Quince offers high-quality, minimalist bedding at direct-to-consumer prices, focusing on sustainable materials like linen and organic cotton for a lower cost. In contrast, Brooklinen is a more established brand with a wider selection of fabrics, weaves, colors, and patterns, positioning itself as a mid-range luxury option with a classic, timeless aesthetic.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right bedding for your home.
Quince: The Affordable Luxury Essential
Quince is a direct-to-consumer brand built on a model of "affordable luxury," delivering high-quality home essentials without the traditional retail markups. Their bedding collection stands out for its simplicity, quality materials, and transparent pricing. Quince is aimed at the modern consumer who values a clean, minimalist style and sustainability but has a keen eye on their budget.
- Product mix: Bedding collections crafted from materials like European flax linen, organic cotton, and mulberry silk. The brand also sells towels, loungewear, and other home goods.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist, modern, and Scandinavian-inspired. The color palette focuses on neutral tones and subtle, versatile textures that create a calm and uncluttered atmosphere.
- Price point: Very competitive and budget-friendly for the quality. A 100% European Linen Duvet Cover Set starts around $150, while organic cotton percale sheet sets are often under $100.
- Quality: High-quality and sustainable. Many products are OEKO-TEX certified, ensuring they are free from harmful chemicals. Their linen is made from European flax, and their silk is Grade A mulberry silk.
- Sales: Prices are already low, but Quince does offer sitewide sales and promotions, often providing 20-30% off.
- Return policy: A straightforward 365-day return and exchange policy on most items.
- Sustainability: A core focus for the brand, with emphasis on eco-friendly sourcing, low-waste manufacturing, and transparent supply chains.
Quince is an excellent choice for anyone seeking simple, elegant, and sustainable bedding at a price that is hard to beat.
Shop Quince: quince.com
Brooklinen: The Premium Bedding Authority
Brooklinen has become a household name in the bedding industry since its launch in 2014, known for offering "internet-famous" sheets. They provide a vast selection of premium bedding, towels, and home essentials with a reputation for quality, comfort, and style. Brooklinen targets shoppers who appreciate a wide range of choices and are willing to invest a bit more for classic designs and exceptional comfort.
- Product mix: Extensive bedding options including percale, sateen, linen, flannel, and cashmere. They also offer a full suite of home goods like towels, bathrobes, shower curtains, and even loungewear.
- Style/vibe: Classic and timeless with a modern refresh. Brooklinen offers a broad palette of solids, subtle patterns, and limited-edition colors that suit traditional, modern, and eclectic decor.
- Price point: Positioned as a mid-range luxury brand. Their popular Luxe Sateen Core Sheet Set starts around $179, and a linen duvet cover is about $250.
- Quality: Excellent craftsmanship and long-lasting materials. Their bedding uses long-staple cotton for enhanced softness and durability and is also OEKO-TEX certified.
- Sales: Holds major sales events, especially around holidays, and offers bundle discounts that provide significant savings when buying complete sets.
- Return policy: Offers an exceptionally generous 365-day return policy, allowing customers to try out products for a full year.
- Shopping Experience: Features a highly detailed website with comprehensive product guides, customer reviews, and styling inspiration. Also operates physical retail stores for an in-person experience.
Brooklinen is the go-to for shoppers who want a wide selection of proven, high-quality bedding and value the peace of mind that comes with a well-established brand and customer-friendly policies.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Quince vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear difference in pricing between the two brands. Quince is the more affordable option across the board. For example, a queen-sized linen duvet cover from Quince costs around $150, while a similar product from Brooklinen is closer to $250. This price gap holds true for most categories, from cotton sheets to pillowcases.
Quince’s direct-to-consumer model allows it to cut out middlemen and offer premium materials at a fraction of the cost, making it an incredible value proposition. Brooklinen positions itself as a premium but accessible brand, and its prices reflect higher marketing costs and a broader operational footprint, including physical stores. If your primary decision-making factor is budget, Quince wins handily.
Quality & Materials
Both brands deliver excellent quality, but they focus on different things. Quince centers on offering a curated selection of high-end materials like European flax linen, organic cotton, and mulberry silk. Their products are well-made, durable, and certified for safety (OEKO-TEX).
Brooklinen also uses top-tier materials like long-staple cotton and European linen, but its strength lies in variety. It offers multiple cotton weaves - crisp Classic Percale, silky Luxe Sateen, cozy Flannel - allowing you to pick the exact texture you prefer. While both brands are durable, Brooklinen has a longer track record and is renowned for bedding that gets softer with every wash.
Style & Aesthetic
Your choice here will come down to personal preference. Quince's aesthetic is decidedly minimalist and modern. Their offerings are dominated by solid, neutral colors like white, beige, and gray, which fit seamlessly into serene, uncluttered bedroom designs. The focus is on the texture and quality of the fabric itself.
Brooklinen, on the other hand, offers a much wider stylistic range. You’ll find an extensive collection of solid colors, from muted earth tones to bold hues, as well as a rotating selection of special edition patterns and prints. This makes Brooklinen a better fit if you want your bedding to be a design statement or if you need to match a specific color scheme.
Shopping Experience
Both brands provide an excellent online shopping experience with easy-to-navigate websites. Quince stands out for its price transparency, often showing you a direct comparison of its prices versus traditional retailers.
Brooklinen elevates the experience with its massive library of customer reviews, detailed blog posts explaining different fabrics, and physical storefronts where you can feel the products before buying. Furthermore, Brooklinen's 365-day return policy is unmatched and provides ultimate peace of mind, significantly outperforming Quince's already generous policy.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both Quince and Brooklinen are committed to responsible manufacturing. Quince places sustainability at the forefront of its brand identity, emphasizing its use of organic, renewable materials and sustainable production methods. Their minimalist packaging is also a plus for eco-conscious shoppers.
Brooklinen also holds certifications like OEKO-TEX, ensuring its products are made without harmful substances. They are transparent about their sourcing and factories. For shoppers concerned with an ethical supply chain, both brands are solid choices, though Quince makes sustainability a more central part of its marketing.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your style preferences, budget, and priorities. Both brands offer quality bedding, but they cater to different shoppers.
Choose Quince if:
- You're on a tighter budget but unwilling to compromise on the quality of materials.
- You love a minimalist, modern, or Scandinavian decor style with neutral colors.
- Sustainability and price transparency are major priorities for you.
- You want luxury materials like high-quality linen or silk for less.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want more choices in terms of fabric weave (percale vs. sateen), colors, and patterns.
- You prefer a timeless, classic aesthetic that can lean either traditional or modern.
- You want the peace of mind that comes with an industry-leading 365-day return policy.
- You value shopping with a highly reputable, established brand with a massive following.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Quince or Brooklinen cheaper?
Quince is significantly cheaper than Brooklinen. Thanks to its direct-to-consumer model that eliminates middlemen, Quince offers products made from similar high-quality materials for a lower price.
Which has better quality bedding?
Both brands offer high-quality bedding meant to last. Brooklinen has a longer reputation for durability and bedding that softens beautifully over time. Quince provides exceptional quality for its price point, comparing favorably to brands that cost twice as much.
Can you return bedding to both stores?
Yes, both brands have excellent return policies. Brooklinen is famous for its risk-free 365-day return window. Quince also offers a generous 365-day policy, making both brands easy to try.
Which brand is better for linen sheets?
Both use 100% European flax, so the base material is comparable. Choose Quince for a more affordable linen experience with a minimalist color palette. Choose Brooklinen if you want more color options and are willing to pay a premium for the brand name and buying experience.
Are both brands good for hot sleepers?
Yes. Both brands offer great options for hot sleepers. Their 100% linen collections are naturally breathable and moisture-wicking. Additionally, Brooklinen's Classic Percale cotton sheets have a crisp, cool feel that is ideal for those who tend to sleep warm.
What is the difference between percale and sateen from Brooklinen?
Brooklinen's Classic Percale has a crisp, matte finish that feels like a freshly ironed hotel sheet, and it's very breathable. Their Luxe Sateen has a silky-smooth, slightly luminous finish that drapes over the body and feels softer to the touch.
How often do Quince and Brooklinen have sales?
Brooklinen is known for its major sales events around Black Friday and other holidays, often offering 20-25% off. Quince's prices are consistently low, so while they sometimes run promotions, you don't need to wait for a sale to get a good deal.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
