The Quince Premium Down Comforter and the Brooklinen Down Comforter both offer exceptional quality, but they differ primarily in price and feel. Quince provides high-quality, responsibly sourced down at a more budget-friendly price point, while Brooklinen delivers a slightly more luxurious, plush experience with a more established brand reputation and a higher price tag.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right down comforter for your bed.
Quince Premium Down Comforter
Quince has built its brand on offering luxury-grade home essentials directly to consumers at radically lower prices. Their Premium Down Comforter focuses on high-quality materials and responsible sourcing, delivering cozy, hotel-style comfort without the steep markup common in the bedding industry.
- What it is: An affordable yet high-quality down comforter made with ethically sourced down and a soft cotton shell.
- Key features: European white down with 700 fill power, 100% long-staple cotton shell, box-stitch construction prevents down shifting, corner loops to secure duvet cover.
- Price: Around $170 (Queen) to $220 (King/Cal King).
- Style: Clean, minimalist, and functional. It features a straightforward design in classic white, fitting easily into any decor scheme.
- Materials/Construction: The shell is made of a breathable 400-thread-count cotton sateen, and the fill is certified RDS (Responsible Down Standard). Box stitching ensures even insulation.
- Pros: Excellent value for the price, 700 fill power offers great warmth and loft, ethically sourced materials, soft and quiet cotton shell, free shipping and 365-day returns.
- Cons: Limited aesthetic options (typically only available in white), may not feel as overly plush as some more expensive luxury brands.
The Quince comforter is perfect for shoppers who prioritize quality materials and ethical sourcing but want the best possible price.
Shop this product: quince.com/home/all-season-premium-down-comforter
Brooklinen Down Comforter
Brooklinen is a leading direct-to-consumer brand credited with making luxury bedding more accessible. Their down comforter is one of their flagship products, celebrated for its premium feel, thoughtful construction, and options that cater to different sleep preferences.
- What it is: A premium down comforter from a well-regarded bedding brand, available in multiple weight options for different climates.
- Key features: Available in Lightweight, All-Season, and Ultra-Warm weights, baffle box construction for maximum loft, down cluster fill (700 for Lightweight/All-Season, 750 for Ultra-Warm), silky-soft 400 thread-count cotton sateen shell.
- Price: $209 (Queen, Lightweight) up to $499 (King/Cal King, Ultra-Warm). The All-Season Queen is typically around $359.
- Style: Classic and luxurious with a visibly fluffy appearance. The baffle-box design gives it a structured, hotel-bed look.
- Materials/Construction: The shell is 100% long-staple cotton, while the fill is hypoallergenic, ethically sourced down from Hutterite Farms in Canada. Baffle-box construction uses internal fabric walls to keep down in place and allows for maximum loft.
- Pros: Multiple warmth options for different sleepers, baffle-box construction is superior for loft and preventing cold spots, exceptionally soft and plush feel, superb brand reputation and customer service.
- Cons: Significantly higher price point than Quince for similar fill power, fewer sales promotions compared to other brands.
The Brooklinen comforter is designed for those who want a proven, premium product and are willing to invest more for specific warmth levels and a more luxurious feel.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/down-comforter
Quince vs. Brooklinen Down Comforter Comparison
Quality & Materials
Both comforters use high-quality, responsibly sourced down and 100% long-staple cotton shells. Quince uses 700 fill power down, which provides excellent insulation and loft. Brooklinen offers a similar 700 fill power in its All-Season model and a higher 750 fill power for its Ultra-Warm option.
The main construction difference is Quince's box-stitch versus Brooklinen's baffle-box design. While both are effective, Brooklinen's baffle-box construction is technically more advanced, using small internal fabric walls to create chambers that allow the down to expand to its fullest loft without shifting. This often results in a fluffier look and slightly more consistent warmth.
Warmth & Weight Options
Here, Brooklinen has a clear advantage in offering variations for everyone. They sell three distinct versions: Lightweight for hot sleepers or warm climates, All-Season for year-round comfort, and Ultra-Warm for those who run cold or live in frigid areas. This allows for precise customization.
Quince offers an All-Season weight that targets the majority of sleepers, making the choice simpler for those who don't have extreme temperature needs. It provides substantial warmth that works for most seasons but might be too warm for hot summer nights without air conditioning.
Style & Aesthetic
Both comforters are designed to be used inside a duvet cover and feature a classic white look. Brooklinen's baffle-box construction gives it a visually puffier, more cloud-like appearance from the get-go. Quince has a flatter quilting pattern, resulting in a cleaner, less voluminous look that still provides plenty of loft. Your choice comes down to whether you prefer a super-lofty, hotel-bed aesthetic (Brooklinen) or a more streamlined, practical one (Quince).
Price & Value
Price is the most significant differentiator. The Quince All-Season Queen comforter is often almost half the price of the equivalent Brooklinen All-Season Queen. For shoppers focused purely on getting high-quality materials - ethically sourced down with 700 fill power and a long-staple cotton shell - Quince offers undeniable value. Brooklinen's higher price reflects its brand prestige, superior baffle-box construction, Canadian down sourcing, and customizable weight options.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both of these down comforters are excellent choices, but they cater to slightly different priorities.
Choose the Quince Premium Down Comforter if:
- Your top priority is getting the best value for your money.
- You want high-quality, ethically-sourced down without paying a premium price.
- A single, versatile all-season weight works perfectly for your needs.
- You prefer a minimalist aesthetic and plan to use a duvet cover anyway.
Choose the Brooklinen Down Comforter if:
- You want to choose a specific warmth level (Lightweight, All-Season, or Ultra-Warm).
- You prioritize maximum loft and prefer the visually plush look of baffle-box construction.
- You are willing to invest more for a product from a highly-reputable, established bedding brand.
- The source of the down (Hutterite farms) and a slightly more luxurious hand-feel are important to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Quince and Brooklinen down comforter?
The three main differences are price, construction, and options. Quince is much more affordable, uses a standard box-stitch design, and comes in one all-season weight. Brooklinen is pricier but uses a superior baffle-box construction for better loft and offers three distinct weight options to customize your warmth level.
Which comforter is warmer?
Comparing the All-Season models, both offer similar levels of warmth with their 700 fill power down. However, Brooklinen's Ultra-Warm version, with its 750 fill power down and baffle-box build, is significantly warmer than any option Quince provides.
Are both comforters made with ethically sourced down?
Yes, both Quince and Brooklinen are committed to animal welfare. Both comforters use down certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS), ensuring the down and feathers come from animals that have not been subjected to unnecessary harm.
How do you wash and care for these down comforters?
For both, it's best to use a large-capacity, front-loading washing machine on a delicate cycle with cool water and a mild detergent. Tumble dry on low heat with wool dryer balls to help fluff the down. Using a duvet cover is highly recommended to protect the comforter and reduce the frequency of washing.
Does the down move around or clump in these comforters?
Both comforters are specifically designed to prevent this issue. Quince uses a box-stitch pattern and Brooklinen uses a baffle-box design. Both methods create individual pockets that keep the down fill evenly distributed and prevent clumping or cold spots.
Is the Quince comforter as good as the Brooklinen?
In terms of core materials, the Quince comforter is remarkably similar to the Brooklinen All-Season model and offers incredible value. The experience is slightly different, though. Brooklinen feels a bit more plush and offers more customization, justifying its price for those who want a premium product with more options.
Which one is better for hot sleepers?
Brooklinen is the better choice for hot sleepers because they offer a dedicated Lightweight version specifically designed with less fill for warmer climates and body temperatures. Quince's All-Season model, while breathable, will likely be too warm for many hot sleepers.
What does "fill power" mean?
Fill power measures the fluffiness and insulating quality of a down product. It refers to the amount of space one ounce of down occupies in cubic inches. A higher fill power (like the 700+ used in both these comforters) means larger down clusters that trap more air, providing better insulation without adding weight.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
