The primary difference between the OXO POP Containers with steel lids and those with classic plastic lids is purely aesthetic and, consequently, price. Both versions share the exact same clear, BPA-free container body and patented push-button airtight seal mechanism, the only distinction is that one has a sleek stainless steel lid cover for a more modern look, while the other features the classic, budget-friendly white plastic lid.
Here’s a detailed look at both options to help you decide which storage solution from OXO is the right fit for your kitchen.
OXO POP Container - Stainless Steel Lid
The steel lid version is the premium offering in the OXO POP lineup, designed for those who want superior organization without compromising on style. It provides the same excellent airtight storage as the classic version but is finished with a sophisticated stainless steel top that flawlessly matches modern appliances and high-end kitchen fixtures, creating a cohesive and polished look in your pantry or on your countertops.
- What it is: A line of modular, airtight food storage containers featuring clear plastic bodies and aesthetically-focused lids topped with fingerprint-resistant stainless steel.
- Key features: Push-button pop-up mechanism for an airtight seal, stackable and space-efficient rectangular shapes, curved corners for easy pouring, and a variety of fill lines for measurement.
- Price: Ranges from roughly $15 to $25 per individual container, commanding a premium over the plastic models.
- Style: Modern, sleek, and industrial. The brushed steel finish integrates perfectly with stainless steel refrigerators, ovens, and other small appliances.
- Materials/Construction: The container is made of durable, clear, BPA-free plastic. The lid consists of a plastic internal mechanism with a decorative stainless steel outer shell and a silicone gasket for the seal.
- Pros: Elevated and premium aesthetic. Lid finish beautifully matches modern kitchens. Highly durable and resistant to fingerprints. Offers the same great functionality as the classic POP containers.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than the plastic lid version. The steel is a decorative cover, not indicative of a more durable internal mechanism.
This container is for the home cook who has invested in a modern kitchen aesthetic and wants every detail, including pantry storage, to be perfectly coordinated.
Shop this product: oxo.com/pop-container-stainless-steel-lid
OXO POP Container - Plastic Lid
This is the iconic, best-selling OXO POP Container that revolutionized pantry organization. Known for its simple white lid and satisfying "pop" mechanism, this version focuses on pure functionality and practicality. It offers top-tier airtight storage in a wide range of modular sizes, making it the go-to choice for organizers who prioritize performance and value over a specific high-end aesthetic.
- What it is: The classic version of OXO's airtight food storage containers, featuring clear plastic bodies and an iconic PFOA- and BPA-free white plastic push-button lid.
- Key features: Same excellent push-button airtight seal, stackable design, curved corners, and convenient fill lines as the steel version.
- Price: More budget-friendly, with individual containers typically priced between $8 and $18.
- Style: Clean, minimalist, and classic. The bright white lid provides a uniform, organized look that works well in any kitchen style, from traditional to farmhouse to contemporary.
- Materials/Construction: BPA-free plastic container body, with a durable all-plastic lid and a silicone gasket seal.
- Pros: More affordable price point. Functional and versatile design fits a wide range of common uses and decor styles. Delivers identical storage performance and quality to the steel version for less money.
- Cons: White plastic may not feel as premium as steel. Doesn't specifically match stainless steel appliances if a cohesive look is a top priority.
This is the perfect container for anyone who needs reliable, highly functional food storage and wants the best value without paying extra for aesthetics.
Shop this product: oxo.com/pop-container-plastic-lid
OXO POP Steel Lid vs. Plastic Lid Comparison
Aesthetics & Style
This is the most significant difference between the two product lines. The steel lid containers are designed to look sleek and modern, providing a high-end feel that complements kitchens with stainless steel appliances. They look like a deliberate design choice displayed on a countertop.
The classic plastic lid containers offer a clean, bright, and uniform look. The white is neutral and creates a satisfyingly organized appearance inside a pantry or drawer. While less "premium" looking than the steel, its timeless design is versatile enough for any kitchen decor.
Materials & Durability of the Lid
While the lids look very different, their core construction and purpose are nearly identical. Both versions feature the exact same BPA-free plastic container, which is durable and shatter-resistant. The sealing mechanism and silicone gasket are also the same across both lines, ensuring identical airtight performance.
The only material difference is the lid's decorative top. The stainless steel version features a thin metal shell over the plastic mechanism, which is great at resisting fingerprints and scratches. The classic version is solid white plastic, which is very durable but could possibly be susceptible to staining from highly pigmented foods over a very long time.
Price & Value
The plastic lid OXO POP containers are the clear winner on price. On average, the steel lid versions cost several dollars more per container. This may not seem like much for a single purchase, but it adds up quickly when outfitting an entire pantry with 10, 15, or even 20 containers. The added expense for the steel version is purely for the cosmetic upgrade, the functionality is identical. From a pure value perspective, the plastic lid version delivers the same performance for less money.
Sizing & Modularity
Excellent news for avid organizers: both the steel and plastic lid versions come in the exact same array of sizes and rectangular shapes. OXO designed the entire POP system to be completely modular. This means you can freely stack a steel lid container on top of a plastic lid container (and vice-versa) without any issues. Their footprints are identical, allowing for seamless integration if you decide to mix and match or upgrade a few select containers later on.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both OXO POP containers offer best-in-class airtight storage, but the right one for you comes down to your priorities in the kitchen.
Choose the OXO POP Container with Steel Lids if:
- Your kitchen is furnished with stainless steel appliances and you want everything to match.
- Aesthetics are a top priority, and you're willing to pay a premium for a sleeker look.
- Your containers will be kept on an open shelf or countertop where they contribute to the decor.
- You simply prefer the look and feel of stainless steel over plastic.
Choose the OXO POP Container with Plastic Lids if:
- You are looking for the best performance at the most affordable price.
- You need to purchase a large number of containers to organize an entire pantry.
- Your primary concern is functionality and airtightness, not specific aesthetics.
- You prefer a clean, bright, and classic look that fits in with any kitchen style.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between OXO POP Steel and Plastic containers?
The only difference is the lid's exterior. The steel version has a stainless steel cover for a premium look, while the plastic version has a classic white plastic lid. The container body, seal mechanism, and performance are identical.
Are both versions airtight?
Yes. Both lines use the exact same signature push-button mechanism and silicone gasket to create a tight, satisfying seal that keeps food fresh. There is no difference in performance between them.
Is the container itself made of steel on the steel version?
No, this is a common point of confusion. For both product lines, the clear container body is made from the same high-quality, BPA-free plastic. Only the lid's decorative top is different.
Is the stainless steel lid version more durable?
Not in a functional sense. While the steel surface is resistant to cosmetic scratches, the internal mechanism that operates the seal is made of the same durable plastic in both models. The durability of the container body and its long-term performance will be the same.
Can I mix and match steel and plastic lid containers in my pantry?
Absolutely. They are designed to be part of the same modular system. A 1.7 QT steel lid container will stack perfectly with a 1.7 QT plastic lid container.
How do you clean the lids?
Both lid types are designed to be easily disassembled for thorough cleaning. The bottom part twists off, allowing you to separate the components and the silicone gasket. This ensures no food gets trapped inside.
Are OXO POP containers dishwasher safe?
Yes. The silicone gaskets are always dishwasher safe. For the container and lid parts, most are top-rack dishwasher safe, but OXO occasionally updates materials. It’s always best to check the specific instructions that came with your container.
Is the price difference for the steel lid worth it?
This is entirely a matter of personal preference. If your kitchen has a strong modern aesthetic and matching appliances is important to you, then the extra cost for the steel lid's premium look might be worthwhile. If you are focused on pure function and budget, the classic plastic lid provides identical performance and is a much better value.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
