of traditional, transitional, and modern styles with a strong emphasis on extensive customization to fit a wider range of interiors.
Let's explore everything you need to know to choose the right home furniture brand for your space.
Thomasville: The Classic American Heritage Brand
With a history spanning over a century, Thomasville has built its reputation on creating elegant, durable furniture inspired by classic American design. The brand is known for its high-quality, handcrafted pieces that often feature rich wood finishes and intricate detailing. Thomasville appeals to customers who are looking to invest in timeless, well-made furniture that can be passed down through generations, making it a staple for traditional and formal home interiors.
- Product mix: Full home furnishings, including comprehensive bedroom sets, formal dining room collections, living room sofas and case goods, and custom upholstery.
- Style/vibe: Predominantly traditional and classic. Designs lean towards formal elegance with an emphasis on craftsmanship, carved wood details, and rich finishes.
- Price point: Mid-to-high end. Sofas typically start around $1,200, while complete bedroom or dining sets can often exceed $3,000.
- Quality: Known for solid wood construction using high-quality woods like cherry and maple, traditional joinery techniques, and meticulous hand-applied finishes that ensure longevity.
- Customization: Offers some custom upholstery options, but the primary focus is on the brand's established collection designs rather than extensive personalization.
- Shopping Experience: Primarily sold through a network of authorized furniture dealers, select online retailers, and dedicated Thomasville showrooms, often emphasizing an in-person shopping journey.
- Sustainability: The brand emphasizes responsible manufacturing, using materials like FSC-certified woods and eco-friendly finishes in many of its pieces.
Thomasville is the go-to choice for those seeking investment-quality furniture with a distinct, traditional aesthetic rooted in American heritage.
Shop Thomasville: thomasville.com
Ethan Allen: The Versatile Customization Expert
Ethan Allen is a well-established American furniture brand famous for blending quality craftsmanship with incredible design flexibility. While rooted in classic principles, its collections span traditional, transitional, and contemporary styles, making them adaptable to almost any home. The brand’s hallmark is personalization, offering a vast array of fabrics, finishes, hardware, and configuration options that allow customers to create truly bespoke pieces.
- Product mix: A comprehensive selection of home goods, including upholstered furniture, bedroom and dining sets, storage, lighting, rugs, and decor.
- Style/vibe: A versatile mix of traditional, transitional, and modern design. Pieces often feature clean lines and adaptable silhouettes that can be personalized for different aesthetics.
- Price point: Mid-range. Sofas commonly start around $1,000, and bedroom sets are typically in the $2,500–$4,000 range.
- Quality: Utilizes solid woods and high-quality engineered materials. Upholstery features durable, high-resilience foam and a wide selection of performance fabrics perfect for families.
- Customization: A key differentiator. Ethan Allen provides extensive options for fabrics, leathers, wood finishes, and hardware on most items.
- Shopping Experience: A seamless integration of their robust e-commerce website and a large network of showrooms (Design Centers) that offer complimentary interior design services.
- Sustainability: Strong commitment to eco-conscious practices, including using responsibly sourced woods, recycled materials, and finishes that meet environmental standards.
Ethan Allen is designed for the savvy homeowner who values high-quality materials and wants the flexibility to personalize furniture to perfectly match their style.
Shop Ethan Allen: ethanallen.com
Thomasville vs. Ethan Allen Comparison
Price Comparison
Both Thomasville and Ethan Allen occupy the mid-to-high end of the furniture market, but they approach pricing differently. Ethan Allen’s prices begin at a slightly more accessible point, with sofas starting around $1,000. Thomasville's entry point is a bit higher, with sofas generally starting at $1,200, reflecting its focus on classic, handcrafted details.
The final cost at Ethan Allen can increase significantly with customization - premium fabrics and finishes will raise the price. In contrast, Thomasville's pricing is more straightforward, tied directly to the specific piece from their collections. Both brands run sales during major holidays, offering significant discounts that make their investment pieces more attainable.
Style & Aesthetic
This is where the two brands diverge most clearly. Thomasville is unapologetically traditional. Its furniture is characterized by classic silhouettes, ornate wood carvings, rich, dark finishes, and formal undertones. It fits perfectly in classic, formal, or heritage-inspired homes and is less suited for modern or minimalist spaces.
Ethan Allen offers a much broader stylistic range. While they have many traditional designs, they also feature an extensive collection of transitional and modern pieces. Their aesthetic is adaptable, allowing a customer to craft a formal, traditional sofa or a sleek, contemporary sectional using the same frame with different fabrics and finishes. This versatility makes Ethan Allen suitable for a wider variety of home decorating styles.
Quality & Construction
Both brands have a strong reputation for producing durable, high-quality furniture. Thomasville is well-regarded for its use of solid wood frames, often with cherry or oak, and traditional joinery techniques that stand the test of time. Their hand-applied finishes are a marker of detailed craftsmanship.
Ethan Allen also uses high-quality solid woods and sustainable engineered materials in its construction. Their focus extends to the longevity of their upholstery, offering high-resilience foam cushions and a large selection of durable performance fabrics ideal for households with children or pets. Both brands prioritize sustainable manufacturing and offer warranties on their products, ensuring peace of mind with your purchase.
Customization Options
Ethan Allen is the clear leader in customization. Their business model is built around giving customers the power to personalize their furniture. For most upholstered items, you can choose from hundreds of fabrics and leathers, select leg styles and finishes, and even pick your cushion fill. This level of detail allows you to create a piece that is truly unique to your home.
Thomasville offers some custom options, primarily for upholstery fabrics on sofas and chairs. However, their main strength lies in their curated collections, where the design details are pre-determined by the brand to maintain stylistic consistency. Shoppers choose Thomasville for the specific designs they offer, not for the ability to build a piece from the ground up.
Shopping Experience
Your shopping journey will look quite different with these two brands. Ethan Allen provides a modern, integrated experience with a powerful website offering virtual room planners and extensive product information, complemented by a large network of Design Centers. Their in-store and online design consultants offer free services to help guide your selections.
Shopping for Thomasville is a more traditional retail experience. While their website serves as a detailed catalog, purchases are typically made through authorized dealers or in a Thomasville showroom. This encourages a more hands-on, in-person discovery process where you can see and feel the pieces before buying.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent, long-lasting furniture, but they cater to very different priorities and design sensibilities.
Choose Thomasville if:
- You love a classic, traditional, or formal interior design style.
- You are looking for heirloom-quality "investment" pieces with timeless appeal.
- You value intricate details like rich wood finishes and ornate carvings.
- You prefer choosing from a curated collection rather than being overwhelmed by choices.
Choose Ethan Allen if:
- You want the freedom to extensively customize furniture to match your unique style.
- Your aesthetic blends traditional elements with modern or transitional updates.
- You need versatile, adaptable pieces that can work in various room sizes and layouts.
- You appreciate a seamless online and in-store shopping experience with robust design services.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Thomasville or Ethan Allen cheaper?
Their price ranges are comparable, but Ethan Allen's starting prices for some categories, like sofas, can be slightly lower. However, extensive customization at Ethan Allen can quickly increase the cost, potentially making a custom piece more expensive than a standard item from a Thomasville collection.
Which has better quality furniture?
Neither brand compromises on quality, but they emphasize different aspects. Thomasville is renowned for its traditional wood craftsmanship and durable, classic construction. Ethan Allen excels in combining quality materials with modern durability features like performance fabrics and customization that stands up to family life. The "better" choice depends on whether you prioritize traditional joinery or modern material innovation.
Which brand is better for traditional homes?
Thomasville is the definitive choice for a strictly traditional home. Its entire brand identity is built on classic American design, heritage, and formal elegance, making its pieces a perfect fit for that aesthetic.
Which brand is more customizable?
Ethan Allen is significantly more customizable. They offer hundreds of fabric and leather options, dozens of wood finishes, and various hardware choices, allowing customers to co-create their furniture with the company's designers.
Can I buy from these brands online?
Yes, but the experience differs. Ethan Allen offers a full e-commerce website where you can configure and purchase items directly. Thomasville's website is more of a product catalog that directs you to local showrooms or authorized dealers to complete your purchase, though some items are available through select online retailers.
Are these brands good for families?
Both are good choices due to their durable construction. However, Ethan Allen has a slight edge for families due to its vast selection of performance fabrics that are resistant to stains and wear, making upholstery easier to maintain with children and pets.
Do both brands have sustainability initiatives?
Yes, both furniture makers are committed to sustainability. They both utilize responsibly sourced and FSC-certified woods, eco-friendly finishes, and manufacturing processes aimed at reducing waste and environmental impact.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
