Stickley is an authority in heirloom-quality, solid wood furniture, celebrated for its American Arts and Crafts and mission-style designs and meticulous craftsmanship. In contrast, Ethan Allen offers a more versatile catalog with transitional and contemporary styles, focusing on customization and accessible luxury for a broader audience.
Let's compare these two iconic American brands to help you decide which is the right investment for your home.
Stickley: The Heirloom Craftsmanship Choice
Stickley is renowned for its timeless, handcrafted furniture that emphasizes solid wood construction and traditional joinery. The brand's identity is deeply rooted in the Arts and Crafts movement, positioning its pieces as lifelong investments meant to be passed down through generations. Discerning buyers who prioritize authentic American craftsmanship, durability, and sustainable materials gravitate toward Stickley for its commitment to quality over trends.
- Product mix: Specializes in living room, dining room, bedroom, and office furniture. This includes iconic mission-style chairs, solid wood dining tables, beds, and custom cabinetry.
- Style/vibe: Classic American, Mission, and Arts and Crafts styles. The aesthetic is defined by straight lines, sturdy construction, rich wood finishes (oak, cherry), and an emphasis on the natural beauty of the material.
- Price point: Luxury. Sofas typically start around $3,000, dining tables from $2,500, and comprehensive bedroom sets often exceed $5,000.
- Quality: Exceptional. Stickley uses solid, FSC-certified hardwoods and traditional construction methods like mortise-and-tenon joinery, resulting in exceptionally durable and long-lasting furniture.
- Customization: Offers some selection of wood finishes and upholstery on certain pieces, but the core focus is on the integrity of their established designs rather than extensive modification.
- Sustainability: A core principle of the brand. Stickley uses responsibly sourced hardwoods and builds furniture intended to last for generations, directly opposing a throwaway culture.
- Where to buy: Available through official Stickley showrooms and a network of authorized high-end furniture retailers.
Stickley is the choice for those who view furniture as a permanent artful investment and value the story of traditional American craftsmanship.
Shop Stickley: stickley.com
Ethan Allen: The Versatile & Customizable Option
Ethan Allen is a well-established American home furnishing brand known for offering stylish, quality furniture that spans a wide range of design aesthetics. A defining feature is their focus on personalization, providing customers with extensive customization options for fabrics, finishes, and configurations. Complemented by complimentary in-house design services, Ethan Allen aims to help homeowners create cohesive, personalized spaces without a luxury-only price tag.
- Product mix: Comprehensive home furnishings, including sofas, sectionals, dining sets, bedroom furniture, home office, lighting, rugs, accessories, and outdoor furniture.
- Style/vibe: Broad and versatile, covering traditional, transitional, and contemporary looks. Their collections are designed to be adaptable, blending classic elegance with modern sensibilities to fit diverse interior styles.
- Price point: Mid-range to luxury. Sofas start around $1,200, dining tables can be found from $1,000, and core bedroom pieces begin near $1,500. Frequent sales and promotions make their pricing more accessible.
- Quality: High-quality construction often used a combination of solid wood and engineered wood veneers to balance durability and cost. Their craftsmanship is reliable and intended for everyday family life.
- Customization: A key strength. Ethan Allen offers thousands of fabric and leather options for upholstery, multiple finishes for wood pieces, and various hardware choices, allowing for highly personalized furniture.
- Services: A major differentiator is their complimentary interior design service available in-store or virtually, helping customers with everything from fabric selection to full room layouts.
- Where to buy: Can be purchased through Ethan Allen's numerous design centers (showrooms) nationwide and on their website.
Ethan Allen delivers a design-forward, customizable furniture experience that balances quality, style, and value for a wide range of customers.
Shop Ethan Allen: ethanallen.com
Stickley vs. Ethan Allen Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a significant price difference between the two brands. Stickley operates in the luxury tier, with prices that reflect its use of solid hardwoods, American craftsmanship, and heirloom-quality construction. A simple dining chair can cost what an accent table might at another store. Their furniture is a substantial financial investment.
Ethan Allen is more accessible, occupying a space between mid-range and high-end furniture. While not inexpensive, its prices are more approachable, especially during their frequent sales events. They offer a better price-to-customization ratio, allowing shoppers to get a personalized look for a moderate investment.
Quality & Construction
Stickley's reputation is built on its uncompromising construction quality. The use of solid FSC-certified hardwoods, combined with time-tested joinery techniques, results in furniture that can physically last for over a century. Every piece is built with integrity and meant to be a permanent fixture in a home.
Ethan Allen furniture is also well-made and durable, designed for the rigors of daily use. They often employ a mix of solid wood frames with engineered wood and high-quality veneers in case goods like dressers and dining tables. While the quality is very good for its price point, it doesn't typically possess the same artisanal, all-solid-wood construction as Stickley.
Style & Aesthetic
Style is a primary differentiator. Stickley is deeply rooted in the American Arts and Crafts and Mission aesthetic. The look is iconic, specific, and timeless. It's for homes that embrace traditional architecture, rich wood tones, and understated, sturdy forms.
Ethan Allen is a stylistic chameleon. Their catalog is a journey through different design eras, from classic 18th-century reinterpretations to sleek, modern sofas and rustic, farmhouse-inspired tables. This versatility makes Ethan Allen an easy choice for homeowners who want to furnish a whole house or whose style doesn't fit neatly into one category.
Customization Options
Ethan Allen is the clear leader in customization. Their business model is built around giving customers control over the final look, with a massive library of fabrics, leathers, wood finishes, and hardware options. If you want a sofa in a specific jewel-toned velvet or a dresser with unique brass pulls, Ethan Allen can almost certainly accommodate.
Stickley offers some choices in wood type, finish, and upholstery, but the selection is much more curated and traditional. The focus is on preserving the specific design intent of each piece, not on reinvention by the customer.
Shopping Experience
Shopping at Stickley often happens at a dedicated showroom or a high-end furniture gallery. The experience is more consultative and slower-paced, focusing on the heritage and craftsmanship of the product. It’s about buying an investment piece, not just filling a room.
The Ethan Allen experience centers on their "Design Centers." These large showrooms are staffed with designers who provide free assistance, making the process of selection and customization less intimidating. Their website is also robust, allowing for online browsing and virtual design consultations that mirror the helpful in-store experience.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands produce excellent furniture, but they serve different sensibilities and needs.
Choose Stickley if:
- You are investing in heirloom pieces you intend to keep for life and pass on.
- You love the historic, authentic look of American Arts and Crafts or Mission furniture.
- Uncompromising solid wood construction and artisanal joinery are your top priorities.
- You value American-made craftsmanship and are willing to pay a premium for it.
Choose Ethan Allen if:
- You want to personalize your furniture with a wide selection of fabrics and finishes.
- Blending styles, from traditional to contemporary, suits your home's aesthetic.
- You would benefit from complimentary interior design services to help guide your choices.
- You're looking for a strong balance of quality, style, and value for your budget.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Stickley or Ethan Allen more expensive?
Stickley is significantly more expensive than Ethan Allen. Its prices reflect its commitment to solid hardwood construction, American artisanal craftsmanship, and heirloom-quality durability. Ethan Allen is positioned as an accessible luxury brand with a broader price range and frequent promotional sales.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Both brands offer high-quality furniture, but they define quality differently. Stickley offers superior artisanal quality with its solid wood materials and traditional joinery, designed to last for generations. Ethan Allen provides excellent everyday quality designed for modern family life, combining solid and engineered woods for a balance of durability and price.
Is Stickley furniture made in the USA?
Yes. A major selling point for Stickley is that many of its signature collections are handcrafted in its workshops in Upstate New York, continuing a long tradition of American manufacturing.
Does Ethan Allen offer design services?
Yes. Ethan Allen is famous for its complimentary interior design service. Customers can work with professional designers in-store or online to plan room layouts, select furniture, and coordinate fabrics and finishes at no additional cost.
What style of furniture is Stickley known for?
Stickley is the preeminent name in American Mission and Arts and Crafts style furniture. This aesthetic emphasizes clean lines, visible joinery, rich oak and cherry wood, and a philosophy of quality craftsmanship.
How much can I customize furniture at Ethan Allen?
Customization is a cornerstone of the Ethan Allen brand. For most upholstered items like sofas and chairs, you can choose from hundreds of fabrics and leathers. For case goods like tables and dressers, there are often multiple wood finishes and hardware options available.
Which brand is better for sustainability?
Stickley has a stronger story in sustainability, primarily through its use of responsibly sourced, FSC-certified solid hardwoods and its heirloom construction methods. Building furniture that lasts a lifetime is inherently sustainable. Ethan Allen also has responsible sourcing and manufacturing practices, but Stickley’s entire ethos is built on durability and natural materials.
Where can I buy Stickley furniture?
You can purchase Stickley furniture through their official brand showrooms and a network of authorized dealer galleries across North America. These retailers are selected for their ability to properly showcase and represent the high-end brand.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
