The Oxo Brew 9-Cup and the Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14-Cup brewers exemplify the core difference between the two brands: Oxo prioritizes sleek, minimalist design and precise brew technology, while Cuisinart focuses on versatility, a broad feature set, and budget-friendly value. Oxo machines typically use thermal carafes and streamlined controls for an effortless, high-quality brew, whereas Cuisinart often packs in multiple settings and larger capacities catered to a wider range of user preferences.
Here’s everything you need to know to decide whether an Oxo or a Cuisinart coffee maker belongs on your kitchen counter.
Oxo Coffee Makers
Oxo is known for kitchen tools that merge thoughtful engineering with modern aesthetics, and their coffee makers are no exception. These machines are designed for the person who wants a consistently great cup of coffee without fuss. They emphasize precision in water temperature and brew cycle timing, ensuring optimal flavor extraction in a sleek, user-friendly package.
- What it is: Precision-focused drip coffee makers known for sleek design, thermal carafes, and simple controls.
- Key features: Rainmaker™ shower head for even saturation, advanced brewing algorithms for consistent temperature control, programmable timers, and double-walled thermal carafes.
- Price: Mid-range, typically from $100 to $200.
- Style: Modern, minimalist, and streamlined with clean lines and neutral tones that fit well in contemporary kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: High-quality stainless steel and BPA-free plastics built for durability and heat stability.
- Pros: Excellent brew quality with precise temperature control. Thermal carafe keeps coffee hot for hours without a warming plate. Aesthetically pleasing, minimalist design. Simple and intuitive to operate.
- Cons: Generally more expensive than comparable Cuisinart models. Fewer features and customization options. Smaller product range to choose from.
An Oxo coffee maker is ideal for those who value brew perfection and a chic, uncluttered design over a long list of features.
Shop this brand: oxo.com/categories/coffee-tea/coffee-makers
Cuisinart Coffee Makers
Cuisinart is a foundational brand in American kitchens, offering a massive lineup of reliable appliances that deliver value and versatility. Their coffee makers reflect this strategy, providing a wide array of options from large-capacity family models to single-serve machines. Cuisinart brewers are workhorses, packed with programmable features to suit different tastes and routines.
- What it is: Feature-rich drip coffee makers offering versatility in brew styles, strengths, and capacities at accessible prices.
- Key features: Customizable brew strength and temperature, 24-hour programmability, auto-off features, self-cleaning cycles, and options for 1-4 cup settings.
- Price: Broad range from $70 to $250, with many popular models under $150.
- Style: A mix of classic and modern, often featuring polished stainless steel housing, digital displays, and a functional layout.
- Materials/Construction: Mainstream construction with sturdy plastics and stainless steel accents. Most models come with a glass carafe and a heated plate.
- Pros: An extensive range of features for the price. Models available in various sizes (up to 14 cups). Strong brand reputation for durability. Widely available and often on sale.
- Cons: Glass carafes don’t retain heat as well as thermal ones. The warming plate can give coffee a "burnt" taste over time. Aesthetics can feel more utilitarian than sleek.
A Cuisinart coffee brewer is perfect for households that need a versatile, programmable machine that can handle different preferences and morning schedules.
Shop this brand: cuisinart.com/shopping/appliances/coffee_makers
Oxo vs. Cuisinart: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Price & Value
When it comes to price, Cuisinart generally offers more budget-friendly options. Models like the popular Cuisinart PerfecTemp (DCC-3200) often retail around $130, providing a great deal of functionality for the cost. Oxo positions itself as a more premium mid-range brand, with brewers like its 9-Cup Coffee Maker priced closer to $180. The value proposition is different: Cuisinart's value is in its feature set and accessibility, while Oxo's value is in its specialized brewing technology and high-end materials.
Build Quality & Materials
Both brands produce durable machines, but they prioritize different components. Oxo consistently uses double-walled stainless steel thermal carafes that maintain temperature exceptionally well without scorching the coffee. This focus on premium materials contributes to better flavor longevity. Cuisinart typically uses sturdy plastics and stainless steel shells with glass carafes. Glass is easy to clean and lets you see how much coffee is left, but it loses heat quickly and relies on a hot plate that can alter the coffee's taste over time.
Design & Aesthetics
The design philosophy is a major differentiator. Oxo embodies a modern, minimalist aesthetic. Its "less is more" approach results in clean lines, matte finishes, and intuitive controls that look beautiful on a contemporary countertop. Cuisinart’s designs are more traditional and function-forward, often featuring a combination of brushed metal, black plastic, and a digital interface with multiple buttons. While perfectly nice, they don't have the same curated design feel as an Oxo product.
Brewing Features & Versatility
Cuisinart is the clear winner if you want features. Its coffee makers commonly include adjustable brew strength (regular or bold), programmable start times, auto-shutoff timers, and even hot water dispensers on some models. They offer a wider range of sizes, from single-serve to large 14-cup brewers, making them ideal for families or offices. Oxo, by contrast, focuses on perfecting one function: making a great pot of drip coffee. Its user input is minimal because the machine is internally programmed for optimal water temperature and drip time, appealing to users who want consistency without complication.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Oxo and Cuisinart make excellent coffee makers, but they are built for entirely different customers.
Choose an Oxo if:
- You prioritize the absolute best-tasting drip coffee and value precise temperature control.
- You want your coffee to stay hot for hours without a burnt taste, thanks to a thermal carafe.
- You appreciate a sleek, minimalist design that complements a modern kitchen.
- You prefer a simple, set-it-and-forget-it machine and don't need lots of extra features.
Choose a Cuisinart if:
- You are looking for the most versatility and features for your money.
- You need a machine with a large capacity (12-14 cups) for a large family or for entertaining.
- You enjoy customizing your brew with settings for strength, temperature, and brew time.
- You prefer a traditional glass carafe and don't mind relying on a warming plate.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Oxo and Cuisinart coffee makers?
The core difference is philosophy. Oxo focuses on brewing precision and modern, minimalist design, often with fewer but more intentional features. Cuisinart aims for versatility and value, packing its machines with a wide array of programmable features and size options at an accessible price point.
Which brand is more expensive?
Oxo is generally more expensive. Their coffee makers typically start around a higher price point ($100+) compared to Cuisinart, which has many highly-rated models available for under $100.
Is a thermal carafe or a glass carafe better?
A thermal carafe (common with Oxo) is better for heat retention, keeping coffee hot for hours without an external heat source that can create a "burnt" taste. A glass carafe (common with Cuisinart) lets you see how much coffee is left and is usually dishwasher safe, but it relies on a warming plate to keep the coffee hot.
Are Oxo coffee makers hard to clean?
No, Oxo designs its products to be user-friendly, and that includes cleaning. The minimalist design with fewer crevices makes wiping down the exterior easy. Carafes and brew baskets are typically removable for thorough washing.
Which brand is better for a small kitchen?
Both brands offer options for smaller spaces. Oxo's 8-cup models have a compact and vertical footprint. Cuisinart also offers smaller 4-cup brewers and single-serve machines that fit well in tight spots.
Can you adjust the brew strength on an Oxo coffee maker?
Most Oxo models are designed for optimal brewing without strength adjustments - you control the strength by how much coffee ground you use. Cuisinart models, on the other hand, almost always include a "bold" setting that slows down the brewing process for a stronger taste.
How long do coffee makers from these brands last?
Both brands are known for durability and typically offer warranties ranging from 1 to 3 years. With regular cleaning and descaling, both an Oxo and a Cuisinart coffee maker can be expected to last for many years of daily use.
Where can I buy Oxo or Cuisinart coffee makers?
Cuisinart is widely available at most major retailers like Target, Walmart, and Amazon. Oxo is also sold on Amazon and its own website, as well as in specialty kitchen stores like Bed Bath & Beyond and Williams-Sonoma.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
