The main difference between My Magic Carpet and Ruggable is their construction and price point. My Magic Carpet offers a single-piece, lightweight washable rug that is more budget-friendly and features bold, trendy designs. Ruggable uses an innovative two-piece system with a removable, washable top cover and a separate non-slip, waterproof rug pad, offering premium durability and a much wider selection of styles at a higher price.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which washable rug brand is the right choice for your home.
My Magic Carpet
My Magic Carpet is a direct-to-consumer brand focused on providing stylish, practical, and highly affordable washable area rugs. Their rugs are designed as a single, lightweight piece, making them straightforward to use and clean. The brand is known for its vibrant, contemporary patterns that appeal to modern and eclectic decor styles, making them a popular choice for busy households with kids and pets.
- What it is: A single-piece, machine-washable area rug designed for convenience and style.
- Key features: Stain-resistant synthetic fibers, non-slip backing, lightweight construction, one-piece design.
- Price: Ranges from approximately $100 to $300, depending on size.
- Style: Bold, colorful, and contemporary. Features many bohemian, geometric, and playful patterns.
- Materials/Construction: Stain-resistant synthetic fibers with an integrated non-slip backing. Rugs are thin and designed to fit easily into standard washing machines.
- Pros: Significantly more affordable than Ruggable. Simple one-piece design means no reassembly is required after washing. Lightweight and easy to move around. Trendy, vibrant designs add a pop of color.
- Cons: Lacks the waterproof barrier Ruggable's system provides. The integrated pad is less cushioned and robust. Larger sizes can be difficult to fit in smaller home washing machines. The design selection is smaller and less diverse.
This brand is ideal for budget-conscious decorators who prioritize trendy designs and the simplicity of a one-piece washable rug, particularly for kids' rooms or apartments.
Shop this brand: mymagiccarpet.com
Ruggable
Ruggable is a leader in the washable rug market, known for pioneering the two-piece rug system. This design includes a lightweight, decorative Rug Cover that can be completely detached from a cushioned, non-slip Rug Pad. The separated top layer is designed to fit easily in a standard washing machine, while the waterproof pad protects your floors from spills and accidents, making it a very popular choice for pet owners and families.
- What it is: A patented two-piece washable rug system with a removable top cover and a separate non-slip rug pad.
- Key features: Interchangeable Rug Covers, waterproof pad to protect floors, non-slip backing, vast design library including brand collaborations (like Disney and Star Wars).
- Price: Starts around $150 and can exceed $600 for larger sizes.
- Style: Extremely broad range, covering everything from traditional Persian motifs to modern geometrics, minimalist designs, and contemporary art.
- Materials/Construction: Covers are typically made from stain and water-resistant polyester. The rug pad is made from recycled materials.
- Pros: The waterproof pad offers superior protection for your floors. The two-piece system makes washing very easy, as only the top layer goes in the machine. A vast selection of designs caters to almost any style. Durable construction holds up well in high-traffic areas.
- Cons: A significantly higher price point. Realigning the Rug Cover perfectly onto the Rug Pad can be tedious. The top covers are relatively thin to ensure they are machine-washable.
Ruggable is an excellent investment for homeowners who need a highly durable, foolproof solution for high-traffic areas and value long-term floor protection and extensive design choices.
Shop this brand: ruggable.com
My Magic Carpet vs. Ruggable Comparison
Materials & Durability
Both brands produce durable rugs, but their construction directly impacts longevity and resilience. Ruggable’s patented two-piece system gives it an edge in durability, largely due to its waterproof Rug Pad made from recycled materials. This pad not only keeps the rug in place but provides an essential barrier against spills, preventing damage to the floor underneath. The polyester top layer is designed to withstand frequent washing without fading or fraying.
My Magic Carpet's rugs are made from stain-resistant synthetic fibers in a single, integrated piece. While durable enough for everyday use in busy households, the construction is less robust. It lacks a waterproof layer, so large spills can eventually seep through to the floor. For high-traffic or spill-prone areas like kitchens and entryways, Ruggable’s system offers more security and peace of mind.
Style & Design Variety
Style is a major differentiator here. My Magic Carpet leans heavily into trendy, vibrant, and playful aesthetics. Its collection includes many bold geometric prints, colorful bohemian patterns, and whimsical designs perfect for animating a kids' room or adding a statement piece to a modern apartment. The selection is fun and fresh but more limited than its competitor's.
Ruggable offers a vastly larger and more diverse library of designs. Their catalog covers a wide spectrum of tastes, from timeless shag rugs and traditional Persian motifs to minimalist patterns and collaborations with well-known brands and artists. This breadth makes it easier to find a rug that fits a classic, transitional, or specific modern interior style, not just trendy ones.
Ease of Use & Cleaning
Both brands were created to solve the problem of cleaning area rugs, but they approach it differently. My Magic Carpet's one-piece design is simple: pick it up and put it in the washing machine. There's no matching or reassembly. However, larger rugs can be bulky and may not fit in all washers.
Ruggable's two-piece system requires separating the dirty top cover from the pad. Because the cover is so thin, even large sizes can fit into a standard home washer with ease. The main drawback is reattaching the cover to the pad, which can take a few attempts to get perfectly smooth and aligned.
Price & Value
There is a clear price difference between the two. My Magic Carpet is the budget-friendly option, with most of its rugs priced between $100 and $300. This makes it an accessible choice for renters, college students, or anyone who wants a washable rug without a significant investment.
Ruggable's products are more of an investment, starting around $150 for small sizes and reaching over $600 for large area rugs. The higher price is justified by the two-piece system, the waterproof pad, floor protection, superior durability, and much wider design selection. While more expensive upfront, Ruggable offers great long-term value, especially for homes with pets or in high-traffic zones.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent washable rug solutions, but they cater to different priorities, styles, and budgets.
Choose My Magic Carpet if:
- You are decorating on a tight budget and need an affordable option.
- You love bold, vibrant, and contemporary patterns.
- You prefer the simplicity of a one-piece rug system.
- The rug is for a lower-traffic area like a bedroom or a space where major spills are less of a concern.
Choose Ruggable if:
- Ultimate floor protection with a waterproof barrier is your top priority.
- You have pets or small children and anticipate frequent spills or accidents.
- You need a wider selection of classic, traditional, or licensed designs to match specific decor.
- You're willing to invest more for long-term durability in a high-traffic area like a living room or entryway.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between My Magic Carpet and Ruggable?
The core difference is the construction. My Magic Carpet is a single-piece washable rug with a built-in liner. Ruggable has a patented two-piece system: a washable top Rug Cover and a separate, waterproof non-slip Rug Pad.
Which washable rug is thicker or feels more comfortable?
While both rug tops are relatively low-pile to ensure they can be machine-washed, Ruggable offers cushioned pad options that can make the overall rug feel thicker and more comfortable underfoot. My Magic Carpet's integrated design is thinner by default.
Which brand is better for pet owners?
Ruggable is generally considered the better choice for pet owners. The waterproof Rug Pad prevents pet accidents from soaking through to the floor, which is a major advantage for protecting hardwood or other types of flooring. Both brands' tops are stain-resistant and machine-washable.
Which brand is easier to clean?
This is subjective. My Magic Carpet is conceptually easier because it's a single item to wash. Ruggable requires separating and reattaching its two-piece system, but its lightweight covers often fit more easily into washing machines than a bulky all-in-one rug, especially in larger sizes.
Does My Magic Carpet slide around?
My Magic Carpet rugs have a non-slip backing designed to keep them in place. However, on some surfaces, any lightweight rug may experience some movement. For high-traffic areas, some users may find a separate rug gripper helpful for extra security.
Do the colors on the websites look accurate in person?
Both brands do a great job of showcasing their products online, but colors may vary slightly depending on your screen's calibration and the lighting in your home. It’s always a good idea to read customer reviews and look at user-submitted photos to get a more realistic sense of the colors.
Can you buy Ruggable covers without the pad?
Yes, once you own a Ruggable system, you can purchase separate Rug Covers to swap out styles for different seasons or whenever you want to change your decor. This interchangeability is a key feature of the brand.
Which brand holds up better after washing?
Both brands design their rugs for machine washing. As long as you follow the care instructions (wash in cold water, dry on low heat), both should hold up well. Ruggable’s system has a long track record for durability due to its premium construction.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
