Liberty Furniture specializes in classic, traditional pieces with an emphasis on solid wood construction and craftsmanship, making it a good choice for those seeking timeless, durable items. By contrast, Ashley Furniture is a large-scale, value-oriented brand that offers a massive selection of styles for every budget, from modern to rustic, prioritizing affordability and accessibility.
Let's look at the details you need to decide which brand is right for your home.
Liberty Furniture: The Classic Craftsmanship Choice
Liberty Furniture is a mid-range manufacturer focused on creating timeless furniture for the traditional American home. The brand is known for its attention to detail, use of solid hardwoods and quality veneers, and designs that favor classic elegance over passing trends. You won't find Liberty in its own branded showrooms, instead, its collections are available through a network of authorized furniture retailers across the country.
- Product mix: Specializes in bedroom sets, dining room furniture, home office, and occasional living room pieces like coffee and end tables.
- Style/vibe: Heavily leans into traditional and transitional styles. Expect rich wood finishes, ornate carvings, and classic silhouettes that feel warm and established.
- Price point: Mid-range. Dressers and side tables typically start around $500, while larger bedroom or dining sets can range from $1,500 to $2,500+.
- Quality: Emphasizes solid wood and kiln-dried hardwood frames, offering a durable and substantial feel. It's built to last, making it a good long-term investment.
- Fit & Sizing: Pieces generally follow standard dimensions suitable for average to large rooms. Their focus is on complete, handsome sets rather than compact or modular designs.
- Shopping Experience: Sold primarily through authorized local and online furniture retailers. This means the customer service and showroom experience can vary depending on the dealer.
Liberty Furniture is ideal for someone looking to invest in well-made, traditional furniture that will not go out of style.
Shop Liberty Furniture retailers at: libertyfurniture.com
Ashley Furniture: The Affordable One-Stop Shop
As one of the largest furniture manufacturers in the world, Ashley Furniture offers something for nearly every style and budget. The brand is a dominant force in the market, known for its vast selection, accessible price points, and extensive retail presence through its Ashley HomeStores. From trendy apartment sofas to sprawling family sectionals, Ashley aims to be a complete solution for furnishing a home affordably.
- Product mix: Offers products for the entire home, including a huge range of sofas, sectionals, recliners, beds, dining sets, mattresses, rugs, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Covers a very wide spectrum of styles, including modern, contemporary, farmhouse, rustic, and traditional. It’s easy to find pieces that fit nearly any interior design scheme.
- Price point: Highly budget-friendly to mid-range. Many statement pieces like sofas and beds are available for under $1,000, driven by frequent sales and promotions.
- Quality: Varies significantly by collection. Economy lines often use engineered wood, composites, and veneers to keep costs low. Their higher-end lines feature better materials and construction.
- Fit & Sizing: Provides an extensive range of sizes, including many multi-functional and compact pieces perfect for apartments and smaller living spaces.
- Shopping Experience: Very accessible, with a strong online store and hundreds of physical Ashley HomeStores that offer a consistent brand experience, plus availability at other major retailers.
A great option for first-time homebuyers, budget-conscious shoppers, and anyone who wants a wide selection of current styles without a hefty price tag.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Liberty Furniture vs. Ashley Furniture Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear price difference between the two brands. Ashley Furniture is the more affordable option, with a business model centered on volume and frequent promotions. You can often find entire living room or bedroom sets for what a single large piece might cost from another brand. Their frequent sales make their already low prices even more appealing for anyone on a tight budget.
Liberty Furniture operates in a mid-range price category. Their furniture costs more because it almost always uses more expensive materials like solid wood and requires more detailed craftsmanship. While not a luxury brand, Liberty represents an investment in durability, positioning its products as a better long-term value than entry-level alternatives.
Style & Aesthetic
Liberty Furniture has a very defined aesthetic. They are experts in traditional, classic, and rustic farmhouse styles. Their collections are characterized by warm wood tones, substantial silhouettes, and timeless details like turned legs or paneled headboards. If you want a home that feels grand and established, Liberty has you covered.
Ashley Furniture is far more versatile and trend-focused. While they also offer traditional lines that compete with Liberty, their catalog is much broader. You'll find sleek modern sofas, cozy farmhouse dining tables, and plush contemporary recliners. This makes Ashley a better fit for shoppers with eclectic tastes or those who want to furnish their home in a popular-at-the-moment style.
Quality & Materials
This is one of the most significant differentiators. Liberty Furniture consistently uses solid wood, high-quality veneers, and time-tested joinery techniques. Their pieces are designed to be heirlooms, offering the kind of durability and heft you expect from well-made traditional furniture. You are paying for a higher standard of construction.
Ashley Furniture's quality is dependent on the specific product line. To meet their accessible price points, many of their more affordable collections use engineered wood, particleboard, and laminates. These materials are functional but are less durable and less resistant to wear and tear than solid wood. Ashley does offer higher-quality collections, but buyers should pay close attention to the materials listed for each item.
Shopping Experience
Your shopping experience will be quite different between the two. Shopping for Ashley Furniture is straightforward and simple. You can visit one of their many Ashley HomeStores for a consistent in-person experience or browse their comprehensive website, which includes customer reviews and financing options.
Shopping for Liberty Furniture involves finding one of their authorized dealers. This could be a local family-owned furniture store or a larger regional retailer. The quality of the showroom and the level of customer service will depend entirely on that specific dealer, not on Liberty itself.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both companies are making efforts toward more responsible practices. Liberty Furniture cites responsible sourcing and durable construction that leads to less waste over time. Their smaller scale and focus on longevity inherently lend themselves to a more sustainable model compared to fast-furniture alternatives.
Given its enormous scale, Ashley has taken steps to incorporate sustainability, including using recycled materials and eco-friendly packaging. For shoppers primarily focused on environmental impact, Liberty's smaller footprint and emphasis on building multi-generational furniture may be more appealing.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands serve different customers well, so your choice depends entirely on your budget, style, and long-term goals for your furniture.
Choose Liberty Furniture if:
- You are specifically looking for traditional, classic, or formal "forever" furniture.
- Quality and durability are your top priorities, and you prefer solid wood construction.
- You’re willing to invest in pieces that are made to last for decades.
- You want a cohesive, elegant look for spaces like a formal dining room or master bedroom.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- You have a strict budget and need affordable options for your entire home.
- You enjoy a wide variety of styles, from modern and contemporary to farmhouse.
- Convenience is key, you want to shop online or in a dedicated brand showroom with frequent sales.
- You are furnishing a first home, apartment, or a space where you anticipate changing styles over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Liberty Furniture or Ashley Furniture cheaper?
Ashley Furniture is significantly cheaper than Liberty Furniture. Ashley is a value-oriented brand with competitive pricing and constant promotions, making it one of the most affordable full-line furniture retailers available.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Liberty Furniture generally offers better and more consistent quality. Their focus on solid hardwoods and proven construction techniques results in more durable, long-lasting furniture compared to Ashley's more budget-focused lines, which often use engineered materials.
Can you buy directly from Liberty Furniture?
No, you cannot buy furniture directly from the Liberty website. It is a wholesale manufacturer, and you must purchase their products through authorized retail partners, which you can find using their website's dealer locator.
What styles does Ashley Furniture sell?
Ashley Furniture sells a vast range of styles. Their catalog includes contemporary, modern, traditional, rustic, farmhouse, mid-century modern, and transitional pieces, making them a one-stop-shop for almost any design preference.
Which brand is better for a family?
The answer depends on the family. For durability and the capacity to withstand years of use, Liberty's solid wood construction is superior. However, for families on a budget or who don't want to worry about young children damaging expensive furniture, Ashley's affordable and easily replaceable pieces are a much more practical choice.
Is Liberty Furniture considered high-end?
Liberty Furniture is not considered a high-end luxury brand, but it occupies a solid mid-range position in the market. It offers a significant step up in quality and materials from entry-level brands without the premium price tag of luxury manufacturers.
How often does Ashley Furniture have sales?
Ashley Furniture is known for its frequent sales events. You can almost always find a promotion running, with major discounts offered during holidays like Presidents' Day, Memorial Day, and Black Friday.
Which brand is better for a formal dining room?
For a formal dining room, Liberty Furniture is the stronger choice. Their expertise is in creating classic, elegant dining sets with detailed craftsmanship that lend a sense of permanence and tradition to a space.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
