The Nespresso Creatista Plus and a classic Breville espresso machine like the Barista Pro both make high-quality espresso drinks, but they use fundamentally different brewing methods. The Nespresso Creatista Plus is an automated, capsule-based machine designed for supreme convenience and speed, offering barista-quality steamed milk with the press of a button. Breville's own line of machines are traditional semi-automatics that give you hands-on control over the entire process, from grinding fresh beans to manually tamping and extracting your shot.
Here’s a complete look at how they compare to help you decide which machine is the right fit for your kitchen counter.
Nespresso Creatista Plus
The Creatista Plus represents the peak of Nespresso's single-serve system, combining the ease of capsules with an advanced, fully automatic steam wand an aspiring latte artist would appreciate. It's essentially a convenience-first machine that doesn’t compromise on the quality of its milk-based drinks. Manufactured by Breville for Nespresso, it borrows high-end components to deliver a simple yet sophisticated home espresso experience.
- What it is: A premium capsule-based espresso machine with an automatic steam wand for milk frothing.
- Key features: Fully automatic steam wand with adjustable milk temperature (11 settings) and texture (8 levels), 3-second heat-up time, high-resolution display, 3 programmable coffee volumes (Ristretto, Espresso, Lungo).
- Price: Around $500
- Dimensions: 16.1" deep x 6.7" wide x 12.2" high. Features a slim, counter-friendly footprint.
- Materials/Construction: Premium stainless steel body and finishes. Features a stainless steel milk frothing wand.
- Pros: Exceptionally easy to use with near-zero learning curve. Delivers consistent espresso shots every time. Automatic steam wand creates excellent microfoam for lattes and cappuccinos. Blisteringly fast from power-on to finished drink. A wide variety of Nespresso capsules available.
- Cons: Locked into using Nespresso's proprietary capsules, which is more expensive than buying whole beans. No control over grind size, dose, or tamp. Less environmentally friendly due to single-use pods (though they are recyclable).
This machine is ideal for anyone who prioritizes speed and consistency, wants excellent milk-based drinks without learning manual steaming techniques, and values a sleek, modern aesthetic.
Shop this product: nespresso.com/us/en/order/machines/original/creatista-plus-brushed-stainless-steel
Breville Barista Pro
The Breville Barista Pro is an all-in-one semi-automatic espresso machine that gives the home user complete control over the brewing process. Featuring a built-in grinder and a manual steam wand, it's designed for coffee enthusiasts who want to engage with the craft of making espresso. It bridges the gap between consumer appliances and professional cafe equipment.
- What it is: An all-in-one semi-automatic espresso machine with a built-in conical burr grinder and manual steam wand.
- Key features: ThermoJet heating system with 3-second heat-up time, integrated conical burr grinder with 30 grind settings, 54mm porta-filter, digital display for shot timing, powerful manual steam wand for creating microfoam.
- Price: Around $850
- Dimensions: 13" deep x 12" wide x 13" high. A larger, more substantial machine.
- Materials/Construction: Heavy-duty brushed stainless steel body. Commercial-style portafilter and brew group for thermal stability.
- Pros: Complete control over every variable (grind, dose, tamp, shot time). Works with any whole coffee bean, offering endless flavor possibilities and lower long-term cost. Manual steam wand allows for superior control and latte art capability. Built-in grinder provides incredible value.
- Cons: A significant learning curve is required to pull great shots and steam milk correctly. Takes more time and effort to prepare a drink. Can be messy (stray coffee grounds). More expensive upfront cost.
The Barista Pro is for the hands-on coffee lover who sees making espresso as a satisfying hobby and wants the tools to perfect their technique and explore different coffee beans.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/espresso/bes878.html
Nespresso Creatista Plus vs. Breville Barista Pro Comparison
Brewing Process & Control
This is the single biggest difference between the two machines. Using the Creatista Plus is a three-step process: insert a pod, select your drink, and place the milk jug under the auto-frothing wand. The machine handles everything, ensuring a consistent result every time with zero user skill required.
The Barista Pro is a fully manual experience. You measure and grind fresh beans, dose them into the portafilter basket, tamp the grounds evenly, lock it into the machine, and press a button to start and stop the extraction. You then manually steam the milk using the powerful steam wand. This process gives you total control but requires practice, patience, and a willingness to learn.
Materials & Construction
While the Nespresso Creatista Plus is manufactured by Breville and features a premium stainless steel housing, its internal components are designed for cartridge-based brewing. It feels solid and well-made for a consumer appliance.
The Breville Barista Pro is built with a more professional approach. The housing is brushed stainless steel, but key components like the portafilter are heavier and designed for better heat retention and durability demanded by manual espresso making. The entire machine feels more robust and industrial.
Price & Value
The Nespresso Creatista Plus costs around $500, making it a more accessible entry into premium at-home coffee. However, the long-term cost is higher due to the price of Nespresso pods, which typically range from $0.80 to $1.20 each. This convenience comes at a recurring cost.
The Barista Pro is more expensive upfront at around $850, but it offers better long-term value. Buying whole coffee beans is significantly cheaper than buying pods. Over a few years, the savings on coffee can easily make up for the initial price difference, especially for those who drink coffee daily.
Style & Aesthetics
The Nespresso Creatista Plus has a sleek, slim, and highly polished aesthetic that fits perfectly into modern kitchen designs. Its compact footprint and seamless look are meant to complement other high-end appliances without taking up too much counter space.
The Barista Pro has a purposeful, professional aesthetic. Its larger size, visible hopper filled with coffee beans, and stainless steel construction give it the look of a piece of cafe equipment that has been scaled down for home use. It makes more of a statement and appeals to those who want their kitchen to feel like a coffee bar.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines are excellent at what they do, but they are built for entirely different types of coffee drinkers.
Choose the Nespresso Creatista Plus if:
- You want great-tasting, cafe-quality lattes and cappuccinos in under a minute.
- Convenience, speed, and consistency are your top priorities.
- You have no interest in the manual process of grinding, tamping, and extracting espresso.
- You prefer a sleek, compact machine with a minimal, modern look.
Choose the Breville Barista Pro if:
- You view making coffee as an enjoyable hobby and want full control.
- You want the freedom to use any coffee bean from any roaster.
- You're excited by the idea of learning how to dial in the perfect shot and create latte art.
- Long-term cost savings on coffee beans is more important than a lower upfront price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between the coffee from a Nespresso and a Breville machine?
Nespresso uses pre-ground, portioned coffee in sealed pods, producing a very consistent, smooth crema and flavor profile. A Breville Barista machine uses freshly ground beans, which generally produces a more complex, aromatic, and flavorful shot of espresso with thicker crema, assuming your technique is correct.
Which machine is better for beginners?
The Nespresso Creatista Plus is far better for absolute beginners. There is virtually no learning curve, you can make a great latte on your first try. The Barista Pro requires study and practice to master.
Can I use my own coffee grounds in a Nespresso machine?
No, Nespresso machines are closed systems designed to work exclusively with their own or compatible third-party coffee capsules. You cannot use your own fresh coffee grounds.
Is the automatic milk frother on the Creatista Plus really that good?
Yes, it's one of the best automatic frothers on the market. It can create silky microfoam with adjustable texture and temperature, making it capable of producing milk suitable for latte art - which is very rare for an automated system.
Over time, which system is more expensive?
Nespresso is more expensive over time. While the machine costs less, Nespresso pods can cost an average of $0.90 per drink. A bag of high-quality coffee beans might cost $18, but it can make around 25-30 double shots, bringing the per-drink cost down to about $0.60-$0.70.
How much cleaning and maintenance does each machine require?
The Nespresso machine is lower maintenance. It requires regular descaling, emptying the used capsule container, and wiping down the steam wand. The Barista Pro requires more daily care, including purging the grinder, wiping down the steam wand, cleaning the portafilter after each use, and periodic backflushing of the brew group.
Which machine makes better coffee?
“Better” is subjective. Nespresso makes incredibly consistent and convenient coffee. A properly dialed-in Breville machine using fresh, high-quality beans will produce a more authentic and flavorful cafe-style espresso that most coffee experts would consider superior.
Why is the Creatista Plus made by Breville but sold by Nespresso?
It's a common collaboration in the appliance industry. Nespresso provides the core coffee pod technology and system, while Breville brings its expertise in building high-quality espresso machine components like fast-heating elements and advanced steam wands.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
