Smithey offers heirloom-quality, American-made cast iron with a signature polished, smooth surface and modern aesthetic, appealing to culinary purists. In contrast, Le Creuset is a classic French brand known for its iconic, vibrant enameled cast iron that requires no seasoning and offers exceptional versatility for a wide range of kitchen tasks.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right premium cookware for your kitchen.
Smithey: The American Artisan Cast Iron
Smithey is a U.S.-based cookware company celebrated for its premium, handcrafted cast iron pieces that blend traditional quality with a clean, modern design. Based in Charleston, South Carolina, their skillets are famous for their CNC-machined and hand-polished interior surfaces, which are much smoother than typical cast iron. It's a favorite for serious home cooks and enthusiasts who value American craftsmanship and want cookware that doubles as a functional work of art.
- Product mix: A focused collection of high-end cast iron including skillets, Dutch ovens, griddles, and roasting pans. They also offer a select range of carbon steel cookware.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist, modern, and sleek. The polished graphite-like surface gives Smithey cookware an understated elegance that stands out from more rustic cast iron brands.
- Price point: Premium. A 10" skillet starts at about $160, and a 5.5 qt Dutch oven is around $300, reflecting the detailed craftsmanship and US-based manufacturing.
- Quality: Exceptional. The cast iron is designed for superior heat retention, and the smooth, polished surface helps build a naturally non-stick patina over time. These are heirloom pieces intended to last for generations.
- Maintenance: Requires seasoning. Smithey cookware comes pre-seasoned but, like all traditional cast iron, needs ongoing care to build and maintain its non-stick surface and prevent rust.
- Manufacturing: Proudly designed and manufactured in the USA.
- Best for: Frying, baking, and achieving an excellent sear on meats. Its smooth surface is particularly good for cooking eggs once well-seasoned.
Smithey offers a refined take on traditional cast iron for discerning cooks who appreciate modern design and the classic performance of a well-seasoned pan.
Shop Smithey: smithey.com
Le Creuset: The Colorful French Icon
Le Creuset is a world-renowned French brand that has been producing iconic cast iron cookware since 1925. Famous for its vibrant, colorful porcelain enamel coating, Le Creuset combines high-performance cooking with a cheerful, timeless aesthetic. Their enameled Dutch oven is a kitchen icon, prized for its versatility, durability, and ability to go from stovetop to oven to table. The brand is a staple in wedding registries and aspirational kitchens everywhere.
- Product mix: Extensive. While famous for enameled cast iron, Le Creuset also offers stoneware, stainless steel cookware, non-stick pans, bakeware, and a wide array of kitchen tools and accessories.
- Style/vibe: Classic, colorful, and cheerful. With dozens of signature colors like Flame, Caribbean Blue, and Nectar, Le Creuset pieces are designed to be statement pieces that add personality to the kitchen.
- Price point: High-end. Their signature 5.5 qt Round Dutch Oven typically costs around $420, while smaller skillets and saucepans range from $120 to $250+.
- Quality: Top-tier. The cast iron core provides even heating and superior heat retention, while the multi-layer enamel exterior is resistant to chipping, staining, and cracking when properly cared for.
- Maintenance: Low-maintenance. The enamel coating is non-reactive, resists sticking, and requires no seasoning. It is easy to clean and even dishwasher-safe, though handwashing is recommended.
- Manufacturing: Le Creuset's cast iron products are still made in the original foundry in Fresnoy-le-Grand, France.
- Best for: Versatile cooking, including braising, slow-cooking, soups, and baking bread. The non-reactive enamel surface is ideal for acidic foods like tomatoes and wine sauces.
Le Creuset excels in producing beautiful, user-friendly cookware that performs consistently and adds a splash of color to any kitchen.
Shop Le Creuset: lecreuset.com
Smithey vs. Le Creuset Comparison
Price Comparison
Both brands operate in the premium to luxury price tier, representing a significant investment for your kitchen. A 10" Smithey skillet costs around $160, while a 10.25" Le Creuset Signature Skillet costs about $175-$220 depending on the color. For Dutch ovens, a 5.5 qt Smithey model runs about $300, whereas the iconic Le Creuset 5.5 qt Dutch Oven is significantly higher at around $420.
While Smithey is by no means inexpensive, Le Creuset often carries a higher price tag, especially for larger pieces like Dutch ovens and braisers. The cost difference reflects Le Creuset's complex enameling process, global brand recognition, and extensive color options. Smithey's pricing is rooted in its American-made artisanship and detailed finishing processes.
Style & Aesthetic
This is one of the most significant differences. Smithey has a refined, modern-meets-rustic look. Its signature feature is the mirror-smooth, graphite-colored cooking surface, contrasting with a more traditional dark exterior. It's an understated piece that speaks to craftsmanship and appeals to a minimalist or industrial kitchen aesthetic.
Le Creuset is all about color. Its identity is tied to its vibrant, glossy enamel finish. With a vast palette ranging from bold and bright to soft pastels, Le Creuset allows you to personalize your kitchen and coordinate your cookware with your decor. It’s a classic, joyful aesthetic that feels both traditional and current.
Quality & Materials
Both brands use high-quality cast iron, but the surface is the key differentiator. Smithey uses raw cast iron that has been meticulously polished. This creates an incredibly smooth foundation to build up a seasoning, which is the layer of polymerized oil that gives cast iron its non-stick properties. When cared for, it provides an unbeatable sear and develops its own unique character over time.
Le Creuset’s cast iron is coated in multiple layers of vitrified porcelain enamel. This creates a non-porous, non-reactive, and rust-proof surface straight out of the box. The quality of Le Creuset's enamel is a benchmark - it's highly resistant to chipping and thermal shock, ensuring longevity. The light-colored interior of many pieces also makes it easy to monitor cooking progress.
Product Selection
Le Creuset offers a much wider range of products. Beyond dozens of shapes and sizes of enameled cast iron cookware, their catalog includes stoneware bakers, mugs, stainless steel pots, cutlery, kitchen tools, and more. They provide a complete kitchen solution for those who want a coordinated look.
Smithey maintains a much more focused collection. Their core products are cast iron skillets in various sizes, alongside a few Dutch ovens, griddles, and specialty pieces. This specialization allows them to concentrate on perfecting the classic cast iron form.
Maintenance & Ease of Use
For ease of use, Le Creuset is the clear winner. Its enamel coating requires no seasoning. You can cook anything in it, including acidic ingredients like tomatoes or citrus, without worrying about stripping your seasoning or imparting a metallic taste. It's easy to clean with soap and water.
Smithey requires the hands-on care of traditional cast iron. You must maintain its seasoning, avoid harsh soaps, and dry it immediately to prevent rust. For many enthusiasts, this ritual is part of the joy of owning cast iron. For others, it can feel like a chore. The payoff is a durable, natural non-stick surface that can be restored indefinitely.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands make fantastic, long-lasting cookware, but they serve different culinary philosophies and styles.
Choose Smithey if:
- You enjoy the process of seasoning and caring for traditional cast iron.
- Achieving the perfect sear on a steak is your top priority.
- You appreciate a sleek, modern, minimalist aesthetic.
- You value American-made craftsmanship and an artisanal story.
- You want an heirloom pan that will develop a unique patina from years of use.
Choose Le Creuset if:
- You want colorful, statement cookware that matches your kitchen decor.
- You prioritize ease of use and low-maintenance cleaning.
- You cook a lot of acidic foods, soups, stews, or braises.
- You are looking for a versatile Dutch oven for everything from baking bread to slow-cooking.
- You want a wide range of matching products, from pots and pans to bakeware and mugs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Smithey or Le Creuset more expensive?
It depends on the piece. For comparable skillets, they are similarly priced. However, for their signature item - the Dutch oven - Le Creuset is considerably more expensive than Smithey's version.
Which pan is better for searing steak?
While both perform well, most chefs prefer the raw, seasoned cast iron of a Smithey skillet for creating a deep, crispy crust on steak. The direct contact with seasoned iron often yields a superior Maillard reaction.
Can you use metal utensils on Smithey and Le Creuset?
You can use metal utensils with care on a Smithey skillet, as the seasoning layer is durable and can be re-applied if scuffed. It is strongly advised not to use metal utensils on Le Creuset, as they can scratch or chip the enamel surface, which cannot be repaired.
Is Smithey cookware non-stick?
With proper seasoning, the cookware can develop an excellent, naturally non-stick surface. It requires building up this layer of seasoning over time and with use. Le Creuset is not technically non-stick, but the smooth enamel surface is easy-release and requires less oil than an unseasoned raw cast iron or stainless steel pan.
Does Smithey cookware rust?
Yes. Like all traditional raw cast iron, a Smithey pan will rust if left wet or if the seasoning is stripped. It must be dried thoroughly after washing and lightly oiled periodically. This is part of the standard care routine.
Does Le Creuset's enamel chip or stain?
Le Creuset’s enamel is extremely durable but can chip if dropped or struck with a hard object. Stains can occur over time, especially with high heat, but most can be removed with a specialty cleaner or a baking soda paste.
Which is better for cooking acidic foods like tomato sauce?
Le Creuset is the clear choice. Its enameled surface is non-reactive, so simmering acidic ingredients will not damage the cookware or give your food a metallic taste. Cooking acidic foods in raw cast iron like Smithey can strip the seasoning.
Which brand is a better investment?
Both are excellent investments that can last a lifetime if cared for. A Smithey can be passed down for generations, and its cooking surface can always be restored. A Le Creuset piece holds its value well and is backed by a limited lifetime warranty that covers manufacturing defects. The best investment depends on which type of cookware lifestyle fits you best.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
