While Oxo Brew and Bonavita are both top contenders in the home coffee maker market, they cater to different user priorities. A leader in user-friendly design and modern aesthetics, Oxo Brew generally offers more advanced features like programmable settings and precise temperature control. Bonavita focuses on simplicity and brewing excellence, delivering consistent, high-quality coffee through stripped-down, durable machines at a more accessible price point.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which coffee brand is the right fit for your kitchen counter.
Oxo Brew
Oxo Brew makes coffee equipment for those who love great design and crave control over their morning cup. Known for its stylish looks and innovative features, the brand has become popular among coffee drinkers who want a reliable, high-performing brewer that is also easy to use. Their products blend sleek, contemporary aesthetics with a focus on functionality and precision.
- What it is: A modern coffee equipment brand known for blending innovative features with user-friendly design.
- Key features: Many models include programmable timers, variable temperature control, and a "single-serve" function.
- Price: Mid-range, with most automatic coffee makers falling between $130 and $250.
- Style: Sleek and contemporary, often featuring stainless steel accents, clean lines, and intuitive digital displays.
- Materials/Construction: Built with high-quality, durable materials like stainless steel and BPA-free plastics for a solid, premium feel.
- Pros: Excellent brewing consistency, advanced programmable features, modern and stylish design, user-friendly interface, built to last.
- Cons: A higher price point compared to Bonavita, and some features may be more than what a casual coffee drinker needs.
Oxo Brew is the perfect choice for coffee enthusiasts who appreciate modern design and want customizable features to perfect their brewing process.
Shop this brand: oxo.com
Bonavita
Bonavita has earned a loyal following by focusing on one thing: brewing exceptional coffee without any fuss. Their brewers are the workhorses of the coffee world, praised for reliability, durability, and a simple one-touch operation that delivers consistently great results. The brand appeals to those who prioritize performance and longevity over flashy features or overly complicated controls.
- What it is: A brand of high-performance coffee makers focused on simplicity, reliability, and excellent brew quality.
- Key features: One-touch brewing operation, powerful heating element for optimal temperature, and minimalist design.
- Price: Affordable to mid-range, with popular 8-cup models priced around $130 and some smaller brewers under $100.
- Style: Functional and utilitarian, with a simple, no-frills appearance that emphasizes practicality over design trends.
- Materials/Construction: Features durable stainless steel carafes, robust plastic elements, and a straightforward build designed for years of use.
- Pros: Unbeatable value for the quality of coffee brewed, incredibly simple to use, durable and long-lasting, compact footprint fits most kitchens.
- Cons: Lacks programmable features, utilitarian aesthetic may not appeal to everyone, fewer models to choose from.
Bonavita is ideal for coffee drinkers who want a durable, no-nonsense machine that makes a top-tier cup of coffee with the press of a single button.
Shop this brand: bonavita.com
Oxo Brew vs. Bonavita Comparison
Style & Aesthetics
This is one of the most significant differences between the two brands. Oxo Brew appliances are designed to be a centerpiece in a modern kitchen, with brushed stainless steel, clean lines, and thoughtful accents that create a premium feel. Every dial and button is intentionally placed for both function and form.
In contrast, Bonavita takes a purely functional approach. Their brewers are simple and understated, with a utilitarian look that prioritizes practicality. While well-built, they don't have the same visual appeal as Oxo's lineup, which could be a deciding factor for those with a strong design sensibility.
Features & Usability
If you're looking for features, Oxo Brew is the clear winner. Their coffee makers often include programmable start times, settings to adjust brew strength or volume, and precise temperature maintenance. This level of control appeals to coffee lovers who enjoy experimenting with their brew.
Bonavita excels at simplicity. Their one-touch operation removes all the guesswork. There are no screens or settings to fiddle with - just add coffee and water and press start. This is perfect for anyone who wants a fantastic pot of coffee without a learning curve.
Materials & Construction
Both brands produce durable and reliable machines. Oxo Brew uses high-quality BPA-free plastics and stainless steel, and their products generally have a solid, weighty feel. They are engineered for consistent performance and longevity.
Bonavita brewers are also built to last, with many users reporting years of dependable service. While the plastics may feel less premium than Oxo's, the core components, like the powerful heating element, are top-notch and designed for repeated, daily use.
Price & Value
Bonavita generally offers better upfront value. You can often get one of their high-performing flagship models for the price of an entry-level Oxo Brew coffee maker. For those on a budget whose top priority is a high-quality finished product, Bonavita is hard to beat.
Oxo Brew justifies its higher price with added features, a more refined finish, and a more sophisticated design. The value proposition here lies in the enhanced user experience, aesthetics, and programmability.
Who Each Brand Works Best For
The choice comes down to personal priorities. Oxo Brew is built for the home barista who wants a stylish, feature-rich machine that offers customization and looks great on the counter. It's for the person who enjoys the process of brewing and wants controls to dial in their perfect cup.
Bonavita is for the purist who values results above all. It’s perfect for the user who wants an SCA-certified brew with minimal effort and values long-term durability over aesthetics or advanced features. If your philosophy is "just give me a great cup of coffee," Bonavita is your brand.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Oxo Brew and Bonavita make excellent coffee equipment, but they are designed for different kinds of coffee lovers.
Choose Oxo Brew if:
- You appreciate a sleek, modern aesthetic in your kitchen appliances.
- You want more control over your brewing process with features like programmable timers and temperature control.
- You're willing to pay a premium for thoughtful design and innovative features.
- Usability and an intuitive interface are important to you.
Choose Bonavita if:
- Your primary concern is brewing excellent, consistent coffee without any fuss.
- You prefer a simple, one-touch machine that is incredibly easy to operate.
- You're shopping on a tighter budget but unwilling to sacrifice brew quality.
- You value function and long-term durability over stylish design.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Oxo Brew and Bonavita?
The main difference is their approach. Oxo Brew focuses on user experience, modern design, and advanced features for custom brewing. Bonavita prioritizes brew quality and simplicity, offering no-frills, durable machines that excel at making great coffee with one-touch operation.
Which brand is better for beginners?
Bonavita is often better for a true beginner because of its simplicity. Its one-touch operation eliminates any learning curve, ensuring a great pot of coffee from the very first use. However, Oxo Brew's intuitive designs also make it easy to learn, even with its extra features.
Is Oxo Brew worth the extra money?
For many, yes. If you value modern design, the ability to program your coffee maker to start before you wake up, and customizable brew settings, the higher price of an Oxo Brew machine is easily justified by the enhanced daily experience.
Do Bonavita coffee makers last a long time?
Yes, Bonavita coffee makers have a strong reputation for durability and longevity. Their simple design means there are fewer digital components that can fail, and their robust construction allows them to perform reliably for years.
Which brand has better temperature control?
Both brands excel at maintaining the optimal brew temperature (195-205°F) for proper coffee extraction, and many models from both are certified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA). While Oxo might offer more user control over the exact temperature, both consistently hit the right mark for brewing.
Are coffee makers from these brands easy to clean?
Yes, both brands design their coffee makers with ease of cleaning in mind. Carafes, brew baskets, and lids are typically easy to access and wash. Some components may even be top-rack dishwasher safe, though it's always best to check the manufacturer's instructions.
Can I find parts for my Oxo Brew or Bonavita coffee maker?
Yes, both manufacturers typically offer replacement parts like carafes and brew baskets on their websites or through customer service channels. This makes it easier to extend the life of your machine if a part is accidentally broken.
How do the aesthetics of Oxo Brew compare to Bonavita?
Oxo Brew has a distinctly modern and premium aesthetic with materials like brushed stainless steel and an emphasis on clean lines, making it a stylish addition to any kitchen. Bonavita is far more utilitarian and functional in its appearance, built for performance rather than to make a design statement.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
