The key differences between Pottery Barn’s Performance and Classic fabrics lie in durability, material composition, and maintenance. Performance fabrics are engineered with synthetic fibers to resist stains, moisture, and fading, making them a practical choice for high-traffic homes, while Classic fabrics are typically made from natural fibers like cotton and linen, prioritizing a softer feel and a more authentic, traditional aesthetic over resilience.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which fabric is the right choice for your furniture and lifestyle.
Pottery Barn Performance Fabric
Pottery Barn Performance fabrics are advanced textiles engineered to handle the demands of everyday life. Treated to repel stains and liquids, these fabrics are a popular choice for sofas and chairs in busy family rooms or homes with children and pets, offering peace of mind without sacrificing the brand’s signature style.
- What it is: A collection of specially designed upholstery fabrics treated for superior stain, spill, and fade resistance.
- Key features: Moisture-repellent, easy to clean with mild soap and water, designed to resist fading from UV exposure, durable construction for high-traffic use.
- Price: Typically costs about 10-20% more than a non-performance alternative on the same piece of furniture.
- Style: Available in a wide variety of colors, weaves, and textures, including velvets, twills, and chenilles, designed to mirror the look of traditional textiles.
- Materials/Construction: Usually made from synthetic fibers such as polyester, acrylic, or specialized blends known for their durability and lack of absorbency.
- Pros: Excellent stain and spill resistance makes cleaning easy. Ideal for households with children or pets. Resists fading in sunny rooms. Holds up well to frequent use.
- Cons: Carries a higher price point upfront. Can sometimes feel slightly less soft or natural compared to cotton or linen. Being synthetic, it is less breathable than natural fibers.
This fabric is the ideal solution for anyone who needs their furniture to be as durable and worry-free as it is stylish, especially in active, lived-in spaces.
Shop this product: potterybarn.com/shop/design-services/fabric-by-the-yard/
Pottery Barn Classic Fabric
Pottery Barn’s Classic fabrics encompass their range of traditional upholstery materials that are not specifically treated with performance features. Comprising natural fibers like linen, cotton, and wool, these fabrics are chosen for their authentic texture, breathability, and luxurious comfort, creating a timeless and inviting feel.
- What it is: A range of standard upholstery fabrics made primarily from natural fibers, focusing on aesthetics and comfort.
- Key features: Soft, natural hand-feel, breathable, available in a wide selection of traditional weaves and patterns.
- Price: Serves as the base price for most furniture pieces, without the 10-20% upcharge of performance options.
- Style: Perfect for achieving a classic, warm, or formal look. Materials like linen and tweed add rich, natural texture to a room.
- Materials/Construction: Often made from natural fibers like cotton, linen, wool, or blends of these materials.
- Pros: Superior softness and natural comfort. A more authentic, textured appearance. Lower upfront cost compared to performance fabrics. Highly breathable material.
- Cons: More susceptible to staining and discoloration. Can be more difficult and costly to clean. May show wear, pilling, or stretching more easily over time in high-use areas.
A Classic fabric is best for formal living rooms, adult-only households, or anyone who values the feel and aesthetic of natural materials above all else.
Shop this product: potterybarn.com/shop/design-services/fabric-by-the-yard/
Performance Fabric vs. Classic Fabric Comparison
Materials & Durability
Pottery Barn's Performance fabrics are explicitly designed for longevity. Their synthetic fibers create a less porous surface that prevents spills from soaking in immediately, giving you time to clean them up. This makes them highly resistant to stains from coffee, wine, or juice. Classic fabrics, often made from porous natural fibers like cotton or linen, absorb spills quickly, making stains much more likely to set. Over the long term, Performance fabrics also hold their shape and resist pilling better under heavy use, while Classic fabrics may stretch or show wear more visibly.
Comfort & Feel
This is where Classic fabrics really shine. Natural fibers like cotton and linen offer a softness, breathability, and authentic texture that is hard to replicate. They feel cozy, inviting, and luxurious to the touch, making them an excellent choice for a comfortable reading chair or a formal sofa. While modern Performance fabrics have come a long way and many options are very soft, they can sometimes lack the plush, natural hand-feel that defines Classic textiles.
Style & Aesthetic
Both fabric lines align with the timeless Pottery Barn aesthetic, and you’ll find plenty of options in neutral colors, subtle patterns, and rich textures in both categories. A Classic fabric like a chunky Belgian linen lends an unmatched look of lived-in, rustic elegance. Performance fabrics are designed to mimic these styles, offering lookalikes in twill, basketweave, and velvet, making it possible to get the aesthetic you want with added protection. The choice often comes down to authenticity versus practicality.
Price & Value
Performance fabrics cost about 10-20% more upfront. For a $1,500 sofa, that could mean an extra $150 to $300. While Classic fabrics save you money at the time of purchase, the value proposition can shift over the lifetime of the furniture. The cost of a single professional cleaning for a bad stain on a Classic fabric sofa can easily exceed the initial upcharge for a Performance upgrade. If you anticipate spills or heavy use, the Performance fabric often provides better long-term value by avoiding cleaning or reupholstery costs down the line.
Who Each One Works Best For
The decision ultimately comes down to your lifestyle. Performance fabrics are the clear winner for families with children, pet owners, or for furniture placed in high-traffic family rooms or sunny breakfast nooks. The peace of mind and easy cleanup they offer is a significant functional benefit. Classic fabrics are better suited for lower-traffic environments like a formal living room, home office, or a household without pets or young kids. They are for those who prioritize the tactile experience and distinct aesthetic of natural fibers and are comfortable with more careful use and maintenance.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both fabric options from Pottery Barn can look beautiful in a home, but they cater to very different needs and priorities.
Choose Performance Fabric if:
- You have children, dogs, cats, or frequent guests who might spill.
- The furniture will be in a main, high-traffic room like the family room or kitchen area.
- You value low-maintenance living and want cleaning to be simple and stress-free.
- Your furniture will be placed in a sunny room where fading is a concern.
Choose Classic Fabric if:
- You prioritize the soft, breathable, and natural feel of materials like linen, cotton, or wool.
- The furniture is for a formal, less-used space like a sitting room or home office.
- Your household has little risk of spills, stains, or heavy wear.
- The specific, authentic texture of a natural textile is essential to your design aesthetic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Pottery Barn Performance and Classic fabrics?
The primary difference is functionality. Performance fabrics are synthetically engineered and treated to resist stains, moisture, and fading, making them durable and easy to clean. Classic fabrics are primarily made of natural fibers like cotton and linen, prioritizing a soft feel and authentic texture but are more susceptible to wear and staining.
Is Pottery Barn's Performance Fabric worth the extra cost?
For most households with kids, pets, or high traffic, yes. The 10-20% upfront cost is often a small price to pay for the peace of mind and protection against stains that could be costly or impossible to remove. For those in low-risk environments, the extra cost may not be necessary.
How do you clean Pottery Barn Performance Fabric?
Most spills on Performance fabrics can be blotted with a dry cloth and cleaned with a simple solution of mild soap and water. Because the fibers resist absorption, messes tend to stay on the surface, allowing for easier cleanup.
Are Performance Fabrics still soft and comfortable?
Yes. Modern performance fabrics have improved significantly in feel and texture. While they may not have the exact same natural feel as pure linen or cotton, many options, like performance velvets and chenilles, are very soft and comfortable for daily use.
Do Classic fabrics stain easily?
Compared to Performance fabrics, yes. Natural fibers like linen and cotton are more absorbent, meaning liquids can seep into the material quickly, leaving behind permanent stains if not treated immediately and professionally.
Which fabric is better for pets?
Performance fabric is undoubtedly the better choice for pet owners. It is more resistant to stains from muddy paws and is easier to clean. Tighter weaves found in many performance options can also hold up better against scratching or claws.
Can I get fabric swatches from Pottery Barn?
Yes, Pottery Barn encourages customers to order free fabric swatches for both Performance and Classic options. This allows you to feel the texture, see the true color, and even test spill resistance at home before making a decision.
Do Performance Fabrics look different than Classic fabrics?
Not significantly. Many Performance fabrics are specifically designed to mimic the appearance of Classic fabrics. While a textile expert might spot differences up close, to the everyday eye, a performance twill can look nearly identical to a cotton twill.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
