Pottery Barn is known for its classic, high-quality furniture with a timeless aesthetic, positioning itself as a premium, investment-focused brand. In contrast, Living Spaces targets budget-conscious shoppers with contemporary, on-trend furniture that prioritizes affordability and style. The primary difference comes down to Pottery Barn's emphasis on heirloom-quality craftsmanship and materials versus Living Spaces' focus on providing accessible, stylish options for modern homes.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right furniture retailer for your space.
Pottery Barn: The Classic American Home Brand
Pottery Barn is a well-established home furnishings brand known for its classic American style that feels both polished and inviting. It caters to homeowners who see furniture as a long-term investment and prioritize high-quality craftsmanship, comfort, and a timeless look. Their collections are designed to outlast passing trends, creating a warm, comfortable foundation for any traditional, transitional, or farmhouse-style home.
- Product mix: A comprehensive selection of home furnishings, including living room, dining room, and bedroom furniture, as well as rugs, lighting, bedding, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Timeless, classic, and transitional designs. They focus on warm neutrals, refined details, and cozy textures that create a sophisticated yet comfortable atmosphere.
- Price point: Mid-to-luxury range. Sofas typically cost between $1,200 and $4,000, beds start around $1,000, and dining tables often exceed $1,500.
- Quality: A major focus for the brand. Most furniture features high-quality materials like kiln-dried solid wood frames, stone tabletops, and multiple performance fabric options for durability.
- Dimensions/Scale: Offers a wide range of sizing for different rooms, but their pieces are often substantial and scaled for larger, open-concept homes.
- Sustainability: Strong commitment to ethical and sustainable practices, using responsibly sourced wood for over 99% of its wood products and offering many Fair Trade Certified and FSC-certified items.
- Return policy: Generally offers a 30-day return window for most items. Made-to-order and monogrammed items are typically not eligible for returns.
- Delivery & Assembly: White-glove in-home delivery is standard for most large furniture items, which includes assembly and placement in your room of choice.
Pottery Barn is the ideal choice for shoppers seeking well-made, enduring furniture who are willing to invest in pieces that will last for years.
Shop Pottery Barn: potterybarn.com
Living Spaces: The Affordable & Stylish Choice
Living Spaces is a furniture retailer that has gained popularity by offering a huge selection of stylish, contemporary furniture at accessible price points. It appeals directly to first-time homeowners, young professionals, and families who want trendy, functional pieces without a major financial commitment. The brand excels at providing good value, convenience, and a wide variety of styles to fit modern tastes.
- Product mix: Offers furniture for every room, including sofas, sectionals, beds, dining sets, and office furniture, alongside mattresses, rugs, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Modern, contemporary, and transitional. The aesthetic is characterized by clean lines, minimalist details, and finishes that align with current interior design trends.
- Price point: Budget-friendly and accessible. Sofas can start as low as $500, beds from $300, and full dining sets are often available for under $1,000.
- Quality: Focuses on value. Materials often include engineered woods, metal frames, and durable synthetic upholstery that offer a great look and reliable function for the price, though they may not have the same longevity as premium brands.
- Dimensions/Scale: Provides an excellent variety of sizes, with many modular and compact pieces well-suited for apartments, condos, and smaller living spaces.
- Shopping Experience: Designed for an easy and straightforward shopping experience, with both large physical showrooms and a robust online store. They frequently offer sales, promotions, and flexible financing.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers several delivery options, including standard drop-off and full-service delivery with assembly for an additional fee.
- Sustainability: While the primary focus is on affordability, Living Spaces does offer some eco-friendly product options and has initiated programs to promote responsible practices.
Living Spaces is perfect for those who need to furnish a space quickly and affordably with modern, fashionable pieces.
Shop Living Spaces: livingspaces.com
Pottery Barn vs. Living Spaces Comparison
Price Comparison
The price difference between the two brands is significant and is their primary differentiator. Living Spaces is the clear winner in affordability. A stylish sofa there could cost you $600–$1,200, while a comparable style at Pottery Barn would likely start around $1,500 and go up from there. A dining table from Living Spaces might be $700, whereas a solid wood table from Pottery Barn could easily be $2,000 or more.
While Pottery Barn's prices are higher, they reflect an investment in higher-grade materials, superior construction, and timeless designs intended to last for decades. Living Spaces delivers excellent value for the money, making it possible to furnish an entire room for the cost of a single anchor piece from Pottery Barn.
Style & Aesthetic
The brands cater to distinct style preferences. Pottery Barn champions a classic, cozy, and sophisticated look rooted in traditional American design. Its aesthetic fits perfectly in suburban homes, farmhouses, and spaces aiming for a warm, inviting, and layered feel. The color palette revolves around warm neutrals, muted tones, and classic patterns.
Living Spaces leans heavily into contemporary, modern, and transitional trends. Its collections are defined by clean lines, sleek silhouettes, and finishes that feel current and fresh. This style works well in urban apartments, minimalist interiors, and for anyone who enjoys updating their decor to reflect current trends without overspending.
Quality & Construction
Quality is where Pottery Barn justifies its price tag. The brand consistently uses premium materials like kiln-dried hardwood for furniture frames, solid wood for case goods, and high-quality upholstery like linen, leather, and performance fabrics. The attention to joinery and finishing details results in durable, long-lasting furniture that can withstand years of family life.
Living Spaces prioritizes balancing quality with price. They often use sturdy engineered woods (like MDF and particleboard), metal, and durable synthetic fabrics. While the construction is sound and well-suited for everyday use, the materials are generally not intended to last a lifetime or become heirloom pieces. It is well-made for its price point but cannot match the longevity of Pottery Barn.
Product Selection & Sizing
Both brands offer a wide selection of furniture for the entire home. Pottery Barn’s pieces often have a more substantial scale and weight, making them well-suited for larger rooms and open-concept living areas. While they offer items for smaller spaces, their signature look feels grander in scale.
Living Spaces provides an impressive array of options, including many modular sectionals and compact pieces specifically designed for apartments and smaller living quarters. Their product range often feels more varied, catering to multiple modern aesthetics at once, giving shoppers plenty of choices within their contemporary style lane.
Shopping Experience
Shopping at Pottery Barn feels like a premium retail experience. Showrooms are expertly styled and inspirational, and the staff often includes design consultants who can help you plan your space. Their online experience is just as polished, with detailed product information and room galleries.
The Living Spaces experience is built around convenience and accessibility. Their large showrooms allow customers to see and try a vast inventory, and their website is easy to navigate. Frequent sales, promotions, and financing deals make the purchasing process straightforward and budget-friendly.
Sustainability & Ethics
Pottery Barn has made a strong, public commitment to sustainability. They have significantly increased their use of FSC-certified wood, use responsibly sourced cotton, and offer a large number of Fair Trade Certified products. This is a core part of their brand identity.
Living Spaces has started incorporating more eco-friendly practices but is less transparent and vocal about these efforts. While they offer some products with sustainable materials, it is not a central tenet of their brand. Shoppers for whom sustainability is a key priority will find much more alignment with Pottery Barn's mission.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal budget, style, and long-term goals for your furniture. Both brands offer good products but serve very different needs.
Choose Pottery Barn if:
- You view furniture as a long-term investment and are willing to pay more for exceptional quality.
- Your interior design style is classic, traditional, or rustic modern farmhouse.
- You prioritize high-end materials like solid wood, kiln-dried frames, and natural fabrics.
- Ethical sourcing and sustainability are important factors in your purchasing decisions.
- You want timeless designs that won't feel dated in a few years.
Choose Living Spaces if:
- You are furnishing a home on a strict budget.
- You prefer contemporary, modern, and on-trend styles over classic designs.
- You are furnishing a first home, apartment, or a secondary space like a guest room or playroom.
- You enjoy updating your decor every few years and don't want to over-invest in trendy pieces.
- Convenience, quick availability, and a wide selection are your top priorities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Pottery Barn or Living Spaces cheaper?
Living Spaces is significantly cheaper than Pottery Barn. A sofa from Living Spaces often costs less than half of an entry-level sofa from Pottery Barn, and this price difference holds true across nearly all furniture categories. Living Spaces is one of the most budget-friendly furniture retailers on the market, whereas Pottery Barn is a mid-to-high-end brand.
Which has better quality furniture?
Pottery Barn has better quality furniture in terms of materials and construction. They use an abundance of solid wood, kiln-dried hardwood frames, and higher-end fabrics designed for longevity. Living Spaces offers good quality for its price point - perfectly functional and durable for everyday use - but it's not built with the same heirloom-quality approach as Pottery Barn.
Which is better for small apartments?
Living Spaces is generally better for small apartments. They offer a wider selection of compact-scale furniture, modular sectionals, and pieces designed to maximize space. Pottery Barn's furniture tends to have a more substantial profile that works better in larger rooms, though they do offer apartment-specific collections.
Is Pottery Barn furniture worth the money?
For those who prioritize longevity, high-quality craftsmanship, and a timeless aesthetic, Pottery Barn furniture is generally considered worth the money. You are paying a premium for materials and construction that are designed to last for many years, unlike fast-furniture pieces that may need replacing sooner.
Does Living Spaces or Pottery Barn have more sales?
Living Spaces has more frequent sales and promotions. It's common to find ongoing discounts, holiday sales events, and financing offers on their website and in stores. Pottery Barn has predictable major sales during holidays like Presidents' Day and Black Friday, but regular, deep discounts are less common.
Which brand is more sustainable?
Pottery Barn is the more sustainable brand. They have made significant, public commitments to responsible wood and cotton sourcing, operate numerous Fair Trade Certified factories, and feature a wide array of FSC-certified products, making this a central focus of their brand messaging and operations.
Is Living Spaces good for families?
Living Spaces can be a great option for families on a budget. Their furniture is functional and affordable, meaning parents are less concerned about wear and tear on an expensive piece. However, Pottery Barn often offers more high-performance and stain-resistant fabric options across their upholstery, which may be more durable for a family with young children in the long run.
Can I see furniture in person from both brands?
Yes, both Pottery Barn and Living Spaces have physical showrooms across the country where you can see, touch, and try out their furniture before buying. Living Spaces typically has larger, warehouse-style showrooms, while Pottery Barn's are styled more like traditional retail stores.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
