The Nuova Simonelli Oscar II and the Breville Dual Boiler are top contenders for high-end home espresso, but they target different users through their design philosophy, price, and build quality. The Oscar II from Nuova Simonelli is a commercial-grade machine built for durability and continuous use, while the Breville Dual Boiler offers a more user-friendly, feature-rich experience specifically designed for the modern home kitchen.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which of these exceptional espresso machines is the right choice for your coffee bar.
Nuova Simonelli Oscar II
The Oscar II is an espresso machine that brings Italian commercial cafe DNA into the home. It's built like a tank, using many of the same high-quality internal components as the brand's larger professional machines. Its performance is focused on one thing: pulling consistent, excellent espresso shots, making it a favorite for purists and those who value durability over bells and whistles.
- What it is: A professional-grade, semi-automatic espresso machine with a heat exchanger boiler system.
- Key features: Commercial-grade 58mm group head, high-capacity 2-liter copper boiler, programmable timed dosing, and a powerful steam wand.
- Price: Around $2,000 - $2,200
- Style: Utilitarian and industrial with a robust stainless steel body and a no-frills interface.
- Materials/Construction: Built with commercial-duty components, including a stainless steel frame, brass elements, and a large copper boiler for superior thermal stability.
- Pros: Exceptional durability and longevity. Delivers cafe-quality espresso extraction and powerful steam performance. Simple, straightforward operation focused on performance. Maintains temperature stability even during frequent use.
- Cons: Lacks some convenient features like a built-in pressure gauge or PID. The industrial aesthetic might not fit all kitchen designs. Higher price point reflects its professional build.
This machine is ideal for the serious coffee enthusiast who prioritizes espresso quality and long-term durability and doesn't mind a slightly more hands-on approach.
Shop this product: nuovasimonelliusa.com/oscar-ii.html
Breville Dual Boiler
The Breville Dual Boiler is engineered to give home users maximum control and convenience without the steep learning curve of a commercial machine. Known for its precision temperature control, user-friendly interface, and rich feature set, it provides everything a budding home barista needs to experiment and produce top-tier espresso and milk foam with remarkable consistency.
- What it is: A user-focused home espresso machine featuring a dual boiler system for simultaneous brewing and steaming.
- Key features: Dual stainless steel boilers with PID temperature control, heated group head, programmable pre-infusion, built-in pressure gauge, and LCD screen for feedback.
- Price: Around $1,200 - $1,500
- Style: Sleek and modern polished stainless steel finish that blends seamlessly into contemporary kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: Sturdy stainless steel body houses high-quality internal parts, including two stainless steel boilers, designed for the demands of daily home use.
- Pros: Excellent value with professional features at a consumer price. Precise PID control allows for superb temperature stability and experimentation. Intuitive and easy to use for all skill levels. Sleek design is very kitchen-friendly.
- Cons: Not built to the same commercial durability standards as the Oscar II. Relies on more electronic components, which could present more long-term maintenance needs. May feel less robust for high-volume use.
The Dual Boiler is for the dedicated home barista who wants granular control, modern conveniences, and a stylish aesthetic without the cost of a true commercial machine.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/espresso/bes920.html
Nuova Simonelli Oscar II vs. Breville Dual Boiler Comparison
Materials & Construction
The fundamental difference lies in their build philosophy. The Nuova Simonelli Oscar II is constructed with commercial-grade durability as its primary goal. It uses heavy-duty brass elements and a large copper boiler, materials chosen for their thermal stability and resistance to an endless cycle of heating and cooling. This machine is designed to be used heavily, day in and day out, making it suitable for even a small café setting.
The Breville Dual Boiler features high-quality materials like stainless steel for its body and boilers, but it is engineered for the home environment. While durable enough for any home user, its construction isn't as overbuilt as the Oscar II. It prioritizes a balance between robustness, features, and cost, which is perfect for home use but not intended for a commercial workload.
Style & Aesthetics
Their appearances are night and day. The Oscar II is pure function-over-form, with an industrial, no-nonsense look that screams "professional equipment." Its focus is on the hardware within, not winning design awards. This appeals to users who appreciate the utilitarian aesthetic of a classic Italian espresso machine.
Meanwhile, the Breville Dual Boiler has a modern, polished appearance that feels right at home in a contemporary kitchen. With its clean lines, brushed stainless steel finish, and clear LCD display, it’s designed to be a centerpiece appliance that is both beautiful and functional.
Dimensions & Sizing
Both machines are fairly similar in footprint and can fit on most kitchen countertops, though neither are particularly small. The Oscar II measures approximately 13 x 11 x 16 inches, while the Breville Dual Boiler is slightly more compact at around 12.5 x 12 x 15 inches. The Breville's slightly smaller stature gives it a minor edge in very tight spaces, but the difference is minimal enough that layouts that can accommodate a major coffee station will have room for either one.
Price & Value
This is one of the most significant differentiators. The Breville Dual Boiler typically costs between $1,200 and $1,500, offering incredible value by packing dual boilers, PID temperature control, and a pressure gauge into an accessible price point. For the majority of home baristas, it represents the best combination of performance and features for the money.
The Nuova Simonelli Oscar II sits in a higher price bracket, typically $2,000 to $2,200. This added cost is a direct investment in its commercial-grade components and durability. While you get fewer user-facing features, your money is going toward longevity and the kind of internal hardware that's built to last for more than a decade.
Who Each One Works Best For
Choosing between these two comes down to your personal priorities. The Nuova Simonelli Oscar II is built for the purist and the small business owner. It's for someone who wants a machine that will endure years of heavy use without fail and values traditional, powerful performance over modern conveniences. It's an investment in raw espresso-making capability.
The Breville Dual Boiler is designed for the enthusiastic home barista who loves to experiment and wants ultimate control over every variable. It's for the person who values precision from a PID, wants immediate feedback from a pressure gauge, and appreciates a polished design that complements their home decor. It offers pro-level performance in a friendly, approachable package.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both of these are a fantastic choice, but they excel in different areas and for different types of coffee lovers.
Choose the Nuova Simonelli Oscar II if:
- Durability and long-term reliability are your top priorities.
- You value cafe-quality build standards over modern digital features.
- You plan to use the machine frequently for years, or even in a small commercial setting.
- You prefer a simple, industrial aesthetic and a straightforward user experience.
Choose the Breville Dual Boiler if:
- You want maximum user control with features like PID and programmable pre-infusion.
- Value for money is a major consideration, it offers premium features for hundreds less.
- A sleek, modern design that fits well in a home kitchen is important to you.
- You want a machine that is intuitive and easier to get started with for all skill levels.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Oscar II and the Dual Boiler?
The main difference is their core design: the Oscar II is a commercial-grade machine focused on extreme durability and proven heat-exchanger performance. The Breville Dual Boiler is a feature-rich "prosumer" machine with two boilers and precise digital temperature control, designed specifically for the discerning home user.
Which espresso machine is better for beginners?
The Breville Dual Boiler is generally better for beginners. Its built-in pressure gauge, LCD feedback, and stable PID-controlled temperature make it far easier to learn on and diagnose any issues with your espresso shots.
Is the Nuova Simonelli Oscar II worth the extra money?
It can be, but it depends on your goals. If you are looking for a machine that could easily last 15-20 years with proper maintenance and can handle back-to-back drinks without a problem, the investment in its commercial components is absolutely worth it.
Can the Oscar II be used in a small coffee shop?
Yes. The Oscar II has the NSF commercial certification in some versions and is often used as a primary machine in very small cafes or as a secondary/decaf machine in larger shops due to its durability and performance.
Which machine has better steam power?
Both have excellent steam power. The Oscar II is known for its relentlessly powerful steam from its large 2-liter boiler, making it very fast for steaming large quantities of milk. The Breville’s dedicated steam boiler also delivers impressive, dry steam that is more than sufficient for any latte art.
How long will these machines last?
With proper care and maintenance, the Oscar II is built to last over a decade or even longer, thanks to its commercial-grade parts. The Breville Dual Boiler should last for many years in a home environment (5-10 years is common), though its greater reliance on electronics might lead to more complex repairs down the line.
Which machine looks better on a kitchen counter?
This is entirely subjective. If you prefer a modern, sleek appliance look, the Breville Dual Boiler is the clear winner. If you like an industrial, professional aesthetic that makes your kitchen look like an authentic cafe, the Nuova Simonelli Oscar II is the better choice.
Which machine is easier to clean and maintain?
Both require regular maintenance like backflushing, descaling, and cleaning the group head. The Breville has automated cleaning cycles that can simplify the process, while the Oscar II requires a more manual but straightforward approach common to commercial machines.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
