The Slip Silk Pillowcase and the Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase are two of the best options available, but they cater to slightly different priorities. Slip is positioned as a luxury beauty product with clinically proven benefits for skin and hair, commanding a premium price, while Brooklinen offers a nearly identical high-quality silk pillowcase with a focus on value and practicality for home use.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which silk pillowcase is the right choice for your bed.
Slip Silk Pillowcase
Slip is largely responsible for the popularity of silk pillowcases in the beauty world. They market their signature product not just as bedding, but as a long-term skincare and haircare investment. It's the original, high-end option often found in luxury department stores and recommended by dermatologists and celebrity hairstylists.
- What it is: A premium, luxury pillowcase made from 100% long-strand mulberry silk, engineered to be gentle on skin and hair.
- Key features: Made from Slipsilk™, their proprietary weave of 22 momme mulberry silk. Created over ten years to provide the ultimate combination of shine, thickness, softness, and durability.
- Price: Around $89 (Queen) to $110 (King).
- Style: Elegant and minimalistic with a very high sheen. Available in a wide variety of colors, from timeless neutrals like white and charcoal to bright pinks and marble patterns.
- Materials/Construction: 100% 6A long-strand mulberry silk with a 22 momme weight and non-toxic dyes. Features a sturdy zipper closure.
- Pros: The established authority in the beauty-focused silk pillowcase market. Unmatched smoothness that reduces friction. Wide range of colors and designs. Zipper closure keeps the pillow secure.
- Cons: Carries a significant premium price tag. More delicate laundering is required to maintain its texture. The high sheen might not suit all bedding styles.
The Slip pillowcase is ideal for someone who views this purchase as a beauty tool and is willing to invest in the original brand known for its luxurious feel and benefits.
Shop this product: slip.com/collections/pillowcases
Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase
Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer brand beloved for making high-quality home essentials accessible. Their Mulberry Silk Pillowcase brings this philosophy to the world of silk, offering a premium-quality product that competes with luxury brands on material and construction but beats them on price.
- What it is: A high-quality, 100% mulberry silk pillowcase designed to provide skin and hair benefits with a focus on value.
- Key features: Made from 100% mulberry silk with a calming, gentle feel. Designed to be breathable and naturally cool to the touch.
- Price: Around $59 (Standard) to $69 (King).
- Style: Modern and versatile with a slightly more subtle sheen than Slip. Comes in a curated set of core colors that match Brooklinen's other bedding collections.
- Materials/Construction: 100% long-strand mulberry silk with a 22 momme weight. Features a deep envelope closure.
- Pros: Exceptional value for a 22 momme mulberry silk pillowcase. Significantly more affordable than Slip. 365-day return policy provides a risk-free trial. Easy to pair with other Brooklinen bedding.
- Cons: Limited color selection compared to Slip. Envelope closure may not feel as secure as a zipper for restless sleepers. Lacks the recognized "beauty brand" status of Slip.
The Brooklinen pillowcase is perfect for anyone wanting the proven benefits of silk without the luxury markup, especially for those prioritizing value and easy-to-coordinate home decor.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/mulberry-silk-pillowcase
Slip vs. Brooklinen Pillowcase Comparison
Materials & Quality
On paper, the materials used by Slip and Brooklinen are nearly identical. Both use 100% long-strand mulberry silk with a 22 momme count, which is the industry standard for high-quality, durable silk bedding. Momme is a measure of silk density, a higher number means more silk per square inch, resulting in a stronger and more lustrous fabric. In your hands, both feel incredibly smooth, soft, and substantial.
The main differentiator here is branding and proprietary processes. Slip built its reputation on its unique Slipsilk™, which emphasizes a specific finish that's been dermatologist and stylist tested. While Brooklinen's silk feels just as premium, Slip's has spent years cultivating the story of being a purpose-built beauty product.
Style & Aesthetics
Your choice here comes down to personal taste. Slip offers a vast array of colors and patterns, from classic blush and charcoal to limited-edition prints and collaborations. The finish has a distinct, high-gloss sheen that screams luxury. It’s designed to be a statement piece on your bed.
The Brooklinen pillowcase takes a more grounded approach. Its color palette is smaller and more curated, featuring core colors like White, Cream, and Carbon that are designed to easily coordinate with the rest of their sheets and duvet covers. The finish is slightly more muted - still lustrous, but less overtly shiny than Slip's, which may appeal to those looking for a more subtle touch of luxury.
Price & Value
This is the most significant difference between the two products. A queen-size Slip pillowcase costs around $89, making it a clear luxury purchase. A standard Brooklinen pillowcase, made from the same quality silk, costs just $59. This $30 price gap is difficult to ignore.
Brooklinen delivers outstanding value. You are getting the same key material benefits - the smooth surface, cooling properties, and durable 22 momme silk - for substantially less money. Additionally, Brooklinen's 365-day "any reason" return policy offers incredible peace of mind, allowing you to try it out for an entire year. Slip's policy is a more standard 60 days on unused items.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both silk pillowcases offer fantastic benefits for your hair and skin, but they serve different buyers.
Choose the Slip Silk Pillowcase if:
- You want the original, iconic beauty-focused silk pillowcase with brand recognition.
- The very high sheen and extensive color options appeal to your personal style.
- You see this as a skincare or haircare tool first and value its reputation among experts.
- Budget is not your primary concern for this purchase.
Choose the Brooklinen Mulberry Silk Pillowcase if:
- You're looking for the best possible value for a high-quality, 22 momme silk pillowcase.
- You want to dip your toes into the world of silk bedding without a massive investment.
- A generous 365-day return policy is important to you.
- You prefer a more understated aesthetic that coordinates easily with other bedding.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Slip and Brooklinen silk pillowcases?
The main differences are price and brand positioning. Slip is positioned as a luxury beauty product at a premium price point (around $89), while Brooklinen offers a pillowcase of identical material quality (22 momme mulberry silk) at a much better value (around $59).
Is Slip's silk pillowcase really worth the money?
If brand prestige, a wider variety of colors, and the experience of owning the "original" are important to you, then yes. For many, it's a worthwhile beauty investment. However, based purely on material quality, you can get the same functional benefits for less.
Is Brooklinen's silk as good as Slip's?
Yes, in terms of specifications, Brooklinen's pillowcase is just as good. Both use 100% long-strand mulberry silk with a durable 22 momme weight, ensuring a smooth, soft, and long-lasting product.
Which pillowcase is better for preventing wrinkles and hair frizz?
Both are equally effective. The benefits come from the smooth surface of the mulberry silk, which reduces friction against your skin and hair as you sleep. Because both pillowcases use the same high-quality material, they will both help minimize sleep creases and prevent hair breakage and frizz.
How do you wash a silk pillowcase from these brands?
Both brands recommend either hand washing or using a delicate machine wash cycle with cold water and a pH-neutral liquid detergent. It's best to place the pillowcase in a mesh laundry bag, wash with like colors, and hang to dry away from direct sunlight.
Does a zipper closure or envelope closure matter?
This is a matter of preference. Slip's zipper closure provides the most secure fit and ensures the pillow will never peek out. Brooklinen's deep envelope closure is sufficient for most sleepers and has the advantage of having no hardware to potentially snag delicate fabrics.
Why is 22 momme silk better?
Momme is a unit of weight measurement for silk, indicating its density. While 19 momme is common, 22 momme silk contains nearly 20% more silk per square yard. This makes the fabric stronger, more opaque, more lustrous, and better equipped to withstand washing and regular use.
Can I return the pillowcase if it's not right for me?
Yes, but the policies differ greatly. Brooklinen has an industry-leading 365-day return policy, allowing you to try the pillowcase for a full year. Slip offers a more conventional 60-day policy for items in their original, unused condition.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
