Rubbermaid is the go-to brand for affordable, durable, and practical food storage, making it ideal for budget-conscious families and everyday use. In contrast, OXO targets consumers who value innovative, ergonomic design and superior airtight technology, offering a more premium, stylish solution for keeping food fresh.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right food storage brand for your kitchen.
Rubbermaid: The Affordable & Functional Choice
Rubbermaid is a long-standing household name known for producing reliable and budget-friendly home organization products. Its food storage line is a staple in many kitchens due to its straightforward functionality, durability, and wide availability. Rubbermaid's an excellent choice for anyone needing a large volume of dependable containers without a significant investment.
- Product mix: Extensive range of food storage containers, pantry organization bins, and other home storage solutions.
- Style/vibe: Simple, utilitarian, and function-first. Designs are practical and come in various standard colors, but aesthetics are secondary to performance.
- Price point: Very affordable. A multi-piece set of basic containers often costs between $10 and $25, making it easy to stock up.
- Quality: Made from durable, BPA-free plastics built for daily use. Higher-end lines offer great leak-proof seals, though some base-level containers may be prone to staining or warping over time with heavy use.
- Fit & Sizing: Offers a massive variety of shapes and sizes, from small snack cups to large bulk bins. Many of their collections are modular and stackable to save space in the fridge and pantry.
For shoppers seeking no-frills, dependable food storage that gets the job done at an unbeatable price, Rubbermaid is a clear winner.
Shop Rubbermaid: rubbermaid.com
OXO: The Innovative & Ergonomic Choice
OXO focuses on thoughtful design and user experience, creating kitchen tools and storage solutions that are a step above the basics. The brand is celebrated for its ergonomic features, high-quality materials, and superior airtight seals that preserve food freshness. OXO is for the home cook who appreciates a well-designed product and is willing to pay more for enhanced performance and style.
- Product mix: High-quality food storage containers (especially their notable POP line), kitchen gadgets, and housewares designed with user comfort in mind.
- Style/vibe: Sleek, minimalist, and modern. Clear bodies and uniform lids create a clean, organized look perfect for an Instagram-worthy pantry.
- Price point: Premium-mid-range. Individual containers or small sets typically range from $15 to $30+, reflecting the higher quality materials and innovative features.
- Quality: Excellent construction using thick, BPA-free plastics that are highly resistant to staining and odors. The airtight locking mechanisms and silicone seals are best-in-class for maintaining freshness.
- Fit & Sizing: A well-curated range of sizes designed for optimal stacking and space efficiency. Their containers are known for fitting together seamlessly on shelves.
OXO is the ideal choice for those who want top-tier performance, a modern aesthetic, and products built for longevity.
Shop OXO: oxo.com
Rubbermaid vs. OXO Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear price difference between the two brands. Rubbermaid is the undisputed budget champion. You can purchase large, multi-piece sets for a low price, and they are frequently on sale at major retailers like Walmart and Target. This makes Rubbermaid highly accessible for families, college students, or anyone needing to acquire many containers at once.
OXO products come with a higher price tag. An OXO container might cost as much as a small set of Rubbermaid containers. This premium price is justified by superior materials, more robust airtight seals, and ergonomic design. You are paying for a product designed for longevity and optimal performance, seeing it as an investment rather than a disposable commodity.
Quality & Materials
Both brands use BPA-free plastic, but the quality differs. Rubbermaid containers are workhorses - durable enough for daily abuse but can fall short in some areas. Over time, some may stain from sauces, retain odors, or warp slightly if microwaved or washed in a hot dishwasher.
OXO containers feel noticeably more substantial. They use thicker, crystal-clear plastic that resists staining and odors exceptionally well. The most significant quality differentiator is the lid and seal. OXO's airtight push-button or locking tab mechanisms create a truly secure seal that outperforms most of Rubbermaid’s standard lids, keeping dry goods crisp and produce fresh for longer.
Style & Aesthetic
The style contrast is stark. Rubbermaid embraces a practical, no-nonsense aesthetic. While functional, the varied lid colors and classic container shapes focus more on utility than visual cohesion. It’s perfect for behind-the-scenes storage in a busy fridge or packed lunch bags.
OXO is designed to be seen. Its containers boast a clean, uniform, and minimalist look that can transform a chaotic pantry into an organized and visually pleasing space. The clear bodies and white lids provide a modern, high-end feel, appealing to those who take pride in their kitchen's appearance.
Fit & Sizing
Both brands offer a wide array of sizes suitable for everything from salad dressing to bulk flour. Rubbermaid provides an enormous variety, though stacking different lines together can sometimes be clunky. Their modular designs are effective but may lack the seamless precision of OXO.
OXO excels at creating space-efficient, stackable systems. The shapes and sizes are intentionally designed to fit together perfectly, maximizing every inch of shelf space. This makes it an ideal choice for anyone prioritizing a neat and orderly storage system.
Shopping Experience
Rubbermaid is incredibly easy to find. It’s sold in almost every supermarket, big-box retailer, and online marketplace. The convenience of picking up a new set during a regular grocery trip is a major advantage.
OXO is also widely available but more common in specialty kitchen stores, department stores like Macy's, and online retailers like Amazon and their direct website. While not as omnipresent as Rubbermaid, it’s still simple to purchase.
Sustainability & Ethics
For consumers focused on sustainability, both brands present a mixed bag as producers of plastic goods. Rubbermaid has initiatives to incorporate recycled materials into some product lines. The brand emphasis is on durability and reusability, which reduces single-use plastic waste.
OXO focuses on longevity as its primary sustainability feature - creating a long-lasting product reduces the need for replacement. They use high-quality, recyclable materials and aim for responsible manufacturing practices. For shoppers looking to buy once and use for years, OXO's durable construction better aligns with a sustainable mindset.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent food storage solutions, but they serve different priorities and budgets.
Choose Rubbermaid if:
- You're shopping on a strict budget and need the best value for your money.
- You need to purchase a large number of containers for a big family or extensive meal prepping.
- You care more about pure function than modern aesthetics.
- You want containers that are durable enough for everyday use and easily replaceable if lost or damaged.
Choose OXO if:
- Keeping food fresh for as long as possible with a superior airtight seal is your top priority.
- You value a sleek, modern, and cohesive look for your pantry and kitchen shelves.
- You are willing to invest more in a product that resists staining, odors, and warping.
- You appreciate ergonomic, user-friendly designs that make opening and closing containers easier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Rubbermaid or OXO cheaper?
Rubbermaid is significantly cheaper than OXO. You can often buy a 20-piece Rubbermaid set for the price of one or two large OXO POP containers, making it the more budget-friendly option.
Which has better quality storage containers?
OXO generally offers higher quality in terms of materials and construction. Their containers feature thicker plastic that's more resistant to staining and odors, and their airtight seals are considered among the best on the market.
Are both Rubbermaid and OXO containers BPA-free?
Yes, both Rubbermaid and OXO manufacture their food-grade plastic containers to be BPA-free, ensuring they are safe for food storage.
Which brand is better for pantry organization?
OXO is typically preferred for pantry organization due to its sleek, uniform aesthetic and highly efficient stacking design. The modular nature of OXO POP containers helps create a visually clean and orderly look.
Can you put OXO and Rubbermaid containers in the dishwasher?
Yes, most food storage containers from both brands are top-rack dishwasher safe. However, always check the product's specific instructions, as some lids or parts might require hand-washing.
Which brand is better for preventing leaks?
Both brands have leak-proof lines, but for all-around performance, OXO's locking lids with silicone gaskets usually provide a more reliable and secure seal, making them excellent for transporting liquids like soups.
Do OXO containers stain less than Rubbermaid?
Yes, users generally report that OXO's higher-quality plastic is more resistant to staining from foods like tomato sauce or curry compared to many of Rubbermaid’s more basic container lines.
Is OXO worth the extra money?
If your priorities are maximum freshness, a stylish and organized aesthetic, and long-term durability against stains and odors, then OXO is worth the investment. If you simply need a functional and affordable solution, Rubbermaid offers better value.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
