The core difference between the Down Fill from Restoration Hardware and standard fill options comes down to material, feel, and price. RH's Down Fill uses premium, responsibly sourced natural duck or goose down for an unmatched soft, luxurious, "sinking-in" feel, while standard fill typically uses synthetic polyester fibers for a firmer, more supportive, and highly affordable result.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right cushion and pillow fill for your home, budget, and lifestyle.
Restoration Hardware Down Fill
Restoration Hardware’s down fill represents the luxury standard in upholstery and pillows. Made from the soft, fluffy clusters found under the feathers of geese and ducks, this natural material is renowned for its exceptional softness, loft, and ability to conform to your body for cloud-like comfort.
- What it is: A premium, natural filling material made from the soft undercoating of waterfowl, used in high-end sofas, chairs, and pillows.
- Key features: Superior softness and "sinking-in" feel, excellent breathability, and lightweight comfort. Often ethically sourced with Responsible Down Standard (RDS) certification.
- Price: Premium pricing, with down-filled cushions and pillows often starting around $150 and going upwards of $300.
- Style: Creates a plush, relaxed, and inviting aesthetic. Cushions have a less structured, more "lived-in" look that defines casual luxury.
- Materials/Construction: Composed of high-quality down clusters, sometimes blended with feathers to provide a bit more structure and support.
- Pros: Unmatched softness and comfort. Lightweight and highly breathable. Molds to your body for personalized support. Durable and can last for decades with proper care.
- Cons: A significant investment due to the high price point. Requires regular fluffing to maintain its shape and loft. May not be suitable for those with severe down allergies.
This fill is the perfect choice for anyone seeking the ultimate in luxurious comfort and is prepared to invest in both the price and maintenance it requires.
Shop this product: rh.com/
Standard Fill Cushions (Polyester/Synthetic)
Often referred to as poly-fill or fiberfill, standard fill is the industry workhorse for cushions, pillows, and upholstered furniture. This synthetic material is made from polyester fibers and is prized for its practicality, being both affordable and easy to maintain. It offers a consistently firm and supportive feel that stands up well to everyday use.
- What it is: A widely used synthetic filling made from polyester fibers, a popular and affordable alternative to natural fills like down.
- Key features: Hypoallergenic, resistant to mold and mites, easy to clean (often machine-washable), and maintains its shape without fluffing.
- Price: Very budget-friendly, with cushions and pillow inserts typically ranging from $20 to $80.
- Style: Provides a clean, structured, and uniform appearance. Cushions look full and tidy as they tend to hold their shape.
- Materials/Construction: Manufactured from fine polyester fibers called fiberfill, which is a mass-produced and cost-effective material.
- Pros: Highly affordable and accessible. Naturally hypoallergenic and moisture-resistant. Low-maintenance and does not require fluffing. Provides consistent, firm support.
- Cons: Lacks the plush softness and breathability of down. Can compress, flatten, or clump over time. Not as durable in the long term. Can retain heat more than natural fibers.
Standard fill is an excellent option for households with children or pets, high-traffic areas, or anyone who values affordability and easy care over luxurious softness.
Shop this product: Widely available at retailers like IKEA and Wayfair.
Restoration Hardware Down Fill vs. Standard Fill Comparison
Comfort & Feel
The contrast in comfort is the most noticeable difference. The Restoration Hardware down fill offers a distinct "sinking-in" sensation. It's incredibly soft, plush, and molds to the shape of your body, providing a feeling of being enveloped in comfort. This is ideal for lounging and relaxing.
Standard fill provides a completely different experience. It's firmer, bouncier, and more supportive. Instead of sinking in, you sit on top of the cushion. While perfectly comfortable for everyday seating, it lacks the luxurious, cloud-like softness that makes down a premium choice.
Materials & Durability
Down is a natural, resilient material that can last for decades if cared for properly. Regular fluffing is all that's needed to redistribute the fill and restore its loft. RH uses high-quality, responsibly sourced down, ensuring a premium-grade product.
Standard polyester fill, while durable for everyday use, has a shorter lifespan. Over time and with use, the synthetic fibers can compress and flatten permanently. Cheaper versions may also clump or become lumpy, especially after washing, and will not last as long as a well-maintained down cushion.
Maintenance & Care
When it comes to maintenance, standard fill is the clear winner for convenience. These cushions typically hold their shape with no effort and are often machine washable, making them simple to care for - a huge plus for busy households or those with pets and children.
Down fill is higher maintenance. To look and feel its best, it requires routine, vigorous fluffing to restore its loft and prevent it from looking flat. For any deep cleaning, down usually requires professional services or very careful handling, as improper washing can damage the delicate clusters.
Price & Value
There is a vast price difference between these two fills. A down-filled cushion from RH is a luxury investment, costing several times more than a standard counterpart. This price reflects the cost of sourcing, processing, and certifying natural down.
Standard fill offers incredible value at the point of purchase. Its low cost makes it accessible to nearly any budget, allowing you to furnish a space affordably. While it may need replacing sooner than down, its upfront cost-effectiveness is undeniable.
The value proposition is different for each. Down's value is in its long-term durability and superior comfort, while standard fill's value is in its initial affordability and ease of care.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both fill types serve distinct needs, and the best choice is entirely dependent on your priorities, lifestyle, and budget.
Choose Restoration Hardware Down Fill if:
- You prioritize a luxurious, soft, "sinking-in" feeling above all else.
- You are creating a high-end, elegant aesthetic and want furnishings to match.
- Your budget accommodates a premium price point for superior comfort.
- You don't mind the daily or weekly routine of fluffing cushions to keep them looking lofty and full.
Choose Standard Fill if:
- You are decorating on a tight budget and need an affordable seating or pillow solution.
- You need durable, low-maintenance cushions for a high-traffic area, rental property, or a home with kids and pets.
- Anyone in your household has allergies to feathers or down.
- You prefer a firmer, more supportive feel and a tidy, structured look without regular fluffing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between RH down fill and standard fill?
The main difference is the material. RH Down Fill is a natural, premium material from waterfowl that is exceptionally soft and plush. Standard fill is a synthetic polyester fiber that is firmer, more supportive, and much more affordable.
Is Restoration Hardware down fill hypoallergenic?
Restoration Hardware's down undergoes a rigorous cleaning process, which removes most dust and allergens, making it suitable for many people. However, those with severe sensitivities to down may still prefer a truly hypoallergenic synthetic material like standard polyester fill.
Which fill type is better for a family sofa?
For most families, especially those with young children or pets, standard fill is the more practical choice. Its durability, resistance to stains, and ease of cleaning make it ideal for withstanding the wear and tear of a busy household.
How long does down fill last compared to standard fill?
With proper care and regular fluffing, high-quality down fill can last for 10-20 years or more, making it a great long-term investment. Standard fill typically lasts 3-5 years before it may start to flatten or become lumpy.
Do down cushions lose their shape?
Yes, down cushions will compress with use and need to be fluffed regularly - ideally daily or every few days - to restore their loft and even shape. This is a normal characteristic of the material.
Can you wash down cushions?
It's generally not recommended to machine wash down cushions unless the care tag explicitly allows it. Most require professional cleaning to avoid damaging the delicate down clusters and ensuring they dry properly to prevent mildew.
Is standard fill comfortable?
Yes, standard fill is comfortable. It provides a reliable feeling of supportive firmness and resilience. However, it does not offer the same deep, plush softness that is characteristic of down fill.
Is the higher price of RH down fill worth it?
Whether the cost is "worth it" is subjective. For individuals who place a high value on luxurious comfort, a particular relaxed aesthetic, and natural materials, the investment in RH down fill is often considered a worthwhile upgrade that elevates the daily experience of their home.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
