The main differences between a coffee maker from Oxo and one from Breville come down to user experience, customization, and price. Oxo coffee makers are designed for simplicity and reliability, offering a straightforward, high-quality brewing experience at a mid-range price point. Breville machines are more premium and feature-rich, providing serious coffee enthusiasts with a high degree of control over the brewing process, but at a significantly higher cost.
Here’s everything you need to know to decide whether an Oxo or a Breville coffee maker belongs on your kitchen counter.
Oxo Coffee Makers
Oxo is known for making thoughtfully engineered kitchen gadgets that just work well, and its coffee makers are no exception. They focus on delivering consistent, high-quality coffee with minimal fuss. Emphasizing user-friendly interfaces and minimalist designs, Oxo coffee makers are perfect for anyone who wants a great cup of coffee without a complicated learning curve.
- What it is: A line of automatic drip coffee makers celebrated for their ease of use, precision temperature control, and consistent brewing performance.
- Key features: Single-dial interface for selecting cup quantity and brew time, precise temperature control for optimal extraction, programmable start times, and double-wall insulated thermal carafes.
- Price: Generally ranges from $150 to $250.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and minimalist with clean lines, a compact footprint, and a mix of stainless steel and black plastic that fits into nearly any kitchen design.
- Materials/Construction: Built with durable, BPA-free plastics and stainless steel accents. Components are designed for easy cleaning.
- Pros: Extremely easy to use, brews consistently excellent coffee, affordable price point for its quality, compact size saves counter space, and many models are Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) certified.
- Cons: Lacks the advanced customization options found on Breville machines, limited control over bloom time or water temperature, and construction includes more plastic components.
An Oxo coffee maker is ideal for the busy household or coffee drinker who values reliability, convenience, and excellent results without needing to tinker with settings.
Shop this brand: oxo.com/categories/coffee-tea/coffee-makers
Breville Coffee Makers
Breville markets itself to the coffee connoisseur, offering premium machines packed with advanced technology for a café-quality experience at home. Their coffee makers are highly customizable, allowing users to fine-tune every variable of the brewing process, from water temperature to flow rate, making them a favorite among home baristas and coffee hobbyists.
- What it is: A line of high-end automatic drip coffee makers offering precision control and a wide range of customizable settings for the discerning user.
- Key features: Adjustable water temperature and bloom time, customizable flow rates, various brewing presets ("Gold," "Fast," "Strong," etc.), and options for single-cup brewing without pods.
- Price: Models typically range from $200 to over $500.
- Style: Sophisticated and professional, with brushed stainless steel finishes, clear digital displays, and a substantial, high-tech appearance that makes a statement on the countertop.
- Materials/Construction: Primarily made from high-quality brushed stainless steel for a premium look and long-term durability.
- Pros: Unmatched control over brewing parameters, durable and high-end construction, versatile presets for different coffee types, beautiful design, and SCA Certified performance.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than Oxo, can be complex for beginners, and has a larger countertop footprint.
A Breville coffee maker is for the coffee enthusiast who wants to experiment with and perfect their brew and is willing to invest in a machine that offers professional-grade features and quality.
Shop this brand: breville.com/us/en/products/coffee/drip-coffee
Oxo vs. Breville Coffee Maker Comparison
Dimensions & Scale
Sizing is a key differentiator between these two brands. Oxo coffee makers are designed to be more compact, typically measuring around 12-14 inches wide and fitting neatly under standard kitchen cabinets. Their smaller footprint makes them an excellent choice for apartments, smaller kitchens, or anyone trying to conserve counter space.
Breville machines are more substantial in both size and visual weight. Often measuring 14-16 inches wide or more, they demand a dedicated spot on your counter. Their larger size is a direct result of their more complex hardware and robust construction, positioning them as a centerpiece for a home coffee station rather than just another appliance.
Materials & Construction
Both brands produce durable machines, but they approach materials differently. Oxo uses a combination of high-quality, BPA-free plastics and stainless steel accents. This balance keeps the price accessible while ensuring reliability for daily use. The components feel well-made and fit together securely.
Breville leans heavily into premium materials, using brushed stainless steel for most of its construction. This gives their coffee makers a distinctly high-end feel, added durability, and substantial weight. While both brands typically offer 1- to 2-year warranties, Breville's heavy-duty build suggests a longer potential lifespan with proper care.
Price & Value
Oxo provides outstanding value. For $150-$250, you get an SCA-certified machine that automates the specialty coffee process, delivering consistently balanced and hot coffee with push-button simplicity. It’s an investment in reliable performance without breaking the bank.
A Breville machine is a luxury purchase, with prices starting where Oxo's lineup ends and going up significantly. The value here is not just in the coffee itself, but in the control and experience. For a coffee enthusiast, the ability to tweak bloom time and water temperature to suit specific coffee beans is worth the premium price tag.
Style & Versatility
The design philosophies of the two brands are very different. Oxo's style is understated and functional. Its clean lines and neutral color scheme are meant to blend in, complementing a modern kitchen without drawing too much attention. It’s versatile enough to work with almost any decor.
Breville’s aesthetic is professional and bold. The gleaming stainless steel, digital displays, and imposing size are meant to be showcased. It’s a statement piece that communicates a serious passion for coffee and pairs perfectly with other high-end, modern kitchen appliances.
Who Each One Works Best For
Oxo is for the person who says, "I just want a great cup of coffee every morning without any effort." It's perfect for busy professionals, families, or anyone who appreciates quality but prioritizes convenience. If you are new to specialty coffee and want consistently good results from your beans, Oxo is a fantastic and reliable starting point.
Breville is for the person who says, "I want to control every element to make the perfect cup of coffee for these specific beans." It's for the hobbyist, the tinkerer, and the connoisseur. If you enjoy dialing in your brew, experimenting with different settings, and treating coffee making as a craft, a Breville machine will grow with your skills.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent coffee makers that excel in different areas, so your choice depends on your daily routine, budget, and passion for coffee.
Choose Oxo if:
- You prioritize "set-it-and-forget-it" simplicity and convenience.
- You want a reliable, high-performing machine for under $250.
- Counter space is limited, and you need a more compact appliance.
- You value SCA-certified brewing performance without needing to control every variable.
Choose Breville if:
- You want to experiment with brew settings like temperature, bloom time, and flow rate.
- You are passionate about coffee and want a machine that offers pro-level control.
- Your budget allows for a premium appliance, and you value a durable, stainless steel build.
- You have dedicated counter space and want a coffee maker that is also a statement piece.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Oxo and Breville coffee makers?
The primary difference is simplicity versus customization. Oxo nails the basics, offering a simple, automated brewing experience that delivers great coffee consistently. Breville provides a suite of advanced, customizable features that let you craft your coffee exactly how you want it, much like a manual brewing setup, but automated.
Which brand is easier to use for beginners?
Oxo is by far the easier brand for beginners. Its intuitive, single-dial interface simplifies the brewing process to just adding coffee and water and pressing a button. A Breville has a steeper learning curve due to its extensive menu of options.
Are Breville coffee makers worth the extra cost?
For a coffee lover who enjoys experimenting with the nuances of brewing, yes. The ability to control all brewing variables justifies the higher cost. For someone who simply wants a delicious, no-fuss pot of coffee in the morning, the extra features may go unused, making Oxo a better value.
Do I need a separate grinder for an Oxo coffee maker?
Yes. Neither Oxo nor Breville's standard drip models have built-in grinders. To get the best results from either brand, you will need a separate, high-quality burr grinder to ensure freshly ground coffee for each brew.
How long do Oxo and Breville coffee makers last?
Both brands are known for durability and typically come with 1 or 2-year warranties. However, a Breville’s extensive use of stainless steel and heavy-duty components often suggests a longer potential lifespan, especially with regular maintenance and care.
Which brand offers better temperature control?
Both brands offer excellent, SCA-certified temperature control that stays within the ideal brewing range. The difference is that Breville's Precision Brewer allows you to *adjust* the temperature, while Oxo maintains an optimal fixed temperature. Both are extremely accurate.
Are the thermal carafes effective for both brands?
Yes, both Oxo and Breville use high-quality, double-wall insulated stainless steel carafes. They keep coffee hot for several hours without an electric warming plate, which can alter the coffee's flavor by continuing to "cook" it.
Can Breville coffee makers brew a single cup?
Many Breville models have dedicated settings for single-cup brewing. They can adjust the water volume and flow rate accordingly to brew directly into a mug, offering greater versatility without the waste of coffee pods.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
