The main difference between Mixtiles and other photo tiles is that Mixtiles is a specific brand offering a uniform, modern, and easily repositionable product with a streamlined app-based experience. The broader category of Photo Tiles includes various brands offering a wider range of materials, sizes, styles, and price points, from high-end acrylic to custom ceramic, providing more customization but a less consistent shopping process.
Here’s a detailed guide to help you decide which one is the right choice for your walls and your photos.
Mixtiles
Mixtiles is a well-known brand that simplifies creating photo displays with its signature lightweight, peel-and-stick tiles. The entire user experience is designed for simplicity, allowing customers to upload photos directly from a phone or computer, select a style, and have a ready-to-hang set of pictures arrive quickly. Their clean, frameless look makes them popular for modern and minimalist decor.
- What it is: A brand of uniform, lightweight photo tiles with a special adhesive that sticks securely to walls without causing damage, allowing them to be repositioned multiple times.
- Key features: Frameless 8x8 squares, repositionable peel-and-stick backing, user-friendly app, fast shipping, and a satisfaction guarantee.
- Price: Typically around $99 for the first 9 tiles, with additional single tiles costing about $11 each. Shipping is often included.
- Style: Uniform, modern, and minimalist. Best for creating cohesive grid galleries with a clean, sleek edge. All tiles are the same size, which helps maintain a structured look.
- Materials/Construction: The tiles are made from a lightweight foam core with a high-quality print and a protective matte finish. They are resistant to moisture and fading.
- Pros: No damage to walls, easy to reposition, simple and fast ordering process through their app, consistent quality and look, affordable for creating a gallery wall.
- Cons: Limited to a single 8x8 inch square size, fewer material options (primarily matte foam), not ideal for those wanting varied sizes or premium finishes like acrylic or gloss.
This brand is ideal for renters or anyone who wants a stylish, affordable, and flexible way to display photos without the commitment of nails and frames.
Shop this product: mixtiles.com
Photo Tiles (General Category)
Unlike Mixtiles, "Photo Tiles" is a broader product category sold by many different companies like CanvasPop, Snapfish, and other specialized online printers. These brands offer a huge variety of options, from different materials and sizes to unique shapes and framing styles. This allows for a much more customized and potentially high-end look, but the quality and user experience can vary greatly from one seller to another.
- What it is: A general term for photos printed on tiles made of various materials for wall display. This includes options from numerous brands.
- Key features: Wide variety of sizes (from 4x4 to 24x36), materials (foam, acrylic, ceramic, wood), and finishes (glossy, matte, textured). Many offer custom shapes and framing.
- Price: Highly variable, ranging from $20 for a single small tile to over $150 for a large or premium acrylic tile.
- Style: Can fit any aesthetic, from high-end glossy displays to rustic decor with wood-mounted prints. The versatility allows for creating highly personal and artistic gallery walls.
- Materials/Construction: Options range from lightweight foam similar to Mixtiles to more durable and premium materials like printed acrylic, high-gloss ceramic, or textured canvas. Durability and quality depend on the specific brand and material chosen.
- Pros: Huge range of customization in size, material, and style. Ability to create large, statement-making feature walls. Some materials offer a more premium, high-art look.
- Cons: Quality and price are inconsistent across different brands. The shopping experience can be more complex. Premium materials are heavier and may not be repositionable or damage-free.
This category is best for homeowners or designers who have a specific creative vision and want complete control over the size, finish, and material of their photo display.
Shop this product: phototiles.com
Mixtiles vs. Photo Tiles Comparison
Dimensions & Sizing Options
Mixtiles keeps things simple with a single, standard size of roughly 8x8 inches. This uniformity makes it easy to plan and create a symmetrical grid layout or a neat, cohesive cluster on your wall. While the look is clean, you are limited to this one size, which may not be ideal for creating a focal point with a large statement piece.
In contrast, the broader Photo Tiles category offers a huge selection of sizes. You can find tiny 4x4 inch tiles for a small accent wall or large-format prints up to 24x36 inches that can anchor an entire room. This flexibility is perfect for creating dynamic gallery walls with mixed sizes, allowing for much more personalization in scale and layout.
Materials & Quality
Mixtiles are constructed from a durable, lightweight foam core with a quality matte finish print. The construction is intentionally designed for their peel-and-stick functionality, ensuring they are light enough to be repositioned many times without falling or damaging walls. They're fade and moisture-resistant, making them practical for most indoor spaces.
Other photo tiles can be found in a range of materials, each providing a different look and level of quality. Acrylic tiles offer a modern, high-gloss finish with vibrant colors, while ceramic tiles are substantial and durable. The print quality varies by brand and price, with higher-end options providing archival-quality prints. However, heavier materials like ceramic are not repositionable and require more permanent mounting.
Price & Value
Mixtiles provides excellent value with straightforward bundle pricing. A set of 9 tiles typically costs around $99, breaking down to just over $10 per tile with shipping often included. This predictable cost makes it easy to budget for a full gallery wall without any hidden fees. This model is very cost-effective for anyone wanting to create a multi-piece display.
The price of generic photo tiles is far less predictable. A single, small foam tile might cost $20, while a larger, premium acrylic tile from a high-end printer could cost $100 or more. While this means the initial cost for a single tile might be higher, you're paying for specific materials, larger sizes, or a more artistic finish. The value proposition depends entirely on your desire for customization versus bundle savings.
Style & Aesthetic
The Mixtiles aesthetic is distinctly modern, clean, and minimalist. The uniform square shape and frameless design put the focus squarely on your photos, creating an orderly display that complements contemporary interiors. The cohesive nature of the product makes it feel intentional and pre-designed, which is great for those who prefer simplicity.
The stylistic possibilities with other Photo Tiles are virtually endless. You can achieve a vibrant, high-end gallery feel with glossy acrylic tiles, a charming, rustic vibe with wood-mounted prints, or an eclectic look by mixing different sizes, shapes, and frames. This flexibility allows you to tailor your photo wall to perfectly match a unique decor theme.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Mixtiles and other photo tiles are great ways to display memories, but they suit different needs, budgets, and decorating styles.
Choose Mixtiles if:
- You are a renter or live in a dorm and want a completely damage-free solution.
- You love changing your decor often and want the ability to easily rearrange your photos.
- You prefer a clean, modern, and cohesive look for your gallery wall.
- You want a simple, fast, and user-friendly ordering experience straight from your phone.
Choose Photo Tiles from other brands if:
- You want more creative control over sizes, materials, and finishes.
- You want to create a high-impact feature wall with a large statement piece or mixed sizes.
- You're looking for a premium material like high-gloss acrylic or durable ceramic for a more permanent installation.
- You are a homeowner and aren't concerned about repositionable, damage-free mounting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Mixtiles and other photo tiles?
The primary difference is brand versus category. Mixtiles is a single brand known for its 8x8 repositionable foam tiles with a simple ordering process. "Photo Tiles" refers to a wide range of products from many brands with diverse sizes, materials (acrylic, ceramic, wood), and price points.
Will Mixtiles damage my walls?
No, Mixtiles are specifically designed to be damage-free. Their special adhesive allows them to be stuck, removed, and repositioned multiple times without peeling paint or leaving residue on standard wall surfaces.
Which option is more affordable?
For building a multi-photo gallery wall, Mixtiles is generally more affordable due to its bundle pricing (e.g., $99 for 9 tiles). For a single statement piece, you may find an affordably priced tile from another brand, but premium materials like acrylic will usually cost more per tile.
Can you create a mixed-size gallery wall with Mixtiles?
No, Mixtiles come in a single 8x8-inch square size. If you want to create a wall display with varying sizes and shapes, you'll need to look at options from other photo tile brands.
What are the material options for generic photo tiles?
You can find Photo Tiles made from lightweight foam board (similar to Mixtiles), high-gloss acrylic for a vibrant look, durable ceramic, printed metal, or wood-mounted prints for a rustic feel.
Which is better for renters?
Mixtiles is the clear winner for renters. Their damage-free, easily repositioned design means you can decorate extensively without worrying about your security deposit or repair needs when you move out.
Is the print quality good on Mixtiles?
Yes, Mixtiles offers high-quality photo printing with a protective matte finish that prevents glare and resists fading. The colors are accurate and sharp for a consumer-grade product.
How do you hang other types of photo tiles?
Mounting methods vary by brand and material. Some lightweight foam options use a similar peel-and-stick method. Heavier tiles made of acrylic, metal, or ceramic typically require more secure mounts, like special hardware, command strips designed for heavier weights, or even professional installation.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
