Thomasville is a heritage brand known for its classic, heirloom-quality craftsmanship and timeless designs, primarily using solid woods and premium materials. In contrast, Ashley Furniture is one of the largest and most affordable furniture retailers, offering a wide variety of trendy and functional pieces at an accessible price point, often constructed from engineered wood and other value-focused materials. The core difference lies in their approach: Thomasville sells investment pieces built to last for generations, while Ashley provides stylish, budget-friendly options for more immediate needs.
This guide will walk you through the key differences to help you decide which brand is right for your home.
Thomasville: The Heirloom-Quality Heritage Brand
Thomasville has built its reputation over a century on the principles of fine craftsmanship and elegant, traditional design. Its furniture is intended for buyers looking to invest in substantial, long-lasting pieces that won't go out of style. The brand appeals to customers decorating classic, transitional, or formal spaces who prioritize durability and materials over fast-furniture trends.
- Product mix: A comprehensive selection of living room collections, bedroom sets, dining furniture, and custom upholstery designed to furnish an entire home with a cohesive, classic look.
- Style/vibe: Rooted in traditional and timeless American design. Expect elegant silhouettes, rich wood finishes, detailed carvings, and classic upholstery that suggest sophistication and permanence.
- Price point: Mid-to-luxury range. Sofas generally start around $1,200, dining sets can run from $2,000 to $5,000+, and complete bedroom sets often exceed $3,000.
- Quality: The brand's key differentiator. Thomasville pieces frequently use solid wood construction, high-grade veneers, and detailed joinery techniques. The focus is on longevity and creating heirloom-quality furniture.
- Shopping Experience: More personalized and service-oriented. Thomasville furniture is primarily sold through select showrooms and authorized retailers rather than large direct-to-consumer stores, often involving design consultations.
- Sustainability: The company often highlights its use of responsibly sourced lumber, including FSC-certified wood, and eco-friendly finishing processes.
Thomasville is for shoppers who prioritize timeless design and long-term durability, viewing furniture as a multi-generational investment.
Shop Thomasville: thomasville.com
Ashley Furniture: The Affordable & Versatile Option
Ashley Furniture is one of the most recognizable names in the industry, offering fashionable furniture at a price nearly anyone can afford. Its business model focuses on volume, variety, and convenience, making it a go-to for first-time homeowners, renters, and families needing functional, stylish pieces without a significant financial commitment. With thousands of retail locations and a massive online presence, Ashley makes furnishing a home fast and simple.
- Product mix: An enormous selection covering every category imaginable, including sofas, sectionals, bedroom furniture, kids' furniture, home office, outdoor, rugs, and mattresses.
- Style/vibe: Highly diverse and trend-driven. Ashley offers styles ranging from modern and contemporary to farmhouse, rustic, and casual, ensuring there's something to fit nearly any mainstream aesthetic.
- Price point: Entry-level to mid-range. Shoppers can find sofas starting around $399, complete bedroom sets for under $1,500, and dining tables for under $500.
- Quality: Focused on value. To keep prices low, Ashley primarily uses engineered wood, particleboard, and wood veneers with fabric or faux leather upholstery. Construction is functional for everyday use but not intended to last for decades like solid wood furniture.
- Shopping Experience: Built for convenience and accessibility. Customers can shop online for quick delivery or visit one of the many Ashley HomeStore locations for a traditional retail experience. Frequent sales and financing options are a major part of their strategy.
- Delivery & Assembly: Many items are available for quick shipping or in-store pickup. While some items come assembled, many require self-assembly to keep costs down.
For styles that are fresh, functional, and budget-friendly, Ashley offers a very accessible path to a fully furnished home.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Thomasville vs. Ashley Furniture Comparison
Price Comparison
There's very little overlap in price between these two brands. Ashley Furniture is firmly positioned as a budget-friendly leader. It’s a place where you can furnish an entire living room for the price of a single Thomasville sofa. Ashley’s affordability comes from its scale of manufacturing and use of cost-effective materials like engineered wood. Numerous sales events and financing make their furniture even more accessible.
Thomasville operates in the mid-to-luxury segment. Its higher prices reflect the cost of superior materials like solid hardwood, higher-quality fabrics, and the detailed craftsmanship involved in production. Shopping at Thomasville is an investment in quality and longevity, whereas shopping at Ashley is a transaction based on immediate needs, style, and budget.
Quality & Construction
Quality is the most significant point of difference. Thomasville builds furniture with the goal of it lasting for decades. You can expect solid wood frames, dovetail joinery on drawers, and durable, high-quality finishes. Their products are heavier, more substantial, and designed to withstand years of consistent use, making them heirloom-quality pieces you could pass down.
Ashley Furniture's construction is centered on providing style and function at a low price point. Most of its case goods are made from particleboard or MDF with laminate or veneer surfaces. Sofas might use a mix of engineered and solid wood in the frame. While perfectly serviceable for years of use, this type of construction is more susceptible to damage from moisture or moving and is not designed with the same longevity as Thomasville's lineup.
Style & Aesthetic
Thomasville's aesthetic is traditional, classic, and elegant. Its designs are often ornate, with graceful curves, detailed woodwork, and a formal presence that feels timeless. This style works best in homes with a traditional, transitional, or grandmillennial aesthetic where furniture serves as a stately centerpiece.
Ashley Furniture offers a much broader, contemporary spectrum of styles. Whether you're looking for a sleek modern sectional, a rustic farmhouse dining table, or a casual transitional bedroom set, you’ll find it at Ashley. Their design team stays on top of current trends, producing furniture that reflects what’s popular right now. This makes Ashley ideal for evolving tastes and more casual living environments.
Product Selection & Sizing
Both brands offer a wide range of products for the entire home, but Ashley’s selection is quantifiably larger and more diverse. Due to its trend-focused approach, Ashley also carries a wide variety of dimensions, including many apartment-friendly and small-space solutions. Their modular sectionals and compact dining sets are great for flexible living.
Thomasville furniture tends to be larger and more substantial in scale, reflecting its traditional design roots. These are statement pieces intended for more spacious primary bedrooms and formal dining rooms, although customizable options provide some flexibility.
Shopping Experience
Shopping at Ashley is a straightforward retail experience. With countless physical stores and a robust e-commerce site, the process is designed for convenience and speed. You can browse, buy, and have furniture delivered within a short timeframe.
Buying from Thomasville is a more considered purchase process. It typically involves visiting an authorized dealer or a design-focused showroom. The experience is more personalized, with sales staff available to help with selections, customization, and coordinating pieces. Lead times can be longer, especially for custom upholstered items.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands serve different customers extremely well, so the best choice comes down to your budget, style, and long-term goals.
Choose Thomasville if:
- You are investing in a "forever" home and want furniture that will last for decades.
- You value high-quality materials like solid wood and premium craftsmanship.
- Your home decor style is traditional, classic, or formal.
- You prioritize durability and longevity over getting the absolute lowest price.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- You are furnishing your first home, apartment, or a temporary space.
- You have a tight budget but don't want to sacrifice on-trend style.
- You need furniture quickly for a growing family, kids' rooms, or a guest room.
- You enjoy redecorating every few years and prefer not to be tied down by expensive pieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Thomasville or Ashley Furniture cheaper?
Ashley Furniture is significantly cheaper than Thomasville. A sofa from Ashley might cost $400–$900, while a Thomasville sofa typically starts at $1,200 and can go much higher. This price difference holds true across all furniture categories.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Thomasville has better quality furniture in terms of materials and construction. They specialize in using solid wood and durable joinery techniques intended to last for generations. Ashley Furniture offers good value for its price, but its materials (like particleboard and engineered wood) are chosen for affordability rather than long-term durability.
Is Thomasville furniture made of real wood?
Yes, Thomasville is known for using real, solid wood and high-quality wood veneers in its furniture construction, which is a key reason for its reputation for quality and its higher price point.
Is Ashley Furniture durable enough for families?
Ashley Furniture can be a great choice for families, especially those with young children. Its low cost means you won't feel as precious about inevitable spills and scratches. While not as durable as solid wood furniture, it's functional for everyday family life, and replacing a piece in a few years is much more affordable.
Where can I buy Thomasville furniture?
Thomasville furniture is typically sold through authorized retail partners, furniture stores with dedicated galleries, and design showrooms. You are less likely to find a standalone Thomasville store today, and the shopping experience is often curated through dealers.
What style of furniture does Ashley carry?
Ashley Furniture carries a huge variety of styles to cater to a broad audience. You can find everything from modern and contemporary to industrial, rustic, traditional, and modern farmhouse designs.
Does Ashley Furniture require assembly?
Many items from Ashley Furniture require some assembly upon delivery. This is a common practice for budget-friendly furniture brands as it reduces shipping costs and damage. Simple items like tables and bed frames often require you to attach legs or connect parts, a process which is generally straightforward.
Which brand holds its value better?
Due to its solid wood construction and classic designs, Thomasville furniture holds its value much better over time. Well-maintained Thomasville pieces are often sought after on the secondhand market. Ashley Furniture has very low resale value, as it is considered more of a disposable, fast-fashion item for the home.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
