Member's Mark is Sam's Club's private label, offering affordable and functional furniture and home goods across a wide range of categories. In contrast, Caraway is a premium direct-to-consumer brand specializing in stylish, non-toxic ceramic cookware with a curated, minimalist aesthetic. The key difference lies in their focus: Member's Mark provides value-driven essentials for the entire home, while Caraway offers high-end, design-conscious tools specifically for the kitchen.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home brand for your needs.
Member's Mark: The All-Around Value Choice
As the in-house brand for Sam’s Club, Member's Mark is built on the promise of quality at a competitive price point. The brand targets budget-conscious shoppers - from families to first-time homeowners - who need reliable and practical home furnishings without a premium investment. Their collections often feature modern, simple designs that can easily integrate into various decor styles.
- Product mix: A wide array of home goods including sofas, beds, dining sets, outdoor furniture, bedding, kitchen appliances, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Practical and modern with a focus on simple silhouettes and neutral colors. The aesthetic is functional and versatile, designed for everyday family life rather than high-concept design.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Sofas can range from $300 to $500, with complete bedroom sets often staying under $1,000. It offers fantastic value for anyone furnishing a space on a budget.
- Quality: Good for its price. Furniture is typically made from engineered wood, MDF, and metal with durable, easy-to-clean fabrics. It's built for practicality, not as heirloom-quality investment pieces.
- Availability: Exclusive to Sam's Club. Products can be purchased in their physical warehouse stores or online through the Sam's Club website.
- Best for: Price-conscious shoppers, families, renters, and anyone needing to furnish a home quickly and affordably with functional, modern pieces.
Member's Mark is the go-to for shoppers who prioritize budget and function, offering stylish and durable home essentials at a wholesale price.
Shop Member's Mark: samsclub.com
Caraway: The Premium, Non-Toxic Kitchen Specialist
Caraway is a direct-to-consumer brand famous for its beautifully designed, non-toxic cookware. Their mission is to blend modern aesthetics with health-conscious materials, creating products that are as beautiful as they are functional. Caraway's target customer is the design-savvy, health-conscious consumer who views kitchen tools as an extension of their home's decor and is willing to invest in quality and sustainability.
- Product mix: A specialized collection focused on cookware sets (pots and pans), bakeware, food storage containers, and kitchen accessories. They do not sell large furniture.
- Style/vibe: Sleek, minimalist, and Scandinavian-inspired. Their products feature clean lines and come in a curated palette of aesthetically pleasing colors, designed to be displayed on countertops.
- Price point: Mid-to-premium. A full cookware set typically costs around $395–$595, positioning the brand as an investment in kitchen quality and style.
- Quality: Excellent. Caraway is known for its durable, ceramic-coated cookware that is non-stick and free from harmful chemicals like PTFE and PFOA. The construction is solid with high-quality metals and finishes.
- Sustainability: A core brand principle. Caraway uses non-toxic coatings, sources materials responsibly, and uses sustainable packaging to reduce environmental impact.
- Availability: Primarily sold directly through the Caraway website, with some products available at select retailers like Crate & Barrel.
Caraway excels at offering high-performance, non-toxic cookware that looks beautiful in any modern kitchen, making it a favorite for those who value health and design.
Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com
Member's Mark vs. Caraway Comparison
Price Comparison
There is no direct price competition between these two brands because they operate in entirely different market segments. Member's Mark is defined by its affordability. It delivers complete rooms of furniture for the price of a single cookware set from Caraway. This makes it an undisputed leader for value-driven home furnishing on a large scale.
Caraway is positioned as a premium brand where price reflects its investment in non-toxic materials, high-end design, and build quality. While expensive compared to mass-market cookware, its price is competitive within the premium, non-toxic cookware niche. You're paying for specialized quality and aesthetics, not just the basic function.
Style & Aesthetic
Both brands embrace a modern, minimalist aesthetic, but with different intentions. Member's Mark designs are simple and neutral to be versatile and fit into as many homes as possible. The goal is functionality and broad appeal. The look is clean and contemporary but rarely makes a bold design statement.
Caraway’s minimalism, on the other hand, is a deliberate design statement. Its cookware is meant to be seen, with a sleek profile and curated colors that enhance a kitchen’s decor. The style is highly intentional and serves as a decor element, which is a key part of its appeal for design-conscious consumers.
Quality & Construction
Quality aligns directly with price point and product focus. Member's Mark uses practical, cost-effective materials like engineered wood, MDF, and durable fabrics to create reliable, everyday furniture. The quality is a solid value for the price but is not intended to last for generations.
Caraway focuses on longevity and performance in its specific category. Its cookware features a mineral-based ceramic coating on a durable aluminum core, ensuring even heating and a slick non-stick surface without harmful chemicals. Its construction is built to withstand daily use while maintaining its look and performance.
Product Selection
This is the most significant point of difference. Member's Mark is a comprehensive home brand. You can buy nearly everything you need to furnish a house, from a sofa and bed to towels and dinnerware. Its strength lies in this extensive breadth of products under a single, value-oriented umbrella.
Caraway is a specialist. It focuses exclusively on best-in-class cookware, bakeware, and kitchen accessories. The brand's limited scope allows it to put immense focus on the quality, safety, and design of every item, making it an authority in its niche instead of a jack-of-all-trades.
Sustainability & Ethics
Caraway makes sustainability a central part of its brand identity. It prominently advertises its non-toxic, eco-friendly materials and responsible production practices. The company ships products in recycled and biodegradable packaging, with no single-use plastics, which appeals strongly to environmentally conscious shoppers.
As a private label of a major corporation, Member's Mark's sustainability initiatives are less visible. While Sam's Club has its own corporate responsibility goals, these efforts are not a primary selling point for the Member's Mark brand itself. Caraway is the far stronger choice for consumers who prioritize eco-friendly and transparent brands.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on what you're shopping for, your budget, and your core priorities.
Choose Member's Mark if:
- You are furnishing an apartment or home on a tight budget.
- You need a wide variety of items, from furniture to bedding, all in one place.
- You prioritize practicality and durability for a busy family lifestyle.
- You are a Sam's Club member looking to maximize the value of your membership.
Choose Caraway if:
- You are looking for premium, non-toxic cookware and kitchen essentials.
- Aesthetics are a top priority, and you want your cookware to complement your kitchen decor.
- You prioritize health and sustainability and want products free of lead, cadmium, PTFE, and PFOA.
- You are willing to invest more for a high-quality product that is well-designed and built to last.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Member's Mark or Caraway cheaper?
Member's Mark is significantly cheaper. It is a budget-focused brand designed to offer maximum value. Caraway is a premium brand, and its prices reflect its higher-end materials, non-toxic technology, and design-forward aesthetic.
Which brand has better quality?
Quality is relative to the product category. Caraway offers superior quality in cookware with its durable, non-toxic ceramic construction. Member's Mark offers good quality for its price in the furniture market, using materials designed for durability and everyday use, but it is not considered premium.
Is Caraway cookware really non-toxic?
Yes, this is one of its primary selling points. Caraway's cookware is made with a ceramic non-stick coating that is free from potentially toxic materials often found in traditional non-stick pans, including PTFE (Teflon®), PFOA, lead, and cadmium.
Do I need a membership to buy Member's Mark products?
Yes. Member's Mark is the exclusive brand of Sam’s Club, so you must have a Sam’s Club membership to purchase its products either in-store or online.
Is Member's Mark furniture made of solid wood?
Generally, no. To keep prices low, Member's Mark furniture is typically constructed from engineered wood, MDF, and wood veneers. While sturdy and functional, it is not the same as solid wood furniture.
Which brand is better for a family?
For furnishing a whole home on a family budget, Member's Mark is the clear choice due to its affordable pricing and durable products. For family cooking, Caraway is an excellent option for parents who prioritize non-toxic materials for health and safety.
Can I buy Caraway products in stores?
While Caraway is primarily a direct-to-consumer online brand, a selection of its products can be found at select retail partners like Crate & Barrel and Zola.
Which brand is better for small spaces?
Member's Mark offers a wide range of furniture sizes and would be the better choice for furnishing a small space, with options like compact sofas and multi-functional storage. Caraway's products are well-designed for efficient storage, with included cookware organizers making them great for any size kitchen, including small ones.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
