Sixpenny offers modern, customizable furniture with a focus on relaxed comfort and practical performance fabrics, placing it in an accessible mid-range price bracket. Maiden Home operates in the premium space, delivering American-made, artisanal pieces with a more classic-modern aesthetic and a higher price point to match its heirloom-quality construction.
Let's compare these two brands to help you decide which is the right investment for your home.
Sixpenny: The Modern & Customizable Choice
Sixpenny has earned a reputation for its handcrafted, comfortable furniture that feels both modern and lived-in. Their approach centers on providing customizable, high-quality pieces directly to consumers online, with an emphasis on durable materials like performance fabrics and responsibly sourced wood. The brand appeals to those decorating modern homes or condos who need stylish, versatile furniture that can stand up to everyday use.
- Product mix: Primarily known for sofas and sectionals, but also offers accent chairs, ottomans, and modular collections for flexible living spaces.
- Style/vibe: Relaxed contemporary and modern comfort. Designs feature clean lines, deep seats, and an approachable, minimalist feel that fits well in casual interiors.
- Price point: Mid-range. Sofas typically cost between $2,000 and $4,500, offering significant value for a handcrafted, customizable product.
- Quality: Built with kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-density foam cushions. Many collections feature slipcovers made from performance fabrics that are stain-resistant and perfect for homes with pets or children.
- Customization: Customers can tailor their furniture by choosing from a curated selection of fabrics, seating configurations, and leg finishes.
- Sustainability: Committed to eco-friendly practices, including using responsibly harvested wood and offering sustainable fabric options. The brand values transparency in its manufacturing process.
- Return policy: Offers a generous return policy, making the online buying process feel lower risk.
- Delivery & Assembly: Most orders include free shipping, with items arriving fully assembled or with minimal setup required.
Sixpenny delivers stylish and durable furniture at an accessible mid-range price, making it a smart choice for design-conscious homeowners who prioritize comfort and practicality.
Shop Sixpenny: sixpenny.com
Maiden Home: The Artisanal & Premium Brand
Maiden Home is a premium furniture brand that partners with artisan craftsmen in the USA to create high-end, custom pieces. The brand’s identity is built on superior construction, lifelong durability, and a refined, timeless aesthetic. With a commitment to American-made quality and sustainable materials, Maiden Home targets discerning buyers who are willing to invest in heirloom furniture that will last for decades.
- Product mix: Specializes in sophisticated sofas, sectionals, and beds, along with a curated range of high-end accent chairs and benches.
- Style/vibe: Classic-modern and timeless elegance. The designs feature refined proportions, elegant lines, and a luxurious feel that suits both traditional and contemporary interiors.
- Price point: Premium. Sofas generally start at $3,000 and can exceed $6,000 for larger or higher-end fabric selections. The brand provides design-driven, high-quality heirloom pieces, investing in American craftsmanship for life.
- Quality: Uses kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-resilience foam cushions, and premium textiles sourced from heritage mills. Construction includes hand-finished details and reinforced joinery for superior durability.
- Customization: Provides extensive customization options, including a wide array of premium fabrics, leather, leg finishes, and configurations to create a truly bespoke piece.
- Warranty: Backed by an impressive lifetime warranty on frames and suspension, signaling strong confidence in the product's longevity.
- Shopping Experience: Offers a personalized, high-touch experience with dedicated design consultants, complimentary swatches, and showroom locations in select cities.
- Sustainability: Emphasizes ethical production with sustainably sourced, American-made materials, supporting local communities and reducing environmental impact.
Maiden Home is for those who view furniture as a long-term investment and appreciate the superior quality that comes from domestic, artisanal craftsmanship.
Shop Maiden Home: maidenhome.com
Sixpenny vs. Maiden Home Comparison
Price Comparison
Sixpenny positions itself as an affordable luxury brand. With sofas in the $2,000 to $4,500 range, it provides excellent value for customizable, well-made furniture. This price point makes it an attainable choice for many households looking to upgrade from big-box retailers without entering the high-end luxury market.
Maiden Home operates at a higher, premium price point, with sofas typically ranging from $3,000 to over $6,000. This cost reflects their commitment to American craftsmanship, high-end materials, lifetime warranties, and a more personalized design service. The price reflects an investment in a piece that is designed and built to last a lifetime.
Style & Aesthetic
Sixpenny's aesthetic is clean, modern, and inviting. Their collections often feature generous proportions, deep seats, and soft upholstery. Slipcovered styles give many sofas a relaxed, coastal, "cloud couch" feeling, ideal for casual and contemporary living spaces. This style appeals to those who prioritize comfort and a laid-back, modern vibe.
Maiden Home leans into a more classic-modern and transitional elegance. Their designs are characterized by refined silhouettes, tailored details, and luxurious finishes. Their pieces are highly versatile and can anchor a sophisticated living room or add a touch of grace to a family-friendly space, easily complementing various classic or contemporary styles.
Quality & Construction
Both brands use top-tier materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-density foam cushions as a baseline for quality. Where they differ is in their finishing touches and guarantees.
Sixpenny excels in practicality, focusing on durable performance fabrics and often slipcovered designs that make a busy home easier to manage. Maiden Home’s focus, on the other hand, is premium craftsmanship with artisanal construction. Hand-finished details, reinforced joinery, and superior cushion construction are signatures of heirloom quality. Maiden Home’s unbeatable lifetime warranty that covers the frame and suspension ensures a better value and peace of mind over time.
Customization Options
Both brands shine in this category, moving far beyond the limited choices of mass-market furniture. Sixpenny offers robust customization across fabrics, configurations, and finishes, allowing customers to easily create a piece that fits their needs and modern style perfectly.
Maiden Home takes this a step further by offering an even broader range of premium, designer-quality textiles such as bouclés, velvets, and linens, as well as made-to-order sizing in many configurations. Their process feels more akin to a high-end interior design service, giving buyers precise control over the final aesthetic.
Shopping Experience
Shopping with Sixpenny is a modern, direct-to-consumer experience. Their website is easy to navigate, with clean visuals and a straightforward customization process. Complimentary shipping and a generous return policy add to the convenience of buying furniture online.
Maiden Home offers a much more high-touch, premium model. They offer showrooms for in-person shopping, in addition to dedicated design consultants who guide customers through every step of the selection process. This hands-on help is part of their commitment to giving consumers total satisfaction in what are, for them, very significant purchases.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both companies make sustainability a core part of their brand identity. Sixpenny focuses on responsibly sourced wood through FSC certification along with other eco-friendly and natural materials.
Maiden Home prides itself on American-based manufacturing. Using artisans for every handcrafted piece produced at their factories, Maiden Home provides unique and sustainable designs. Sourcing materials from local suppliers in the US further minimizes global emissions and ensures full transparency. Each of their products also earned a certification from GreenGUARD for their low emission record.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your budget, aesthetic preferences, and long-term priorities. Both brands create outstanding furniture, but for a unique style and consumer shopping experience.
Choose Sixpenny if:
- Your style is relaxed, modern, or contemporary.
- You need durable, easy-to-clean performance fabrics for a home with kids or pets.
- You're looking for great value in the $2,000–$4,500 price range for well-crafted furniture.
- You appreciate a streamlined online shopping experience with free shipping.
Choose Maiden Home if:
- You prioritize American-made quality and artisanal craftsmanship.
- You want furniture built to be an heirloom, backed by a lifetime warranty.
- Your style is a classic modern elegance, perfect with just about any aesthetic or design style, and your budget starts around $3,000 for your main sofa.
- In-home design professionals deliver superior, professional design services. They excel at both personalized service and shopping while helping you design your custom furniture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sixpenny or Maiden Home cheaper?
Sixpenny sofas are definitely less expensive. They're more popular in the high middle-end range between $2,000 - $4,500. By contrast, Maiden Home starts around a high $3,000 base price with sofas priced at or over $6,000 USD, placing them in the luxury home goods segment.
Which has better quality furniture?
Both brands offer superior quality sofas. They both use premium construction and hardwood frames. Maiden Home stands out as a luxury brand offering custom craft designs made in America as a long-term investment. Sixpenny's line features more everyday use furniture, focusing on durable, resilient frames, and cushions, making them ideal for families with kids or pets.
Which brand makes the most resilient furniture for households with kids & pets?
Sixpenny focuses more on practical everyday designs that withstand the wear and tear of active homes, whereas Maiden Home emphasizes premium, durable construction designed as lifetime investments.
Where is my new Sixpenny or Maiden Home sofa made?
Both brands source high-quality materials but primarily manufacture in the U.S., emphasizing sustainable and ethical practices.
Which brands offer furniture guarantees that will last a lifetime?
Maiden Home provides a lifetime warranty on frames and suspension, reflecting its confidence in long-term durability.
Can I view or purchase Sixpenny sofas in-store?
Sixpenny primarily operates online, but they occasionally have pop-up events where you can view their products in cities like NYC and LA.
Can I customize my Sixpenny or Maiden Home sofa?
Yes, both brands offer extensive customization options, allowing you to tailor designs to your preferences.
Who is better for my design ideas: Sixpenny or Maiden Home?
It depends on your specific design needs and budget. Sixpenny offers practical customization for contemporary styles, while Maiden Home provides premium, bespoke solutions for a luxury aesthetic.
If both brands are sustainable, what makes a difference when choosing my furniture?
Both brands emphasize sustainability, but Sixpenny focuses on affordability and durability for everyday use, while Maiden Home offers high-end, environmentally conscious craftsmanship with long-term durability.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
