Moccamaster is a Dutch brand focused on handcrafted, minimalist drip coffee makers that promise perfect brewing temperature and unrivaled durability for purists. In contrast, Breville is an Australian appliance giant that offers technologically advanced, feature-rich coffee machines - from drip to espresso - designed for convenience and customization.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right coffee maker for your kitchen.
Moccamaster: The Handcrafted Brewer for Purists
Moccamaster is known for one thing: making exceptional drip coffee makers that are built to last a lifetime. Handcrafted in the Netherlands, these machines use a unique copper boiling element to heat water to the precise SCAA-certified temperature range for optimal coffee extraction. Their target audience is the coffee aficionado who values build quality, brew consistency, and timeless design over digital features and programmability.
- Product mix: Exclusively high-end automatic drip coffee makers. Models primarily vary by carafe type (glass vs. thermal) and brewing capacity (from 5 to 10 cups).
- Style/vibe: Minimalist, retro-modern aesthetic with a distinct industrial chic. Available in a wide variety of polished metal and bold color finishes.
- Price point: Premium, ranging from approximately $300 to $400. This is an investment piece for serious coffee enthusiasts.
- Quality: Exceptional. Features durable metal housing and a powerful copper boiling element. Machines are designed to be repairable, not disposable, contributing to a lifespan of 10+ years.
- Fit & Sizing: Generally compact with a small countertop footprint, making them suitable for most kitchen spaces. They stand between 12 and 14 inches tall.
- Warranty: A generous 5-year manufacturer's warranty, reflecting the brand’s confidence in its durability and craftsmanship.
- Sustainability: High emphasis on longevity and repairability to reduce waste. Uses high-quality, recyclable materials and energy-efficient components.
Moccamaster is the choice for those who want a simple, high-performance coffee maker that brews a perfect cup and looks great doing it.
Shop Moccamaster: moccamaster.com
Breville: The Innovative Tech-Forward Brewer
Breville is a global leader in user-friendly, high-tech kitchen appliances, and its coffee machine lineup is a prime example of its innovative approach. Catering to a wide audience, Breville offers everything from simple drip brewers to advanced all-in-one espresso machines. Their products are characterized by brushed stainless steel designs, intuitive digital displays, and customizable settings for those who want control over every aspect of their brew.
- Product mix: Extensive range of coffee machines, including drip coffee makers, grinders, pour-over adapters, and a very popular line of semi-automatic espresso machines like the Barista Express.
- Style/vibe: Modern and tech-centric. Brushed stainless steel is the dominant finish, creating a sleek, contemporary look that fits well in modern kitchens.
- Price point: Mid-range to high-end. Breville's drip coffee makers typically cost between $150 and $300, while their advanced espresso machines can exceed $2,000.
- Quality: Very good. Built with stainless steel, heavy-duty plastic, and glass components. The emphasis is on technology and features, which can mean more electronic parts that are susceptible to wear over a long period.
- Fit & Sizing: Variable. Drip coffee makers are comparable in size to other brands, while their espresso machines can be larger and require more counter space. Most drip brewers offer up to a 12-cup capacity.
- Customization: A key selling point. Many models offer programmable start times, adjustable brew strength, water temperature control, and different brewing modes (e.g., Gold Cup, Cold Brew).
- Warranty: Typically a 1-year limited product warranty on their drip coffee makers.
Breville is perfect for the home brewer who enjoys experimenting with settings and values the convenience of modern, programmable features.
Shop Breville: breville.com
Moccamaster vs. Breville Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear price difference between these two brands. A Moccamaster is a premium investment, typically costing between $300 and $400 for any of their models. The price reflects its Dutch-made craftsmanship, durable materials like copper and metal, and the 5-year warranty.
Breville positions its drip coffee makers in a more accessible mid-range, generally from $150 to $300. The value from Breville comes from its array of digital features, advanced customization, and modern technology. You pay less upfront but get more programmable functions, though the standard warranty is shorter at one year.
Quality & Materials
Moccamaster is famous for its build quality. The body is made from durable metal, and the star of the show is the internal copper boiling element, which heats water quickly and maintains the ideal brewing temperature. This focus on premium, simple mechanics is why these machines often last for decades.
Breville uses a combination of stainless steel and high-quality plastics. While their machines are well-built and feel sturdy, the complex electronics, digital screens, and internal plastic components can be points of failure over the long term compared to Moccamaster's analog simplicity.
Style & Aesthetic
Moccamaster coffee makers are design icons with a distinct retro-modern look. Their simple, lean profile and wide range of vibrant, unique colors like turquoise, yellow, and orange make them a statement piece that can add a pop of personality to a kitchen.
Breville champions a sleek, contemporary aesthetic dominated by brushed stainless steel. Their machines look like modern, sophisticated appliances, complete with LCD screens and intuitive button layouts. This style is designed to blend seamlessly with other modern kitchen gadgets.
Shopping Experience
Moccamaster machines are sold through their official website and specialty coffee retailers like Williams Sonoma or Seattle Coffee Gear. The shopping experience feels more curated, targeting customers who are specifically seeking out a high-end, artisanal product.
Breville is much more widely available. You can find their products in big-box stores like Best Buy, department stores, and online marketplaces like Amazon. This widespread distribution makes it easier to compare models and find deals.
Sustainability & Ethics
Moccamaster's entire philosophy is built on sustainability through longevity. They design their machines to be fully repairable, with replacement parts readily available. This approach aims to keep coffee makers out of landfills. The machines are also energy-efficient.
While an innovative company, Breville doesn’t emphasize longevity and repairability in the same way. Their focus on electronics means appliances are often replaced rather than repaired when a component fails after the warranty period. However, they use recyclable packaging and incorporate some energy-saving features.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right brand really comes down to what you value most in your daily coffee ritual: simplicity and perfection, or technology and control.
Choose Moccamaster if:
- You believe drip coffee can be exceptional and want café-quality results at home.
- You value durability and want a machine built to last for 10+ years.
- You appreciate a simple, analog experience - just turn it on and let it brew perfectly.
- You love a minimalist or retro design aesthetic and want your coffee maker to be a statement piece.
Choose Breville if:
- You love technology and want to customize your coffee with adjustable settings.
- You enjoy the convenience of features like auto-start timers and brew strength controls.
- You want more than a drip brewer and are also interested in espresso or all-in-one machines.
- You prefer a modern stainless steel design that matches other kitchen appliances.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Moccamaster or Breville cheaper?
Breville is decidedly cheaper for a drip coffee maker. Breville's models typically run from $150 to $300, while a Moccamaster will cost you between $300 and $400.
Which has better quality furniture?
Moccamaster is renowned for superior build quality and durability. Its handcrafted metal construction and copper heating element are designed for longevity and consistent performance. Breville offers good quality with its stainless steel designs, but its reliance on complex electronics can make it less durable over a 10+ year time frame.
How long does a Moccamaster last compared to a Breville?
A Moccamaster is designed to last for over a decade and comes with a 5-year warranty to back that up. Individual parts are also replaceable. A Breville coffee maker is more typical of modern electronics, often lasting 3-5 years, and comes with a 1-year warranty.
Are Moccamaster coffee makers worth the high price?
For coffee enthusiasts who prioritize taste and long-term durability, a Moccamaster is widely considered worth the investment. Its ability to brew at the perfect temperature creates a noticeably better cup of coffee, and its longevity means you won't need to replace it for many years.
Is Breville a good brand for coffee beginners?
Yes, Breville's intuitive interfaces, clear instructions, and convenient features like pre-sets and programmable timers make it an excellent choice for beginners who want great results without a steep learning curve.
Which brand is better for coffee purists?
Moccamaster is the clear choice for coffee purists. It focuses on doing one thing perfectly: brewing drip coffee at the Specialty Coffee Association's (SCA) ideal temperature and time for optimal flavor extraction.
Does Moccamaster or Breville offer more color options?
Moccamaster offers a much wider and more interesting range of colors. While Breville sticks mainly to classic brushed stainless steel, silver, and black, Moccamaster has a rainbow of choices, including Polished Silver, Stone Grey, Turquoise, and Butter Yellow.
Which brand is a more sustainable choice?
Moccamaster is the more sustainable option. Its design philosophy is centered around longevity, repairability, and using high-quality, recyclable materials to minimize environmental impact and waste. They are built to be kept, not replaced.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
