The Ninja Creami is a standalone countertop machine that turns frozen bases into ice cream and other treats, while the KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker is an attachment that depends on a stand mixer to churn frozen desserts. The Creami is a complete, all-in-one system, whereas the KitchenAid model is a component that adds functionality to an existing appliance from KitchenAid.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which frozen dessert maker from Ninja or KitchenAid is the right choice for your kitchen countertop.
Ninja Creami Ice Cream & Frozen Treat Maker
The Ninja Creami is an innovative and popular standalone appliance designed to make frozen desserts quick and easy. Unlike traditional makers that churn a liquid base, the Creami works by shaving and blending a pre-frozen solid base inside its pint containers, creating everything from dense ice cream and Italian gelato to smooth sorbets and milkshakes with the press of a button.
- What it is: A self-contained electric machine that transforms frozen-solid bases into creamy desserts.
- Key features: One-touch programs for various desserts (Ice Cream, Sorbet, Gelato, Milkshake, Mix-in), "Creamify" technology with a downward-moving paddle, includes lid-topped pint containers for freezing and storage.
- Price: Ranges from $179 to $229, depending on the model and included accessories.
- Style: Modern and compact, with a sleek plastic body and an intuitive digital control panel. It fits easily on most countertops.
- Materials/Construction: The housing is made of durable plastic, and the paddle assembly features stainless steel for longevity and performance. Containers are BPA-free plastic.
- Pros: A complete all-in-one unit, no other appliances needed. Extremely easy to use with its preset functions. Pint containers are easy to store in the freezer. Can process non-traditional bases (like canned fruit) for quick sorbets.
- Cons: Requires you to freeze the base for a full 24 hours before processing. Can be quite loud during operation. Smaller batch size (one pint at a time).
This dessert maker is ideal for anyone who wants a dedicated, versatile machine for making a wide array of frozen treats without needing to own a stand mixer.
Shop this product: ninjakitchen.com/products/ninja-creami-ice-cream-sorbet-milkshake-maker
KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker is a classic attachment that consists of a two-part accessory converting a KitchenAid stand mixer into a traditional ice cream machine. It offers a large, double-walled freeze bowl and a dasher (paddle) that uses the mixer's powerful motor to churn a liquid base into classic, creamy ice cream or sorbet.
- What it is: A purpose-built attachment for KitchenAid stand mixers that allows for at-home ice cream churning.
- Key features: Large 2-quart capacity, a drive assembly that fits most modern tilt-head and bowl-lift stand mixers, and a dasher to fold air into the base. Provides traditional, slow-churn results.
- Price: Approximately $150 to $200, but you must also own a stand mixer ($300-$600+).
- Style: Has the classic, recognizable KitchenAid aesthetic with polished, professional lines that flawlessly match the brand's iconic stand mixers.
- Materials/Construction: The freeze bowl and dasher are made of heavy-duty, durable plastic, and the quality lives up to KitchenAid's reputation for long-lasting appliances.
- Pros: Cost-effective if you already own a mixer. Makes larger 2-quart batches. The slow churning process creates a classic, airy ice cream texture. Generally quieter than the Ninja Creami.
- Cons: Requires you to own a compatible KitchenAid stand mixer, making the total startup cost high. The large 2-quart bowl takes up significant freezer space and must be frozen solid (15-24 hours). Less versatility in texture and style (primarily a churner).
This attachment works best for enthusiastic home cooks who already rely on their KitchenAid stand mixer and want to expand its functionality to make large batches of traditionally-churned ice cream.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com/countertop-appliances/stand-mixers/attachments
Ninja Creami vs. KitchenAid Attachment Comparison
Process & Performance
The core difference between these two appliances is how they make frozen treats. The Ninja Creami uses a process where it spins and shaves a solid frozen block of ingredients into a creamy texture. You freeze your base solid for 24 hours in the provided pint container, then the machine does the rest in about 2-3 minutes. This method produces a very dense, smooth final product similar to gelato.
In contrast, the KitchenAid attachment is a traditional churner. You freeze the insulated bowl for 15-24 hours, then attach it to your mixer. As you pour in the liquid base, the mixer's motor rotates the dasher, which scrapes the freezing sides of the bowl and churns air into the mixture. This traditional process takes about 20-30 minutes and results in a lighter, airier ice cream.
Capacity & Dimensions
The KitchenAid attachment has a clear advantage in batch size, with a 2-quart capacity that a family can enjoy. However, its large freeze bowl (~8 inches tall and 11 inches wide) requires a significant amount of dedicated freezer space to be effective. The machine itself is just the attachment, so its counter space is determined by your stand mixer's footprint.
The Ninja Creami works with individual pint containers, which limits you to a smaller batch at a time. This is perfect for single servings or trying different flavors, and the pint containers are much easier to fit into a crowded freezer. The Creami machine itself is fairly compact (about 16 inches tall and 6.5 inches wide), fitting neatly on most countertops.
Price & Value
If you don't own a stand mixer, the Ninja Creami offers much better value. For a single purchase of around $200, you get a complete, ready-to-use frozen dessert maker. There are no hidden costs or required companions.
If you are already a proud KitchenAid stand mixer owner, the attachment provides tremendous value. For roughly $150, you are adding a completely new function leveraging a machine you already have and trust. Purchasing a mixer plus the attachment would be a far more expensive initial investment, approaching $500 or more.
Who Each One Works Best For
Each dessert maker excels for very different kinds of users. The Ninja Creami is a fantastic choice for those who value convenience, versatility, and speed on processing day. Its ability to create different textures with its pre-set programs makes it ideal for creatives who want to make more than just ice cream. It is the best option for people living in apartments or homes with smaller freezers who do not already have a stand mixer.
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment best serves existing KitchenAid enthusiasts. If you love your mixer and want to unlock another one of its capabilities, this is a no-brainer. It is ideal for bakers and home chefs who appreciate classic, traditionally-made ice cream and need to make larger batches for family or gatherings. It’s perfect for someone with a spacious freezer who enjoys the slow, methodical process of churning.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines are excellent at making frozen desserts, but they serve different needs, kitchen spaces, and budgets.
Choose the Ninja Creami if:
- You want an all-in-one appliance and don't own a KitchenAid mixer.
- You are short on freezer space and prefer storing small pints over a bulky bowl.
- You value speed and one-touch convenience during processing.
- You want to experiment with creating gelato, acai bowls, and milkshakes - not just ice cream.
Choose the KitchenAid Attachment if:
- You already own and use a compatible KitchenAid stand mixer.
- You prefer the light, airy texture of traditionally churned ice cream.
- Making large, family-sized batches (up to 2 quarts) is your priority.
- You have plenty of dedicated space in your freezer for a large pre-freeze bowl.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Ninja Creami and KitchenAid Attachment?
The primary difference is their function and design. The Ninja Creami is a complete, standalone appliance that shaves a solid frozen block into a creamy dessert. The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker is an attachment requiring a stand mixer to work and churns a liquid base in a frozen bowl.
Do I need a KitchenAid mixer to use the attachment?
Yes, absolutely. The attachment has no motor or power source of its own, it relies entirely on the power and rotational force of a compatible KitchenAid stand mixer to churn the ice cream.
Which one is faster to make ice cream with?
Both require at least 15-24 hours for their primary component (the base pints or the freeze bowl) to freeze solid. Once frozen, the Ninja Creami is much faster, processing a pint in under 3 minutes, while the KitchenAid attachment takes 20-30 minutes of continuous churning.
Which machine makes better tasting ice cream?
This is subjective and depends on your texture preference. The Ninja Creami produces a very smooth, dense, and rich texture almost like gelato, while the KitchenAid creates the traditional, lighter, and more airy texture associated with classic churned ice cream.
How much freezer space do I need?
For the Ninja Creami, you need enough space to stand a few pint-sized containers upright. For the KitchenAid attachment, you'll need a large, clear, flat space approximately 11" wide and 8" tall to store its bulky freezer bowl for at least 15 hours before use.
Which is easier to clean?
Both are quite easy to clean, as their primary components - pints and lids for the Creami, and the bowl and dasher for the KitchenAid - are top-rack dishwasher safe. The process is comparable for both.
Can the Ninja Creami do more than just ice cream?
Yes, its presets allow for making Gelato, Sorbet, Lite Ice Cream, Milkshakes, and Smoothie Bowls. It also has a Mix-in function to evenly distribute extras like chocolate chips or nuts after the initial processing.
Is the KitchenAid attachment a better long-term investment?
If you already own the mixer, it can be a fantastic long-term investment. KitchenAid products are known for their durability and longevity, and this attachment upholds that standard. For someone buying from scratch, the Ninja Creami might seem better, but it depends on your overall kitchen appliance ecosystem.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
