The Oxo Good Grips baking dish and the classic Pyrex dish both excel at baking lasagnas and casseroles, but they solve different user needs through design and materials. Oxo focuses on ergonomics with its large, comfortable handles and practical features, while Pyrex relies on its time-tested, highly durable borosilicate glass that lets you monitor cooking at a glance.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right baking dish for your kitchen.
Oxo Good Grips Baking Dish
Oxo is known for its thoughtful, user-friendly kitchen tools, and its bakeware is no exception. Designed with a focus on practicality and comfort, the Oxo Good Grips line features prominent, easy-to-hold handles that provide a secure grip, even when wearing bulky oven mitts. This design approach makes maneuvering a hot dish from oven to countertop safer and more comfortable.
- What it is: A line of baking dishes, available in borosilicate glass or non-stick metal, designed with an emphasis on ergonomic handling and modern convenience.
- Key features: Signature large, comfortable handles, sturdy borosilicate glass or aluminized steel construction, often includes a matching lid for storage.
- Price: Mid-range, typically $15 to $30 for standard sizes.
- Style: Contemporary and functional, with clean lines and a focus on intuitive usability.
- Materials/Construction: Offered in thermal shock-resistant borosilicate glass as well as aluminized steel with a ceramic-reinforced, two-layer non-stick coating.
- Pros: Excellent, easy-to-grip handles increase safety and comfort. Non-stick options provide superior food release. Modern aesthetic fits well in contemporary kitchens. Borosilicate glass construction adds durability and thermal shock resistance.
- Cons: Larger handles take up more storage and oven space. Non-stick coatings can degrade over time and require careful handling. Often slightly more expensive than comparative Pyrex models.
The Oxo dish is perfect for home cooks who prioritize secure handling, modern convenience, and the easy cleanup that comes with non-stick options.
Shop this product: amazon.com/OXO-Good-Grips-Baking-Dish/dp/B013Q2CP2Q/
Pyrex Baking Dish
A true kitchen icon, Pyrex has been a staple in homes for over a century. Its reputation is built on incredibly durable and reliable tempered glass bakeware that can go from freezer to oven to table without issue. Pyrex dishes are famously non-porous, meaning they won't absorb food odors, flavors, or stains, making them exceptionally long-lasting and versatile.
- What it is: A classic baking dish made of timeless, durable tempered glass, known for its longevity and resistance to heat and stains.
- Key features: Made from high-quality, non-porous glass, safe for the oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher, allows you to see food as it cooks.
- Price: Generally very affordable, with most standard dishes ranging from $10 to $25.
- Dimensions: Available in a wide array of standardized sizes, including the classic 9x13-inch and 8x8-inch pans that most recipes call for.
- Materials/Construction: Made from borosilicate or tempered soda-lime glass, both of which are designed to withstand high temperatures and thermal shock.
- Style: Classic, simple, and transparent. A timeless look that focuses on utility and the ability to serve directly from the dish.
- Pros: Extremely durable and can last for decades. Transparency allows for easy monitoring of baking progress. Non-reactive glass won't stain or absorb odors. Incredibly versatile for baking, serving, and storing food.
- Cons: Glass can shatter if dropped or exposed to extreme, sudden temperature changes (like placing a hot dish on a wet, cold countertop). Handles are smaller and integrated into the glass, offering less grip than Oxo.
This is a foundational piece of bakeware for anyone who values classic durability, versatility, and the ability to watch their food bubble away to perfection.
Shop this product: target.com/p/pyrex-easy-grab-3qt-glass-baking-dish-with-lid/-/A-14765636
Oxo vs. Pyrex Comparison
Materials & Durability
Both brands use high-quality, thermal shock-resistant borosilicate glass, which means you're getting a durable product either way. The core difference lies in Oxo's added material options. Oxo also offers bakeware made from aluminized steel with non-stick coatings, which is excellent for things like coffee cakes and brownies where a quick, clean release is essential.
In terms of longevity, a Pyrex glass dish, if cared for, can genuinely last a lifetime without degrading. Oxo's glass dishes are equally robust, but their non-stick metal alternatives have a finite lifespan, as all non-stick coatings eventually wear down.
Design & Ergonomics
This is where Oxo clearly stands out. The Good Grips line is built for easy handling. Its substantial, comfortable handles are easier to grab with bulky oven mitts, providing a far more secure feeling when moving a hot, heavy casserole. Pyrex handles are much smaller, formed from the glass itself, and can be harder to grip securely.
While the Oxo handles excel in function, they do add to the dish's overall footprint, which can be an issue in smaller ovens or crowded cupboards. Pyrex's streamlined designs lend themselves to easier stacking and storing.
Price & Value
Pyrex generally holds the edge on affordability. A standard 9x13-inch Pyrex dish is often priced lower than its Oxo counterpart. Given its incredible durability, Pyrex offers outstanding long-term value. One dish can serve a kitchen reliably for decades.
Oxo's slightly higher price buys you superior handling and modern design. For those who feel unsteady handling hot bakeware or simply want a more comfortable cooking experience, the modest extra cost for an Oxo dish is easily justified by the added ergonomic features.
Style & Versatility
Aesthetics are subjective, but each brand has a clear design identity. Pyrex is timeless and an iconic brand. Its clear glass allows you to monitor browning on the sides and bottom - a key advantage for pies and casseroles. It also transitions seamlessly from oven to table in any setting.
Oxo provides a more contemporary and a cohesive look. Their clean lines and prominent branding appeal to those who have other Oxo tools in their kitchen. The versatility of Oxo's line - offering both glass and non-stick metal - means you can choose the best material for the job, rather than relying on one type.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Oxo and Pyrex make excellent baking dishes, but they are designed for slightly different priorities.
Choose the Oxo Baking Dish if:
- Safety and a secure grip are your top priorities when handling hot dishes.
- You appreciate modern, ergonomic designs in your kitchen tools.
- You specifically want a non-stick option for cakes or sticky casseroles.
- You do a lot of meal-prepping and want a baking dish with a secure, well-fitting lid.
Choose the Pyrex Baking Dish if:
- You value extreme durability in a "buy it for life" piece of kitchenware.
- You want to monitor the cooking progress from the sides and bottom.
- You're looking for the most budget-friendly, high-quality option available.
- You need versatile cookware that excels in the trifecta of baking, serving, and storing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Oxo and Pyrex baking dishes?
The primary difference is design philosophy. Oxo prioritizes ergonomics with large, easy-to-grip handles for safer handling. Pyrex focuses on material simplicity and longevity with its classic, ultra-durable, all-glass design.
Is Oxo's glass bakeware the same as Pyrex?
Both brands use high-quality borosilicate glass, which is prized for its ability to withstand thermal shock (sudden temperature changes). In terms of the glass itself, they are very comparable in quality and durability.
Can you put a hot Pyrex dish on a cold counter?
No, this should be avoided with any glass bakeware. Placing a hot dish on a cold or wet surface can cause thermal shock, where the glass contracts too quickly and cracks or shatters. Always place hot glass dishes on a trivet, potholder, or dry towel.
Which brand is better for baking brownies or cakes?
While you can bake beautifully in either, many people prefer Oxo's non-stick metal pans for this task. The non-stick coating ensures an easy release, keeping the edges of brownies and cakes intact without the need for excessive greasing.
Are the lids for an Oxo and a Pyrex glass baking dish interchangeable?
No, they are not. Each brand designs its lids to fit its specific bakeware dimensions and handle shapes. Always use the lid that came with your specific dish for the best fit.
How do you clean non-stick Oxo bakeware to make it last?
To preserve the non-stick coating, wash Oxo metal bakeware by hand with a soft sponge and mild dish soap. Avoid using abrasive scrubbers, harsh detergents, or metal utensils that could scratch the surface.
Which brand offers a better warranty?
Both have strong guarantees, but Pyrex is famous for its limited lifetime warranty on its glass dishes, underscoring their confidence in the product's longevity. Oxo offers a satisfaction guarantee across its products, with great customer service for addressing any issues.
Do Oxo's large bakeware handles get hot in the oven?
Yes, the entire baking dish, including the handles, gets hot in the oven. The benefit of Oxo's design is that the handles are shaped to be easily and securely gripped while wearing thick oven mitts, reducing the risk of dropping the dish.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
