The primary difference between the Parachute Duvet Insert and the Brooklinen Duvet Insert comes down to luxury material versus accessible variety. Parachute focuses on premium, responsibly sourced down for a deeply plush, minimalist result at a higher price point, while Brooklinen offers more options - including down, down-alternative, and various warmth levels - at a more budget-friendly price.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you find the perfect duvet insert for your bed.
Parachute Duvet Insert
Parachute's duvet insert is the centerpiece of its bedding collection, designed for those seeking a premium, hotel-quality sleep experience at home. It embodies the brand's minimalist aesthetic, focusing on high-quality natural materials and simple, effective construction. This insert is known for its light-as-air feel combined with generous loft and all-season warmth, making it a go-to for comfort purists.
- What it is: A luxury duvet insert available in European white down or a hypoallergenic microfiber down-alternative fill.
- Key features: Features a sateen cotton shell, baffle box construction to keep the fill evenly distributed, and responsibly sourced materials certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS).
- Price: Ranges from $289 (Twin) to $469 (King/Cal King) for Down Alternative, $429 (Twin) to $649 (King/Cal King) for Down.
- Style: Clean, minimalist, and modern. Designed to create a serene and uncluttered sleep environment.
- Materials/Construction: The down option uses a 750-fill-power European white down, providing exceptional loft without heavy weight. The alternative fill is a soft, airy microfiber. Both are encased in a 100% cambric cotton shell.
- Pros: Exceptionally plush and luxurious feel. Made with high-quality, responsibly sourced materials. Breathable cotton shell helps regulate temperature. Durable construction is built to last for years.
- Cons: Priced in the luxury tier, making it a significant investment. Fewer warmth options compared to competitors. Down-alternative version is less lofty than the real down.
The Parachute insert is for anyone willing to invest in superior comfort, natural materials, and a quiet luxury aesthetic for their bedroom.
Shop this product: parachutehome.com/collections/duvet-inserts
Brooklinen Duvet Insert
Brooklinen’s approach is to provide high-quality bedding directly to consumers, cutting out the middleman to offer accessible prices. Their duvet inserts reflect this mission by offering impressive comfort and thoughtful features - like multiple warmth levels and fill types - that cater to a wider range of sleepers and budgets. This versatility has made Brooklinen a majorly popular choice for outfitting a well-made bed without a luxury markup.
- What it is: A versatile collection of duvet inserts available in Down and Down Alternative fills, each offered in three distinct tiers (Lightweight, All-Season, and Ultra-Warm).
- Key features: Specific weight options for different climates and sleeper types. Hypoallergenic fills are available. Features corner loops to secure the insert within a duvet cover.
- Price: Ranges from $159 (Twin) to $269 (King/Cal King) for Down Alternative, $249 (Twin) to $459 (King/Cal King) for Down. Frequent sales are common.
- Style: Modern classic. Designed to be a functional, comfortable foundation that works with any decor style.
- Materials/Construction: The down options feature a sateen or long-staple cotton shell with a blend of down clusters and feathers for All-Season models, and all-down clusters for its premium offerings. Both down and alternative fills use baffle box construction.
- Pros: More affordable than many competitors. Wide variety of warmth and fill options to match personal preference. 365-day return policy provides great peace of mind. Easy to care for, with clear instructions for each fill type.
- Cons: The basic down option has a mix of feathers, which isn't as premium as Parachute's all-down fill. Direct-to-consumer model means you can't feel it in-store before buying.
This duvet insert is perfect for savvy shoppers who want specific warmth options and great quality for the price.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/collections/duvet-inserts
Parachute vs. Brooklinen Duvet Insert Comparison
Materials & Fill Options
Parachute keeps it simple, offering two premium choices: European white down with a 750 fill power or a high-quality microfiber alternative. The focus is on the top-tier quality of those two materials inside a soft, breathable cotton shell. Brooklinen, on the other hand, embraces variety. Their range includes down, down alternative, and weighted options, giving shoppers more control over the feel and function of their insert. Brooklinen uses responsibly sourced down but also uses a feather blend in some models to keep costs down.
If you subscribe to a "less but better" philosophy and want the best quality natural down, Parachute is streamlined for you. If you want more choices, including specific hypoallergenic or warmth-rated fills, Brooklinen’s lineup is more comprehensive.
Warmth & Comfort
Comfort is a key deciding factor, and both brands deliver, just differently. Parachute’s inserts are typically offered in an all-season weight, which provides lofty, breathable warmth that works well for most of the year in temperature-controlled rooms. The comfort comes from its premium, cloud-like feel.
Brooklinen tackles comfort through customization. They offer Lightweight, All-Season, and Ultra-Warm versions of both their down and down-alternative inserts. This allows you to pick an exact weight for your sleeping preference and climate. A hot sleeper in a warm state could choose the Lightweight version, while a cold sleeper in a drafty house could opt for the Ultra-Warm. For pure plushness, Parachute has a slight edge, but for personalized warmth, Brooklinen is the clear winner.
Price & Value
Brooklinen is consistently more affordable across the board. For a Queen size All-Season down-alternative duvet, Brooklinen is around $200, while Parachute is closer to $350. The gap is similar for the down versions. Plus, Brooklinen frequently runs sitewide sales, which can bring the price down even further.
Parachute positions itself as an investment piece - you pay more for the higher fill power, meticulous sourcing, and luxury branding. The value is in its long-term durability and premium feel. For shoppers looking for the best deal and excellent all-around quality, the value proposition of Brooklinen is hard to beat, especially with their year-long trial window.
Who Each One Works Best For
Parachute is an ideal choice for the design-conscious consumer who prioritizes GRS/Oeko-Tex-certified natural materials and a luxury, hotel-like aesthetic. It's for the person who values an exceptionally light-but-warm feel and is willing to invest in a premium foundation piece for their bed that will last for many years. It suits minimalist, modern, and Scandinavian-inspired bedrooms perfectly.
Brooklinen is made for the practical, savvy shopper who wants choice and a great balance of quality and price. It’s perfect for couples with different temperature preferences, allergy sufferers needing a reliable hypoallergenic option, or anyone living in a climate with dramatic seasonal shifts. The ability to choose a specific warmth level makes it a more versatile and functional bedding solution for a wider variety of people.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Parachute and the Brooklinen are excellent options, but they serve different needs and budgets.
Choose the Parachute Duvet Insert if:
- You prioritize a luxurious, soft, and airy feel above all else.
- You are willing to spend more on high-quality, ethically sourced down.
- You prefer a simple, streamlined "all-season" option without too many choices.
- You appreciate a minimalist aesthetic and premium branding.
Choose the Brooklinen Duvet Insert if:
- You're looking for the best quality at a more accessible price point.
- You want to choose your perfect warmth level (Lightweight, All-Season, or Ultra-Warm).
- You need a hypoallergenic option that performs nearly as well as genuine down.
- You appreciate the peace of mind that comes with a 365-day return policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Parachute and Brooklinen duvet inserts?
The main difference is luxury focus versus practical variety. Parachute offers premium down or down-alternative fills with an emphasis on a luxurious, airy feel. Brooklinen provides more options in terms of fill and warmth levels (Lightweight, All-Season, Ultra-Warm) at a more accessible price.
Which duvet insert is warmer?
Brooklinen likely offers the warmest option with its "Ultra-Warm" duvet insert, which is specifically designed for very cold sleepers and climates. Parachute's down insert is very warm due to its high fill power but is marketed as an all-season option suitable for year-round use.
Are both brands hypoallergenic?
Yes, both brands offer excellent hypoallergenic down-alternative options. Parachute uses a premium microfiber fill, while Brooklinen's alternative fill is made from repurposed shaved microfibers for a fluffy and allergy-friendly experience.
How do I care for my duvet insert?
For both brands, it's generally recommended to dry clean or machine wash in a commercial-size front-load washing machine on a delicate cycle according to label instructions. Using a duvet cover is the best way to protect your insert and reduce the need for frequent washing.
Do Parachute and Brooklinen inserts have corner loops?
Yes, both Parachute and Brooklinen inserts come equipped with corner loops. These are small fabric loops at each of the four corners that allow you to tie them to the inside of your duvet cover, preventing the insert from shifting or bunching up.
Is the higher price of Parachute worth it?
Whether it's "worth it" depends on your priorities. The extra cost of a Parachute duvet insert gets you higher fill power down, creating a lighter and loftier feel, along with prestigious material certifications. Many users find this luxury feel is a worthwhile long-term investment. If you value personalizing your warmth level over pure loft, Brooklinen provides better value.
How long is the return period?
Brooklinen has one of the most generous return policies in the industry, offering a 365-day window for returns or exchanges. Parachute offers a more standard 60-day return window.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Brooklinen is an excellent choice for hot sleepers because they offer a "Lightweight" option specifically engineered to provide less insulation. While the natural down in Parachute's insert is breathable, having a purpose-built lightweight version from Brooklinen may offer more comfort.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
