The Pottery Barn Seadrift and Gray Wash finishes both offer a relaxed, coastal aesthetic, but they differ significantly in color temperature and texture. Seadrift is a warm, beige-toned finish with a textured, weathered surface that mimics natural driftwood, giving it a rustic feel. In contrast, Gray Wash is a cooler, smoother true gray finish that allows the wood grain to show through, creating a more modern and refined look.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right finish for your home's style and your personal taste.
Pottery Barn Seadrift Finish
The Seadrift finish is designed to capture the essence of a sun-bleached piece of wood found on the shore. It’s defined by its warm, sandy-beige color and visible, layered texture. Often achieved through a hand-applied distressing process, this finish gives furniture pieces a charming, lived-in character that feels instantly comfortable and inviting.
- What it is: A warm-toned wood finish with a textured, weathered appearance reminiscent of natural driftwood.
- Key features: Features a hand-applied, multi-step process that creates a slightly distressed and textured surface, warm sandy or beige undertones, and a matte appearance.
- Price: The price is determined by the furniture piece itself, not the finish, it is priced similarly to other standard finishes like Gray Wash.
- Style: Ideal for coastal, farmhouse, cottage, and rustic interior design styles.
- Materials/Construction: Typically applied to furniture made from solid wood, kiln-dried wood, and high-quality veneers, then sealed with a protective lacquer for durability.
- Pros: Warm and inviting feel adds character to a room. The textured and distressed surface is excellent at hiding minor nicks, dust, and scratches. Pairs beautifully with natural fibers like linen and jute.
- Cons: The distinct rustic look may not fit well in sleek, minimalist, or highly modern interiors. Its warm undertones can sometimes limit the wall colors it coordinates with.
This finish is perfect for anyone wanting to create a cozy, casual, and beach-inspired space with a touch of rustic charm.
Shop this finish: potterybarn.com/search?words=seadrift
Pottery Barn Gray Wash Finish
The Gray Wash finish offers a modern, sophisticated take on coastal style. It uses a cool-toned, semi-transparent gray wash that subtly accentuates the natural grain of the wood beneath. The result is a smooth, clean, and understated look that feels both contemporary and timeless, making it exceptionally versatile.
- What it is: A cool-toned, light gray wood finish with a smooth surface that allows the natural wood grain to remain visible.
- Key features: Semi-transparent gray stain, smooth texture with no-to-minimal distressing, and a versatile neutral color palette.
- Price: Priced competitively with other popular finishes, cost is dependent on the specific furniture item, not the finish choice.
- Style: Excels in modern coastal, contemporary, transitional, and minimalist decor settings.
- Materials/Construction: Applied to high-quality solid woods and veneers, and protected with a clear topcoat to guard against moisture and daily wear.
- Pros: Highly versatile and easy to integrate into many different decor schemes. Its sleek, understated look feels modern and clean. Pairs well with a wide range of colors, from bold hues to soft pastels.
- Cons: The smooth surface can be less forgiving of scratches and dings compared to a distressed finish. Cool tones might feel stark in a home dominated by very warm palettes.
The Gray Wash finish is well-suited for those who appreciate a refined, modern coastal aesthetic that is both versatile and chic.
Shop this finish: potterybarn.com/search?words=gray%20wash
Seadrift vs. Gray Wash Comparison
Style & Aesthetic
The biggest difference between Seadrift and Gray Wash lies in the feeling they create. The Seadrift finish is all about warmth, comfort, and rustic charm. Its textured, weathered appearance is perfect for creating a cozy atmosphere, making it a natural fit for farmhouse styles or a laid-back beach cottage look. It evokes a feeling of history and casual elegance.
On the other hand, the Gray Wash finish is cool, crisp, and contemporary. Its smooth surface and subdued gray hue lend a more polished and sophisticated air to furniture. This finish thrives in modern or transitional spaces, acting as a clean, neutral foundation that complements minimalist decor without overpowering it. It’s less "lived-in" and more "put-together."
Texture & Feel
Running your hand over a piece of Seadrift furniture, you’d likely feel a subtle texture. The distressing process gives it an intentionally imperfect, tactile quality that enhances its rustic appeal. This texture also serves a practical purpose, as it helps camouflage everyday wear and tear.
Gray Wash furniture is noticeably smoother to the touch. The focus is on the visual effect of the gray stain over the wood grain, not on creating a physical texture. This sleekness contributes to its modern profile but means that deeper scratches or scuffs may be more visible than on its distressed counterpart.
Materials & Construction
Both finishes are applied to furniture built with Pottery Barn's commitment to quality. You'll find them on pieces crafted from solid woods, engineered woods, and premium veneers, often from sustainably sourced materials. The core construction does not differ based on the finish you choose.
The difference is purely in the finishing process itself. Seadrift requires a multi-step, often hand-applied technique to build up its layered, weathered look. Gray Wash involves applying a semi-transparent stain that elegantly colors the wood while allowing its natural character to shine through, followed by a protective sealant.
Price & Value
When comparing the same piece of furniture - for example, a dresser available in both finishes - you will generally find no price difference between Seadrift and Gray Wash. Pottery Barn prices its products based on the item's size, design, and overall construction, not the specific color finish applied.
The true value comes from choosing the finish that best aligns with your home's aesthetic and your long-term vision for the space. Both are durable, well-made options designed to last for years, so the right choice is whichever finish you'll be happier living with day in and day out.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both finishes offer timeless appeal and incredible quality, but they cater to distinct decorative styles.
Choose Seadrift if:
- You're creating a warm, cozy, and inviting vibe.
- Your decor is inspired by farmhouse, rustic, or casual coastal styles.
- You want a textured finish that is forgiving of minor wear and adds character.
- You plan to pair your furniture with natural textures like linen, jute, and rattan.
Choose Gray Wash if:
- You prefer a clean, sleek, and contemporary aesthetic.
- Your home's style is modern coastal, minimalist, or transitional.
- You want a smooth, versatile neutral that highlights the natural wood grain.
- Your color palette includes cool tones like blues, greens, and true grays.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Seadrift and Gray Wash?
The primary difference is color temperature and texture. Seadrift is a warm, beige-toned finish with a noticeably textured and distressed surface. Gray Wash is a cool-toned, true gray finish with a smooth, consistent surface.
Is Pottery Barn Seadrift a gray color?
No, Seadrift is primarily a warm beige or sandy color. Its name evokes the "driftwood" look, which can be grayish, but Pottery Barn's interpretation leans heavily into warm, sun-bleached tones rather than cool grays. For a true gray, you should choose the Gray Wash finish.
How do you clean Pottery Barn furniture with these finishes?
For both finishes, the best practice is to dust frequently with a soft, clean, dry cloth. For spills, wipe them up immediately with a slightly dampened cloth and then dry thoroughly. Avoid using chemical cleaners, silicone-based polishes, or abrasive materials, as they can damage the protective topcoat.
Does the Seadrift finish hide scratches well?
Yes, one of the biggest advantages of the Seadrift finish is its ability to camouflage minor scuffs, nicks, and everyday wear. The built-in distressing and textured surface make small imperfections blend in naturally.
Is the Gray Wash finish durable for homes with children or pets?
Yes, all Pottery Barn furniture, including pieces with a Gray Wash finish, is sealed with a protective lacquer for durability. While its smooth surface doesn't hide scratches as effectively as a distressed finish, it is designed to withstand normal household use.
Can I mix Seadrift and Gray Wash furniture in the same room?
Mixing wood tones is possible but should be done with care. Because Seadrift is warm and Gray Wash is cool, they could clash if not balanced. To make it work, use textiles and decor that incorporate both beige and gray tones to visually tie the furniture pieces together.
Which finish is more timeless?
Both have lasting appeal. Gray Wash's cool neutrality makes it extremely versatile and able to adapt to changing style trends easily. Seadrift’s warm, rustic charm is a perennial favorite that defines classic coastal and farmhouse decor, which are styles that have remained popular for decades.
Are these finishes applied to real wood?
Yes, these finishes can be found on furniture made with a combination of solid woods (like poplar or pine), engineered woods, and high-quality wood veneers applied over a solid core. Always check the "Details & Dimensions" section on a specific product page for exact material composition.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
