Pottery Barn focuses on classic, timeless sheet collections made from luxurious materials like Egyptian cotton, targeting shoppers who value durability and a traditional aesthetic. In contrast, West Elm offers sheets with a modern, trend-forward design, emphasizing sustainable materials like organic and Fair Trade Certified cotton at a more accessible price point.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right sheets for your bedroom.
Pottery Barn: The Classic, Luxurious Choice
Pottery Barn is a household name for high-quality home furnishings, known for its warm, classic style that feels both upscale and inviting. Their sheet collections reflect this focus on premium materials, superior craftsmanship, and timeless designs that won't go out of style. Shoppers turn to Pottery Barn for bedding that feels luxurious, wears well over time, and brings a sense of refined comfort to the bedroom.
- Materials: Primarily focuses on high-end fabrics including Egyptian cotton, organic cotton, Belgian flax linen, and high-thread-count sateen and percale weaves.
- Style/vibe: Classic, traditional, and sophisticated. Expect elegant neutral color palettes, subtle patterns, and an emphasis on texture and feel over bold, trendy graphics.
- Price point: Mid to upper range. A queen-size sateen sheet set typically costs between $150 and $250, while Belgian flax linen can be over $300.
- Quality: Known for long-lasting quality and durability. High thread counts (400-600 TC is common) and meticulous construction mean these sheets are built to last for years with proper care.
- Sizing &, Fit: Offers a full range of standard sizes with deep-pocket fitted sheets (often 16" high) that accommodate thicker mattresses and toppers.
- Sustainability: Offers a selection of bedding made from organic cotton and materials that are certified to STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX®, indicating they are tested for harmful substances.
- Sales: Holds regular sales events, particularly around holidays like Presidents' Day, Memorial Day, and Black Friday, with discounts often ranging from 20-40% off.
- Return policy: Accepts returns for most items within 30 days of receipt, though monogrammed and final sale items are not eligible.
Pottery Barn is ideal for those who see bedding as a long-term investment and prioritize a luxurious feel and classic style over the latest trends.
Shop Pottery Barn Sheets: potterybarn.com
West Elm: The Modern, Sustainable Option
As Pottery Barn's sister brand, West Elm brings a modern, clean-lined, and mid-century aesthetic to the home furnishing space. Their bedding collections are geared toward design-conscious shoppers who prioritize sustainability, ethical production, and fresh, contemporary style. West Elm excels at offering on-trend colors and functional fabrics that look chic and feel great without a luxury price tag.
- Materials: Strong focus on eco-friendly materials like 100% organic cotton, TENCEL™, and European flax linen. Many collections feature innovative, functional weaves like wrinkle-resistant or moisture-wicking sateen.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and contemporary. Features a mix of solid colors in both muted and bold tones, subtle geometric patterns, and relaxed textures perfect for an unfussy, stylish bedroom.
- Price point: More accessible. A queen-size organic cotton sheet set generally runs from $100 to $180, offering excellent value for the quality and design.
- Quality: Good, reliable quality with a strong emphasis on Fair Trade Certified factories and responsibly sourced materials. While durable, the focus is often more on modern design and sustainability than ultra-high thread counts.
- Sizing &, Fit: Carries standard sizes with deep pockets designed for modern mattresses. The fit is typically crisp and tailored to maintain a clean, minimalist look.
- Sustainability: This is a core part of the brand's identity. A large percentage of West Elm's bedding is Fair Trade Certified, GOTS certified organic, and made with eco-friendly fibers like TENCEL™.
- Sales: Offers frequent promotions, bundling discounts, and end-of-season sales, making their stylish bedding even more affordable.
- Return policy: Similar to its sister-brand, offering returns within 30 days for most items.
West Elm is the go-to for shoppers who want their bedroom to feel modern and responsible, prioritizing organic materials and ethical production in their bedding choices.
Shop West Elm Sheets: westelm.com
Pottery Barn vs. West Elm Sheets Comparison
Price Comparison
Price is one of the most significant differentiators between the two brands. West Elm is distinctly more budget-friendly. You can often find a high-quality queen organic cotton set for around $120-$150. In contrast, a comparable set from Pottery Barn would likely start around $150-$200.
While both brands frequently run sales, West Elm's baseline prices are lower, making them the better choice for shoppers who want quality and style without a premium investment. Pottery Barn positions itself as a luxury option, and its pricing reflects that commitment to higher-end materials like Belgian flax and high-thread-count Egyptian cotton.
Quality & Materials
Both brands offer excellent quality, but their material focus differs. Pottery Barn emphasizes luxurious, time-tested fabrics for a rich, soft feel. Their 400+ thread count sateen sheets feel buttery smooth, while their Belgian flax linen is known for being substantial and durable.
West Elm’s quality is defined more by its sustainability and innovation. They lead with GOTS-certified organic cotton and airy TENCEL™ Modal, which is known for its cool feel and eco-friendly production process. While Pottery Barn's sheets might feel more classically plush, West Elm offers modern comfort with an ethical backstory you can feel good about.
Style & Aesthetic
Your design preference will quickly point you to the right brand. Pottery Barn’s aesthetic is built on timeless elegance. Their sheets feature sophisticated neutral colors like ivory, gray, and blue, with traditional patterns like simple borders or subtle jacquards. They are designed to create a serene, hotel-like retreat and pair perfectly with classic or transitional decor.
West Elm captures a more modern, relaxed vibe. Their color palette includes earthy tones, on-trend hues, and artful geometric prints. The overall look is sleeker and more in line with minimalist or mid-century modern interiors. If you want bedding that feels current and design-forward, West Elm is the clear winner.
Fit & Sizing
You can't go wrong with either brand when it comes to fit. Both offer a complete range of sizes from Twin to California King and feature deep-pocketed fitted sheets that will comfortably fit most modern mattresses (up to 16 inches deep). Shoppers report that both brands' sheets fit true to size and stay securely on the mattress, so this factor is largely a tie.
Sustainability & Ethics
While Pottery Barn offers some organic lines, sustainability is West Elm's territory. West Elm has made ethical and eco-friendly practices a central part of its brand identity. A vast majority of their bedding is Fair Trade Certified, meaning the artisans who make it earn a premium for their work. They are also a leader in using GOTS-certified organic cotton. If buying from a transparent, socially conscious brand is your top priority, West Elm is the superior choice.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to personal style, priorities, and budget. Both brands offer high-quality sheets that will give you a great night's sleep.
Choose Pottery Barn if:
- You prefer a classic, traditional, or transitional decor style.
- You are focused on luxurious materials and a plush, substantial feel.
- You're willing to invest more for long-term durability and a five-star hotel experience at home.
- High-thread counts and fabrics like Egyptian cotton or Belgian flax linen are important to you.
Choose West Elm if:
- Your home aesthetic is modern, minimalist, or mid-century.
- Sustainability, organic materials, and ethical production are at the top of your list.
- You are looking for the best style and quality at a more accessible price point.
- You appreciate trendy colors and functional fabrics like breathable TENCEL™.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Pottery Barn or West Elm sheets cheaper?
West Elm sheets are generally cheaper. Their queen sheet sets usually range from $100 to $180, while Pottery Barn's start around $150 and can exceed $250 for their more luxurious collections.
Which brand has better quality sheets?
This depends on your definition of "quality." For traditional luxury, durability, and a plush feel, Pottery Barn is often considered higher quality due to its use of high-end materials like Egyptian cotton and high thread counts. For quality defined by sustainability, ethical manufacturing, and modern materials like organic cotton, West Elm excels.
What are the main differences between their sheet materials?
Pottery Barn focuses on classic luxury materials like high-thread-count sateen, percale, Belgian flax linen, and Egyptian cotton. West Elm prioritizes sustainable and innovative materials, leading with GOTS-certified organic cotton, TENCEL™ Modal, and European flax linen, often with a Fair Trade certification.
Which brand is better for a modern bedroom?
West Elm is better for a modern bedroom. Their clean lines, contemporary color palettes, and subtle geometric patterns are designed specifically to complement modern, minimalist, and mid-century modern aesthetics.
Does West Elm or Pottery Barn have better sales on bedding?
Both brands have frequent sales, especially around major holidays. Because West Elm's starting prices are lower, its sale prices are often more dramatic, making it a great place to find a bargain. However, Pottery Barn's sales provide a valuable opportunity to get their premium sheets at a significant discount.
Are West Elm sheets actually sustainable?
Yes, sustainability is a core tenet of the West Elm brand. A large number of their sheet collections are made with 100% organic cotton, produced in Fair Trade Certified facilities, and use eco-conscious materials like TENCEL™. They are a leader in responsible home furnishings.
How deep are the pockets on their fitted sheets?
Both brands typically offer deep-pocket fitted sheets designed to fit mattresses up to 16 inches deep. This accommodates most modern mattresses, including those with pillow tops or extra toppers.
What is the return policy for sheets at both stores?
Both Pottery Barn and West Elm generally offer a 30-day return window for most non-custom items. Sheets can be returned within this period if they are in new, unused condition, though it's always best to check their current policy online before purchasing.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
