Maytag refrigerators are built with a focus on durability and reliable performance, offering functional, no-frills designs ideal for busy families. In contrast, KitchenAid positions itself as a premium brand, delivering sleek, modern aesthetics and advanced culinary features for design-conscious homeowners and passionate home cooks.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right refrigerator brand for your kitchen.
Maytag: The Dependable Workhorse
Maytag is a long-standing American appliance brand synonymous with dependability and sturdy construction. Targeting households that prioritize longevity and performance, Maytag refrigerators are designed to withstand the demands of daily family life. They are known for their solid build, straightforward features, and accessible price points, making them a practical choice for those who want a reliable appliance without paying for high-end styling or complex technology.
- Product mix: Offers a full range of configurations, including traditional top-freezer models, side-by-side units, and spacious French door refrigerators.
- Style/vibe: Classic and utilitarian design. The aesthetic is clean and functional, meant to blend into a traditional kitchen rather than stand out as a centerpiece.
- Price point: Mid-range and budget-friendly. Most models are priced between $1,000 and $2,500, offering excellent value.
- Quality: Known for robust construction and dependable compressor systems. Materials are chosen for durability over luxury, ensuring a long lifespan with minimal maintenance.
- Fit & Sizing: Provides a variety of standard sizes suitable for most kitchen layouts, from smaller 30-inch models to larger-capacity units for families.
- Sales: Frequently included in holiday sale events at major big-box retailers like Lowe's, The Home Depot, and Best Buy.
- Return policy: Varies by retailer but typically follows industry standards, usually offering a window for returns if the product is defective.
- Delivery & Assembly: Widely available through appliance stores and big-box retailers, which offer standard delivery and installation services.
Maytag is the go-to choice for consumers seeking a durable, hardworking refrigerator that gets the job done without over-the-top features or a premium price tag.
Shop Maytag: maytag.com
KitchenAid: The Premium Culinary Centerpiece
A part of the Whirlpool family of brands, KitchenAid is a premium appliance manufacturer celebrated for its iconic stand mixers and a full suite of high-performance kitchen appliances. KitchenAid refrigerators cater to avid home chefs and design-oriented consumers who want their appliances to be both functional and beautiful. They are characterized by sleek designs, high-end materials, and innovative features designed to preserve food quality and enhance the cooking experience.
- Product mix: Extensive selection of French door, side-by-side, counter-depth, and built-in refrigerators.
- Style/vibe: Sophisticated and modern. Features sleek handles, fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finishes, and an upscale appearance that serves as a kitchen focal point.
- Price point: Premium. Refrigerators typically start around $2,000 and can exceed $4,000 for high-end, feature-rich models.
- Quality: Constructed with high-grade materials, advanced insulation, and innovative cooling technologies for precise temperature management. The build quality emphasizes both durability and a refined look and feel.
- Dimensions/Scale: Offers a wide range of sizes, especially popular for their counter-depth and built-in models which provide a custom, seamless look for kitchens. The modern look is also good for small, modern kitchens.
- Customization: Some models offer customizable panels that can be fitted to match your kitchen cabinetry for a true built-in look.
- Features: Often includes advanced options like interior water dispensers, smart home connectivity, platinum interior designs, and extended fresh produce preservation systems.
- Delivery & Assembly: Sold through authorized appliance dealers and premium retailers who often provide white-glove delivery and professional installation services.
KitchenAid is ideal for those willing to invest in a stylish, high-performance refrigerator that complements an upscale kitchen design.
Shop KitchenAid: kitchenaid.com
Maytag vs. KitchenAid Refrigerator Comparison
Price Comparison
Price is one of the most significant differentiators between these two brands. Maytag is firmly positioned in the mid-range market. Its refrigerators typically cost between $1,000 and $2,500, making them an accessible option for budget-conscious families who still want a reliable, North American-built appliance.
In contrast, KitchenAid operates in the premium category. Its prices generally start where Maytag's top out, ranging from around $2,000 to over $4,000. This higher cost reflects the brand's focus on advanced features, superior materials, and sophisticated design, appealing to buyers who view their kitchen appliances as a long-term investment in their home's aesthetic and functionality.
Style & Aesthetic
Maytag refrigerators are designed with a functional, utilitarian approach. They feature classic designs, simple lines, and standard finishes that fit into any traditional kitchen. The brand prioritizes usability and durability over visual trends, resulting in a look that is dependable but not necessarily a "statement" piece.
KitchenAid places a strong emphasis on design and aesthetics. Its refrigerators boast a modern, chef-inspired look with features like textured satin-glide handles, smudge-proof stainless steel, and refined interior lighting. A KitchenAid refrigerator is often chosen not just for its performance but for its ability to elevate the overall look of a kitchen, making it a design element in its own right.
Quality & Construction
While both brands are owned by Whirlpool Corporation and share a commitment to quality manufacturing, their focus differs. Maytag's reputation is built on sturdiness and longevity. Its components, like compressors and shelving, are engineered for heavy use and long-term reliability. The focus is on creating a workhorse that consistently performs year after year.
KitchenAid also builds durable appliances but layers in high-end materials and precision engineering. This includes advanced temperature management systems that actively monitor and adjust temperatures, high-quality insulation for energy efficiency, and durable, easy-to-clean shelving. The construction aims to provide a more premium user experience, from the smooth glide of the drawers to the quiet operation.
Shopping Experience
Maytag refrigerators are widely accessible. You can find them at nearly any major home improvement or appliance store, such as The Home Depot, Lowe's, and Best Buy. The buying process is straightforward and targeted toward the mass market, with frequent sales and promotions.
KitchenAid products are typically sold through authorized appliance dealers and premium kitchen design showrooms, in addition to some major retailers. The shopping experience is often more consultative, with salespeople trained to explain the advanced features and customization options. Professional installation is more common, especially for built-in and counter-depth models that require a precise fit.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands prioritize energy efficiency, and you'll find ENERGY STAR certified models from both Maytag and KitchenAid. This certification ensures lower energy consumption, which saves money on utility bills and reduces environmental impact. Maytag's durability-first approach can be seen as sustainable, as a longer-lasting appliance means less waste. KitchenAid often incorporates more advanced insulation and efficiency technologies in its premium models to further reduce their energy footprint.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your budget, style preferences, and priorities for your kitchen.
Choose Maytag if:
- Your primary concern is reliability and long-term durability.
- You're working with a mid-range budget of $1,000 to $2,500.
- You prefer a simple, classic design that is functional and easy to use.
- You need a dependable refrigerator for a busy family household.
Choose KitchenAid if:
- You view your refrigerator as a key design element in your kitchen.
- You want advanced features like precise temperature management systems and smart technology.
- You have a premium budget and are willing to invest $2,000 or more.
- You are interested in built-in or counter-depth models for a seamless, high-end look.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Maytag or KitchenAid more expensive?
KitchenAid is consistently more expensive than Maytag. KitchenAid is a premium brand with refrigerators starting around $2,000, while Maytag is a mid-range brand with models typically priced between $1,000 and $2,500.
Which brand is more reliable, Maytag or KitchenAid?
Both brands are known for reliability, as they are manufactured by Whirlpool Corporation. However, Maytag's brand identity is historically built around durability and longevity, often marketed as a "workhorse" appliance. KitchenAid is also very reliable but focuses more on premium features and design in its marketing.
Are Maytag and KitchenAid made by the same company?
Yes, both Maytag and KitchenAid are owned and manufactured by the Whirlpool Corporation. This means they often share platforms and core components, but they are designed and marketed for different customer segments.
Which refrigerator has better features?
KitchenAid generally offers more advanced, high-tech features. These can include advanced food preservation systems, smart connectivity, interior water dispensers, and customizable storage options designed for home chefs.
Is KitchenAid considered a luxury brand?
Yes, in the major appliance category, KitchenAid is positioned as a premium or entry-level luxury brand. It sits above mainstream brands like Maytag and Whirlpool but below ultra-high-end brands like Sub-Zero or Thermador.
How long do Maytag refrigerators usually last?
With proper care, a Maytag refrigerator can be expected to last between 10 to 15 years, which is in line with the industry average for a quality appliance. Their reputation for durability sometimes allows them to last even longer.
Do both brands offer a good variety of models?
Yes, both brands offer a wide selection of configurations, including popular French door and side-by-side models. KitchenAid has a slightly larger emphasis on built-in and a broader selection of counter-depth models for a more custom look and modern kitchen design.
Which brand is better for a family?
Maytag is often the more practical choice for a family. Its refrigerators are designed for heavy use, typically offer greater capacity for the price, and their straightforward functionality is perfect for a busy household that prioritizes durability over advanced features.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
