Riley is a premium home textiles brand centered on sustainability, offering modern, minimalist designs crafted from organic and recycled materials. In contrast, Brooklinen is a widely popular direct-to-consumer leader known for its accessible luxury, providing high-quality, classic bedding at a more budget-friendly price point through frequent sales and value-driven bundles.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right bedding brand for your home.
Riley: The Sustainable Luxury Brand
Riley is an emerging home brand for the eco-conscious consumer who doesn’t want to sacrifice quality or style. The company's identity is built on ethical manufacturing and sustainable materials, making it a go-to for shoppers who prioritize environmental impact. Their product line feels curated and intentional, focused on creating a restful, healthy, and stylish sanctuary in the bedroom.
- Product mix: Primarily high-end bedding, including sheet sets, duvet covers, pillowcases, and sleep accessories. The focus remains on core bedroom textiles.
- Style/vibe: Sleek, contemporary, and minimalist. Riley favors muted earth tones, natural textures, and an understated elegance that complements modern interior design.
- Price point: Premium pricing reflects its focus on sustainability. Sheet sets typically start around $150, with complete bundles reaching $400 or more.
- Materials: Specialized in eco-friendly fabrics such as organic cotton, linen, and recycled fibers. These materials are chosen for their softness, breathability, and low environmental impact.
- Sustainability: This is Riley’s main differentiator. From the sourcing of raw materials to transparent supply chains and responsible manufacturing, every step is designed to be Earth-friendly.
- Return policy: Offers a satisfaction guarantee, allowing customers to shop with confidence. They also provide free shipping on orders over a certain threshold.
Riley is the choice for shoppers willing to invest more in bedding that is thoughtfully designed and sustainably produced.
Shop Riley: rileyhome.com
Brooklinen: The Accessible Quality Leader
Launched in 2014, Brooklinen quickly became a dominant force in the online bedding market by making high-quality sheets more affordable. They offer a massive range of products beyond the bedroom, including towels, loungewear, and shower curtains. Praised for exceptional customer service and frequent promotions, the brand appeals to anyone seeking stylish, durable home essentials without paying traditional luxury markups.
- Product mix: Extensive selection of bedding, bath towels, loungewear, and home accessories. This makes it a one-stop shop for outfitting much of the home.
- Style/vibe: Classic, clean, and highly versatile. Brooklinen's color palettes include timeless neutrals and subtle patterns that can easily adapt to a variety of decor styles, from modern to traditional.
- Price point: Competitive and accessible, making it a strong value proposition. Sheet sets typically range from $100 to $250.
- Materials: Famous for their use of durable, long-staple cotton and airy linen, known for getting softer with every wash.
- Sales: Brooklinen is well-known for its frequent sales and bundle discounts, particularly around major holidays, making their products even more affordable.
- Return policy: Noted for its generous 365-day return policy on most items, which is one of the best in the industry.
Brooklinen delivers impressive quality and timeless style at a price point that makes luxury home goods accessible to a broad audience.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Riley vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
The most immediate difference between these two brands is the price. Brooklinen is positioned as the more budget-friendly option, with its popular sheet sets often starting around $100. They frequently run sales - offering 15-20% off site-wide - and provide bundle discounts that deliver excellent value for shoppers looking to get high-quality bedding without breaking the bank.
Riley operates in a more premium price tier. Their sheets start closer to $150, and their prices reflect the investment in organic materials, ethical certifications, and sustainable production methods. While you are paying for that eco-friendly peace of mind, it means a higher upfront cost, and their sales are generally less frequent than Brooklinen's.
Quality & Materials
Both brands offer excellent products, but they prioritize different material philosophies. Brooklinen built its reputation on long-staple cotton, a fabric known for its long, durable fibers that create smooth, strong yarns. This results in sheets that are incredibly soft, resistant to pilling, and designed to last and improve with each wash.
Riley's focus is on sustainable luxury. Their collections feature organic cotton and linen praised for their natural softness and breathability. These eco-friendly choices appeal to those who want fabrics with minimal chemical processing and a reduced environmental footprint. The textile feel might be more natural or textured compared to the silky smoothness of some of Brooklinen’s top sellers, but quality and craftsmanship are evident in both.
Style & Aesthetic
Their design approaches cater to different tastes. Riley favors a sleek, modern, and minimalist aesthetic. The color options are often muted and sophisticated, focusing on natural tones and simple elegance. This look is perfect for contemporary bedrooms where a calm, uncluttered atmosphere is desired.
Brooklinen is more versatile and classic. Their extensive color palette and selection of simple patterns are designed to fit seamlessly into any decor, whether it’s modern, traditional, or bohemian. While always stylish, their look is less about making a specific design statement and more about providing a quality, timeless foundation for your bedroom.
Fit & Sizing
You can’t go wrong with either brand when it comes to fit. Both offer standard sizing for sheets, duvet covers, and pillows, complete with detailed guides on their websites. Shoppers note that Brooklinen sheets often feature generous deep pockets, making them an excellent choice for thicker or pillow-top mattresses.
Riley focuses on a perfectly tailored, snug fit. Their fitted sheets, in particular, are known for their strong elastic and precise cut, ensuring a smooth, wrinkle-free appearance on the mattress.
Shopping Experience
Brooklinen has perfected the direct-to-consumer online shopping experience. Their website is easy to navigate, loaded with thousands of customer reviews, and very transparent about product features. The frequent sales and easy-to-understand bundle savings make the checkout process straightforward and satisfying. Excellent customer service and a rock-solid return policy further enhance trust.
Riley offers a more curated, boutique-like experience. The website is minimalist and clean, telling a strong brand story about sustainability. While it features clear product information, the experience is less about promotions and more focused on educating the customer about the value of their eco-friendly products.
Sustainability & Ethics
If sustainability is your deciding factor, Riley is the clear front-runner. The entire brand is built on a foundation of environmental responsibility, from choosing organic and recycled fabrics to ensuring ethical treatment of workers in their supply chain. This commitment is central to their identity and a key part of what you are investing in.
Brooklinen is also making moves toward greater sustainability. They have incorporated eco-friendly materials and responsible partnerships into their business model and are transparent about these initiatives. However, sustainability exists as one priority among many, alongside affordability, variety, and accessible quality. For Brooklinen, it's an evolving feature, for Riley, it's the core mission.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal priorities and values. Both brands deliver outstanding products for the home.
Choose Riley if:
- Sustainability and ethical production are your top priorities when shopping.
- You prefer a clean, minimalist, and contemporary design aesthetic for your bedroom.
- You are willing to invest a bit more for premium organic and recycled materials.
- You value a brand that has a curated, boutique feel and a strong eco-friendly mission.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You are looking for the best possible value and love getting a good deal during frequent sales.
- You want a wide range of products, colors, and timeless styles that fit any decor.
- Durability and the proven softness of long-staple cotton appeal to you.
- You appreciate a hassle-free shopping experience with top-rated customer service and a very generous return policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Riley or Brooklinen cheaper?
Brooklinen is significantly more affordable. Their regular prices are lower, and they offer frequent sitewide sales and bundle deals that provide substantial savings, making them a better choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Both brands offer excellent quality, but with different features. Brooklinen's long-staple cotton is known for its exceptional durability and smoothness. Riley's quality is centered on artisan craftsmanship and the premium feel of organic, sustainable materials.
Which brand is more sustainable?
Riley is the more sustainable brand. Its entire business model is built around eco-friendly materials, a transparent supply chain, and ethical production practices. This is their main mission and key selling point.
Which has a better return policy?
Brooklinen is known for its industry-leading 365-day return window, which gives you an entire year to decide if you love its products. Riley offers a satisfaction guarantee, which is good, but Brooklinen's policy is more generous.
Which is better for hot sleepers?
Both brands offer great options for hot sleepers. Linen sheets, available from both Riley and Brooklinen, are highly breathable and excellent for warm climates. Riley's focus on natural, organic fibers may also provide a slight edge in chemical-free breathability.
How often does Brooklinen have sales?
Brooklinen has sales very frequently, most notably their annual Birthday Sale in the spring and Black Friday/Cyber Monday events, plus other promotions throughout the year. It's rare to go more than a couple of months without a sales event.
Is Riley worth the higher price?
If sustainability, organic materials, and a minimalist aesthetic are your highest priorities, then yes. The higher price covers the cost of responsible sourcing and ethical production, which is a valuable investment for many conscious consumers.
Do Brooklinen sheets get softer?
Yes, one of the signature features of Brooklinen's long-staple cotton and linen sheets is that they are designed to get progressively softer and more comfortable with each wash.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
