Quince delivers modern, minimalist home essentials using a direct-to-consumer model that keeps prices remarkably low, while Pottery Barn is a premium, established retailer known for its classic, traditional, and well-crafted furniture that commands a higher price. Quince is the go-to for affordable style and quality basics, whereas Pottery Barn caters to those seeking timeless, investment-worthy pieces and an immersive, full-service shopping experience.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home furnishings brand for your space.
Quince: The Affordable Modern Essentials Brand
Quince is a direct-to-consumer brand that has gained popularity for its "affordable luxury" approach, offering high-quality home essentials and furniture without the traditional retail markup. By eliminating middlemen, Quince provides minimalist, on-trend pieces at prices that are often a fraction of their competitors. Their target customer is a modern, budget-conscious shopper who values style, quality, and price transparency more than brand heritage.
- Product mix: A curated selection of furniture for the living room, bedroom, and dining room, with a strong focus on essentials like sofas, beds, bedding, rugs, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Modern minimalism with a touch of Scandinavian influence. Expect clean lines, neutral color palettes, simple silhouettes, and versatile designs that fit well in contemporary homes.
- Price point: Highly accessible. Sofas start around $599, high-quality bedding sets are often under $100, and solid wood coffee tables can be found for under $400.
- Quality: Surprisingly solid for the price. Furniture often features kiln-dried hardwood frames, performance fabrics, and durable finishes, designed for reliable everyday use.
- Sales: Quince's model is based on everyday low prices, so they don't run frequent, large-scale sales like traditional retailers. The value is built into the initial price.
- Return policy: Offers a 365-day return window for most items, making for a straightforward and customer-friendly experience. Furniture returns may have different T&Cs.
- Delivery & Assembly: Most items ship free. Furniture delivery is typically curbside, and some assembly is usually required by the customer.
Quince delivers stylish, durable furniture and home goods at compelling prices, making it a top choice for anyone furnishing a home on a budget.
Shop Quince: quince.com
Pottery Barn: The Classic American Home Brand
Pottery Barn is a household name in American home furnishings, known for its warm, inviting, and timeless style. As part of the Williams-Sonoma portfolio, the brand offers a vast range of high-quality furniture, decor, and textiles that blend classic comfort with refined taste. Pottery Barn appeals to homeowners, families, and design enthusiasts who are willing to invest in long-lasting pieces that create a cohesive, sophisticated look.
- Product mix: Extensive selection covering all home categories, including living room, bedroom, dining, home office, outdoor, lighting, rugs, and decor. They also offer bath, bedding, and seasonal collections.
- Style/vibe: Classic, traditional, rustic, and transitional. The aesthetic is warm, comfortable, and sophisticated, often featuring distressed wood finishes, cozy textiles, and substantial silhouettes.
- Price point: Mid-to-luxury. Sofas typically start around $1,200, bed frames around $1,000, and dining tables can range from $1,000 to $4,000+.
- Quality: Top-tier craftsmanship is a brand hallmark. Expect solid wood construction, high-end performance fabrics, detailed finishes, and sturdy joinery designed for longevity.
- Customization: Many upholstered items are available in dozens of fabrics and colors. Some case goods offer different finish options, allowing for personalization.
- Awards program: Part of a loyalty program from Williams-Sonoma branded chains called "The Key," which rewards shoppers 1% to 5% with promotional deals and early access, and free design consultations, depending on the tier. Members get special offers and early access to sales events.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers white-glove delivery for most furniture, which includes unpacking, assembly, and placement in your room of choice for a flat fee.
Pottery Barn excels at providing premium, 'forever' furniture that balances timeless design with durable, family-friendly construction.
Shop Pottery Barn: potterybarn.com
Quince vs. Pottery Barn Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a significant price gap between the two brands. Quince's direct-to-consumer strategy allows it to offer products at what feels like wholesale pricing. A beautifully designed sofa at Quince can cost $599-$1,500, whereas a similarly sized sofa at Pottery Barn will typically start at $1,200 and can easily exceed $4,000 for larger sectionals with premium fabric.
This difference extends across all categories. Queen-sized bedding sets at Quince often hover around $100 for premium materials like linen or organic cotton, while Pottery Barn's equivalent sets usually start at $150 and go up from there. Shoppers prioritizing budget will find Quince to be the clear winner, while shoppers at Pottery Barn are paying for brand reputation, more robust construction, and a higher level of service.
Style & Aesthetic
The brands' design philosophies are worlds apart. Quince champions modern minimalism. Its furniture features clean lines, sleek forms, and a muted, neutral color palette that feels light and contemporary. This makes Quince pieces highly versatile and ideal for urban apartments, starter homes, and spaces with a modern or Scandinavian feel.
Pottery Barn embraces a warmer, more traditional American aesthetic. Its collections have a sense of permanence and comfort, featuring rustic wood finishes, classic silhouettes like rolled-arm sofas, and rich, inviting textures. This style is perfect for those aiming for a cozy, sophisticated, and timeless look that feels established, making it a great fit for traditional homes, family living rooms, and rustic or farmhouse interiors.
Quality & Construction
Both brands prioritize quality, but they occupy different tiers. Quince provides excellent value by using materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames, solid woods, and high-performance, stain-resistant fabrics. While built for durability, the focus is on achieving a high-end feel at an accessible price point.
Pottery Barn operates in a premium market where craftsmanship is paramount. Their furniture often features superior construction techniques, such as solid wood frames, intricate joinery, hand-applied finishes, and higher-grade upholstery. Their pieces are designed as long-term investments meant to withstand years, if not decades, of family life, which justifies their higher cost.
Product Selection & Sizing
Pottery Barn offers a much broader and deeper product catalog. You can furnish your entire home, from major furniture pieces down to the smallest decorative accessories, all in one place. Their furniture sizing is also more generous, with large sectionals, substantial dining tables, and oversized beds available to fill more spacious homes.
Quince provides a more curated and minimalist selection focused on essential pieces. Their furniture is often designed with modern living in mind, making many of their items well-suited for smaller-scale spaces like apartments or condos where efficiency is key. While their assortment is growing, it doesn't yet match the sheer volume of Pottery Barn's offerings.
Shopping Experience
The shopping experiences are fundamentally different. Quince is exclusively online, offering a streamlined, user-friendly website with transparent product details and customer reviews. The process is designed for convenience, simplicity, and efficiency, appealing to digitally native shoppers.
Pottery Barn offers a comprehensive omnichannel experience. You can browse their detailed website, get inspired by catalogs, and most importantly, visit physical showrooms to see, touch, and test out furniture in person. They also offer services like free in-home design consultations, which provide a level of support Quince's model doesn't include.
Delivery & Assembly
Quince's offer of free shipping on most items is a major advantage. However, this is typically a standard curbside delivery, and customers are responsible for bringing items inside and performing any necessary assembly, which can be a significant task for larger furniture.
Pottery Barn sets the standard with its white-glove delivery service for furniture. For a flat rate, a delivery team will bring your items into your home, place them in the room of your choice, assemble them completely, and remove all packaging materials. This hassle-free service adds considerable value, especially for large, heavy pieces.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both companies are committed to responsible practices. Quince's DTC model inherently reduces waste by avoiding overproduction for physical storefronts, and the brand is transparent about its ethical factories and sustainable material choices like organic cotton and linen.
Pottery Barn has extensive and well-established sustainability initiatives. They are a leader in using FSC-certified wood, fair trade-certified products, and recycled materials. Their commitment to responsible retail is a core part of their brand identity and is reflected across their vast product lines.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your style, budget, and shopping preferences. Both brands offer compelling products, but they cater to very different customers.
Choose Quince if:
- You have a strict budget but refuse to compromise on modern style or quality.
- You love a minimalist, clean, and contemporary aesthetic.
- You are furnishing an apartment or a smaller space and need appropriately scaled furniture.
- You are a confident online shopper and don't mind assembling your own furniture to save money.
Choose Pottery Barn if:
- You are looking for investment pieces that will last for a decade or more.
- You prefer a classic, rustic, or traditional style that feels warm and established.
- You want to see, touch, and test out furniture in a physical showroom before buying.
- You value premium services like interior design help and white-glove delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Quince or Pottery Barn cheaper?
Quince is significantly cheaper across all product categories. Thanks to its direct-to-consumer business model that cuts out retail markups, shoppers can expect to pay anywhere from 30-60% less at Quince for items of comparable style and material compared to Pottery Barn.
Which has better quality furniture?
Pottery Barn generally offers higher-quality furniture with more robust construction, premium materials like solid wood, and finer craftsmanship details. However, Quince provides exceptional quality for its price point, offering durable pieces that represent a great value for budget-conscious shoppers.
Are Quince and Pottery Barn sustainable brands?
Yes, both brands have a strong focus on sustainability. Pottery Barn has robust initiatives around responsibly sourced wood (FSC-certified) and fair trade practices. Quince prioritizes sustainable materials, avoids excess inventory with its DTC model, and is transparent about its ethical factory partners.
Which is better for small spaces, Quince or Pottery Barn?
Quince is generally better for small spaces. Its modern, minimalist designs often have smaller footprints and more compact proportions that are well-suited for apartments, condos, and smaller homes. Pottery Barn's furniture tends to be larger and more substantial in scale.
Where can I shop for these brands?
Quince is an online-only brand and sells exclusively through its website. Pottery Barn offers an omnichannel shopping experience, with a robust e-commerce site and physical showrooms located across the country.
Does Pottery Barn or Quince furniture come assembled?
Most Pottery Barn furniture is delivered via their white-glove service, which includes full assembly in your room of choice. Most Quince furniture requires self-assembly, although the process is typically straightforward.
Which brand's style is more timeless?
Both brands offer timeless styles, just from different eras. Pottery Barn's look is rooted in classic, traditional design that has been popular for generations. Quince's minimalist and modern aesthetic is also considered timeless in contemporary design circles, as its clean lines and simple forms are unlikely to go out of style.
What brands are similar to Quince?
If you like Quince's model and pricing, you might also like other direct-to-consumer brands such as Burrow, Article, and Thuma.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
