The Smeg MFF01 Milk Frother and the Breville BMF600XL Milk Cafe are two top-tier electric frothers that differ fundamentally in their approach: Smeg prioritizes distinctive retro style and simplicity, while Breville focuses on precision, performance, and versatility. The Smeg frother is a design-forward appliance for casual daily use, whereas the Breville is a high-performance tool for the home barista who wants café-quality control over foam texture and temperature.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right milk frother for your at-home coffee bar.
Smeg MFF01 Milk Frother
The Smeg Milk Frother is an extension of the brand's iconic '50s retro aesthetic, transforming a simple kitchen gadget into a stylish statement piece. It’s designed for users who value form as much as function, offering straightforward operation in a compact, eye-catching package. Available in a wide array of vibrant colors, it's built to complement other Smeg appliances like toasters and kettles.
- What it is: A retro-style electric milk frother focused on aesthetics and ease of use for creating hot and cold foam.
- Key features: Simple one-button control dial, multiple frothing functions (hot froth, cold froth, hot milk), built-in measuring cup lid, compact design.
- Price: Around $130 - $150
- Style: Bold and iconic '50s retro design, available in numerous colors including cream, black, red, and pastel green.
- Materials/Construction: Colored plastic and metal body with a stainless steel inner carafe.
- Pros: Stunning design that adds character to any kitchen. Very easy to operate with a simple control knob. Works well for basic foaming and heating. Compact footprint is ideal for small countertops.
- Cons: Limited control over foam texture and temperature. Smaller capacity than its competitors. The exterior is prone to showing fingerprints. Primarily plastic construction is less robust than Breville's stainless steel.
The Smeg frother is perfect for anyone whose top priority is creating a stylish, coordinated kitchen aesthetic without needing granular control over their foam.
Shop this product: https://www.smeg.com/us/products/MFF01CRUS
Breville BMF600XL Milk Cafe
From the high-performance appliance maker Breville, the Milk Cafe is engineered for coffee enthusiasts who demand precision and consistency. Using induction heating and interchangeable frothing discs, it provides unparalleled control over milk temperature and texture, from silky micro-foam for lattes to stiff foam for cappuccinos. Its sleek, utilitarian design prioritizes professional-grade functionality.
- What it is: An advanced electric milk frother with customizable temperature and foam settings for professional-style results.
- Key features: Adjustable temperature control (from cold stir to 180°F), interchangeable discs for latte (smooth) or cappuccino (frothy) foam, induction heating for even heat, large 3-cup capacity.
- Price: Around $159.95
- Style: Modern and minimalist with a brushed stainless steel finish that matches other contemporary kitchen appliances.
- Materials/Construction: Durable brushed stainless steel jug and a sturdy base with high-quality electronic components.
- Pros: Excellent control over temperature and foam texture allows for true cafe-quality drinks. Large capacity is great for families or entertaining. The stainless steel jug is durable and dishwasher safe, making cleanup easy. Works exceptionally well with non-dairy milks.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive. The larger size takes up more counter space. The design is purely functional and lacks the aesthetic charm of the Smeg.
This is the ideal frother for discerning home baristas who want to replicate their favorite coffee shop drinks with perfect texture and temperature every time.
Shop this product: https://www.breville.com/us/en/products/coffee/bmf600.html
Smeg vs. Breville Milk Frother Comparison
Style & Aesthetic
This is the most significant point of difference. The Smeg is a design object intended to be seen. Its curved, glossy body and chrome accents evoke mid-century charm, serving as a bright pop of color on your countertop. It's for kitchens where every detail is curated.
The Breville Milk Cafe takes the opposite approach. Its brushed stainless steel body is modern, sleek, and utilitarian. It’s designed to look professional and blend quietly with other high-end appliances, prioritizing function over standout looks.
Features & Performance
Breville is the clear winner on performance and features. Its adjustable temperature dial allows you to get your milk exactly as hot as you want it, which is crucial for different types of coffee and for optimizing the flavor of non-dairy milks. The two interchangeable frothing discs - one for smooth latte foam and another for airy cappuccino foam - provide real versatility. The induction heating ensures fast, even heat without hot spots.
The Smeg offers basic functions: hot froth (light or dense), hot milk, or cold froth, selected via a simple Turn-and-Push knob. While effective for everyday use, it doesn't offer the precision or customization of the Breville. It produces good-quality foam but is less adaptable to specific coffee-making styles.
Capacity & Dimensions
The Breville Milk Cafe has a large 25 oz (3 cup) jug, capable of frothing enough milk for two to three lattes at once. This makes it ideal for families or for when you have company. This larger capacity results in a bigger footprint on your counter.
The Smeg frother is more compact, with a maximum frothing capacity of around 8.5 oz. It's perfectly suited for making one drink at a time and is a great choice for smaller kitchens or single coffee-drinker households where counter space is a premium.
Materials & Construction
Breville uses premium, heavy-duty brushed stainless steel for its jug, which is not only durable but also dishwasher-safe for effortless cleanup. The base is sturdy and feels built to last for years of heavy use. The Smeg has a robust build with high-quality plastic and a steel inner vessel, but its emphasis is on the colorful finish rather than heavy-duty materials.
Price & Value
The Smeg frother is a C-Suite style frother that sits squarely in the mid-range premium appliance category, with its price justified almost entirely by its iconic design and brand name. The Breville Milk Cafe costs more, but that extra cost directly translates to a wider feature set, superior performance, larger capacity, and more durable construction. Breville offers more value for the serious coffee aficionado, while Smeg provides value for the design enthusiast.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Smeg and Breville frothers are excellent at what they do, but they are built for entirely different coffee drinkers and kitchens.
Choose the Smeg Milk Frother if:
- Your kitchen's aesthetic is a top priority, and you love retro or vintage design.
- You want a simple, straightforward appliance for making a good latte or cappuccino.
- Counter space is limited, and you need a compact machine.
- You already own or plan to buy other matching Smeg appliances.
Choose the Breville Milk Cafe if:
- You are passionate about coffee and want precise control over milk temperature and texture.
- You need a larger capacity to make drinks for multiple people at once.
- Performance, durability, and easy cleaning are more important to you than looks.
- You frequently experiment with different dairy and non-dairy milks to find the perfect micro-foam.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between the Smeg and Breville milk frothers?
The main difference is their core focus. The Smeg frother is a design-first appliance focused on style and simple operation. The Breville frother is a performance-first tool focused on precision, versatility, and creating café-quality foam.
Which frother makes better foam?
For most coffee enthusiasts, the Breville makes objectively "better" foam because you can control its temperature and adjust the aeration with different discs. It excels at creating the silky, fine-textured micro-foam ideal for latte art. Smeg produces good-quality foam, but lacks this level of nuanced control.
Is the Smeg milk frother worth the price?
Yes, if style is a key consideration. You are paying a premium for its unique '50s retro design and the Smeg brand name. Its performance is reliable for daily use, making it a worthwhile purchase for those who prioritize both form and function.
Can the Breville Milk Frother make cold foam?
Yes, it has a "cold stir" setting that froths the milk without activating the heating element. This is perfect for making iced lattes, iced cappuccinos, or cold foam cold brew.
How do you clean the Smeg milk frother?
The Smeg frother's stainless steel inner jug is non-removable, so it must be cleaned by hand. The interior has a non-stick coating that makes it easy to rinse and wipe clean with a soft cloth after each use.
Is the Breville milk frother jug dishwasher safe?
Yes, a major advantage of the Breville Milk Cafe is that its stainless steel jug is removable from the induction base and is completely dishwasher safe, which makes for very easy cleanup.
Which frother is better for a beginner?
The Smeg's simple one-knob operation is incredibly user-friendly and perfect for a beginner who just wants warm, frothy milk without any complexity. Breville is also easy to use, but its additional features may be overkill for someone just starting.
Do these frothers work with non-dairy milk?
Yes, both frothers perform well with almond, soy, and especially oat milk. However, the Breville's adjustable temperature control can be a significant advantage, as some non-dairy milks froth better at slightly lower temperatures than cow's milk.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
