The Staub Dutch oven is a premium, French-made piece of heirloom-quality cookware known for superior heat retention, while the Sur La Table in-house Dutch oven is a stylish, mid-range alternative offering solid performance at a much more accessible price. The primary difference comes down to craftsmanship and cost: Staub is a lifetime investment for serious cooks, whereas Sur La Table provides excellent value for everyday home cooking.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which enameled cast iron Dutch oven is the right fit for your kitchen.
Staub Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Staub represents the gold standard in French enameled cast iron, favored by professional chefs and passionate home cooks alike. The cookware is renowned for its exceptional heat retention, cooking performance, and iconic design, featuring a signature matte black interior that excels at searing. Each piece is crafted in France and built to last for generations, making it a true kitchen heirloom.
- What it is: A premium, French-made enameled cast iron cocotte (Dutch oven) designed for slow-cooking, braising, searing, and baking.
- Key features: Textured matte black enamel interior for better browning, a tight-fitting flat lid with self-basting spikes for continuous moisture, and an extremely durable, chip-resistant exterior glaze.
- Price: Premium, starting around $300 for a 4-quart model and reaching $600 or more for larger sizes.
- Style: Timeless and classic French country aesthetic. Comes in a range of vibrant, deep colors like cherry red, sapphire blue, and graphite grey.
- Materials/Construction: Heavy-duty single-cast iron with multiple layers of vitrified enamel. The knob is typically nickel-plated brass, oven-safe to very high temperatures.
- Pros: Unmatched heat retention and even distribution. Self-basting lid keeps food moist. Exceptional durability with a lifetime warranty. Beautiful design that works for both cooking and serving. Does not require seasoning.
- Cons: High price point can be prohibitive. Very heavy and can be difficult to lift and maneuver. Enamel can still chip if dropped or handled roughly.
The Staub Dutch oven is ideal for the serious cook who values top-tier performance and wants to invest in a piece of cookware that will last a lifetime.
Shop this product: staub.com/us/products/cocottes-round/
Sur La Table Dutch Oven
As a leading kitchen retailer, Sur La Table developed its own line of cookware to deliver reliable, professional-grade performance at a more accessible price. Their enameled cast iron Dutch ovens are designed for the enthusiastic home cook, combining handsome design, solid construction, and practical features for everyday use without the premium investment of high-end brands.
- What it is: An in-house branded enameled cast iron Dutch oven focused on providing great value for everyday cooking tasks.
- Key features: Smooth, light-colored enamel interior makes it easy to monitor food. Generally lighter in weight than its premium counterparts. Wide handles for a secure grip.
- Price: Mid-range, typically priced between $100 and $250 for common sizes like 5-6 quarts.
- Style: Clean, modern, and versatile. Available in an array of classic and contemporary colors that blend easily into various kitchen designs.
- Materials/Construction: Enameled cast iron body with a stainless steel knob. Quality is solid for daily use but less robust than premium brands like Staub.
- Pros: Excellent value for the price. More affordable than high-end European brands. Lighter weight makes it easier to handle. Frequently available during sales events, offering further savings.
- Cons: Heat retention and distribution are good but not on par with heavier, thicker options like Staub. The warranty is limited, not a lifetime guarantee. Long-term durability is not at the same heirloom level.
Sur La Table's Dutch oven is a great choice for home cooks who need a versatile, attractive workhorse for soups, stews, and bread without breaking the bank.
Shop this product: surlatable.com/cookware/dutch-ovens-casseroles/
Staub vs. Sur La Table Dutch Oven Comparison
Materials & Construction
There's a noticeable difference in craftsmanship between the two. Staub uses a thicker gauge of cast iron and a multi-coat enameling process, resulting in a heavier pot that feels incredibly robust. Its matte black interior is unique and designed for excellent browning, while the exterior glaze is deep and lustrous. This is backed by a lifetime warranty, signaling the brand's confidence in its durability.
Sur La Table's Dutch oven features a lighter-weight cast iron construction. The build quality is still solid for everyday kitchen tasks, but it doesn't have the same tank-like heft or flawless finish as a Staub. The enamel is reliable but may be more susceptible to chipping over the long term. The warranty is typically limited, reflecting its position as a value-oriented product.
Cooking Performance
The heavier construction of the Staub pays dividends in performance. It heats up slowly but retains that heat with incredible efficiency, providing extremely even cooking with no hot spots. Its tight-fitting, spiky lid creates a self-basting effect, continuously returning moisture to the food, which is fantastic for long braises and roasts. The matte interior helps develop a dark, rich fond when searing meats.
The Sur La Table Dutch oven performs very well for its price point. It heats evenly and does a great job with soups, stews, and baking bread. However, it won't retain heat quite as long as the Staub, and its lid doesn't offer the same high-tech basting features. For most day-to-day recipes, the difference may be subtle, but for precision-dependent slow-cooking, the Staub has a clear edge.
Style & Versatility
Staub offers an iconic, timeless French aesthetic that often serves as a kitchen centerpiece. Its deep, jewel-toned colors and signature brass or nickel knob make it a statement piece you'd be proud to display on the stove or table. Sur La Table leans into a more modern, slightly understated design. Its colors are clean and contemporary, designed to complement a wide range of kitchen decor styles without necessarily being the focal point.
Price & Value
This is the most significant differentiator. A Staub Dutch oven is a luxury item with a starting price of over $300. It's an investment in a piece of cookware that, with proper care, should last a lifetime. Sur La Table offers exceptional value, with Dutch ovens priced roughly a third of what Staub charges. For a much smaller initial cost, you get a highly functional and attractive piece of cookware that will handle the majority of a home cook's needs.
Who Each One Works Best For
The Staub Dutch oven is built for the culinary enthusiast, professional chef, or serious home cook who sees cookware as a long-term investment. If you prioritize maximum performance, heirloom-level durability, and classic design - and have the budget for it - Staub is difficult to beat.
The Sur La Table Dutch oven is perfect for new homeowners, hobbyist cooks, and anyone looking for a reliable and stylish kitchen workhorse on a more moderate budget. It's a fantastic entry point into the world of enameled cast iron cooking, offering about 80% of the performance for less than 50% of the price.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Dutch ovens are excellent choices for their intended audience, but they cater to very different priorities.
Choose the Staub Dutch oven if:
- You're an experienced cook who will notice and appreciate superior heat retention.
- You want an heirloom-quality piece that will last for decades.
- Your budget allows for a premium, long-term kitchen investment.
- You value iconic French craftsmanship and design.
Choose the Sur La Table Dutch oven if:
- You are looking for the best performance you can get at a mid-range price.
- You need a dependable, all-purpose Dutch oven for everyday meals.
- You prefer lighter cookware that's easier to lift and clean.
- You want to get into cast iron cooking without the high initial cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Staub and Sur La Table Dutch ovens?
The main differences are price, construction, and performance. The Staub is a premium, heavy-duty French product with superior heat retention and a lifetime warranty, costing over $300. The Sur La Table is a mid-range, more affordable option offering great value and solid daily performance for around $100-$250.
Is a Staub Dutch oven really worth the money?
For serious cooks who frequently braise, roast, and slow-cook, a Staub is often considered a worthwhile investment. Its exceptional heat retention, self-basting lid, and extreme durability deliver tangible performance benefits and a product that can last a lifetime, justifying the high cost over many years of use.
Which one is better for baking bread?
Both are excellent for baking bread, but the Staub's thicker walls and superior heat retention will often yield a slightly better oven spring and a crispier crust. A Sur La Table Dutch oven, however, will still produce a fantastic loaf of artisan bread at home.
Can you use metal utensils in these Dutch ovens?
It's not recommended. To protect the enamel finish on both brands, you should use wooden, silicone, or nylon utensils. Metal tools can scratch or chip the enamel surface over time.
Which Dutch oven is more durable?
The Staub is more durable. Its heavier build, multi-layer enamel, and rigorous quality control, backed by a lifetime warranty, put it in a different class of longevity compared to a mid-range product with a limited warranty.
How high can the oven temperature be?
Staub Dutch ovens with their metal knobs are typically oven-safe up to 500°F (260°C). Sur La Table's models are also oven-safe to similar temperatures, but it's always best to check the manufacturer's specific guidelines for the exact model you have.
Is the black interior of the Staub better than a light one?
It's a matter of preference. Staub’s matte black interior excels at searing and hides stains over time, but it can make it harder to monitor the "fond" (browned bits) at the bottom. The light-colored interior of the Sur La Table makes it easier to watch food as it cooks and prevent burning.
Which is easier to clean?
Both are relatively easy to clean with hot soapy water and a non-abrasive sponge. The light-colored enamel on a Sur La Table may show stains more easily over time, requiring occasional deep cleaning, while the Staub's black interior hides them well.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
