The main difference between doors from Semihandmade and IKEA comes down to customization, material quality, and price. Semihandmade offers high-end, custom-made doors in a vast array of styles and materials designed to elevate standard IKEA cabinets into bespoke furniture. In contrast, IKEA provides a more limited range of budget-friendly, mass-produced doors made from standard materials like fiberboard and laminate.
Here's everything you need to know to decide whether to choose a premium, custom look or a wallet-friendly, off-the-shelf solution for your next project.
Semihandmade Doors
Semihandmade has built its business on transforming standard IKEA cabinet systems with high-quality, designer-forward fronts. The company gives homeowners a way to achieve a custom look for their kitchen, bathroom, or closet without the cost of fully custom cabinetry. They specialize in a wide range of styles and materials that you simply cannot find at IKEA, making them a go-to for designers and DIYers looking for a premium finish.
- What it is: Custom, made-to-order cabinet doors, drawer fronts, and panels designed specifically to fit IKEA's Sektion, Akurum, Pax, and Godmorgon cabinet frames.
- Key features: Extensive catalog of styles including Shaker, slab, beaded, and textured panels. Available in a huge variety of materials and finishes, from painted MDF to real wood veneers.
- Price: Premium pricing, typically ranging from $150 to $350 per door.
- Style: Boutique, high-end, and highly customizable. It can fit nearly any aesthetic, from traditional farmhouse to modern minimalist and everything in between.
- Materials/Construction: High-quality materials like durable medium-density fiberboard (MDF) for painted doors and real wood veneers in species like walnut and white oak. The construction is focused on durability and a refined finish.
- Pros: Creates a truly custom, expensive look for a fraction of the price of full custom cabinets. Superior material quality and durability. Vastly more style and color options. Increases home resale value with a more designed look.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than IKEA's options. Production and shipping lead times can be several weeks long. Requires more planning as it's an online-only, made-to-order purchase.
Semihandmade doors are for homeowners who prioritize aesthetics and are willing to invest more for a durable, customized look that elevates their space far beyond a standard install.
Shop this product: semihandmade.com/collections/fronts
IKEA Doors
IKEA doors are the default choice for the brand's world-famous modular cabinetry systems. Known for their affordability, accessibility, and straightforward Scandinavian design, these doors offer a functional and clean look. They are designed for easy DIY installation and are readily available, making them a convenient option for quick renovations, rental properties, or any project where budget is the top concern.
- What it is: A pre-made, mass-produced range of cabinet doors and drawer fronts designed to fit IKEA’s specific cabinet frames.
- Key features: A range of core styles like Shaker (Axstad, Grimslov) and slab (Veddinge, Voxtorp). Doors come pre-drilled for easy installation. Globally available and in-stock for immediate projects.
- Price: Highly budget-friendly, typically ranging from $30 to $150 per door.
- Style: Modern, functional, and minimalist with a distinct Scandinavian influence. Fewer options, but the styles available are versatile.
- Materials/Construction: Primarily made from engineered materials like fiberboard with foil, laminate, or painted finishes. Some higher-end options feature real wood veneers. Designed for cost-efficiency.
- Pros: Extremely affordable, often a fraction of the cost of Semihandmade. Available immediately for pickup or delivery. Simple, clean styles work for many modern designs. Very easy to plan for and purchase.
- Cons: Limited material and color selection. Materials are less durable and can be prone to chipping or water damage over time. The look is very common and lacks a custom feel. Styles can be discontinued, making replacements difficult years later.
IKEA doors are ideal for anyone on a tight budget, renters, or DIYers who need a fast, simple, and functional solution without the complexity of custom orders.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/kitchen-cabinet-doors-fronts-10780/
Semihandmade vs. IKEA Doors Comparison
Materials & Construction
This is where the two brands differ the most. IKEA focuses on affordability, using fiberboard with foil or laminate finishes. While functional for everyday use, these materials can be susceptible to scratches, dents, and swelling from moisture, especially in a high-traffic kitchen or bathroom.
Semihandmade prioritizes a premium finish and longevity. Their painted Shaker doors use a high-quality MDF core which is more stable and less prone to warping than solid wood, and their wood veneers are real wood layers that provide a rich, authentic look. This superior construction results in doors that not only look better up close but also hold up better to wear and tear.
Style & Versatility
IKEA offers a curated selection of popular styles that fit a modern, generally minimalist aesthetic. You can get a classic Shaker, a glossy slab, or a basic raised panel, but your choices within those categories are limited to a handful of colors. The versatility is in their simplicity - they act as a blank canvas.
Semihandmade's catalog is dramatically larger and more diverse. They offer dozens of door styles and a wide spectrum of trendy, classic, and bold colors. From textured panels and beaded frames to Quarter Sawn or Classic Walnut wood grains, their options allow you to achieve a much more specific and personalized design. If you want your kitchen to have a unique character, Semihandmade offers far more creative freedom.
Fit & Customization
Both Semihandmade and IKEA doors are designed to fit IKEA’s own cabinet systems, so installation on a new IKEA kitchen is simple with either brand.
The key difference is that Semihandmade can produce doors and panels in custom sizes. This is a massive advantage if you need to fit cabinetry around odd angles, integrate non-IKEA appliances, or create custom-sized wardrobes. IKEA is strictly limited to its standard modular dimensions, offering no flexibility for non-standard projects.
Price & Value
There is no contest when it comes to the lowest price: IKEA is the clear winner. A full kitchen of IKEA doors can cost under $2,000, while the same kitchen with Semihandmade doors could easily run $6,000 or more. If your primary goal is to complete a project for the least amount of money, IKEA is the answer.
However, value is about more than just the upfront cost. Semihandmade provides value through superior durability, timeless design, and a high-end aesthetic that can increase your home's resale value. The investment translates into a kitchen that looks and feels custom-built, providing long-term satisfaction and visual appeal that IKEA can’t match.
Shopping Experience & Lead Time
The IKEA experience is built on convenience and immediacy. You can design, purchase, and take home an entire kitchen's worth of doors in a single day. Their online tools are straightforward, and their massive inventory means products are usually available right away.
Choosing Semihandmade requires more patience and planning. As a made-to-order product, you can expect lead times of several weeks to over a month. The ordering process is entirely online, which involves selecting samples, measuring carefully, and waiting for production. It’s a less immediate process but offers a much more customized and high-quality result.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent products, but they are designed for very different customers and project goals.
Choose Semihandmade if:
- You want a custom-designed, high-end look without paying for fully custom cabinetry.
- The specific style, color, or material you want isn't available from IKEA.
- Durability and premium materials are more important to you than the lowest possible price.
- You have a healthy budget and can wait several weeks for your doors to be manufactured.
Choose IKEA if:
- You are on a tight budget and need the most cost-effective option available.
- You need your cabinet doors immediately to complete a fast project.
- You are happy with a simple, modern look and don't need extensive customization.
- You are completing a project for a rental unit or a space where premium materials are not a priority.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Semihandmade and IKEA doors?
The primary differences are material quality, customization, and price. Semihandmade uses higher-grade materials like solid wood-veneered MDF for bespoke, on-trend doors at a premium price. IKEA uses mass-produced fiberboard and laminate for a much smaller range of affordable, basic doors.
Are Semihandmade doors higher quality than IKEA?
Yes, objectively so. Semihandmade uses more durable materials, higher-quality finishes, and more refined construction methods. Their doors are heavier, more resistant to wear, and feel more substantial than standard IKEA doors.
How much more expensive is Semihandmade than IKEA?
You can generally expect to pay two to four times more for Semihandmade doors compared to IKEA doors for the same kitchen layout. A basic door from IKEA might cost $50, while a similar-sized door from Semihandmade could be $200 or more.
Do Semihandmade doors fit IKEA cabinets perfectly?
Yes, they are engineered specifically to work seamlessly with IKEA's Sektion (kitchen), Pax (closet), and Besta (storage) cabinet systems, using the same hinge and drawer hardware.
Can I get Semihandmade for a non-IKEA kitchen?
While their primary business is making fronts for IKEA systems, Semihandmade can often create custom-sized doors for projects using other cabinet boxes. You would need to check with their team for specific capabilities.
Which brand has more style options?
Semihandmade has a significantly larger and more diverse selection of styles, colors, and finishes. They offer options ranging from classic Shaker to modern slab and textured fronts in a huge palette of paint colors and wood tones.
Is it hard to install Semihandmade doors on IKEA cabinets?
No, the installation process is just as easy as installing IKEA's own doors. The doors are sized to fit and come with options for pre-drilling holes for IKEA's hinge system, making the process straightforward for any DIYer.
Which option adds more resale value to a home?
A kitchen featuring Semihandmade fronts would likely add more perceived value to a home upon resale. It creates a custom, "designer kitchen" look that stands out more than a standard IKEA installation.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
