Sur La Table is a culinary specialist, offering high-performance, professional-grade cookware and tools for passionate home cooks. In contrast, Crate & Barrel is a broader home furnishings retailer where stylish, modern kitchenware is just one part of its larger collection of furniture and decor.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right retailer for your kitchen.
Sur La Table: The Culinary Enthusiast's Destination
Sur La Table is renowned for its extensive selection of high-quality cookware, kitchen tools, and culinary accessories designed for those who are serious about cooking. The brand appeals to both home cooks and professional chefs with a curated assortment of premium brands and exclusive items that emphasize function and durability without sacrificing style.
- Product mix: A deep focus on anything kitchen-related, including high-end cookware, bakeware, cutlery, innovative cooking gadgets, and small kitchen appliances. They carry their own collections as well as top-tier brands from around the world.
- Style/vibe: Functional, professional, and performance-driven. The aesthetic often leans slightly traditional or utilitarian, prioritizing how a product cooks over how it looks on a shelf.
- Price point: Mid-to-upscale. Small tools can be found for around $20, while high-performance cookware sets can exceed $500. A quality non-stick skillet typically starts around $50.
- Quality: Professional-grade materials are standard, including heavy-gauge stainless steel, enameled cast iron, and high-performance non-stick surfaces built for longevity and intensive use.
- Services: Famously hosts in-store cooking classes and demonstrations, fostering a community of culinary enthusiasts and providing a hands-on learning experience.
- Return policy: Offers returns on unused items within 60 days with proof of purchase.
- Sales: Holds frequent sales events, especially during holidays and seasonal transitions, often with significant discounts on cookware sets and specific brands.
Sur La Table is the quintessential stop for anyone looking for specialized, performance-driven equipment to elevate their cooking.
Shop Sur La Table: surlatable.com
Crate & Barrel: The Modern Home Outfitter
Crate & Barrel is a leading home furnishings brand celebrated for its modern, timeless furniture, decor, and housewares. Its kitchen and dining collections are designed to blend style and function seamlessly, appealing to contemporary homeowners who want their kitchen tools to be as beautiful as they are practical. Their clean lines and high-quality craftsmanship make them a favorite for those creating a cohesive, modern home.
- Product mix: A comprehensive home outfitter offering everything from sofas and beds to dining tables, decor, and a robust kitchenware section. Kitchen products include cookware, serveware, barware, and kitchen gadgets.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and timelessly elegant. The aesthetic is defined by clean lines, neutral colors, and designs that complement contemporary interiors.
- Price point: Mid-range to premium. Basic utensils start around $15, while cookware sets typically range from $200 to $400. You can find an everyday non-stick pan starting at roughly $30.
- Quality: Emphasizes durable, quality materials like sleek stainless steel, ceramics, and responsibly sourced wood that look good and hold up to daily use.
- Services: Provides interior design consultation services for the whole home and maintains a popular wedding registry program.
- Sustainability: Strong commitment to eco-friendly practices, including responsible material sourcing (FSC-certified wood), GREENGUARD-certified furniture, and sustainable packaging.
- Return policy: Non-furniture items can be returned within 30 days of receipt.
Crate & Barrel is ideal for those who value a clean, modern aesthetic and want their kitchen essentials to be a stylish extension of their home's overall design.
Shop Crate & Barrel: crateandbarrel.com
Sur La Table vs. Crate & Barrel Comparison
Price Comparison
Generally, Sur La Table comes with a higher price tag for comparable items, reflecting its focus on professional-grade materials and performance. A high-quality chef's knife or skillet will consistently be more expensive at Sur La Table than a comparable everyday model from Crate & Barrel. For example, a reliable non-stick skillet may start at $50 at Sur La Table, while Crate & Barrel’s options begin around $30.
When it comes to entire sets, the difference is also clear. A comprehensive cookware set from Sur La Table can easily cost over $500, whereas similar sets at Crate & Barrel are usually priced between $200 and $400. Both retailers run excellent sales, so savvy shoppers can find good deals, but Sur La Table's baseline pricing remains higher.
Style & Aesthetic
The primary visual difference lies in intent. Sur La Table's aesthetic is functional and professional. Pieces are designed for performance first, which often results in a rugged, almost commercial kitchen look. Their products appeal to those who view their kitchen as a workshop.
Crate & Barrel leads with a modern, design-centric approach. Its cookware and tools feature clean lines, understated colors, and a minimalist feel. These products are created to be displayed and to integrate seamlessly into a stylish, contemporary kitchen aesthetic where form is just as important as function.
Quality & Construction
Both brands offer high-quality products, but their construction priorities differ slightly. Sur La Table focuses on robust, heavy-duty construction suited for intensive use. Think thicker-gauge metals, heat-resistant coatings, and designs engineered for precise cooking. Many of their exclusive products are built to last a lifetime.
Crate & Barrel products are also well-made and durable for home use. They use quality stainless steel, durable ceramics, and solid-wood accents. While perfectly capable for a home cook, their items are not necessarily built with the same professional-level intensity in mind as some of Sur La Table's specialty offerings.
Product Selection
Sur La Table's product catalogue is deep and narrow: almost everything is for the kitchen. You will find a much wider variety of specialized tools, a broader range of high-end brands like Le Creuset and All-Clad, and more technical equipment. It's the destination for finding that niche gadget you can't get elsewhere.
Crate & Barrel offers a curated selection of kitchen essentials as part of a much larger home goods store. While they also carry popular brands, their range isn't as specialized. Their advantage is being a one-stop shop where you can buy a new Dutch oven along with a sofa, bath towels, and decorative vases.
Shopping Experience
The shopping experience at Sur La Table is highly interactive and educational. Staff are knowledgeable about culinary techniques, and the popular in-store cooking classes create a community-like atmosphere. It’s an experience-driven environment for people passionate about food.
Crate & Barrel offers a more traditional retail experience focused on style and design. Their stores are beautifully merchandised, inspiring customers with whole-home vignettes. They also offer design services to help you coordinate your kitchenware with your new dining table or living room furniture.
Sustainability & Ethics
Crate & Barrel has a more pronounced and transparent commitment to sustainability. The brand actively promotes its use of responsibly sourced materials and has earned certifications like FSC for its wood products and GREENGUARD for low-emission finishes. This focus is a core part of their brand identity.
Sur La Table engages in responsible sourcing, but it's not a central pillar of their marketing in the same way. For shoppers who prioritize third-party certifications and transparent eco-friendly policies, Crate & Barrel has a clear edge.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your relationship with your kitchen and your overall shopping goals.
Choose Sur La Table if:
- You are a serious cook who prioritizes performance and durability above all else.
- You are searching for a specific, high-performance, or specialized kitchen tool.
- You enjoy talking to knowledgeable staff and learning new cooking techniques.
- You view your kitchen primarily as a space for creativity and culinary experimentation.
Choose Crate & Barrel if:
- You want your kitchenware to match your home's modern, minimalist style.
- You are furnishing other areas of your home and want a convenient one-stop-shop.
- You appreciate a brand with a strong, transparent commitment to sustainability.
- You need attractive, quality kitchen essentials for everyday cooking and entertaining.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sur La Table or Crate & Barrel more expensive?
Sur La Table is generally more expensive. Its products are often professional-grade and come from premium culinary brands, leading to a higher price point compared to Crate & Barrel's stylish-yet-accessible home offerings.
Which brand has better quality cookware?
This depends on your definition of quality. For raw cooking performance and extreme durability under heavy use, Sur La Table often has an edge. For high-quality materials combined with modern aesthetics suitable for everyday home use, Crate & Barrel is excellent.
Which store is better for a wedding registry?
Both are extremely popular. If you're a couple passionate about cooking and want to stock your kitchen with top-tier gear, a Sur La Table registry is ideal. If you're furnishing your entire new home, Crate & Barrel offers a much broader selection, from pots and pans to bath towels and bed linens.
Can you buy furniture at Sur La Table?
No. Sur La Table is exclusively focused on cookware, bakeware, kitchen tools, and culinary electrics. Crate & Barrel is a full-fledged home furniture and decor retailer.
Do both stores carry other brands?
Yes, both retailers carry their own private-label collections alongside a curated selection of other well-known brands. You can find names like Le Creuset, All-Clad, and Staub at both stores, though Sur La Table often has a wider range of these brands' offerings.
Which is better for small kitchen gadgets?
Sur La Table excels in this category. Their stores are treasure troves of unique, specialized, and innovative gadgets for every conceivable kitchen task, often with a wider and more technical selection than Crate & Barrel.
Are Sur La Table’s cooking classes worth it?
Their cooking classes are very popular and generally well-reviewed. They are considered a fun and effective way to learn specific skills, from knife work to pastry making, in a hands-on, sociable environment.
Which store is better for dinnerware and serveware?
While Sur La Table has a nice selection, Crate & Barrel is the clear winner here. Their collections of dinnerware, glassware, flatware, and table linens are far more extensive and come in a wider array of modern styles perfect for entertaining.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
