The OXO and Simplehuman shower caddies both solve the problem of shower clutter, but they target different priorities through their design, materials, and price. An OXO shower caddy focuses on practical affordability and user-friendly features with durable plastics and rust-resistant metals, while a Simplehuman shower caddy offers a premium, modern aesthetic with high-grade stainless steel and innovative adjustable designs for a higher price.
Here is everything you need to know to decide which shower caddy is the right fit for your bathroom and budget.
Oxo Good Grips 3-Tier Shower Caddy
Oxo's shower caddies are designed with practicality and everyday usability as the top priority. They are known for their reliable, no-fuss construction, strong grip, and ample storage, making them a fixture in homes that value function and durability without a high upfront cost.
- What it is: A user-friendly shower storage solution known for its thoughtful, ergonomic design and affordability.
- Key features: Non-slip hook that grips shower head pipe, rust-proof stainless steel and anodized aluminum parts, bottle holes for storing shampoo upside down, built-in hooks for razors and loofahs.
- Price: Typically priced between $20 and $35.
- Style: Functional and utilitarian, with clean lines and neutral tones (white, grey, and metallics) that blend easily into most bathroom settings.
- Materials/Construction: A mix of durable, rust-resistant stainless steel, anodized aluminum, and sturdy plastics for trays and hooks.
- Pros: Excellent value for the price. Sturdy and reliable construction prevents slipping. Thoughtful features like bottle holes and specialized hooks increase functionality. Widely available at major retailers.
- Cons: The design is more functional than stylish. Plastic components may feel less premium than all-metal competitors. Limited adjustability compared to higher-end models.
This caddy is ideal for renters, families, and anyone who needs a dependable and affordable storage solution that just works.
Shop this product: oxo.com/categories/bath/shower-tub.html
Simplehuman Tension & Over-the-Door Pole Shower Caddy
Simplehuman approaches shower organization as a design element, offering sleek, modern caddies that combine premium materials with smart engineering. Their products are built to last and elevate the look of a bathroom, appealing to those who see accessories as part of their home's overall aesthetic.
- What it is: A premium, modern shower caddy that prioritizes high-end materials, style, and innovative features.
- Key features: Adjustable shelves that move up, down, or sideways. Made from rust-proof stainless steel and anodized aluminum. Models include over-the-door, hanging, and tension pole designs. Features like a quick-dry soap dish and sturdy shower head clamp with suction cups.
- Price: Ranges from around $40 to $70, depending on the model.
- Style: Sleek, minimalist, and contemporary. It features clean lines and high-quality metallic finishes that feel at home in modern or designer bathrooms.
- Materials/Construction: Constructed almost entirely from high-grade stainless steel and anodized aluminum, ensuring it remains rust-free and looking new for years.
- Pros: Superior build quality and materials. Beautiful, modern design elevates bathroom decor. Highly adjustable shelves accommodate a wide range of bottle sizes. Smart engineering features provide exceptional stability.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than many competitors. Limited retail availability outside of their website and select premium stores. The higher price may not be justifiable for everyone.
This caddy is perfect for style-conscious homeowners who want a long-lasting, sophisticated fixture and are willing to invest in premium quality and design.
Shop this product: simplehuman.com/collections/shower-caddies
Oxo vs. Simplehuman Shower Caddy Comparison
Materials & Construction
Both brands use rust-proof materials, but their approach differs. Oxo caddies typically combine stainless steel or anodized aluminum for the mainframe with durable plastic for the shelving and hooks. This hybrid construction is cost-effective and highly functional, though the plastic elements can feel less premium over time.
Simplehuman, on the other hand, almost exclusively uses high-grade stainless steel and anodized aluminum for the entire structure. This all-metal build not only provides exceptional durability and corrosion resistance but also contributes to the caddy’s weighty, high-end feel and polished appearance.
Style & Aesthetics
Style is the most significant visual differentiator. Oxo's design philosophy is practical and unobtrusive. Its caddies feature simple forms and neutral colors that are meant to organize without drawing attention, blending into the background of almost any bathroom decor.
Simplehuman treats its caddies as decorative hardware. The designs are modern, minimalist, and sleek, with polished metallic finishes that complement contemporary faucets and fixtures. If you want your storage to be a conscious part of your bathroom's design, Simplehuman is the clear choice.
Price & Value
Oxo offers excellent value for budget-conscious consumers. For $20-$35, you get a thoughtfully designed, reliable shower caddy that will last for years and effectively organizes your essentials without fuss. It's a smart purchase that serves its purpose well.
Simplehuman positions itself as a premium investment, with prices from $40-$70. The value here is in longevity, superior materials, and a designer look. If you appreciate finely crafted objects and are planning on using the caddy for many years, the higher upfront cost can be justified by its durability and visual appeal.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands make excellent shower caddies, but they serve different buyers with different priorities.
Choose the Oxo if:
- You're on a practical budget and want the best function for your money.
- You prioritize stability, smart storage features, and durability over style.
- You're a renter or simply need a straightforward solution that works without overthinking it.
- You prefer to buy home goods from widely available stores like Target or Amazon.
Choose the Simplehuman if:
- Aesthetics are a top priority, and you want your shower caddy to look like a modern fixture.
- You are willing to invest more for premium, all-metal materials and superior longevity.
- You need adjustable shelves to fit oversized bottles and custom arrangements.
- You view your home accessories as long-term investments in quality and design.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between OXO and Simplehuman caddies?
The main difference comes down to design philosophy and price. Oxo prioritizes affordable, practical function with durable, mixed materials. Simplehuman is a design-forward, premium brand that uses high-end, all-metal materials to create a stylish and long-lasting product at a higher price point.
Are Simplehuman caddies really rust-proof?
Yes, Simplehuman caddies are made from high-grade stainless steel and anodized aluminum, materials specifically chosen for their excellent corrosion resistance. They are among the most reliable options on the market for preventing rust in a humid shower environment.
Will an Oxo shower caddy fit my large shampoo bottles?
Most Oxo models are designed with ample shelf spacing to accommodate standard to large-sized bottles. Many also feature specialized holes that allow you to store bottles upside down, which is useful for thick conditioners.
How do you clean these shower caddies?
Both caddies are easy to clean. A non-abrasive cleaner or a simple mixture of vinegar and water with a soft cloth will remove soap scum and water spots without damaging the finish. Their open-wire shelf designs allow for easy rinsing and quick drying.
Which brand is more durable?
Both brands are known for durability, but Simplehuman has an edge due to its all-metal construction. While Oxo's plastic components are sturdy, high-grade stainless steel and aluminum will generally hold up better and maintain their appearance longer over a decade of use.
Which one is easier to install?
Both are equally easy to install for their respective types. Most hanging models from both brands feature a non-slip design that simply hooks over the shower head, often with suction cups at the bottom for added stability. Installation typically takes less than a minute with no tools required.
Will the metal damage my shower head or tile?
No. Both brands incorporate protective features to prevent damage. Hanging caddies from both Oxo and Simplehuman have a rubberized or silicone coating on the hook to protect the shower pipe from scratches. Suction cups used for stability are also made of soft plastic that won't harm tile or fiberglass.
Where can I buy Oxo and Simplehuman caddies?
Oxo shower caddies are widely available. You can find them on Amazon and at major retailers like Target, Bed Bath & Beyond, and The Container Store. Simplehuman products are sold directly on their website, on Amazon, and in select higher-end home goods stores.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
