The key differences between brass from Pottery Barn and pieces from specialty brand Tumbled Brass come down to finish, style, and price. Pottery Barn's brass is typically polished, brushed, or smoothly antiqued, offering a refined and classic look for versatile decor styles. In contrast, Tumbled Brass provides a more specific vintage aesthetic, with intentionally aged, matte, and weathered finishes that are rich in character and more budget-friendly.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right brass finish for your home hardware, lighting, and decor.
Pottery Barn Brass
Pottery Barn is a leading home furnishings retailer known for its classic designs that seamlessly fit into traditional, transitional, and contemporary homes. Their brass offerings reflect this philosophy, providing a sophisticated and timeless look through hardware, lighting, and decorative accessories that are built to last.
- What it is: A wide range of brass hardware, decor, and lighting fixtures available in polished, brushed, and antiqued finishes.
- Key features: Smooth, consistent, and often lacquered finishes that resist tarnishing. Wide product selection from small knobs to large chandeliers.
- Price: Mid-range to premium. Knobs and pulls typically start at $15-$25, while lighting fixtures can range from $100 to over $500.
- Style: Classic, traditional, and transitional. The finishes are refined and elegant, working well with sophisticated and polished interior designs.
- Materials/Construction: Generally made from solid brass or high-quality brass alloys, finished with a protective coating to ensure durability and a long-lasting sheen.
- Pros: Excellent quality and craftsmanship. Versatile style fits many decor schemes. Trusted brand reputation with warranties. Products are readily available both online and in stores.
- Cons: Higher price point compared to specialty brands. Finishes can be less unique or character-driven. Polished brass can show fingerprints easily.
Pottery Barn brass is perfect for homeowners seeking durable, high-quality fixtures with a timeless, elegant look that will complement a polished home for years to come.
Shop this brand: https://www.potterybarn.com
Tumbled Brass
Tumbled Brass is a specialty online retailer focusing exclusively on hardware and fixtures with an authentic, vintage-inspired aged appearance. Their products are designed to add character and a sense of history to a space through matte, weathered, and intentionally imperfect finishes.
- What it is: Artisanal brass hardware and accessories featuring a matte, worn, or weathered finish created through a tumbling process.
- Key features: Unique, rustic finish that evokes vintage charm. Meant to develop a natural patina over time. Adds texture and warmth.
- Price: Affordable to mid-range. Cabinet knobs and pulls generally cost between $10 and $30, with smaller accent lighting pieces ranging from $50 to $150.
- Style: Farmhouse, industrial, vintage, and eclectic. The aesthetic is warm, rustic, and full of personality.
- Materials/Construction: Solid brass is subjected to a proprietary tumbling process that distresses the surface, creating an authentically aged look without artificial coatings.
- Pros: Budget-friendly prices make it great for DIY updates. Unique finish adds instant character. The matte, worn look hides fingerprints and wear.
- Cons: A niche style that doesn't suit every home. Product range is more limited, focusing on smaller hardware. The finish is intentionally imperfect, which may not appeal to everyone.
Tumbled Brass is a wonderful choice for anyone aiming to introduce vintage or industrial character on a budget, especially for hardware updates on cabinets and furniture.
Shop this brand: https://www.tumbledbrass.com
Pottery Barn Brass vs. Tumbled Brass Comparison
Style & Aesthetic
The most significant difference lies in the aesthetic. Pottery Barn offers versatility with its polished, brushed, and antique brass finishes. These options feel refined, elegant, and clean, easily integrating into traditional homes, sophisticated transitional spaces, or even modern decor that needs a touch of metallic warmth. It’s a safe and classic choice that won’t go out of style.
Tumbled Brass, on the other hand, makes a very specific style statement. Its matte, weathered finish is much more rustic and textural. It’s perfect for adding authentic, historical-feeling charm to farmhouse kitchens, industrial lofts, or eclectic rooms filled with vintage finds. This finish isn't meant to look new - it's designed to look like it has a story, bringing warmth and character that polished finishes can sometimes lack.
Materials & Quality
Both brands use high-quality solid brass as their base material, ensuring durability. The divergence is in the finishing process. Pottery Barn typically applies a protective lacquer or coating to its brass pieces. This helps maintain the consistent shine of polished brass or the smooth look of brushed brass while protecting it from tarnishing and heavy patina.
A brand like Tumbled Brass embraces the natural aging process. The tumbling and distressing techniques create a pre-worn look, and the final product is often unlacquered. This allows the brass to continue aging naturally, developing its own unique patina over time in response to its environment and use, a desirable quality for those seeking "living finishes."
Price & Value
Pottery Barn operates in the mid-to-high end of the market. You are paying for the brand's reputation, extensive quality control, design, and customer service experience, which can include in-store consultations and generous return policies. Their pieces are investments in a timeless look.
Tumbled Brass offers a much more accessible price point. Because they specialize in a specific type of hardware and sell directly online, they can provide a unique, design-forward look for less. This makes them an exceptional value for impactful cosmetic updates, like swapping out all the knobs on a kitchen or a piece of furniture, where costs can add up quickly.
Product Selection & Availability
As a major retailer, Pottery Barn offers a vast selection of brass items. You can find everything from cabinet pulls and curtain rods to sinks, large chandeliers, and floor lamps, allowing you to create a coordinated look throughout an entire room or home. You also have the benefit of seeing many of these items in person at a physical store.
Tumbled Brass has a more curated and limited offering, focusing primarily on cabinet and furniture hardware like knobs and pulls, with a smaller selection of accent lighting. Their strength is in their specialty, providing deep expertise and focused aesthetic within that niche.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both offer quality brass products, but they are designed for very different results and projects.
Choose Pottery Barn Brass if:
- You prefer a timeless, classic, and versatile style that coordinates easily.
- Your home decor is polished, traditional, or transitional.
- You want a consistent, protected finish that resists tarnishing.
- You are shopping for larger fixtures like lighting or faucets and value a major brand's warranty.
- Shopping in-store to see and feel products is important to you.
Choose Tumbled Brass if:
- Your aesthetic leans toward farmhouse, industrial, vintage, or rustic styles.
- You love the character and warmth of aged, naturally patinaed materials.
- You're completing a budget-friendly DIY project, like updating cabinet hardware.
- You want a unique, textural finish that stands out and adds personality.
- You prefer a matte, low-sheen look that hides fingerprints and smudges.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Pottery Barn's brass finish and Tumbled Brass?
The main difference is the finish and overall aesthetic. Pottery Barn brass is typically polished, brushed satin, or evenly antiqued for a clean, classic, and refined look. Tumbled Brass is intentionally matte, distressed, and weathered for a rustic, vintage character.
Which brand is more expensive?
Pottery Barn is generally more expensive. It is a premium home furnishings brand, and its prices reflect factors like brand reputation, extensive design collections, and both retail and online presence. Tumbled Brass is much more affordable, making it a great option for hardware updates on a budget.
Will Tumbled Brass darken or change color over time?
Yes, most tumbled brass finishes are unlacquered, meaning they are "living finishes." They will continue to interact with the environment and naturally darken or develop a patina over time, which is considered a desirable trait of this style.
How do I clean Pottery Barn brass?
For most of Pottery Barn's lacquered brass, a quick wipe with a soft, dry cloth is all that is needed. Avoid using harsh chemical cleaners or abrasive polishes, as they can damage the protective coating.
Is all Pottery Barn brass real brass?
Pottery Barn's brass products are typically made from solid brass or a high-quality brass alloy, often over a base metal. Their product descriptions provide specific material information for a given item.
Which is better for a kitchen hardware update?
This depends on your style. For a classic, transitional, or modern farmhouse kitchen, Pottery Barn offers beautiful, durable options that feel sophisticated. For a more rustic, vintage, or industrial kitchen, Tumbled Brass provides tremendous value and character for an authentic, aged look.
Can you mix the two styles?
Absolutely. Mixing metals and finishes can create a layered, interesting look. For example, you could use rustic Tumbled Brass pulls on your cabinets and complement them with a more refined, polished brass pendant light from Pottery Barn above the island.
Does Pottery Barn offer an aged brass finish?
Pottery Barn often carries an "Antique Brass" finish. This finish is a chemically created patina that gives a darkened, aged appearance. However, it is typically more uniform and smooth compared to the physically distressed and matte texture of Tumbled Brass.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
