While an espresso machine from Smeg and one from Breville both make excellent coffee, they serve fundamentally different customers. A Smeg machine makes a statement with its iconic 1950s retro design and vibrant colors, prioritizing aesthetics and ease of use, whereas a Breville prioritizes technological innovation and professional-level performance with a sleek, modern look.
Here’s a detailed comparison of their features, style, and value to help you decide which brand best fits your kitchen and coffee habits.
Smeg Espresso Machine
Smeg is celebrated for its distinctive, retro-inspired kitchen appliances that serve as stylish statement pieces. Their espresso machines follow this philosophy, combining a nostalgic 1950s aesthetic with simple, user-friendly functionality. Available in a range of eye-catching colors like pastel pink, creamy white, and cherry red, a Smeg machine is often chosen by those who value design just as much as their daily coffee.
- What it is: A line of semi-automatic espresso machines designed with a focus on vintage style, bold colors, and straightforward operation.
- Key features: Iconic mid-century modern design, compact footprint, simple three-button interface, and Thermoblock heating system for quick startup.
- Price: Typically ranges from $500 to $1,200.
- Style: Retro, 1950s-inspired. Known for polished chrome details, curved lines, and a wide array of color options not found in other brands.
- Materials/Construction: Features a durable stainless steel body wrapped in a colorful enamel finish. The emphasis is on external build quality and aesthetic appeal.
- Pros: Unmatched retro design makes it a kitchen showpiece. Small footprint is ideal for smaller countertops. Extremely simple and intuitive to use. Available in numerous colors to match any decor.
- Cons: Lacks the advanced features of competing machines in the same price range. Not built for baristas who want to fine-tune every shot. Higher price point is more for design than for a long list of features.
The Smeg espresso machine is ideal for the design-conscious homeowner who wants a reliable, easy-to-use appliance that looks fantastic on their countertop.
Shop this product: williams-sonoma.com/products/smeg-espresso-coffee-machine/
Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine
Breville is a powerhouse in the coffee world, known for its high-performance machines that bring café-quality espresso into the home. Their products are packed with innovative technology, durable components, and features that give users precise control over the brewing process. The wildly popular Barista Express is a perfect example of this, combining a high-quality grinder and a powerful espresso maker into one seamless unit.
- What it is: An all-in-one, semi-automatic espresso machine with a built-in grinder, aimed at home baristas who want control and professional results.
- Key features: Integrated conical burr grinder, precise PID temperature control, pressure gauge for optimal extraction, and a powerful steam wand for microfoam milk texturing.
- Price: Ranges from around $600 to over $2,000, with popular models like the Barista Express landing around $750.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and professional. The brushed stainless steel finish is designed to look at home in a contemporary kitchen.
- Materials/Construction: Built with high-grade stainless steel inside and out. Breville machines are engineered for consistent performance and longevity under frequent use.
- Pros: Offers incredible control and professional features for the price. The built-in grinder provides excellent value. Durable, robust construction. Capable of producing true café-quality espresso and latte art.
- Cons: Has a steeper learning curve for complete beginners. Its larger footprint requires more counter space. The aesthetic, while clean, is less distinctive than Smeg's.
A Breville machine is for the coffee enthusiast who wants to dive deep into the craft of espresso making and values performance, control, and durability above all else.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/espresso/bes870.html
Smeg vs. Breville Comparison
Style & Aesthetic
This is the most significant difference between the two brands. Smeg offers a journey back in time with its iconic 1950s aesthetic, bold colors, and curved, polished profiles. It's an appliance designed to be seen and admired - a true statement piece that adds personality and a pop of color to a kitchen. It perfectly suits retro, eclectic, or Scandinavian decor styles.
Breville, on the other hand, embodies a sleek, professional, and contemporary style. Dominated by brushed stainless steel and clean lines, a Breville machine looks more like a serious piece of kitchen equipment than a decorative item. Its utilitarian design is timeless and blends seamlessly into modern kitchen environments but lacks the flair and personality of a Smeg.
Performance & Features
Breville is the clear leader in performance and features. Models like the Barista Express come standard with features serious coffee lovers demand: an integrated grinder, digital temperature control (PID) for shot consistency, and a pressure gauge to monitor extraction. These tools allow you to experiment with grind size, dose, and temperature to perfect your espresso.
Smeg machines are much simpler by design. They offer basic, reliable functionality with easy-to-use buttons for one-shot, two-shot, or steam functions. They lack the fine-tuning capabilities of a Breville. Smeg machines will produce a good espresso, but they don't provide the control needed for a coffee hobbyist looking to experiment and grow their skills.
Materials & Construction
Both brands use high-quality stainless steel and have a solid feel. However, their engineering priorities differ. Smeg focuses on a flawless external finish and a sturdy frame that feels premium to the touch. It's built to look good for years.
Breville's construction is focused on function and durability for heavy, daily use. Internal components are robust, thoughtfully laid out, and parts are often designed for easy maintenance or replacement. This engineering approach ensures that a Breville can withstand the daily grind of a serious coffee routine for much longer.
Price & Value
While an entry-level Smeg and a model like the Breville Barista Express might be similarly priced, the value proposition is completely different. With Smeg, you are paying a premium for its unique design, brand name, and Italian style.
With Breville, your money goes directly toward performance-enhancing features. The value is packed into the technology - the integrated grinder alone is worth several hundred dollars. For coffee purists, Breville offers significantly more bang for your buck in terms of what ends up in the cup.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands make excellent machines, but they appeal to very different home baristas.
Choose a Smeg if:
- Aesthetics are your number one priority and you want an appliance that doubles as kitchen decor.
- You want a machine that is stylish, compact, and comes in fun, vibrant colors.
- You value simplicity and prefer a straightforward, no-fuss appliance for your daily coffee.
- You are a casual espresso drinker who doesn't need to experiment with advanced settings.
Choose a Breville if:
- You are a coffee hobbyist who wants to make café-quality drinks at home.
- You want precise control over variables like grind size, dose, and temperature.
- You see the value in an all-in-one machine with a high-quality integrated grinder.
- Performance, durability, and features are more important to you than a specific aesthetic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Smeg and Breville espresso machines?
The main difference is their core philosophy. A Smeg espresso machine is a style-focused appliance that delivers good, simple coffee in a beautiful, retro package. A Breville is a performance-focused tool packed with advanced technology to give home baristas precise control over the espresso-making process.
Is Smeg a good brand for espresso?
Yes, Smeg is a reputable brand that makes reliable espresso machines. They are well-built and produce a consistent shot of espresso. However, they are designed for simplicity and style, not for the aspiring professional barista who wants to fine-tune every aspect of the brew.
Is a Breville espresso machine worth the money for a beginner?
Absolutely. While machines like the Breville Barista Express have advanced features, they are also designed with user-friendly elements that help beginners learn. It's an excellent machine to grow with - simple enough to start on but with enough depth to keep you engaged for years.
Which brand is more durable?
Both are well-built, but Breville is generally considered more durable for heavy-duty, daily use. Its internal engineering is designed for longevity and consistent performance, whereas Smeg's build prioritizes a flawless external finish and aesthetic quality.
Do Smeg espresso machines have a built-in grinder?
No, the popular Smeg ECF01 espresso machine does not have a built-in grinder. You would need to purchase a separate one, while many popular Breville models like the Barista series come with an integrated, high-quality conical burr grinder.
How do they compare in size on a countertop?
Smeg espresso machines are generally more compact and have a smaller footprint, making them a great choice for kitchens with limited counter space. Breville machines, especially all-in-one models with grinders, tend to be wider and taller, requiring more room.
Which machine is easier to use?
The Smeg machine is significantly easier to use right out of the box. With just three buttons, the learning curve is almost nonexistent. A Breville has more settings and requires some practice to dial in the perfect shot, making it more complex initially.
Can you adjust the temperature on a Smeg espresso machine?
Smeg machines have preset temperature settings that are not user-adjustable. In contrast, many Breville models feature PID (Proportional Integral Derivative) control, allowing you to adjust the water temperature by degrees for optimal coffee extraction. This is a critical feature for serious coffee enthusiasts.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
