Ninja offers innovative, specialty kitchen gadgets like the Creami, a versatile machine that creates a wide array of frozen treats from ice cream to smoothie bowls using a unique blending process. In contrast, KitchenAid is an iconic brand known for durable, premium appliances with a timeless design, offering classic ice cream makers that function as both standalone units and popular stand mixer attachments.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right frozen dessert maker for your kitchen.
Ninja Creami: The Versatile & Modern Dessert Maker
Ninja is known for producing powerful and versatile kitchen appliances, and the Ninja Creami is one of its most popular innovations. Rather than a traditional churner, the Creami freezes a solid block of your ingredient base in a pint and then uses a high-speed blade to shave and blend it into a smooth, creamy texture. This unique process opens the door to a wide variety of frozen treats beyond classic ice cream, making it a favorite for creative home cooks looking for a multifunctional and easy-to-use device.
- Product mix: A specialized frozen dessert maker capable of creating ice cream, sorbet, gelato, smoothie bowls, and milkshakes. All models also include a "mix-in" function for adding things like candy, nuts, or chocolate chips.
- Style/vibe: Sleek and modern with a functional, minimalist aesthetic. Its compact and upright design fits well in contemporary kitchens without demanding too much counter space.
- Price point: Generally runs between $200-$250, offering a budget-friendly option for a powerful and versatile machine. It frequently goes on sale at major retailers.
- Quality: Constructed with durable plastics and metal accents designed for frequent home use. While it feels sturdy and reliable, it is considered a mid-range appliance in terms of overall longevity.
- Dimensions/Scale: Compact and relatively small, measuring approximately 8 x 8 x 12 inches, making it easy to store in a cabinet or on a countertop in a smaller kitchen.
- Key features: The revolutionary "Creamify" technology which shaves frozen base ingredients is its biggest selling point, allowing users to create low-sugar or high-protein treats that are difficult to make in traditional ice cream machines. It features multiple one-touch programs for different dessert types.
The Ninja Creami provides outstanding versatility and modern convenience in a compact, budget-friendly package, making it an excellent gadget for creative cooks and health-conscious households.
Shop Ninja: ninjakitchen.com
KitchenAid: The Iconic & Durable Choice
KitchenAid has built its legacy on timeless design and professional-grade performance, best known for its iconic stand mixer. The brand extends this reputation to its ice cream makers, which come in two forms: a wildly popular attachment for the stand mixer and larger standalone models. KitchenAid ice cream makers use a traditional churn method, where a frozen freezable bowl chills the base while a dasher mixes it to create smooth, classic ice cream and sorbet. This focus on durability and quality makes it a staple for those who see kitchen tools as a long-term investment.
- Product mix: Its most common product is the ice cream maker attachment, which connects to a stand mixer. The brand also produces larger standalone compressor models that don't require pre-freezing a bowl.
- Style/vibe: Classic, retro-inspired, and timeless. Known for its signature colors, a KitchenAid appliance is often purchased as a statement piece to display on the countertop.
- Price point: The attachment is affordable at around $100, but it requires the KSM - the stand mixer - (which costs more than $300 alone). Standalone models are more of a premium purchase, typically retailing for $250-$350 or more.
- Quality: Famous for superior build quality using die-cast metal components, stainless steel, and thick plastics. KitchenAid appliances are built to last, with many users reporting their machines work perfectly for over a decade.
- Dimensions/Scale: The attachment is compact, but the stand mixer itself has a significant footprint. The standalone machines are larger and heavier than the Ninja Creami, around 10 x 10 x 15 inches, positioning them as a more substantial appliance.
- Warranty & Support: The brand is well-regarded for its customer service and longer warranty periods, supporting its reputation for producing investment-quality appliances.
KitchenAid represents a long-term investment in quality craftsmanship and classic American design, making it the top choice for traditionalists and serious home cooks.
Shop KitchenAid: kitchenaid.com
Ninja Creami vs. KitchenAid Comparison
Price Comparison
In terms of upfront cost for a standalone machine, the Ninja Creami is typically the more affordable option, costing between $200 and $250. It’s an all-in-one system ready to go out of the box. KitchenAid has a slightly trickier price structure. The very popular freezable bowl attachment is only around $100 but is useless without a stand mixer, which is a separate investment of $300+.
KitchenAid's standalone compressor models, which don't require a separate mixer, command a premium price, often starting at $250 and going up significantly from there. So, for a new user with no existing appliances, Ninja offers better value. For existing KitchenAid stand mixer owners, the attachment is a highly economical way to start making ice cream.
Style & Aesthetic
The design philosophies of the two brands are worlds apart. Ninja opts for a modern, tech-forward aesthetic with neutral colors, digital displays, and sleek plastic bodies. It's designed to be functional and fit into a contemporary kitchen without much fuss.
On the other hand, KitchenAid is all about timeless, retro style. Famous for its vibrant color palette, from "Empire Red" to "Aqua Sky," its products are designed to be beautiful countertop centerpieces. The metal construction adds to a premium, classic feel that many home designers and cooks actively seek out for its visual appeal alone.
Quality & Construction
KitchenAid has built its reputation on tank-like durability. With die-cast metal parts and heavy-duty motors, their appliances are engineered for longevity and are often considered a "buy it for life" purchase. Their ice cream makers, especially the standalone models, feel substantial and robust.
The Ninja Creami is well-built for a modern appliance, using high-quality, durable plastics and a powerful motor designed to handle its unique shaving process. However, it's not made with the same premium materials as a KitchenAid and is more typical of today's countertop electronics, with a functional lifespan measured in years, not decades.
Functionality & Versatility
This is where the Ninja Creami truly shines and justifies its popularity. Its unique technology allows it to make a huge range of treats, including smoothie bowls, light ice cream with healthier bases (like protein shakes or frozen fruit), gelato, and milkshakes, all with specialized, one-touch settings. The ability to finely process a frozen block makes it incredibly forgiving with non-traditional recipes.
KitchenAid's ice cream makers are more traditional churners. They excel at making fantastic classic ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sorbet with a smooth, rich mouthfeel. However, they are less versatile than the Creami and are primarily designed for recipes that have a certain level of fat and sugar designed for traditional churning.
Shopping Experience
Ninja products are ubiquitous and easy to find. You can buy them directly from their website, Amazon, or big-box retailers like Walmart and Target. The purchasing process is straightforward, with a focus on fast shipping and frequent promotions.
KitchenAid is sold through its own website, department stores, and specialty kitchen retailers. The shopping experience is more curated, often involving selecting specific colors or accessory bundles. KitchenAid's customer support and warranty service are highly regarded, reinforcing the brand's premium positioning.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to what you want to make, your budget, and your aesthetic preferences. Both deliver excellent results but are designed for different users.
Choose Ninja Creami if:
- You want maximum versatility to make everything from smoothie bowls to gelato.
- You're interested in making healthier, low-sugar, or high-protein frozen desserts.
- You have limited kitchen space and prefer a more compact, modern gadget.
- You're looking for an affordable, all-in-one solution without needing other appliances.
Choose KitchenAid if:
- You primarily want to make classic, churn-style ice cream, custard, and sorbet.
- You already own a KitchenAid stand mixer and want an inexpensive attachment.
- Durability and premium metal construction are your top priorities.
- You love its iconic, retro design and want an appliance that doubles as kitchen decor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ninja Creami or KitchenAid cheaper?
The Ninja Creami is generally cheaper as an upfront, standalone machine, costing around $200-$250. While the KitchenAid ice cream maker attachment is very affordable at about $100, it requires you to already own one of their stand mixers, which can cost $300 or more itself. KitchenAid's dedicated compressor ice cream makers are more expensive than the Creami.
Which has better quality ice cream?
Neither is definitively "better," as they produce different textures. KitchenAid's traditional churning process creates classic, dense, and creamy ice cream. The Ninja Creami's shaving process results in a lighter, smoother texture that can be closer to gelato or a soft serve, and is exceptionally good at making non-traditional recipes creamy.
Can you make healthy ice cream with both?
While you can use alternative sweeteners in a KitchenAid, the Ninja Creami excels at making healthy treats. Its unique technology can process ingredients with low amounts of fat and sugar - like protein shakes or simple frozen fruit - into a surprisingly creamy dessert, something traditional churners struggle with.
Which is more durable?
KitchenAid is the clear winner on this point. Its reputation is built on heavy-duty, die-cast metal construction designed to last for a decade or more. The Ninja Creami is well-made with durable plastics but is not considered the same level of long-term investment.
Do I need an appliance to make ice cream with KitchenAid?
Yes, to use KitchenAid's most popular ice cream maker, you need one of their stand mixers. The ice cream maker is an attachment consisting of a freezer bowl and a dasher paddle that connects to the mixer's motor. However, they do offer standalone models that don't need any other equipment.
How does the Ninja Creami process work?
Instead of churning a liquid base, you first freeze your ingredients solid in special Creami pints for 24 hours. Then, you place the pint in the machine, and a powerful paddle with sharp blades rapidly spins and shaves down the frozen block, transforming it into a smooth, scoopable dessert in minutes.
Is one easier to clean than the other?
Both are relatively easy to clean. The Ninja Creami's pints and blade are dishwasher safe. The KitchenAid attachment bowl is not typically dishwasher safe and must be washed by hand, but it is a simple process. The main prep difference is that the Ninja needs a 24-hour full freeze of the ingredients, while the KitchenAid bowl needs to be pre-frozen for at least 15 hours before churning.
Which gadget is more versatile?
The Ninja Creami is far more versatile. Its programmed settings allow it to make smoothie bowls, light ice cream, milkshakes, sorbet, and gelato, and it also features a mix-in function. A KitchenAid is primarily for making traditional ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sorbet.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
