Raymour & Flanigan offers a mid-range selection of furniture focused on long-term quality and classic styles, supported by a strong personalized showroom experience primarily in the northeastern U.S. In contrast, Ashley Furniture is a global retail giant that prioritizes affordability and trendy designs, making stylish furniture accessible to budget-conscious shoppers across the country through a vast network of stores.
Let's compare these two furniture retailers to help you decide which is the right fit for your home and budget.
Raymour & Flanigan: The Quality & Comfort Retailer
Raymour & Flanigan is an established American furniture retailer that has built its reputation on offering a wide range of quality home furnishings with a customer-centric approach. The brand appeals to homeowners looking for lasting comfort and timeless style, blending durable construction with accessible, mid-range pricing. Their strong showroom presence across the Northeast makes them a go-to for shoppers who want to see and test furniture in person before buying.
- Product mix: A comprehensive selection of furniture for the living room, bedroom, dining room, and home office, plus mattresses and home decor. They are well-known for their extensive inventory of sofas, sectionals, and bedroom sets.
- Style/vibe: Styles range from contemporary and modern to more traditional and transitional designs. The overall aesthetic is comfortable, refined, and built to outlast fleeting trends.
- Price point: Mid-range. Sofas typically start around $499, with many popular models falling in the $800–$2,000 range. Bedroom sets are often priced between $1,000 and $3,000.
- Quality: The brand emphasizes quality construction, frequently using solid hardwood frames, high-density foam cushions, and durable performance fabrics designed to resist stains and wear.
- Delivery & Assembly: Raymour & Flanigan is known for its fast and often free delivery service. Most in-stock items can be delivered within a few days, and setup service is typically included.
- Shopping Experience: A standout feature is their personalized in-store service and large showrooms. Their website also allows for easy browsing, customization, and scheduling of design consultations.
- Sales: You can find frequent sales and promotions, especially around major holidays like Memorial Day, Labor Day, and Black Friday.
- Return policy: The company offers a straightforward return policy, making the shopping process more convenient and risk-free for customers.
Raymour & Flanigan is an excellent choice for those willing to invest in comfortable, durable furniture with a classic aesthetic and who value a high level of customer service.
Shop Raymour & Flanigan: raymourflanigan.com
Ashley Furniture: The Affordable & Trendy Leader
As one of the largest furniture manufacturers in the world, Ashley Furniture excels at offering an immense variety of on-trend home furnishings at highly competitive prices. The brand is a go-to for first-time homeowners, students, and budget-conscious families looking to furnish their space stylishly without breaking the bank. With a massive nationwide presence through both standalone stores and a user-friendly website, Ashley makes furniture accessible to nearly everyone.
- Product mix: An extensive catalog covers everything from living room sectionals and bedroom suites to dining tables, home office desks, outdoor furniture, and home decor accents.
- Style/vibe: Ashley Furniture leans heavily into trendy, modern, and casual styles. You'll find everything from farmhouse chic and mid-century modern to industrial and glam designs. The vibe is youthful and versatile.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Sofas can start as low as $299, and entire bedroom sets are often available for under $1,500, making it a leader in budget-friendly furniture.
- Quality: To maintain low prices, Ashley primarily uses materials like engineered wood, metal frames, and easy-care synthetic fabrics. While generally durable for its price point, it is not built with the same heirloom-quality materials as more expensive brands.
- Shopping Experience: The shopping journey is convenient and accessible through its vast network of physical stores, often operated as Ashley HomeStore locations, and a powerful online platform that offers customer reviews and room-planning tools.
- Sales: Ashley is known for aggressive sales, frequent promotions, and attractive bundle deals that allow customers to furnish a whole room for a set price.
- Delivery & Assembly: The company offers various delivery options, including doorstep delivery and in-home assembly service for a fee.
- Return policy: Standard return policies are in place, though it's important to review the terms for online versus in-store purchases as they may differ.
Ashley Furniture is the top contender for anyone whose main priority is finding stylish, trend-forward furniture at the most affordable prices on the market.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Raymour & Flanigan vs. Ashley Furniture Comparison
Price Comparison
This is the most significant difference between the two brands. Ashley Furniture is the clear winner on price. With sofas starting at around $299 and dining sets well under $1,000, it's one of the most budget-friendly options available. They regularly offer deep discounts and package deals that are hard to beat.
Raymour & Flanigan operates in a mid-range price bracket. Their sofas generally start at $499 and go up from there, reflecting a higher investment in materials and construction. While they do have frequent sales, their baseline pricing is notably higher than Ashley's, positioning them as a step-up for shoppers willing to pay more for quality.
Style & Aesthetic
Raymour & Flanigan focuses on timeless, comfortable styles that blend traditional, transitional, and contemporary looks. Their collections are often more refined and elegant, designed to appeal to homeowners looking for versatile pieces that won't go out of fashion quickly. The aesthetic is warm, inviting, and family-oriented.
Ashley Furniture, on the other hand, embraces trends. Their inventory is always changing to reflect the latest in home design, whether it's rustic farmhouse, sleek modern, or bold glam. This makes Ashley's selection more youthful and dynamic, ideal for someone who enjoys updating their decor and wants furniture that feels current.
Quality & Construction
In terms of materials and build, Raymour & Flanigan generally has a quality advantage. They often feature solid hardwood frames, high-density foam cushions for better shape retention, and performance fabrics that hold up to daily wear. Their furniture is intended to be a longer-term investment in your home.
Ashley Furniture achieves its low prices by using more economical materials like engineered wood, particleboard, and standard polyester fabrics. While the construction is solid for the cost, it may not withstand heavy use over many years as well as pieces from a higher-end brand. It offers tremendous value, but a trade-off in longevity is expected.
Product Selection
Both brands offer an enormous selection for every room, so you're unlikely to be disappointed with the variety from either. Ashley Furniture's product catalog is arguably larger overall due to its scale as a global manufacturer, featuring an especially wide range of accent pieces, decor, and budget-friendly options.
Raymour & Flanigan provides a curated but still vast selection with a focus on cohesive collections. This can make it easier to furnish an entire room with a consistent look and feel. They also carry a broad range of mattresses from top brands, making it a great one-stop shop for bedroom furnishing.
Shopping Experience
If you value in-person shopping, Raymour & Flanigan excels with its large showrooms and attentive staff. Primarily concentrated in the Northeast, their stores provide a great environment to test comfort and see materials firsthand. Their delivery service is also a key selling point, known for its speed and inclusivity.
Ashley Furniture provides unparalleled accessibility with stores all across the United States and a powerful e-commerce site. Their online tools, like virtual room planners, make remote shopping straightforward. The in-store experience at an Ashley HomeStore is more typical of a large retail chain, focused on volume and efficiency.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both companies are making some progress in sustainability but are not industry leaders. Raymour & Flanigan has taken steps to source from FSC-certified suppliers and promotes responsible recycling programs. They tend to be more transparent about their manufacturing partners.
Ashley Furniture has focused its efforts on using low-emission finishes and engineered wood products crafted from recycled fibers. As a massive global corporation, its supply chain is complex, but it continues to implement and expand its various corporate recycling initiatives.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer solid value, but they appeal to different customer priorities. Your decision will likely come down to budget, style preference, and how long you expect your furniture to last.
Choose Raymour & Flanigan if:
- You view new furniture as a long-term investment and prioritize durability.
- You prefer timeless transitional, traditional, or comfortable contemporary styles.
- Your budget is in the mid-range, and you are willing to pay more for better-quality materials.
- You want to test furniture in a showroom and value personalized customer service.
- You live in the northeastern U.S. and can benefit from their excellent delivery network.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- Sticking to a tight budget is your top priority.
- You love staying on top of current home decor trends and enjoy switching things up.
- You're furnishing a first home, apartment, or a low-traffic space like a guest room.
- You want endless options and the convenience of shopping at a nationwide retailer or online.
- You are looking for bundle deals to get an entire room furnished affordably and quickly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Raymour & Flanigan or Ashley Furniture cheaper?
Ashley Furniture is significantly cheaper than Raymour & Flanigan. With sofas starting as low as $299 and very competitive pricing on sets and bundled deals, Ashley is one of the most affordable national furniture retailers available.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Raymour & Flanigan generally offers better quality furniture. They more frequently use higher-grade materials like solid wood frames, high-density foam, and durable performance fabrics, making their furniture a better option for long-term durability and heavy-duty use.
Is Ashley Furniture made of real wood?
Some pieces from Ashley Furniture may include solid wood components, but many are constructed with engineered wood, MDF, or particleboard topped with veneers. This practice is common in budget-friendly furniture as it keeps costs low while still providing a durable and attractive finish.
How long does furniture from Ashley and Raymour & Flanigan last?
With proper care, furniture from Raymour & Flanigan is built to last for many years, often 7-15, thanks to its robust materials. Ashley furniture provides excellent value for its price and can last for several years (generally 3-7), but it may not hold up as well under heavy, long-term use compared to more expensive alternatives.
Where are Raymour & Flanigan stores located?
Raymour & Flanigan has a strong retail presence concentrated in the northeastern United States, with showrooms in states such as New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island.
Which brand is better for families with kids and pets?
This is a tough one. Raymour & Flanigan's offerings of performance fabrics make their upholstered pieces highly resistant to stains and wear, which is a major advantage. However, Ashley's low prices mean you might worry less about the inevitable spills and damage from kids and pets, making it easier to replace if needed.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, both companies have return policies, but the specific terms differ. It's important to check their websites directly for details on return windows, restocking fees, and the process for items bought online versus in a physical store.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
